UPDATE: New Writer Seeking Advice and Story Review

BillBlack

Virgin
Joined
May 27, 2008
Posts
4
I posted my story in the author's hang out for critique, and was met with a torrent of (mostly) constructive criticism. Most helpfully from sweetsubsarahh, among others. I have revised my story with some of your suggestions taken into account. I hope it is now better than "three stooges working in a bakery." So please read, and let me know if it is.

For your consideration:

My Music Teacher

It was on my eighteenth birthday that I first caught a glimpse of her pussy.

It was during class, and she was my music teacher. I sat in the front row, and as she jumped up to sit on her desk, I caught a glimpse of something black and wet beneath her skirt. Every day I came early and sat in front of her, and sometimes I would see the hole in her.

I think she saw me watching, because she would look into my eyes as she sat on her desk and played her guitar. Each time I saw her the dark slit would seem to get wetter, sopping wet, dripping.

She stared at me for the longest time today in class. I wore shorts, and I was leaning back, my legs thrust forward under her desk. I felt something warm drip on to my bare leg, and startled, I saw it was a clear liquid from her dark slit. Her eyes were only for me as she finished the song, and dismissed the class.

“Bill,” she said in a low voice. “I want you to stay after class.”

I sat nervously as all the other students filed out. She stood up. “Come to me,” she said softly. I walked to her, anxious, and she wrapped her long bare arms around me.

“Now we’re going to play a game,” she whispered in my ear. “I’m going to tell you to do something, and you do it.” I nodded, my head pressed into her chest. She smelled of sweet roses.

“Now take your finger,” she instructed, “and put it up there. Where you looked.” And I reached my finger up under her skirt and it found the soaking wet place. My finger didn’t stop but slid up, all the way up, and she shuddered and gasped. I drew it out.

“Yes,” she said softly. “Now do it again.” It slid in, like jelly. “Again,” she whispered. “Again.” I slid it up there again, and again, rhythmically. “Faster,” she said. “Harder.” And I did it, faster and harder, and she squeezed my body tight and cried out, panting.

She sat on her desk then, out of breath, and pulled up her skirt to her belly. I saw the slit exposed. There was a stripe of black hair above it, and it looked like two moist lips. Her thighs looked silvery.

“Now come,” she said, and I walked to her. She took my head and gently pushed it down to the wetness. My tongue licked out, tasting it. “Oh,” she moaned. “Oh.” I licked it again, harder, and she cried out. It tasted warm and salty, and it smelled good, like her. She pushed my face deep into her, and soon I was all soaked as I licked her, desperate to taste, to drink every last drop of her as she cried out again and again.

Finally she lifted my head up. I looked into her eyes. She looked drained, dreamy. She sat up on her desk and reached down to my pants. She unbuckled the belt and pulled the pants and my underwear down, and there was my cock. It was throbbing, erect, so hard it felt like it would burst. She stepped down and sat me on her desk, and now she bent over me. Clear fluids were dripping down my tip. She took me in her mouth and it felt like a deep, warm cave. She sucked back and forth, and I couldn’t control myself, had never felt anything like this. All at once I burst in her mouth, I felt what seemed like gallons of liquid erupt, and I grunted and pulled her to me. She coughed but swallowed it down, and when she lifted her face I saw the white juice seeping slowly down. She kissed me then, and in the wet kiss I tasted mine and she tasted herself. Her tongue was in my mouth, moving around gently.

She looked at me dreamily and reached down. I was still hard. Surprised, she stroked me in her hand. She got up and began to unbutton her shirt, and she was wearing nothing beneath. She took it off and her breasts spilled out, pale and heavy. The nipples were large, a dark red color. Her belly was tight. She stepped out of her skirt and lay back on the desk, relaxed. She told me to take all my clothes off, which I did. She stared at my bulging penis, engorged again with blood. “Now come to me,” she said.

I got up on top of her, and we laid there together. I could feel her warm silky body under me. She ran a hand through my hair. I reached out tentatively, and she smiled and put my hand on her breast. It was so soft, like feathers. I caressed it, and bent down to take her nipple in my mouth. I sucked on it and she was as surprised as I was when milk flowed out. But she let me continue, and she stroked me as I sucked the warm milk from her.

“Now,” she said to me, “I want you in me.” She was staring at me fixedly, and panting. Her face and breasts were flushed a deep red in the fading light. She caressed my face. “Take your cock,” she said, “and put it in.” She guided me with her hand, and with my tip I felt the soft warm opening. “Ooh,” she moaned softy, her head against mine. She wrapped her arms around me.
“Put it in,” she told me, her eyes closed. I slipped it in, just an inch, and she moaned. I pulled it out again, teasing. “Put it in,” she whispered urgently, her mouth open. Again I pushed it in a little, and then took it out.

