Judaism AMA

[Winter_Fare]

I didn't argue in bad faith. I asked a question, you didn't answer because the answer would not serve you and your thoughts.

There was snark.

October 7th, when Hamas (made up of Palestinians) raided a music festival. They raped, killed, and kidnapped Jews. This was the start of Israel and Hamas war.

This is false. This awful conflict has been going on for generations. Apartheid and Zionism are just as much a part of what makes the murderous perennial chaos as The backwards hateful anti-Semitism of Hamas.

Palestinians are taught, as children, to hate Jews. I was never taught to hate a person or people and I will never teach my children to hate a person or people.

I mean wow. Do you really think it's so one sided? A recent study found that 60% of Israeli Jews felt that Arabs were less than human, also, 60% of Palestinian Arabs felt that Jewish people were less than human.

I do care about people, I care about people's lives. I have experienced death firsthand, I have seen it, I have held someone as they died.

Okay. People in general are very much sheltered from death and dying I suppose. I'm not. Occupational hazard.

Also, I closely knew one of the kidnapped victims that did not get the opportunity to be freed, because she was killed.

That is awful and those responsible could have been brought to justice lawfully. Instead we have this disgusting immoral illegal war filled with atrocities that make October 7th look like a family picnic

I wish the war was not happening. I wish people made love and not war. But when Hamas did what they did on 10/7, they started a war. Stuff is terrible in a war.

Again, a narrow view of a conflict that has been ongoing for generations.

Also, I am not a bad person, I do not argue in bad faith, or have hate for anyone. I hope you can perceive this as sincere, as it is.

It's human to be biased. We all have biases. You have been personally affected by the atrocities of October 7th, so I don't blame you at all for your sincere conviction that the genocide in Gaza is justified.

 

[AnomalyLady]

There was snark.

This is false. This awful conflict has been going on for generations. Apartheid and Zionism are just as much a part of what makes the murderous perennial chaos as The backwards hateful anti-Semitism of Hamas.

I mean wow. Do you really think it's so one sided? A recent study found that 60% of Israeli Jews felt that Arabs were less than human, also, 60% of Palestinian Arabs felt that Jewish people were less than human.

Okay. People in general are very much sheltered from death and dying I suppose. I'm not. Occupational hazard.

That is awful and those responsible could have been brought to justice lawfully. Instead we have this disgusting immoral illegal war filled with atrocities that make October 7th look like a family picnic

Again, a narrow view of a conflict that has been ongoing for generations.

It's human to be biased. We all have biases. You have been personally affected by the atrocities of October 7th, so I don't blame you at all for your sincere conviction that the genocide in Gaza is justified.

I acknowledge your response and politely end the conversation. Thank you for conversing.

 

[AnomalyLady]

Cool!

What did they tell you about DSG’s fetish for shooting babies in the name of the Torah?

DSG?

If you are referring to BrightShinyGirl, show me where she said something along the lines of, "I have a fetish for shooting babies in the name of the Torah." Or, admit you are lying.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

OKay does it have material and non material realities discussed ? Material as in we humans or this whole cosmos but does it have any mention of the non material aspect of this world in Judaism?

Also what are you thoughts on if following different religions makes us any different?

There is a strain of of mystical Judaism, but it’s very much not the mainstream.

Judaism is much more concerned with the here and now. The standard rabbical answer to questions about the afterlife is “What are you worrying about that for! Pay attention to living!”

 

[Noor]

There was snark.

This is false. This awful conflict has been going on for generations. Apartheid and Zionism are just as much a part of what makes the murderous perennial chaos as The backwards hateful anti-Semitism of

False?!? they live-streamed the rapes and massacre. Some of us were unlucky enough to be on twitter and tik tok when those evil monsters were streaming it!

Hamas.

I mean wow. Do you really think it's so one sided? A recent study found that 60% of Israeli Jews felt that Arabs were less than human, also, 60% of Palestinian Arabs felt that Jewish people were less than human.

Where are you coming up with these numbers? Palestinian citizens of Israel make up about 20% of the country’s population. Israel was also allowing Gazan workers to work in Israel which no other country in the Middle East was doing.
It maybe true that Arabs feel that way, and I’m sure Israelis are currently having trust issues with Palestinians but I have never heard or seen a credible study that they felt they weren’t human. I personally I felt that those people who committed the atrocities on 10/7 were monsters, but I’m not Israeli and I probably wouldn’t felt that way on 10/6.

Yes, it’s one sided. Gazans bring up children as martyrs to kill Jews or so their school text books say and Israelis bring their children to repair the world, to make a positive difference, and help others.

Okay. People in general are very much sheltered from death and dying I suppose. I'm not. Occupational hazard.

That is awful and those responsible could have been brought to justice lawfully. Instead we have this disgusting immoral illegal war filled with atrocities that make October 7th look like a family picnic

Again, a narrow view of a conflict that has been ongoing for generations.

It's human to be biased. We all have biases. You have been personally affected by the atrocities of October 7th, so I don't blame you at all for your sincere conviction that the genocide in Gaza is justified.

