Judaism AMA

[Hel_Books]

Children are starving in masses in Gaza .

I notice you didn't dispute anything I posted, just did some bold-font four-letter-word ranting, so I'll have to assume you agree that Hamas is stealing the food aid for their fighters at the expense of their children and that the moslems are using children as human shields and that Izz al-Din Haddad isn't sharing any of his food with the children, or allowing any of them to shelter in his network of tunnels.

The Hamas charter calls for the elimination of Israel. They weren't content with ethnically cleansing the Gaza, where Jews have lived for thousands of years. What did these moslems think would happen?

If Iran had used all that money they spent arming Hamas (stirring up trouble to give their own people someone to hate other than their repressive theocratic government) on development aid instead, the people of Gaza would be living peaceful, prosperous lives now. But anti-semites don't learn the lessons of 1940: if the Nazis had quit while they were ahead, they would have ended up quite successful. And you'd have just adored that, wouldn't you?

 

[Rightguide]

ONE BLOOD LIBEL



TWO BLOOD LIBEL



THREE BLOOD LIBEL

"Blood Libel"....it's not just for use against Jews anymore.​

​

The three of you are all vile, horrible people.​

​

Rather than acknowledge the obvious....Genocidal Israel is starving Gazan children..... the three of you "double down" and attempt to use Genocidal Israel's atrocities to insinuate that Gazans are doing this to their own children. ​

​

Despicable.​

Doing "whatever it takes" to rationalize Genocidal Israel's war crimes shows us your utter lack of morality and compassion. The three of you profane your professed faith, and desecrate the name of God you claim to worship.​

And Noor, you are the worst of the worst. Claiming that pictures of starving children are somehow re-purposed from other famines is beneath contempt. I would challenge you to prove your claim, but you have a long documented history of making claims you can't support. You are simply a liar. That never happened. Prove me wrong. You cannot.​

The three of you have all committed Chillul Hashem and bring discredit to your chosen faith by choosing to support government atrocities over the tenets of Judiasm.​

​

Israel is completely to blame for the ongoing starvation in Gaza, and no amount of "but ackshually" from you three changes that underlying fact.

Don't forget to work in the word "antisemitism!" and "but but 10/7!" "the hostages" "whaddabout HAMAS" and the old standbys "rape 'n murder! RAPE 'n MURDER!" in your inevitable incoherent replies. Bonus points for any new ad hominem you untermensch can come up with.

​

NY Times Admits 'Gaza Boy Famine' Photo Hoax​

By All Israel News Staff | Wednesday, 30 July 2025 11:45 AM EDT



Following online backlash regarding its use of a photo depicting Mohammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq, a young Palestinian boy in Gaza who suffers from cerebral palsy, as one of the lead images in an article about the food shortage in Gaza, The New York Times appended an editorial note to the story on Tuesday.

The Times admitted that Mohammed suffers from “preexisting health problems,” and claimed that it had “learned new information” about him in the editorial statement it released on 𝕏.

“We have appended an Editor's Note to a story about Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq, a child in Gaza who was diagnosed with severe malnutrition. After publication, The Times learned that he also had pre-existing health problems,” the editorial note said.

"We have since learned new information, including from the hospital that treated him and his medical records, and have updated our story to add context about his pre-existing health problems,” the statement read.

https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/new-york-times-gaza-photo/2025/07/30/id/1220631/

 

[ll74]

Lol

 

[RobDownSouth]

I notice you didn't dispute anything I posted, just did some bold-font four-letter-word ranting, so I'll have to assume you agree that Hamas is stealing the food aid for their fighters at the expense of their children and that the moslems are using children as human shields and that Izz al-Din Haddad isn't sharing any of his food with the children, or allowing any of them to shelter in his network of tunnels.

I didn't need to "dispute" anything. You attempted to deflect from the fact that genocidal Israel is starving innocent children via government policy, and now you're churlish that I won't "play defense" and defend the positions that you've once again assigned to me. Nothing you stated above has any relevance to the genocidal Israeli government's current government-sponsored deliberate starvation of innocent children in Gaza

Side note: please stop "assuming" anything about me and subsequently criticizing me for the positions you've assigned to me. That's called "ascription" and makes you look foolish.

The Hamas charter calls for the elimination of Israel. They weren't content with ethnically cleansing the Gaza, where Jews have lived for thousands of years. What did these moslems think would happen?

Perhaps the Hamas charter does call for "the elimination of Jews".
That's irrelevant here and now (unless your faith decrees "two wrongs make a right").
The genocidal Israeli government is starving innocent children via government policy today.

That is inhumane and wrong, yet you seem very determined to rationalize this criminal behavior.
You should be ashamed of your lack of a moral compass.

