Sean
We'll see.
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2005
- Posts
- 96,193
That ignores the French tradition of offensive satire and cartoons as a way of changing their culture. Charlie Hebdo was offensive to almost everyone, but that was a normal part of French political debate. Before the attack, Charlie Hedbo's circulation was small. It won't be now.
Satirical criticism of their rulers and the Catholic church was widespread before the French Revolution of 1789, and offensive satire is valued in France almost as much as the Declaration of Independence is in the US.
Most French satire is more subtle than Charlie Hebdo, which was at the extreme edge of what was acceptable.
The satire that was possible in France would not have been acceptable in the UK because our traditions are different. Our satire has more humour, is gentler, and rarely produces an angry reaction. Some people satirised by UK cartoons have asked for copies (or bought the original) of the cartoon criticising them. That had happened with a few Charlie Hebdo cartoons but most targets found the cartoon too cruel (and usually accurate!).
For the most part is was racist and unfunny. That doesn't mean they don't have the right to publish it without fear of getting their heads blown off.