Illegal war? You don’t get to go in and massacre somebody, and then whine when they declare war and fight back.
Israel and Gaza are surrounded by Arab Islamic Middle Eastern countries and not one of those countries will take Gazan refugees or workers because of the troubles esp terrorism they have had in the past when they have.
No one In the Middle East, wants the Israelis and the Gazans,

If Israel had wanted to get rid of Gaza, they would’ve leveled it long ago. They have the weapons and they have the military power, but they’re not interested.
They don’t care about Gaza, they left Gaza over a decade ago. They even unburied their historic dead and took them to Israel. As long as Gaza would leave them alone, Israel would be fine.
As far as a part the rest of it, what country continues to supply water, electricity, phone service, internet and food to a people that they want to annihilate?

 

[Shyintrovert01]

There is a strain of of mystical Judaism, but it’s very much not the mainstream.

Judaism is much more concerned with the here and now. The standard rabbical answer to questions about the afterlife is “What are you worrying about that for! Pay attention to living!”

Did you ever try exploring on this question "who am I"

What is your answer when you ask yourself "who am I"?

 

[Lance_Castro]

Yeah, this looks like no babies got killed.

The UN estimates the Jews have killed about 42,000 women and children in Gaza so far.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

 

[AnomalyLady]

Yeah, this looks like no babies got killed.

The UN estimates the Jews have killed about 42,000 women and children in Gaza so far.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Do you not understand war? Still don't see where BSG said she has a fetish.

 

[Noor]

Cool!

What did they tell you about DSG’s fetish for shooting babies in the name of the Torah?

Why would they bother to do that? Jews love babies and children. They don’t bring them up to be martyrs. A Jewish family revolves around the children. Parents will go without so their children will have the best education.

You must mean the Koran which does have passages which some interpret as killing non-Muslims but the Torah has now.

 

[Lance_Castro]

Why would they bother to do that?

Why is Israel commiting genocide in Gaza?

You’re joking, right?

I’m amazed at you bloodthirsty trolls here defending these crimes against humanity.

 

[AnomalyLady]

Why is Israel commiting genocide in Gaza?

You’re joking, right?

I’m amazed at you bloodthirsty trolls here defending these crimes against humanity.

Describe the word "genocide."

Addition, not with a Insta video, with your own words.

 

[Lance_Castro]

You are vile, evil trolls.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_genocide

 

[AnomalyLady]

You are vile, evil trolls.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_genocide

Your. Own. Words.

 

[Lance_Castro]

Israel limits entry of baby formula in Gaza as infants die of hunger

While waiting to enter Gaza on a medical aid mission, an American doctor watched Israeli security forces confiscate the cans of powdered baby formula packed in his luggage. The vital product is desperately lacking in the Palestinian enclave, where about 50 children have died of hunger since March.
By Laure Stephan (Beirut (Lebanon) correspondent)
Published on July 1, 2025, at 11:30 am (Paris)

 

[Lance_Castro]

Thousands of babies face starvation in Gaza as milk supplies run dry

Doctors in Gaza are warning of a ‘silent catastrophe’ that threatens the lives of thousands of babies and infants. Israel’s blockade of Gaza means supplies of formula milk have run out – and starving mothers are unable to breast feed their children.

 

[Lance_Castro]

Reminds me of the Holocaust.

There are many ways to die in the Gaza Strip, and during a visit to a neonatal ward on Friday, NBC News’ team on the ground witnessed one reserved for the enclave’s most vulnerable residents: babies starving for lack of formula as Israel continues to restrict supplies from entering Gaza.

At the neonatal ward in Khan Younis’ Nasser Hospital, Dr. Ahmad al-Fara spends the day attending to beeping incubators, trying to keep half a dozen babies alive, each one trapped in a crisis that could claim their life.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

Did you ever try exploring on this question "who am I"

What is your answer when you ask yourself "who am I"?

I’m a Jewish mom living in LA who likes to cook, watch cartoons, and take care of my family. I write smut as a hobby so that’s why I’m on Lit. Life is too short to waste it on navel-gazing.

 

[Noor]

Thousands of babies face starvation in Gaza as milk supplies run dry

Doctors in Gaza are warning of a ‘silent catastrophe’ that threatens the lives of thousands of babies and infants. Israel’s blockade of Gaza means supplies of formula milk have run out – and starving mothers are unable to breast feed their children.

It must be all those guys with stomachs that we see in the videos in Gaza that drink all the aid milk, also seen on the videos. I haven’t seen many starving women or children either.
Have you ever seen any one who is starving? Adults look more like the recently released male hostages.

 

[Lance_Castro]

Alleged women posters here supporting the wholesale extermination of innocents.

Probably Russian trolls.

During the first two months of bombing, Israel dropped 25,000 tonnes of explosives on the Gaza Strip. Many of these were unguided "dumb bombs" dropped in densely populated areas obliterating entire neighbourhoods.[118]

Since 7 October 2023 the IDF has been accused of extrajudicial killing of unarmed Palestinian detainees[119][120] and healthcare personnel.[121] Israeli soldiers have summarily executed Palestinian civilians, often in front of their families.[122]

They have killed Palestinians waving white flags.[122] In April 2024, mass graves were found containing corpses with their hands tied,[123] including women and the elderly.

