Report child abuse?

M's girl

Leaving
Joined
Jun 22, 2005
Posts
7,156
I could really use your help with this one.

M and I are wondering what we should do. We live in a somewhat quiet neighbourhood where people tend to know one another. I come from the city so I'm different and don't interact that much with everyone in the street.

We live here for one and a half year now almost, and do have contact with our nextdoor neighbours on one side from day one. They are the kind of people that are very much in your face all the time. If it weren't for locks on my doors they would be in my house also all the time. I also use caller-ID to filter the 10 phonecalls or more per day she tends to make (although it's getting less - I guess it's starting to sink in that we are so much more private than that). On the other hand, if I would ever need her (their) help she (they) would be there in a heartbeat. They are like that too. We are very self supporting, though, and are afraid they will ask back what they give, but double (that happened already).

Anyway, these are people who are very simple. He has his own company (true) but the kind of work he does does not require a lot of education. His wife helps him with the administration somewhat. She's not Mrs Clever either but she has a big mouth, which gets her, surprisingly sometimes (to me), a long way. They are very self absorbed. He works all the time and is almost never at home for his wife and kids (and all the animals they have). She is a stay at home mum (but on benefits) but is too busy making social phone calls all day on her mobile phone. Their children are being totally neglected most of the time, but that's not all.

The children are (boy) 10, (girl) 5 and (boy) 1.... They hardly ever pay attention to them. The children are so frustrated as a result of that, that they don't know how to behave 'normal' anymore, resulting in other children (and those childrens parents) not wanting to have anything to do with them. This is starting to include me, because, frankly, when they are at 'your house' (oké, my house) they are rude, start fights all the time, never ever listen, can't eat or drink 'normal' without making one big mess, break things and such. I know they are children and all children do these things sometimes. But they do it on purpose and all of the time. But I know where it comes from and I also feel sorry for them. Their behaviour is one big cry for help and attention!

The lack of attention is not all. I must say... I have never noticed that they beat the children up other than the slap on the butt every now and then. So the abuse is not physical, what makes it harder to define, I guess.

But they abuse their children psychologicaly. By not paying attention and shouting and yelling at them ALL THE TIME. They yell them out of their beds in the morning and yell them back in. When they make a move either parent does not like they are sent away and called names, like asshole (the boy) and cunt of whore (the little girl! :eek: ) The children have problems with sleeping, which does not surprise me at all. So every night the parents scream from the livingroom without lifting their butt all sorts of terrible stuff to try to keep them in bed and/or quiet, which only upsets and frustrates the children more. They get up and go to bed by themselves. No goodnight kisses in their bedrooms, no helping (for the girl who is only 5!) with washing and dressing/undressing, although she gets yelled at if she puts on something that does not fit or is dirty. Dirty laundry is lying everywhere in the house, including in the children's rooms. They are yelled at for making a mess in their rooms but mum is the one who can't keep one square meter of her house clean and organized for more than one hour. How are the children supposed to learn how to keep things organized?! The many animals in the house also pee everywhere, including in the children's rooms. The children (and the animals) get yelled at because of that.

It's noise, noise, noise coming from next door, all of the time. And it's heartbreaking to hear!

The problem is: they really think there is nothing wrong with the way they raise the children. Granted, they take them out to fairs and such every once in a while and they get presents a lot. They take away the presents too as punishment whenever they feel like it, something I can understand under certain circumstances, but they are being totally inconsistant, which is very confusing for such young children.

The yelling and screaming and neglect are getting to us both (M and me) and we have talked a few times about informing the proper authorities. But then what? I know we should talk to them first. That is scary, I have to admit. Plus I really don't want to get involved in this actually. On the other hand I (we) feel there is something that needs to be done for the sake of the chidren. It is really heartbreaking what's happening to them.

Anyone with experience in something like this? I think I know what I (we) should do and in what order, really.... but I just could use some more advice and feedback from the crowd here.

