Public Comment Board

[Quberotica]

Hi. I wrote a story and submitted it and allowed public comments. As an author can I reply there to the people who've taken the time to leave feedback? It seems like the only way I can do so is to grade my own story. That seems a little immoral.

Thank you.

 

[Jenny_Jackson]

Hi. I wrote a story and submitted it and allowed public comments. As an author can I reply there to the people who've taken the time to leave feedback? It seems like the only way I can do so is to grade my own story. That seems a little immoral.

Thank you.

You can make comments in reply to your own stories. However, most of us reply in PM or email.

 

[voluptuary_manque]

I reply personally to anyone that leaves an email return address. Flamers never do so I get to be nice to people who are nice to me.

 

[Quberotica]

It's just an anonymous reader advising me to get an editor. And personally I agree with him. I submitted the story too soon and I had some verb tenses that didn't agree. Also I had the incorrect word in some places like begging instead of beginning or on instead of one.

I read through carefully a couple more times caught them and corrected them and have submitted a corrected version. I really just wanted to say that and I promise not to rush things so much next time.

Although personally I bet those who leave their remarks there rarely return to see if there's a reply.

Ah well, I just wondered if there was some sort of protocol here as I'm just a newbie who wants to walk on his own for awhile, even if I fall flat on my face.

 

[Jenny_Jackson]

It's just an anonymous reader advising me to get an editor. And personally I agree with him. I submitted the story too soon and I had some verb tenses that didn't agree. Also I had the incorrect word in some places like begging instead of beginning or on instead of one.

I read through carefully a couple more times caught them and corrected them and have submitted a corrected version. I really just wanted to say that and I promise not to rush things so much next time.

Although personally I bet those who leave their remarks there rarely return to see if there's a reply.

Ah well, I just wondered if there was some sort of protocol here as I'm just a newbie who wants to walk on his own for awhile, even if I fall flat on my face.

If you get a really juicy PM, Email or PC from some Annomyous Asshole, you can post it in the AH. There's a thread in there titled "Annomyous"

 

[MarshAlien]

If you get a really juicy PM, Email or PC from some Annomyous Asshole, you can post it in the AH. There's a thread in there titled "Annomyous"

Or here in the Story Feedback Forum. There's a thread called "Best 'Worst Public Feedback.'" It's always more fun to share!!