 

[Winter_Fare]

False?!? they live-streamed the rapes and massacre. Some of us were unlucky enough to be on twitter and tik tok when those evil monsters were streaming it!

You quoted me, but not the person I was replying to, so this question doesn't really work. No way did I say the atrocities didn't happen. It's the disproportionate response to them I take issue with.

Where are you coming up with these numbers?

https://pcpsr.org/en/node/989

I have never heard or seen a credible study that they felt they weren’t human.

Check out the link, it's true.

I personally I felt that those people who committed the atrocities on 10/7 were monsters, but I’m not Israeli and I probably wouldn’t felt that way on 10/6.

Agreed.

Yes, it’s one sided. Gazans bring up children as martyrs to kill Jews or so their school text books say and Israelis bring their children to repair the world, to make a positive difference, and help others.

I call BS. Neither Israel nor Palestine are populated with only good or only bad, only tolerance or only intolerance. Collective punishment is abhorrent, labelling children as Hamas terrorists is abhorrent.

Illegal war? You don’t get to go in and massacre somebody, and then whine when they declare war and fight back.

For well over a hundred years we have had standards of how to treat children and other non combatants, including journalists. Israeli forces make a mockery of those standards. It's deliberate dehumanisation.

Israel and Gaza are surrounded by Arab Islamic Middle Eastern countries and not one of those countries will take Gazan refugees or workers because of the troubles esp terrorism they have had in the past when they have.
No one In the Middle East, wants the Israelis and the Gazans,

Okay. Your point? Just because Israel is happy to exploit Arabs that doesn't give them the moral high ground.

If Israel had wanted to get rid of Gaza, they would’ve leveled it long ago. They have the weapons and they have the military power, but they’re not interested.
They don’t care about Gaza, they left Gaza over a decade ago. They even unburied their historic dead and took them to Israel. As long as Gaza would leave them alone, Israel would be fine.

No. Neither local nor world politics is ever that simple

As far as a part the rest of it, what country continues to supply water, electricity, phone service, internet and food to a people that they want to annihilate?

Israel.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

Reminds me of the Holocaust.

There are many ways to die in the Gaza Strip, and during a visit to a neonatal ward on Friday, NBC News’ team on the ground witnessed one reserved for the enclave’s most vulnerable residents: babies starving for lack of formula as Israel continues to restrict supplies from entering Gaza.

At the neonatal ward in Khan Younis’ Nasser Hospital, Dr. Ahmad al-Fara spends the day attending to beeping incubators, trying to keep half a dozen babies alive, each one trapped in a crisis that could claim their life.

There were no hospitals with babies in incubators during the Holocaust. The Nazis killed babies by holding them by the legs and bashing them against the wall. Or gassing them with their mothers after the selection.

 

[Noor]

You quoted me, but not the person I was replying to, so this question doesn't really work. No way did I say the atrocities didn't happen. It's the disproportionate response to them I take issue with.

https://pcpsr.org/en/node/989

Check out the link, it's true.

Agreed.

I call BS. Neither Israel nor Palestine are populated with only good or only bad, only tolerance or only intolerance. Collective punishment is abhorrent, labelling children as Hamas terrorists is abhorrent.

For well over a hundred years we have had standards of how to treat children and other non combatants, including journalists. Israeli forces make a mockery of those standards. It's deliberate dehumanisation.

Okay. Your point? Just because Israel is happy to exploit Arabs that doesn't give them the moral high ground.

No. Neither local nor world politics is ever that simple

Israel.

You're getting your info from a Palestinian source, which is probably based on Hamas numbers, hardly a credible source.
How about something independent? Something not Palestinian, not Israeli and not UN, using actual numbers.

 

[AnomalyLady]

Reminds me of the Holocaust.

There are many ways to die in the Gaza Strip, and during a visit to a neonatal ward on Friday, NBC News’ team on the ground witnessed one reserved for the enclave’s most vulnerable residents: babies starving for lack of formula as Israel continues to restrict supplies from entering Gaza.

At the neonatal ward in Khan Younis’ Nasser Hospital, Dr. Ahmad al-Fara spends the day attending to beeping incubators, trying to keep half a dozen babies alive, each one trapped in a crisis that could claim their life.

If you have not learned all the terrible details about the Holocaust if you compare the two.

 

[BrightShinyGirl]

You're getting your info from a Palestinian source, which is probably based on Hamas numbers, hardly a credible source.
How about something independent? Something not Palestinian, not Israeli and not UN, using actual numbers.

The first image on the page they linked to is staged. That’s a clue right off the bat that it’s anti-Israel propaganda.

 

[Winter_Fare]

You're getting your info from a Palestinian source, which is probably based on Hamas numbers, hardly a credible source.
How about something independent? Something not Palestinian, not Israeli and not UN, using actual numbers.

How about you go ahead and admit that there's no such thing as an unbiased source. And that your knee jerk "probably" is kind of worthless without some sort of evidence in kind.