hypothetically speaking

[smoothg103rd]

If someone told me to kill them and I did it,does that still make me a murderer?

 

[Lancecastor]

No, it doesn't count.

Swing away!

 

[smoothg103rd]

No, it doesn't count.

Swing away!

Why not? I'll still face murder charges.

 

[pensivepoet]

Damn it, Smoot, you've found the perfect loophole.
God hisself couldn't convict you.

 

[smoothg103rd]

Damn it, Smoot, you've found the perfect loophole.
God hisself couldn't convict you.

I'm saying this to prove a point about men beating women during sex. They're still woman beaters just as I will still be a murderer.

 

[VaticanAssassin]

What the fuck is hypothetically?!

 

[smoothg103rd]

What the fuck is hypothetically?!

A song

https://youtu.be/X9nnP0E2g3I

 

[ryan8558]

Could also be conspiracy to commit murder.

 

[pensivepoet]

In either instance, don't blame it on the dog.
Son of Sam already tried that.

 

[smoothg103rd]

Could also be conspiracy to commit murder.

Answer the question I asked.

 

[Recidiva]

Yes. You would be guilty.

As for the comparison, having consensual sex is legal. There is no such thing as consensual murder in the eyes of the law.

Even if a dude presents a note saying "This guy wanted me to kill him and eat him.." (which has in fact happened, thanks Craigslist)

 

[Hypoxia]

If the voices in your head order you to kill, you must do so.

You must always obey your voices.

They're easy to blame.

While you're at it, since your voices will soon put you in prison for the rest of your life, you won't need your savings account, so send me all your money and valuables and drugs and shit like that. Right away. Go on, your voices will tell you to.

 

[ryan8558]

Answer the question I asked.

yes!

And possibly conspiracy.

Murder would not necessarily be death penalty, but then if you also are in a conspiracy to commit that murder you could very well get the death penalty.

My advice would be to get the best attorney you can afford.

 

[smoothg103rd]

Yes. You would be guilty.

As for the comparison, having consensual sex is legal. There is no such thing as consensual murder in the eyes of the law.

Even if a dude presents a note saying "This guy wanted me to kill him and eat him.." (which has in fact happened, thanks Craigslist)

So If I beat and bruise a woman with her consent, I'm not a woman beater?

 

[smoothg103rd]

yes!

And possibly conspiracy.

Murder would not necessarily be death penalty, but then if you also are in a conspiracy to commit that murder you could very well get the death penalty.

My advice would be to get the best attorney you can afford.

If the voices in your head order you to kill, you must do so.

You must always obey your voices.

They're easy to blame.

While you're at it, since your voices will soon put you in prison for the rest of your life, you won't need your savings account, so send me all your money and valuables and drugs and shit like that. Right away. Go on, your voices will tell you to.

I'm not saying that someone told me to kill them, or that I have any intentions on killing someone. If I did, do you think I will post it here? I'm not that dumb.

I'm just trying to prove a point. Murders will be murders,regardless. So woman beaters should be woman beaters, regardless.

 

[Recidiva]

So If I beat and bruise a woman with her consent, I'm not a woman beater?

You are a woman beater. You just beat a woman. It's up to her to press or not press charges.

Consent doesn't always protect people because there are *gasp* liars in the world and that's why trust in relationships is important.

 

[smoothg103rd]

You are a woman beater. You just beat a woman. It's up to her to press or not press charges.

Consent doesn't always protect people because there are *gasp* liars in the world and that's why trust in relationships is important.

So bdsm is for woman beaters? Finally someone is in agreement.

 

[Recidiva]

So bdsm is for woman beaters? Finally someone is in agreement.

Woman beaters, man beaters, self beaters, group beaters. Regular and alternative beating used.

That is however legal and murder isn't.

Another reason why people would rather go to a reputable (or disreputable) dominatrix or otherwise because they're less likely to go to court over providing a service with a stable address and a client list and are more likely to just want repeat business.

 

[pensivepoet]

If I force a woman to go fishing with me, forced or not, she's still a fisherperson.
If my butcher gets his haircut at Cecil's, but Cecil eats pasta, my butcher doesn't become italian.
If a train is travelling at 65mph for 12 hours, it will still take 2 days to reach St Louis.
Understand?

 

[Recidiva]

If I force a woman to go fishing with me, forced or not, she's still a fisherperson.
If my butcher gets his haircut at Cecil's, but Cecil eats pasta, my butcher doesn't become italian.
If a train is travelling at 65mph for 12 hours, it will still take 2 days to reach St Louis.
Understand?

That is a trippy use of the not transitive property...

I like it.

 

[smoothg103rd]

Woman beaters, man beaters, self beaters, group beaters. Regular and alternative beating used.

That is however legal and murder isn't.

Another reason why people would rather go to a reputable (or disreputable) dominatrix or otherwise because they're less likely to go to court over providing a service with a stable address and a client list and are more likely to just want repeat business.

Do that bdsm shit on someone that didn't tell you too and you're going to jail. It isn't legal, the people involved just don't press charges.

 

[smoothg103rd]

If I force a woman to go fishing with me, forced or not, she's still a fisherperson.
If my butcher gets his haircut at Cecil's, but Cecil eats pasta, my butcher doesn't become italian.
If a train is travelling at 65mph for 12 hours, it will still take 2 days to reach St Louis.
Understand?

Nah..

 

[pensivepoet]

That is a trippy use of the not transitive property...

I like it.

Thanks
I was just trying to make things simple.

 

[Recidiva]

Do that bdsm shit on someone that didn't tell you too and you're going to jail. It isn't legal, the people involved just don't press charges.

Yeah, well, do the sex shit on someone that didn't tell you to and the same thing happens.

As a drug user you should be able to appreciate that people use BDSM to create brain drugs. Having a whole lotta input and setting off fear, pain and other stuff during sex can feel awfully good.

You don't need to kinkshame or compare it to something else, you can just compare it to consensual sex.

People are into different things, their brains work differently, and if they get up and walk away thinking "That was awesome!" then good.

They can't if they are dead.

 

[Lancecastor]

Smoot, I want you to kill yourself with your permission.

Thank you.