Two Guys find out they are cheating with the same Girl

[Fuumayami]

These two guy are connected in some way, but idk what would be better - friends, brothers, father and son (leaning towards this.)
They find out and now keep it a secret together, but ever since then, they've been competitive in trying to "win" her.
The girl, I'm thinking, is sexy, very naughty, open-minded - often bringing her own slutty friend(s) to have threesomes, and has a loud personality, she's different from their wives. Should the girl be connected with someone they know? Like a sister's friend?

I'm wondering how should they find out? How did they meet this girl? What are some sort of shenanigans they would go through? What are some hot scenes that can happen?
Thoughts?

 

[000zing]

I've always like the idea of 'symmetry' in a plot, where similar things are happening at the same time, with whatever degree of ignorance or 'unknowingness' on the part of the MCs.

Better, IMHO, to have the two friends cheating with each other's girlfriends... or ideally even married couples. Admittedly, you lose the competition aspect and the 'naughty' hottie thing.

Sorry if this digresses.

 

[TheWritingGroup]

The naughty girl is met in different settings. Guy 1 knows her as a temp at his office, "Shelly", who dresses just a little too sexy for work and flirts outrageously. Guy 2 meets "Meesh" at a charity of some kind, say working in a food bank (or a church thing if you're comfortable with that). In that environment, she's much more shy and dresses in jeans and a loose sweatshirt. (Real name: Michelle.)

She likes both for different reasons: Guy 1 is hot, Guy 2 is nice (to oversimplify). She dates 2 and fucks 1 ... and then they both arrange to bring her to the same club. By this time, Michelle has figured out that they know each other.

--Annie

 

[TinaG_2023]

And the girl lives happily ever after!

 

[Rob_Royale]

I like the father / son aspect. She's the receptionist at the doctor's office that their family has been going to for decades.
They meet in the office after hours. Tables with stirrups, ya know?

After bringing her friends in for threesomes occasionally she tells them both that she will be inviting another man, for a MFM threesome and they can either be cool with it or it's over between them.

The surprise when she inivtes both men at the same time is just priceless.

 

[Fuumayami]

I've always like the idea of 'symmetry' in a plot, where similar things are happening at the same time, with whatever degree of ignorance or 'unknowingness' on the part of the MCs.

Better, IMHO, to have the two friends cheating with each other's girlfriends... or ideally even married couples. Admittedly, you lose the competition aspect and the 'naughty' hottie thing.

Sorry if this digresses.

This would be nice for another story idea.

 

[Fuumayami]

I like the father / son aspect. She's the receptionist at the doctor's office that their family has been going to for decades.
They meet in the office after hours. Tables with stirrups, ya know?

After bringing her friends in for threesomes occasionally she tells them both that she will be inviting another man, for a MFM threesome and they can either be cool with it or it's over between them.

The surprise when she inivtes both men at the same time is just priceless.

Oh yes that sounds believable. She doesn't know they are related, they probably have common last names and doesn't put two and two together.
The meet up when trying a new threesome would be shocking and I think hilarious. Ultimately, the sexy girl is able to seduce them and have the threesome. The two men agree to share this secrecy. Maybe on a darker note, the lady finding this out, use this as leverage to expose their affair if they don't satisfy her needs? Idk

 

[Rob_Royale]

Oh yes that sounds believable. She doesn't know they are related, they probably have common last names and doesn't put two and two together.
The meet up when trying a new threesome would be shocking and I think hilarious. Ultimately, the sexy girl is able to seduce them and have the threesome. The two men agree to share this secrecy. Maybe on a darker note, the lady finding this out, use this as leverage to expose their affair if they don't satisfy her needs? Idk

In my mind, she does know. But he wants what she wants and is the sort of woman who could have a dozen lovers at a moments notice. And the taboo of having them together is more than she can resist.

The dialog of the two men meeting in the parking lot is what has me in stitches as I imagine the wild stories about why they are a the docs office at 8pm on a Sunday.