Thanks in advance guys :rose:
 
Sorry, meant to post this in café..... :eek:

Lady G, please feel free to move it there if you think it's more appropriate.... :D
 
i think it's a legitimate how to question: how to handle bad parents whose proximity messes up your life.

i don't honestly think there's anything you can do here: the threshold for law enforcement appears to be physical abuse. this is clearly bad parenting and they should be avoided, but short of moving to a different neighborhood, i really don't see any recourse.

ed
 
I'm not sure about that. About that not being a valid reason. Also things may be different by law here in NL... :eek: I an goig to link from the Dutch board to here to get insight from the Dutch also (hopefully) but since we are a small crowd on Dutch Lit I wanted to get your perspecitives too, if you don't mind.

I must admit.... sometimes I think I should distance myself from them (we do hope to move in the near future anyway, but that could also take another year or more from now since it involves moving abroad.... Moving would be the solution for US... but isn't that unfair towards those children? They can't do anything themselves. It's up to (adult) people (like me?) to step up on behalf of them.

Or is it not?
 
what would the solution be, though? do you want the children taken away from the parents? their crime is really one of bad parenting, and that can't really be fixed, can it?

ed
 
silverwhisper said:
what would the solution be, though? do you want the children taken away from the parents? their crime is really one of bad parenting, and that can't really be fixed, can it?

ed


No, I do not want the children taken away from their parents. I want the parents to start behaving differently. I know. I have no idea what I can do, but MAYBE, tell them that if they don't clean up their act, I will report them will help?

But then what? That is the whole dilemma. But you know... I'm now thinking about these children 15 years from now. Young adults who MUST realize by then that they were being treated like absolute SHIT by their parents and everyone around them looked and listened and DID NOTHING!

It breaks MY heart thinking that will happen and I would be so ashamed if I did not al least TRY something. But what?

Please keep the replies coming. I think I need your input more than I already thought! :eek:
 
While everything that you have posted does smack head on w/terrible parenting skills - according to most definitions, it is not child abuse.
 
capricious_chic said:
While everything that you have posted does smack head on w/terrible parenting skills - according to most definitions, it is not child abuse.


You are probably right, I don't know. It's sad parents first have to beat up their children real bad first before it is, while this may result in far more damage! It's starting to show already.... :eek:
 
the sad truth however is that you cannot intervene in how someone else (mis)treats their children short of an act of abuse. think of how you might receive a criticism of that sort, without any sort of apparent warning.

this will escalate into a very, very ugly confrontation, very, very quickly.

ed
 
silverwhisper said:
the sad truth however is that you cannot intervene in how someone else (mis)treats their children short of an act of abuse. think of how you might receive a criticism of that sort, without any sort of apparent warning.

this will escalate into a very, very ugly confrontation, very, very quickly.

ed

Well, yes, that's what I'm afraid of too...

So I should pretend not to see and not to hear? That's going to be a hard one....by the way.... their yelling at the children literaly wakes me up every single morning. It's not because of that, that I want them to change their behaviour though...
 
that might however be the right avenue to pursue: just plain rudeness. :>

ed
 
silverwhisper said:
that might however be the right avenue to pursue: just plain rudeness. :>

ed


I'm afraid I'm not very good at that. It would come in handy now, wouldn't it?
 
no: i meant tell them that it's just plain rude for them to wake you guys w/ the yelling.

ed
 
M's girl said:
You are probably right, I don't know. It's sad parents first have to beat up their children real bad first before it is, while this may result in far more damage! It's starting to show already.... :eek:


I've been in similar situations before. It isn't easy and my heart always aches for the children involved. In my old neighborhood I always had children playing around and in my house. Many times, these children came from homes much like you described. As far as having them over to play with your children - if you are very clear about boundaries and what is and isn't acceptable in your home - most children will respect it, especially if you enforce it strictly. When they don't, send them home and explain why they can't play at your house that day and assure them that if they want to play another day they are welcome to as long as they can follow the rules in your home. For many children, it only takes one person caring about how they behave to make them want to.

