Twin dating

[Nightscream89]

So I was thinking, what if 2 identical twin brothers that live together (for college or just because they are that close) are joking around one day and they decide to make a dating profile under a fake name and then mixing their photo's into one profile to see if there would be anyone that notices that there are 2 different people in the photo's.

The idea backfires because obviously no one inspects the photo's enough to notice any differences. However they do match with a beautifull girl. So they decide to step it up a notch and take turns going on dates with the while she thinks it's the same guy every time. Problems arise as both brother actually fall in love with the girl and the girl falls in love with the brothers (thinking they are one person.)

The brothers do decide to keep it going at first, even as far as when the girl stays the night the first time, first one brother has sex with her, then he goes to the bathroom where he switches with his brother who goes in for round two. Or something like that?
She probably thinks the guy is insatiable...

And then of course later in the story, how will she find out? Do the brothers come clean or does she accidentally find out, what is the fallout? Does she leave? Does she start dating them both? How will she handle that the man that she is hopelessly in love with, is actually 2 men?

 

[beliefofmine]

I'd read it.

 

[Rob_Royale]

I'd read it.

Yeah, what they said. Sounds hot.

 

[PhoenixLord]

If you wrote it, I'd suggest making the similarities with each sibling something subtle, like one of their nipples is higher than the other.

Also, I'd definitely read it if it included a secret ending like, "Turns out, she's a twin as well..."

 

[beliefofmine]

If you wrote it, I'd suggest making the similarities with each sibling something subtle, like one of their nipples is higher than the other.

Also, I'd definitely read it if it included a secret ending like, "Turns out, she's a twin as well..."

And then what if he's actually not a twin. He's schizophrenic like in Fight Club.

 

[Nightscream89]

If you wrote it, I'd suggest making the similarities with each sibling something subtle, like one of their nipples is higher than the other.

Also, I'd definitely read it if it included a secret ending like, "Turns out, she's a twin as well..."

I like the idea of her noticing that some things are off, however since most people wouldn't immediately think of identical twins, to her the thought of him being 2 people doesn't cross her mind even though some things seem off.

She being a twin as well could be a funny secret/alternate ending. In my head eventually she dates both brothers.
Also thought about her being angry at first and breaking it off but then she returns to them a bit later after she found out she's pregnant. Having no possible way of discovering which twin is the father, they all become one family with her getting into a relationship with both brothers.

Anyone have any ideas of scenario's where the two might swap places?

 

[LiterallyLiterate]

I like the idea, sounds like a nice mix of hot and humorous. I’d read it.

As for differences, I agree they should be subtle. Maybe twin number 2 has a slightly longer or thicker cock, so that when he gets back for round two, she’s surprised he seems bigger?
What if one of them is very much into stroking and caressing her during sex, while the other likes to slap her ass or pinch a little?
Maybe one prefers regular sex while the other always wants anal?

Lots of options to play around here, and I hope the story eventually leads to her discovering there’s two of them, the inevitable argument and make-up sex would be awesome. You could add in pretty much every single MMF trope in the book.

 

[LiterallyLiterate]

Missed the question about scenarios for swapping.

What about a country fair, with a corn maze? They could swap back and forth lots if times.

Dinner and a movie, they could swap when he excuses himself to go to the bathroom after dinner.

It’s pretty much just a matter of finding any kind of break where they’re separated for a few minutes to make a switch. Maybe she could even spot the other twin from afar and comment how he looks very similar, though not close enough to see the details and become suspicious.

Or maybe she does become suspicious? Maybe she starts trying to test her theory by laying small traps to find out if there’s actually two?

I can see the scene where one brother has to replicate a hickey on the other, or some well-placed scratches across the back?

 

[Carnevil9]

I like the idea of her eventually finding out, and being cool with it. "What? I get TWO cocks to fuck me? Yes please!!"

 

[Carnevil9]

And then what if he's actually not a twin. He's schizophrenic like in Fight Club.

As I recall, Tyler and Edward Norton also fucked the same girl. And she didn't know it.

 

[PhoenixLord]

I like the idea of her noticing that some things are off, however since most people wouldn't immediately think of identical twins, to her the thought of him being 2 people doesn't cross her mind even though some things seem off.

She being a twin as well could be a funny secret/alternate ending. In my head eventually she dates both brothers.
Also thought about her being angry at first and breaking it off but then she returns to them a bit later after she found out she's pregnant. Having no possible way of discovering which twin is the father, they all become one family with her getting into a relationship with both brothers.

Anyone have any ideas of scenario's where the two might swap places?

Restaurant, public park, the mall, their apartment.

 

[Nightscream89]

I like the idea of her eventually finding out, and being cool with it. "What? I get TWO cocks to fuck me? Yes please!!"

What if she finds out while they are having a sexy night.
Maybe she gives one a hickey, they didn't think about it and switched.

She notices that the hickey is suddenly gone after he went to the bathroom.

The twin ends up coming into the room, still naked and they confess what they were doing.
Her response?
"Let's discuss this in the morning when I can think straight. Seeing now two of you naked... I just want you two to fuck me!"

 

[1darknightowl]

If you wrote it, I'd suggest making the similarities with each sibling something subtle, like one of their nipples is higher than the other.

Also, I'd definitely read it if it included a secret ending like, "Turns out, she's a twin as well..."

Having a twin fantasy I would read it.

there could be quirks in her personally throughout. When she finds out, we the reader find out she has been playing the same game with her twin.

 

[Audiflex]

So I was thinking, what if 2 identical twin brothers that live together (for college or just because they are that close) are joking around one day and they decide to make a dating profile under a fake name and then mixing their photo's into one profile to see if there would be anyone that notices that there are 2 different people in the photo's.

The idea backfires because obviously no one inspects the photo's enough to notice any differences. However they do match with a beautifull girl. So they decide to step it up a notch and take turns going on dates with the while she thinks it's the same guy every time. Problems arise as both brother actually fall in love with the girl and the girl falls in love with the brothers (thinking they are one person.)

The brothers do decide to keep it going at first, even as far as when the girl stays the night the first time, first one brother has sex with her, then he goes to the bathroom where he switches with his brother who goes in for round two. Or something like that?
She probably thinks the guy is insatiable...

And then of course later in the story, how will she find out? Do the brothers come clean or does she accidentally find out, what is the fallout? Does she leave? Does she start dating them both? How will she handle that the man that she is hopelessly in love with, is actually 2 men?

This is such a wild and chaotic concept, it’s like a rom-com meets a psychological thriller! The idea of the twins switching places and the girl being completely unaware is hilarious but also low-key stressful. The fallout would be intense, imagine her reaction when she finds out! She could either be horrified and feel completely betrayed, or (if she’s super open-minded) she might be like, “Wait, so I get two of you?!” Either way, it’s a recipe for drama, laughs, and some serious moral dilemmas. Would totally watch this as a movie!

 

[inka2222]

First of all, there was at least one such story on LE with the sexes reversed (he dated twin girls, even married "her"). Matter of fact I think there were several.

Second, the whole "sex with one twin when he/she thinks she's with another", regardless of how hot it is, has one tiny little problem: in many if not most jurisdictions it would be legally considered rape. May not cause problems in-story, but something to pay attention to.

 

[ICantLeafYou]

I'd read it.

They'd have to be gay/dating another man for me to be into it, but I like the premise.

 

[Carnevil9]

Not sure why I didn't think of this before, but the Cronenberg movie "Dead Ringers" starred Jeremy Irons as two twin gynecologists who seduce the same woman. Only she knows there are two of them, but doesn't know she is fucking both of them. Tour de force performance(s) by Irons.

It was remade recently as a miniseries with Rachel Weisz as the twin gynos. That took it to a whole nother level of kink.

 

[wouldloveto]

Another hot idea that I would definitely read. My mind is already coming up with scenarios, especially the idea the two of them taking her one night. She would be wowed by his/their stamina and it would fit right in with her needs... yep... lots of thoughts...

 

[Husky_Embrace]

So I was thinking, what if 2 identical twin brothers that live together (for college or just because they are that close) are joking around one day and they decide to make a dating profile under a fake name and then mixing their photo's into one profile to see if there would be anyone that notices that there are 2 different people in the photo's.

The idea backfires because obviously no one inspects the photo's enough to notice any differences. However they do match with a beautifull girl. So they decide to step it up a notch and take turns going on dates with the while she thinks it's the same guy every time. Problems arise as both brother actually fall in love with the girl and the girl falls in love with the brothers (thinking they are one person.)

The brothers do decide to keep it going at first, even as far as when the girl stays the night the first time, first one brother has sex with her, then he goes to the bathroom where he switches with his brother who goes in for round two. Or something like that?
She probably thinks the guy is insatiable...

And then of course later in the story, how will she find out? Do the brothers come clean or does she accidentally find out, what is the fallout? Does she leave? Does she start dating them both? How will she handle that the man that she is hopelessly in love with, is actually 2 men?

It sounds like The Prestige. You could follow that plotline to the letter, except erotifying it and maybe not have them live the same life.

In the movie the first woman notices, saying she can tell when he's truthfully saying he loves her and when not. The movie has a worse reason than you for having them switch. In the movie it's because they live the same life, which literally sets the stage for their best trick, the transported man. You have a twin where at first it is more a game of masquerade, which accidentally goes into the extreme. They both like her, so neither wants to give up. Even when they start to sleep with her.

What @inka2222 mentions is true, but this might be the whole concept you build the story around. The woman does not notice a difference. She is actively dating both, so it isn't a casual swap or anything. She gets to know both and progress to having sex with both, even though she thinks it's one person. I'm not saying it is morally okay to withhold the information that they are actually two different persons, just that in how she meets them and then interacts with them complicates the issue.

What makes it truly interesting is that it's like dating your ex and your current partner at the same time. You've changed the time, and obfuscated the identity, but otherwise nothing.

I'm an identical twin myself. If it was me, I would never date the same woman. It would just be really, really weird. Even it is one after the other. At the same time... No. Just no.

Curious to the story though.