If Iran had used all that money they spent arming Hamas (stirring up trouble to give their own people someone to hate other than their repressive theocratic government) on development aid instead, the people of Gaza would be living peaceful, prosperous lives now. But anti-semites don't learn the lessons of 1940: if the Nazis had quit while they were ahead, they would have ended up quite successful. And you'd have just adored that, wouldn't you?

You can sense the palpable stench of desperation in your argument when you attempt to distract from the discussion by invoking Iran, Antisemitism AND the old Jewish bugaboo, the Nazis in one incoherent paragraph. That's known as the "Gish Gallop", by the way: throw everything at your opponent and pray that something....anything...gains traction.

To address your febrile meandering:

• Iran has nothing to do with the current genocidal Israeli policy of starving innocent children in Gaza.
• Antisemitism has nothing to do with the current genocidal Israeli policy of starving innocent children in Gaza.
• The Nazis had nothing to do with the current genocideal Israeli policy of starving innocent children in Gaza.
• Genocidal Israel, on the other hand, has EVERYTHING to do with the current governmental policy of starving innocent children in Gaza.

So once again, I ask you, WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU?

 

[RobDownSouth]

NY Times Admits 'Gaza Boy Famine' Photo Hoax​

<Derp snip>

Your talking point was throroughly debunked in my Post 773 above.

It's not a "hoax". It's not a "full retraction" either. It's a one line clarification of a single sentence, that in no way shape or form invalidates the fact that genocidal Israel is starving innocent children in Gaza.

Go be ignorant somewhere else, you potato-fed, inbred and nearly dead septuagenarian dullard.

 

[Lazaran]

Your talking point was throroughly debunked in my Post 773 above.

It's not a "hoax". It's not a "full retraction" either. It's a one line clarification of a single sentence, that in no way shape or form invalidates the fact that genocidal Israel is starving innocent children in Gaza.

Go be ignorant somewhere else, you potato-fed, inbred and nearly dead septuagenarian dullard.

It was a YUUUUUGE omission of an incredibly relevant / important piece of information (especially when one considers the FACT that the child’s mother INTENTIONALLY LIED about the child’s preexisting health condition).



The New York Times disgraced itself; full stop.



We. Told. Them. So.

 

[Lance_Castro]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

 

[JohnEngelman]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

All the Israelis want is to live in peace in a tiny sliver of land bordering the Mediterranean Sea.

 

[JohnEngelman]

I am confident that those in the West who side with the Palestinians against Israel would rather live in Israel than in ay Muslim country in the world.

 

[RobDownSouth]

It was a YUUUUUGE omission of an incredibly relevant / important piece of information (especially when one considers the FACT that the child’s mother INTENTIONALLY LIED about the child’s preexisting health condition).



The New York Times disgraced itself; full stop.



We. Told. Them. So.

Utter nonsense.

So one child was not born completely healthy and there is no doubt whatsoever that the genocidal Israeli starvation campaign made his condition infinitely worse.

There are plenty of other pictures of starving Gazan children coming out of Gaza now,,,,what do you suppose is the root cause of their skeletal bodies? I'd say the genocidal Israel intentional starvation campaign.

The New York Times was made aware of a single error in a news piece. They candidly and openly corrected their error. That's not a "disgrace" by normal definition of the word.

That's called "taking responsibility for errors you made", which appears to be inconceivable to the average Israeli citizen.

Would you like to know what IS a disgrace, though?

Starving innocent children.

Starving innocent children is both a moral failing, and official Israeli policy.

 

[RobDownSouth]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Amen.

 

[Lazaran]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

MAYBE this iteration of Israel will be remembered as “the lion” that said “no more” to Iran’s (and Russia’s) “boil the frog” proxy war strategy (of course, it took Hamas’ 10/7 rape, torture, murder, and kidnapping operation to turn the boiling frog into a lion).

Also:

Israel has never managed to get a surrender and a declared & honored recognition as THE Jewish State with a right to exist from its vanquished enemies over the years / decades. MAYBE THIS TIME (although Israel first has to finish the job in Iran and eliminate Hamas, etc - and Ukraine has to prevail, because Putin / Russia is working with Iran and Hamas, etc).

Ultimately:

It appears Israel needed / needs to drop the conventional weapons & spy craft equivalent of an atomic bomb on its terroristic tormentors (including Iran & Russia) to end the cycle of violence (a diplomatically achieved peace was never realistic).

A regionally contained non-nuclear Armageddon, NOW, seems preferable to a worldwide nuclear Armageddon in the near future if Iran (with Russia’s assistance) is allowed to / succeeds in developing a nuclear arsenal. Suboptimal, to be sure, but still better than the alternative.





We. Told. Them. So.

 

[Lazaran]

Utter nonsense.

So one child was not born completely healthy and there is no doubt whatsoever that the genocidal Israeli starvation campaign made his condition infinitely worse.