As for the parents. There is no real answer. For me, I find these people intolerable and they well know it. I set rules for group things and family visits as well, stating that I won't tolerate excessive yelling or profanity around my children. I find most adults have a harder time w/this than their children. If that means they don't want to come over - I'm completely ok with that.
 
capricious_chic said:
...... In my old neighborhood I always had children playing around and in my house. Many times, these children came from homes much like you described. As far as having them over to play with your children - if you are very clear about boundaries and what is and isn't acceptable in your home - most children will respect it, especially if you enforce it strictly. When they don't, send them home and explain why they can't play at your house that day and assure them that if they want to play another day they are welcome to as long as they can follow the rules in your home. For many children, it only takes one person caring about how they behave to make them want to.

This is how I deal with it too. The thing is, they cling to me like I have honey on me or something. The little girl.... every once in a while I babysit her for an hour or so. I sit down with her with some crayons and paper and we draw pictures and talk and so... She gets all quiet and loves things like this. But that's only when we are alone. Which results in her wanting to be with me all the time and her mother wondering why (the hell) that is :rolleyes:

I'm not saying I'm thát good.... I'm saying I don't understand she does not understand about these kind of things. The statements the mother makes about how she and her husband raise the childred flat out baffle me sometimes. They are thát ignorant. Where do you start to tell them this is also a form of abuse, because I still think it is, even if the law says nothing about this...
 
MG, if I were you, I would not confront them. As ed said, it's bound to get ugly very quickly.

I don't see why you can't have an anonymous chat with someone in authority. Even if ultimately nothing is done, at least it will be investigated and it will be on record.

I feel very sad for the children, as they are the ones taking the brunt of their parents' ignorance and bad behavior.
 
bobsgirl said:
MG, if I were you, I would not confront them. As ed said, it's bound to get ugly very quickly.

I don't see why you can't have an anonymous chat with someone in authority. Even if ultimately nothing is done, at least it will be investigated and it will be on record.

I feel very sad for the children, as they are the ones taking the brunt of their parents' ignorance and bad behavior.


Thank you BG...

I was thinking about that (reporting and such)... maybe that's the way to go.

There's one thing that makes me wonder if I COULD have a talk with HER and not making things very bad. She, somehow, seems to look up to me, for whatever reason. It matters to her a great deal what I do and say, as far as I can see. Still, this could not be anything else than a straight attack to their parenting skills (or the lack of rather) and I guess there is no way to bring that message nicely...?
 
I had a very similar situation to this a number of years ago. The parents never had time and/or didn't care. In my case, most of this was directed at the youngest child in the family. He was rude, abusive towards other kids in the neighborhood and just plain mean.

After trying to deal with this for a few months, I called child services. It turned out there was nothing that they could do directly. But, they did help me. They offered some great advice and one of their social workers became a support person for me. I called on her for help a number of times.

Tread lightly though. In my case, he eventually became part of our family. All he needed was the love and support of a caring family. Almost 20 years later, he still calls me dad.
 
M's girl said:
Thank you BG...

I was thinking about that (reporting and such)... maybe that's the way to go.

There's one thing that makes me wonder if I COULD have a talk with HER and not making things very bad. She, somehow, seems to look up to me, for whatever reason. It matters to her a great deal what I do and say, as far as I can see. Still, this could not be anything else than a straight attack to their parenting skills (or the lack of rather) and I guess there is no way to bring that message nicely...?

Well, of course I'm sure you'd be polite, but her reaction might be another matter entirely. You think they're difficult neighbors now. Imagine what it would be like after that. And they might take it out on the kids (which it sounds like they do anyway).

It's a sad situation.

I was just thinking. Wouldn't their calling their children those ugly names be considered abuse?
 
webber1998 said:
.... In my case, he eventually became part of our family. All he needed was the love and support of a caring family. Almost 20 years later, he still calls me dad.


