two towers

S.Daedalus said:
It was a great movie from just a cinematic point and a pleasure to watch if you can not look at the book at the same time.

Just my thoughts.

~ Stephen

I can totally see where you're coming from here. I know the books very well, but I tried to put them in the back of my mind when watching it, as I knew there would be significant changes. I can see how the changes could be an annoyance, though. There were far more numerous and important changes vs. the book in TTT than in TFotR. Without outlining the various differences between book and movie, I will say that I agree with most of the changes, as they make the characters (and the story) more "human". The ending of the Frodo/Faramir storyline was a bit jumbled (the battle in Osgiliath ended rather abruptly and conveniently, just in time for Faramir to "release" Frodo), but I think overall it added to the dramatic effect, as Faramir risks more in the movie than in the book.

I think the mindset you have going into an adaptation is very important. If you look at the original text as sacrosanct, gospel, or history, then your mind will balk at any major changes. I tried to look at it as a movie BASED on and inspired by the book, and in that light I think it succeeded. Still, I can see why other fans of the book would disagree.
 
I wish they would show them all together. Make a day of it. Event theater with intermissions.
 
i agree tortoise books and movies are completely different mediums im always going to enjoy the book more so but i can still enjoy the movie as a fantastic movie and tribute to one of my fav books

in the end they've made the greastest ever fantasy films i've ever seen ... i don't really care if they've changed bits from the books
 
I have a friend who is one of those people that has a hard time seperating the books from the movies. He liked the first movie decently, but a direct quote about The Two Towers was that "they took the book, put it through a shredder, then tried to put it back together again."

Now, I've never read the book. So from a purely narrative point of view I think both movies succeed extremely well. I was very pleased with The Two Towers as a middle book, despite some questions that arose later.

I wasn't sure how Frodo knew anything about Golem...how did this occur? Anyone care to explain?

The sequence where Frodo and Sam are capture seemed a bit forced or rushed...and their release did as well. Is that terribly different in the book?

Per the cavern scene in the first movie...where are all the dwarves? Have they all been killed, or just the group that was in the cave in the first movie?

Maybe little facts like these would become more clear if I read the books at some point...

-Phil
 
Here is how I see it, if you are a fan of Toliken<sp> you will like it. If you like movies which are intellectually challenging in that they cause you to reflect on detailed orgins of fictious people and places(fantasy realms) you will like it. If you like D&D, or the idea of D&D, and or topics similar to D&D, fantasy, medevil magic, or the ideas of such you will like it.

If however you are not detail minded. You do not relate well to stories which are epics where they refer to people, places, or things which are often seen as sci-fi or fictional. You will probally not like it. These stories which are often compared to Star Wars for a myrid of reasons, are similar to a role playing game made into a movie. They emerse you in a rich world of fantasy, which people who have been following these stories for years have grown accustomed. This is why it seems as though some people are talking in a foreign language when they are discussing these tales(movies).

I have always liked the fantasy realms, but have found the structure of say a D&D(Dungeons & Dragons) enviroment a bit too contrived for my taste. I find I am too creative to be spoon fed these fictious tales run amuck as some sort of legacy of the truth. Although I enjoy them, and symbolism they employ, I find that the elitism fawned on by many of the more devout fans a bit unnerving.

While I do not denounce those who wish to show their praise by doing so, it is not my cup of tea. As it is often said to copy is the sinceriest form of flattery.

I suggest to those who have seen the hype to consider these things prior to gleening on a work which draws it's roots and style from a great author whose novels are quite diverse and hardly the norm. Be sure you understand these things before you pass judgement over such cult like antics as those who love to dream more than live.

:cool:
 
Shelob wasn't moved to tRotK because of budget, the movies were all completed (except for postproduction) before Fellowship even came out. They moved Shelob so that there could be more in Return. It was a ending point. Fellowship did that... went a bit into Towers so they could have a decent place to end it.
 
Back
Top