There are plenty of other pictures of starving Gazan children coming out of Gaza now,,,,what do you suppose is the root cause of their skeletal bodies? I'd say the genocidal Israel intentional starvation campaign.

The New York Times was made aware of a single error in a news piece. They candidly and openly corrected their error. That's not a "disgrace" by normal definition of the word.

That's called "taking responsibility for errors you made", which appears to be inconceivable to the average Israeli citizen.

Would you like to know what IS a disgrace, though?

Starving innocent children.

Starving innocent children is both a moral failing, and official Israeli policy.

You have been brought to the trough countless times, but you refuse to drink…



One MOAR time:

This is ALL on Hamas (and Iran, Russia, etc).

Besides Hamas’ 10/7 rape, torture, murder, and kidnapping operation:

• Hamas, etc, attacked President Biden’s floating pier aid effort, attacked / hijacked UN aid efforts, and discharged weapons around air drop sites where civilians were trying to retrieve the food aid, etc.

• Hamas is CONTROLLING AND SELLING foreign aid (food, etc) to civilians to maintain power (there’s a reason Hamas demands that the UN be put back in charge of aid deliveries and that they (Hamas) control the border with Egypt.

• Hamas is (HAS BEEN) negotiating in THE WORST faith over a ceasefire and hostage for prisoners exchange deal.

• Hamas WANTS TO prolong the crisis and the associated death, destruction, and suffering - because "it" is working (See: your aid & comfort posts and the response from many foreign governments).

Bottom line:

Hamas is "winning" the narrative war thanks to media that may or may not be influenced by Arab / Muslim money & intimidation, open & blatant social media propaganda, and by the free labor from well intentioned dupes (take that last one personal if you wish).





We. Told. Them. So.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

The Temple Mount Sifting Project.

Archeological digs are forbidden on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, but in 1999, Muslim authorities constructed an illegal extension to the mosque on top of the mount. Fortunately, archeologists tracked down where the bulldozed debris had been dumped, and for two decades they’ve been carefully sifting through it, yielding Jewish artifacts dating back to the First Temple era—the one that was built by Solomon!

 

[RobDownSouth]

You have been brought to the trough countless times, but you refuse to drink…



One MOAR time:

This is ALL on Hamas (and Iran, Russia, etc).

Besides Hamas’ 10/7 rape, torture, murder, and kidnapping operation:

• Hamas, etc, attacked President Biden’s floating pier aid effort, attacked / hijacked UN aid efforts, and discharged weapons around air drop sites where civilians were trying to retrieve the food aid, etc.

• Hamas is CONTROLLING AND SELLING foreign aid (food, etc) to civilians to maintain power (there’s a reason Hamas demands that the UN be put back in charge of aid deliveries and that they (Hamas) control the border with Egypt.

• Hamas is (HAS BEEN) negotiating in THE WORST faith over a ceasefire and hostage for prisoners exchange deal.

• Hamas WANTS TO prolong the crisis and the associated death, destruction, and suffering - because "it" is working (See: your aid & comfort posts and the response from many foreign governments).

Bottom line:

Hamas is "winning" the narrative war thanks to media that may or may not be influenced by Arab / Muslim money & intimidation, open & blatant social media propaganda, and by the free labor from well intentioned dupes (take that last one personal if you wish).





We. Told. Them. So.

There is no reality where I will acquiesce to your utter fiction that Hamas is solely responsible for the collective punishment and Genocidal Israeli government-sponsored starvation program. None.

Genocidal Israel has ceded the moral high ground for decades to come, to please the nihilist faction of Jews that celebrate their lack of basic humanity as some sort of perverted "virtue".

Netanyahu and his genocidal government have painted targets on the backs of all genocidal Israelis as well as the huge phalanx of diaspora Jews worldwide.

And your complete refusal to acknowledge the genocidal Israeli government's role in the mass starvation is enough to convince many people that you and your fellow diaspora Jews gave tacit approval to genocidal Israel's barbaric conduct.....and that in turn renders you and your family, to use the genocidal Israeli term, "fair game".

Sleep with one eye open, henceforth and forever more. Stay safe. They're not coming for you now, but odds are they will in your lifetime.

 

[Lazaran]

There is no reality where I will acquiesce to your utter fiction that Hamas is solely responsible for the collective punishment and Genocidal Israeli government-sponsored starvation program. None.

Genocidal Israel has ceded the moral high ground for decades to come, to please the nihilist faction of Jews that celebrate their lack of basic humanity as some sort of perverted "virtue".

Netanyahu and his genocidal government have painted targets on the backs of all genocidal Israelis as well as the huge phalanx of diaspora Jews worldwide.

And your complete refusal to acknowledge the genocidal Israeli government's role in the mass starvation is enough to convince many people that you and your fellow diaspora Jews gave tacit approval to genocidal Israel's barbaric conduct.....and that in turn renders you and your family, to use the genocidal Israeli term, "fair game".