Wow..... :rose:

Were you EVER sorry afterwards, about getting involved? This must have taken sooo much of your time and energy. This boy has been VERY lucky to have you in his life, you know that?

Well, I don't even know if I'm a Saint like that! Last thing I wish for is for those children to lose their mum and/or dad. I don't even want to think about becoming responsible for them at this point, like you did. I just wish the parents would wake up and smell the coffee, by lack of a better expression in my vocabulaire...
 
bobsgirl said:
I was just thinking. Wouldn't their calling their children those ugly names be considered abuse?

Verbal abuse. I guess? It is when it's done from one adult to the other, isn't it? For me (and maybe there is no difference, but for me) treating a child like that is even worse. It is also rediculous and says something about the IQ of the parents of course. A five year old girl and the phrase "fucking whore" (kuthoer in Dutch) do not mix where I come from.
 
M's girl said:
I could really use your help with this one.

M and I are wondering what we should do. We live in a somewhat quiet neighbourhood where people tend to know one another. I come from the city so I'm different and don't interact that much with everyone in the street.

We live here for one and a half year now almost, and do have contact with our nextdoor neighbours on one side from day one. They are the kind of people that are very much in your face all the time. If it weren't for locks on my doors they would be in my house also all the time. I also use caller-ID to filter the 10 phonecalls or more per day she tends to make (although it's getting less - I guess it's starting to sink in that we are so much more private than that). On the other hand, if I would ever need her (their) help she (they) would be there in a heartbeat. They are like that too. We are very self supporting, though, and are afraid they will ask back what they give, but double (that happened already).

Anyway, these are people who are very simple. He has his own company (true) but the kind of work he does does not require a lot of education. His wife helps him with the administration somewhat. She's not Mrs Clever either but she has a big mouth, which gets her, surprisingly sometimes (to me), a long way. They are very self absorbed. He works all the time and is almost never at home for his wife and kids (and all the animals they have). She is a stay at home mum (but on benefits) but is too busy making social phone calls all day on her mobile phone. Their children are being totally neglected most of the time, but that's not all.

The children are (boy) 10, (girl) 5 and (boy) 1.... They hardly ever pay attention to them. The children are so frustrated as a result of that, that they don't know how to behave 'normal' anymore, resulting in other children (and those childrens parents) not wanting to have anything to do with them. This is starting to include me, because, frankly, when they are at 'your house' (oké, my house) they are rude, start fights all the time, never ever listen, can't eat or drink 'normal' without making one big mess, break things and such. I know they are children and all children do these things sometimes. But they do it on purpose and all of the time. But I know where it comes from and I also feel sorry for them. Their behaviour is one big cry for help and attention!

The lack of attention is not all. I must say... I have never noticed that they beat the children up other than the slap on the butt every now and then. So the abuse is not physical, what makes it harder to define, I guess.

But they abuse their children psychologicaly. By not paying attention and shouting and yelling at them ALL THE TIME. They yell them out of their beds in the morning and yell them back in. When they make a move either parent does not like they are sent away and called names, like asshole (the boy) and cunt of whore (the little girl! :eek: ) The children have problems with sleeping, which does not surprise me at all. So every night the parents scream from the livingroom without lifting their butt all sorts of terrible stuff to try to keep them in bed and/or quiet, which only upsets and frustrates the children more. They get up and go to bed by themselves. No goodnight kisses in their bedrooms, no helping (for the girl who is only 5!) with washing and dressing/undressing, although she gets yelled at if she puts on something that does not fit or is dirty. Dirty laundry is lying everywhere in the house, including in the children's rooms. They are yelled at for making a mess in their rooms but mum is the one who can't keep one square meter of her house clean and organized for more than one hour. How are the children supposed to learn how to keep things organized?! The many animals in the house also pee everywhere, including in the children's rooms. The children (and the animals) get yelled at because of that.

It's noise, noise, noise coming from next door, all of the time. And it's heartbreaking to hear!

