Angeline
Poet Chick
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2002
- Posts
- 27,333
Thanks for this. It sent me back to my copy of The Chicago Manual of Style (13th Ed., which is somewhat out of date) to review the details on the use of ellipses.
I've been using them with no spaces, which is apparently incorrect, so thanks for that. But it seems that you are supposed to lead and trail with a space as well ("[t]hey are usually separated from each other and from the text and any contiguous punctuation by 3-to-em spaces"). So that means your first example should appear as: Annie, I would simply love . . . to read your poems this afternoon.
Where the omitted text falls between sentences, "the first dot is the period—that is, there is no space between it and the preceding word." So the second example should look like this: Write a sestina? Oh, gods. . . . The same rule applies if the omitted text follows a different punctuation mark, e.g.: Write a sestina? Oh, gods! . . .
I think.
All of this is at least somewhat a matter of personal style, or of the style guidelines of whatever publication the work appears in.
I used to use the 13th Edition of the Chicago Manual all the time. Then I got the 14th when it came out, but I don't remember ever reading that the first ellipsis point is considered the period. I always thought it was the last one. Lol. I also used the APA Style Manual and the U.S. Govt Printing Office Style Manual and the New York Times Style Sheet. Sigh. I'm sure it was the last dot in one of those.
I worked with this wonderful old woman who was my editor mentor. She had been educated at one of the "Seven Sisters" schools and was oh so proper and precise. (She was also a Quaker and suitably long-suffering.) Sometimes I'd ask her about some nutty esoteric point of style and she'd look over her half-glasses at me and say "Well dear it depends on what you had for breakfast this morning." In other words, it's absolutely precise except for when it's totally arbitrary.

(Personally I like most style manuals except for Fowler who I think is a boring old fart!)