Sleep with one eye open, henceforth and forever more. Stay safe. They're not coming for you now, but odds are they will in your lifetime.

I’m not Jewish (or religious) - at all.

As I mentioned before: You have lost all objectivity. You can’t even get basic facts correct.



Side note:

Remember when so many Democrats / "Liberals" fought so hard for "Palestine" and ended up losing America AND "Palestine"???

Yeah, me too…





We. Told. Them. So.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

There is no reality where I will acquiesce to your utter fiction that Hamas is solely responsible for the collective punishment and Genocidal Israeli government-sponsored starvation program. None.

Genocidal Israel has ceded the moral high ground for decades to come, to please the nihilist faction of Jews that celebrate their lack of basic humanity as some sort of perverted "virtue".

Netanyahu and his genocidal government have painted targets on the backs of all genocidal Israelis as well as the huge phalanx of diaspora Jews worldwide.

And your complete refusal to acknowledge the genocidal Israeli government's role in the mass starvation is enough to convince many people that you and your fellow diaspora Jews gave tacit approval to genocidal Israel's barbaric conduct.....and that in turn renders you and your family, to use the genocidal Israeli term, "fair game".

Sleep with one eye open, henceforth and forever more. Stay safe. They're not coming for you now, but odds are they will in your lifetime.

The genocide slur has always been a permission structure to allow Jew-haters to feel righteous and justified.

 

[Lance_Castro]

The genocide slur has always been a permission structure to allow Jew-haters to feel righteous and justified.

I don’t think you’re a Jew.

Just as I don’t think televangelists are Christians.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

I don’t think you’re a Jew.

Just as I don’t think televangelists are Christians.

Antisemites don’t get to decide who is or isn’t a Jew.

 

[Lance_Castro]

Antisemites don’t get to decide who is or isn’t a Jew.

Dudes pretending to be jewish women are fun to laugh at.

Lol

 

[JohnEngelman]

I don’t think you’re a Jew.

Just as I don’t think televangelists are Christians.

I know you are wrong about BrightShinyGirl and televangelists.

BrightShinyGirl is Jewish, I am Christian, and I do not like the way you have been harassing BrightShinyGirl.

 

[MiaBabe23]

Thank you for the thread and chance to ask questions
You’ve probably been asked this or questions similar, so apologies if you’ve already provided a comparable answer
I’ve had some really uncomfortable exchanges with Jewish friends and acquaintances, good people, about Gaza, where acts they would vehemently condemn when committed by any other state or actor, are minimized or even justified when committed by Israel
Have you ever caught yourself doing so, and why do you think this can happen?

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

Thank you for the thread and chance to ask questions
You’ve probably been asked this or questions similar, so apologies if you’ve already provided a comparable answer
I’ve had some really uncomfortable exchanges with Jewish friends and acquaintances, good people, about Gaza, where acts they would vehemently condemn when committed by any other state or actor, are minimized or even justified when committed by Israel
Have you ever caught yourself doing so, and why do you think this can happen?

Which acts are you asking me to condemn? There’s lots of misinformation being spread by pro-Palestinians and a lot of well-intentioned people have been taken in.

 

[MiaBabe23]

Which acts are you asking me to condemn? There’s lots of misinformation being spread by pro-Palestinians and a lot of well-intentioned people have been taken

Most obviously, the widespread killing of unarmed civilians, including children. Some obvious examples are the ‘flour massacre’ and similar events; food blockades, causing widespread starvation; the killing of aid workers and burial in shallow graves; attacking non-combatant locations such as hospitals and schools without any forewarning for civilians
There are a range of independent testimonies from UN agencies, aid agencies and civilians themselves
So is it that you’re of the view that what’s being reported is inaccurate, but you would condemn these events as horrific if true?

 

[Hel_Books]

Hel_Books said:
I notice you didn't dispute anything I posted, just did some bold-font four-letter-word ranting, so I'll have to assume you agree that Hamas is stealing the food aid for their fighters at the expense of their children and that the moslems are using children as human shields and that Izz al-Din Haddad isn't sharing any of his food with the children, or allowing any of them to shelter in his network of tunnels.

I didn't need to "dispute" anything. You attempted to deflect from the fact that genocidal Israel is starving innocent children . . .

Perhaps not, as the most recent news stories show all that is pure propaganda. But you can tell that just by looking at the photos yourself, without having to read the New York Times retractions. News video and photos from actual famine areas (like, say, Sudan) show stick-figure adults barely able to walk carrying emaciated children. Because they could hardly allow their children to go hungry while they fed their faces, could they? The "news" from Gaza invariably shows well-fed young men in the background waving their weapons and shouting Death to Israel.