The problem is: they really think there is nothing wrong with the way they raise the children. Granted, they take them out to fairs and such every once in a while and they get presents a lot. They take away the presents too as punishment whenever they feel like it, something I can understand under certain circumstances, but they are being totally inconsistant, which is very confusing for such young children.

The yelling and screaming and neglect are getting to us both (M and me) and we have talked a few times about informing the proper authorities. But then what? I know we should talk to them first. That is scary, I have to admit. Plus I really don't want to get involved in this actually. On the other hand I (we) feel there is something that needs to be done for the sake of the chidren. It is really heartbreaking what's happening to them.

Anyone with experience in something like this? I think I know what I (we) should do and in what order, really.... but I just could use some more advice and feedback from the crowd here.

Thanks in advance guys :rose:

Speaking about Dutch circumstances, psychological child abuse is a certified cause for action from the proper authorities. I'll give my more than 2 cts. in the Dutch café since it's a vastly different situation in different countries.
I'm ashamed to say the Netherlands are really backward when it comes to child abuse and dealing with it.

I know, one of my majoring subjects was child abuse.

:mad:
 
Black Tulip said:
Speaking about Dutch circumstances, psychological child abuse is a certified cause for action from the proper authorities. I'll give my more than 2 cts. in the Dutch café since it's a vastly different situation in different countries.
I'm ashamed to say the Netherlands are really backward when it comes to child abuse and dealing with it.

I know, one of my majoring subjects was child abuse.

:mad:


Pfew... I'm happy to hear you say that... well, under the circumstances, of course. (Boy... what am I getting myself into?!)

Anyway... I thought it was different with us (NL). I'm glad that it is, because NOT recognizing this kind of abuse would be soooo wrong. It hurts children in such a bad way. Maybe even harder than a good spanking on a daily basis without all the verbal abuse to go along with it, I don't know... :eek:

So, are we really that much behind then? If we have (at least) recognized this as being abuse? I look forward to your opinion and wise words in the Dutch Lit Café then...

Other responses and stories are still very welcome of course.
Thanks to everyone involved in this thread so far! :rose:
 
Ok, for the mixed crowd in here.

In Dutch law there are a number of things considered child abuse, which warrants action from the child care officials.

  • physical abuse
  • psychological abuse
  • sexual abuse
  • physical neglect
  • emotional neglect
  • pedagogic neglect

(sorry for the clumsy translations)

In the Netherlands, the current outlook is to keep children in their family as long as possible, going for support (and education) of the parents, and taking care of all involved children.

Recent studies have showed that being witness to violence of any sort inside the house is just as harmful for a child as being the victim. Not only does it leave emotional and psychological scars, it can also severely affect the ability to learn.

One of my teachers for this specific subject had been the victim of abuse in her childhood and she said one of the worst realizations when she got older, was the fact that nobody did anything even though lots of people must have had doubts.

:(
 
Black Tulip said:
Ok, for the mixed crowd in here.

In Dutch law there are a number of things considered child abuse, which warrants action from the child care officials.

  • physical abuse
  • psychological abuse
  • sexual abuse
  • physical neglect
  • emotional neglect
  • pedagogic neglect

(sorry for the clumsy translations)

In the Netherlands, the current outlook is to keep children in their family as long as possible, going for support (and education) of the parents, and taking care of all involved children.

Recent studies have showed that being witness to violence of any sort inside the house is just as harmful for a child as being the victim. Not only does it leave emotional and psychological scars, it can also severely affect the ability to learn.

One of my teachers for this specific subject had been the victim of abuse in her childhood and she said one of the worst realizations when she got older, was the fact that nobody did anything even though lots of people must have had doubts.

:(

See, that's what I mean. The little girl adores me. I guess if I would move within a year she will forget about me and maybe another 'nice' neighbour who will give her some attention will come along. But what if I stay longer? I have no doubt that she will remember me later on and think the same, that I did not care. And I do. :(

Thanks BT :rose:
 
Back
Top