She was moaning hard now. “Put it in,” she said to me, more forcefully, and I just shoved it, deep as I could. I felt her juice spurt out of her like an avalanche, drenching us. She screamed and I knew she had climaxed. But I didn’t stop. I fucked her over and over, as hard as I could. Her pussy felt ripe, like a fruit so swollen it was ready to burst. In and out I went, faster and faster. She clung to my back desperately, crying out, climaxing again and again. Finally I built up and I could stand it no longer, and my cum came gushing out of me as she orgasmed for the last time. I didn’t pull out, and we lay there, intertwined, panting and silent. Both sweaty, soaked. For the longest time we lay there, until finally we both moved to get up. We dressed.

She looked at me for a long time, wondering. “I’ll see you around, Bill,” she said finally. And I walked out.
 
As a sex scene vignette, its fine, and you shouldn't have any trouble posting it on Lit. I didn't read the original beyond the "dark and stormy night" opening, so I can't say how much this has improved technically, but this version is quite good technically, with just a missing comma or two here for publishing standards.

One phrase early on set my teeth on edge:

"sometimes I would see the hole in her." That's quite awkward and more crass than the rest of the language (which itself--along with the images--borders on the sophomoric, but is saved by some quite good description). I'd try to clean that up, especially as it comes early in the short story and will set the discerning reader on a defensive "warning" stance. Maybe something a little more literary, such as "puckered slit."

One important comma missing early too, in the next paragraph:

" . . . Each time I saw her[comma] the dark slit . . ." Anything else not quite right is subjective and nitpicky, so shouldn't be noticed by most readers.

The next to last paragraph needs to be set off by a extra return space.

So, this is certainly good enough for posting at Lit. without some anal retentive poster (justifiably) saying "get an editor." Too bad it couldn't be set in an actual story that starts someplace and goes someplace and makes an actual interesting/unique point, though.

It could use some more emotional pointing on the narrator's reaction, if you wanted to kick the quality up a couple of notches. This is his first time (presumably) and fulfilling a wet dream. A range of emotions from numbness/clumsiness through getting a little cocky and bumbling embarrassingly and being brought back by his teacher's guidance/instruction to a coming of age finding that an 18-year-old can go on autopilot and do what comes naturally to mutual satisfaction would please both the juvenile voyeurs and the more discerning reader.

I'd quibble about the believability of the teacher (and you might, to better effect, have her say something that indicates why this particular 18-year-old attracts her to take this risk), but we're seeing scenarios like this in real life just about every day.

I know I was among those who told you you needed to make getting past 18 explicit from the get go to get it published here--and you have taken care of that, if a bit clumsily. An 18th birthday event is a little bald and overachieving. A more subtle Introduction would, again, kick the quality up, I suggest.

E.g., something like starting" "Because I'd been pushed so hard to take the high school team to its second football state championship [ergo establishing his charisma and hunkiness in the mind of the reader through showing, without having to "tell" it], I'd lost concentration on my classes, and this was my second try at graduating. So, I'd overloaded on sure-pass courses in my repeat senior year [establishing not only enough age and a reason to being in a "flake" course, but also a little shortfall in smarts and maturity, which would make his immediate succumbing more believable, and, at the same time, establishing believability that the teacher would separate him from the herd in terms of what she'd be attracted to and willing to risk to deflower]. So, here I sat in music class, only able to keep awake by the possibility of seeing again what I thought the teacher had flashed at me. Was I imagining it, or had she done it on purpose? And had she done it just for me? [adding mystery and foreshadowing in your introductory paragraph]
 
Last edited:
P.S.: If you were interested in what could be done to make this into more than a sex scene, into an actual short story, here's an example of that without adding much more material.

You could slap the sentence "I learned early in life the difference between love and lust." unto the front end of the opening paragraph (and I should have said in my earlier posting that the first paragraph is the most important one--your current one is limp and bald and foreshadows not enough). Then you could add (in just a phrase here or there) a male friend to the first paragraph, the narrator's good buddy, who is in the music class for exactly the same reason.

Then to the tail end of what you have now, you could add a paragraph (briefly and elegantly) describing all of the callow youth's salivating over what had happened to him and how much he loved this music teacher (who you could name at this point, thus making her a person for the first time in the story--and bolstering the "love" that the narrator sees in what has happened) and that they could run off together and get married and he'd get a job and they'd raise a family, etc.--and how he'd tell her all that in class the next day.

Then a kicker ending paragraph, where he stumbles into class late all alight with the future and there's the music teacher flashing his best buddy, ready to start her cycle again with another ripe youth.

Just an example.
 
Back
Top