Ginger or Mary Ann?

[ydahecnot]

The recent sad death of Dawn Wells has brought the ages-old Gilligan’s Island debate to the fore. In my mind, it’s Mary Ann by a mile: nicer personality and killer smile are the main things, but her body was on point, too. Then again, I am also in the Bailey Quarters and Janet camps.

What say you?

 

[IsItBad]

mary ann

but I wouldn't kick ginger out of bed

 

[Mr_bogey]

Why choose? Threesomes are not taboo any longer (but I'm a sucker for a brunette).

 

[ydahecnot]

I gotta be honest: Ginger didn’t really do much for me. One’s mileage may vary

 

[jaF0]

Hey, the old bag had the money.

Crank up your inner gigolo.

 

[ydahecnot]

Do you think Lovey had some secret kink to her?

 

[jaF0]

She wasn't totally disgusting in an heiress next door kind of way.

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/0c/5c/ba/0c5cbad2db38bf2165f2b5690897181e--khaki-pants-sweet-memories.jpg

'Gilligan, be a dear and put it right here, will you?'

 

[ydahecnot]

Hmmm, Thurston as cuck...intriguing

 

[tnman03]

Good grief man. The long time default decision on this dilemma was always “why both of course…” I don’t know how many times I was in a break room at night and some old Gilligan’s Island rerun came on. Invariably either someone made a comment about that island would be full of babies in real life. Or the “which one would you do” discussion started.

 

[ydahecnot]

But to quote Dylan, you gotta serve somebody

 

[tnman03]

But to quote Dylan, you gotta serve somebody

Yeah...well there's this older than old B&W Twilight Zone rerun in rerun-ville somewhere about the cookbook on serving man....

 

[ydahecnot]

Yeah...well there's this older than old B&W Twilight Zone rerun in rerun-ville somewhere about the cookbook on serving man....

The wonders of the imprecision of English. I liked the one of the boy who can send people into the TV.

Back to the point: I wasn’t saying that you could boink only one. I asked which you would prefer

 

[LLCox]

I would liked to have turned Mary Ann into a little slut.

 

[ydahecnot]

Oh, that’s only a fantasy away

 

[Writer_FM]

I want Mary Ann, but every once in a while I want her to get dolled up like Ginger.

 

[Trekka]

Ginger.
By a mile.
Got a thing for redheads.

 

[ydahecnot]

I like where this thread is going

 

[beachbaby179]

I wouldn't have done either of them, because... wrong team. Yanno. But I identify much more with Maryann. Which, from the comments so far, is a good thing, I think.

Sorry, Trekka.

 

[ydahecnot]

Booo!

Not the Mary Ann part

 

[Trekka]

*takes ball and goes..... over to the stable thread

 

[ydahecnot]

Staying and describing would be preferable

 

[Trekka]

Are you holding tightly onto your pear?

 

[ydahecnot]

Fingertips are twitching a little

 

[tnman03]

Ginger.
By a mile.
Got a thing for redheads.

Can't fault you for that eye for redheads and all that feistiness.

 

[Trekka]

I’m imagining the long auburn hair of my favorite redhead, entwined around my fingertip...