Looking for Feedback/Constructive Criticism on my stories.

Joined
Apr 27, 2024
Posts
8
Hello, I'm a fairly new author, with seven stories published so far. Unfortunately I can't seem to get a lot of traction here. Like anyone else, I'd like to be successful, a novelist eventually. So I'd greatly appreciate any and all feedback and/or constructive criticism concerning my stories. Thank You.
 
I just read the first few paragraphs of Thistles in the Garden and, honestly, it’s so convoluted I lost the will to continue.

I get the desire to be atmospheric, but… this is extreme.
 
I just read the first few paragraphs of Thistles in the Garden and, honestly, it’s so convoluted I lost the will to continue.

I get the desire to be atmospheric, but… this is extreme.
Thank You. I am trying too be a better author. Might I suggest you try Tear You Apart.

I can, work at dialing back the atmosphere.
 
Thank You. I am trying too be a better author. Might I suggest you try Tear You Apart.

I can, work at dialing back the atmosphere.
You don't really need to dial back the atmosphere, it suits the story. What you do need to do is pay more attention to your edit - you've got a bunch of avoidable typos, words missing, silly mistakes. Nothing diabolical, but enough to draw attention to the need for a better edit.

Your enthusiasm for your story shows through, though, which for me, made up for the newbie errors.

Coincidentally, my latest work in progress has a similar theme, although it's a female vampire and a male victim, although he doesn't (quite) know it yet. So it was interesting to read another take on the genre.

I gave you a five, for enthusiasm.
 
You don't really need to dial back the atmosphere, it suits the story. What you do need to do is pay more attention to your edit - you've got a bunch of avoidable typos, words missing, silly mistakes. Nothing diabolical, but enough to draw attention to the need for a better edit.

Your enthusiasm for your story shows through, though, which for me, made up for the newbie errors.

Coincidentally, my latest work in progress has a similar theme, although it's a female vampire and a male victim, although he doesn't (quite) know it yet. So it was interesting to read another take on the genre.

I gave you a five, for enthusiasm.
Thank You so very much. I can work on the editing. I need to work harder, on that aspect.

The positive feedback about the content made my day, I have several more stories in the works right now. I will check your work out as well.
 
Back
Top