lovecraft68
Bad Doggie
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2009
- Posts
- 45,673
Yeah okay, I'll bite the fucking bullet and start a Shades thread.
However, instead of rendering my opinion on it (which we all know) or getting other people here's takes. Lets talk facts.
Check this out. Pasted from the 50 Shades kindle page
Customer Reviews
(8,598)
3.2 out of 5 stars
5 star
3,608
4 star
861
3 star
642
2 star
754
1 star
2,733
See all 8,598 customer reviews
“ So i started reading the first book and finished it in 2 days. ” Gülce Arman | 1,556 reviewers made a similar statement
“ Please, don't waste your time, money and brain reading this book. ” Jo G | 1,662 reviewers made a similar statement
“ The books are not well written, incredibly repetitive, there is little character development, and the sex scenes are, well, vanilla. ” sailorgirl27 | 1,984 reviewers made a similar statement
First off, let me give Amazon props for putting quotes from two negative reviews at the top rather than burying them to protect their best sellers rep.
Now here is the link to the page, please read at least the first couple of reviews.
http://www.amazon.com/Fifty-Shades-...=1342359067&sr=1-1&keywords=50+shades+of+gray
Now I know there is "trolling" on amazon. Theres some haters reviewing this thing, but over 2500+? This book is closing in on having as many one bombs as 5's. I also want to point out that when this thing hit Good Morning America(first time I'd heard of it) I checked this same page and it had 3,000 reviews and a rating over 4. The people buying for the hype since then are not happy.
And the negative reviews are mostly long and detailed. These people aren't lit hate trolls they're thoughtful reviewers who are pissed they just wasted $10-$20 on this thing.
My point is people can see this. They are seeing it is barely a 3 out of 5 rating and they're still dumping their hard earned money on it.
This is the "Oh, you haven't read it yet? Well what's wrong with you? Mentality.
Proof? I was at my nephews Birthday party last week and my wife's cousin who is a school teacher told me she was reading it. She said so far she wasn't liking it. I asked why she was continuing and she said that:
"Everyone at school is talking about it and I want to be able to talk about it too"
That's Shades audience right now. This isn't about "mommy porn" or erotica breaking through, this is about keeping up with the jones', about being trendy, about not feeling like one of the cool kids if you haven't read this.
Again, brilliant marketing and lightning in a bottle and good for James making millions.
But end of the day this thing has all the substance of a Milli Vanilli concert.
Herd mentality.
However, instead of rendering my opinion on it (which we all know) or getting other people here's takes. Lets talk facts.
Check this out. Pasted from the 50 Shades kindle page
Customer Reviews
(8,598)
3.2 out of 5 stars
5 star
3,608
4 star
861
3 star
642
2 star
754
1 star
2,733
See all 8,598 customer reviews
“ So i started reading the first book and finished it in 2 days. ” Gülce Arman | 1,556 reviewers made a similar statement
“ Please, don't waste your time, money and brain reading this book. ” Jo G | 1,662 reviewers made a similar statement
“ The books are not well written, incredibly repetitive, there is little character development, and the sex scenes are, well, vanilla. ” sailorgirl27 | 1,984 reviewers made a similar statement
First off, let me give Amazon props for putting quotes from two negative reviews at the top rather than burying them to protect their best sellers rep.
Now here is the link to the page, please read at least the first couple of reviews.
http://www.amazon.com/Fifty-Shades-...=1342359067&sr=1-1&keywords=50+shades+of+gray
Now I know there is "trolling" on amazon. Theres some haters reviewing this thing, but over 2500+? This book is closing in on having as many one bombs as 5's. I also want to point out that when this thing hit Good Morning America(first time I'd heard of it) I checked this same page and it had 3,000 reviews and a rating over 4. The people buying for the hype since then are not happy.
And the negative reviews are mostly long and detailed. These people aren't lit hate trolls they're thoughtful reviewers who are pissed they just wasted $10-$20 on this thing.
My point is people can see this. They are seeing it is barely a 3 out of 5 rating and they're still dumping their hard earned money on it.
This is the "Oh, you haven't read it yet? Well what's wrong with you? Mentality.
Proof? I was at my nephews Birthday party last week and my wife's cousin who is a school teacher told me she was reading it. She said so far she wasn't liking it. I asked why she was continuing and she said that:
"Everyone at school is talking about it and I want to be able to talk about it too"
That's Shades audience right now. This isn't about "mommy porn" or erotica breaking through, this is about keeping up with the jones', about being trendy, about not feeling like one of the cool kids if you haven't read this.
Again, brilliant marketing and lightning in a bottle and good for James making millions.
But end of the day this thing has all the substance of a Milli Vanilli concert.
Herd mentality.
Last edited: