"Three Sisters: Too much of a good thing."

[Lustful_Male]

"Three Sisters"​

Jacob rolled reluctantly off his girl friend, sweating and panting, his heart pounding in his chest. He drew a deep breath and called out, "O-o-o-o-o-o-o-h ... my ... god ... Alexandra"

Jake and Alex had been sleeping together for just over a month now, and -- once they'd become a little more familiar with how to push the other lover's buttons -- the sex had always been good. But this...

"Ohmygod..." he murmured softly as if one word, the euphoria of his third orgasm of the night still running wild through him. "No one..."

The thought evaded him for a moment as he relished the moment. No woman had ever made him cum three times in one night. Alex had simply been phenomenal, and he thanked his lucky stars for having her as a lover.

Careful with that word, Jakey-boy, a voice spoke inside his mind. Lover's a little close to love ... and it's too early for that. It's just sex, remember that.

He wasn't sure whether he really believed that or not. He and Alex were great together, in and out of bed, and he was already entertaining ideas of asking her to be exclusive with him on Valentines Day, just a month away. It wasn't like he was bedding anyone else at the moment -- in fact, she'd been his first in more than six months -- but he was still young, not even 21 yet, and the macho man inside of him kept telling him to leave his options open and not get tied down!

Jake and Alex had been class mates since grade school and close friends through high school, and he thought it was so ironic that only now were they becoming this close. They'd been in different cliques pretty much all of their school years, otherwise, he was sure, they would have hooked up long before graduation. Despite having known each other most of their lives, they hadn't begun dating until after they showed up for the same History of Western Civilization class at college and, later, went out for coffee and learned that they'd always had the hots for the other.

With his breathing beginning to settle, Jacob rolled quickly out of Alex's bed and crossed the room to retrieve the uncapped water bottle he'd left on her dresser. He lifted it and swigged long and hard, then turned to face her. She was so beautiful lying there naked, her perfect body glistening with its own sheen of sweat covering it. Her chest was heaving like his own, those perfect tits and their swollen nipples rising and falling rhythmically.

He heard a sound in the hallway and his stomach turned over, thinking that someone in the family was home and had heard their rather loud display of passion. They had never made love here, at the family home; this was the first time that she'd been certain that no one would be around, and with the coast clear, they'd come here -- rather than the apartment he shared with three guys -- so they could be totally alone and as loud and rambunctious as they wanted to be.

Remembering that the only other living soul in the house was that of the dog, Peaches -- who had started howling every time Alex had cum over the last three hours -- Jacob went to and opened the bedroom door and stepped out into the hall, calling as he looked about, "C'mere girl. It's all good now. You can come--"

His heart jumped clear up into his throat as he found a half-naked Elayna standing near the end of the hall, staring at him and smiling. She struck a post and asked, laughing, "Can I come...really?"

Jacob jumped back into Alex's bedroom and slammed the door behind him.

On the bed, Alex sat up quickly, asking, "What's wrong?"

Jacob wasn't sure how to react. Did he tell her that they weren't alone? Did he tell her that someone in her family had probably heard them making love? Did he tell her that her older sister had just seem him stark ass naked...? The Prom Queen, underwear model, and -- most recently -- Maxim magazine cover girl sister?

Hell no! he told himself, keep this to yourself! Last thing he needed was for the sister that he was fucking to know that the sister that he'd always wanted to fuck had just seem him naked ... and then made a joke about it!

"Nothing," he answered. "The, uh ... the dog ... what's her name...? She jumped up on me ... startled me. Claws, you know--" He gestured toward his nude body. "Could'a hurt. No worries, everything's cool."

Everything wasn't cool, of course. His heart was pounding like a jack hammer from the shock. But even worse, the sudden onset of fantasies -- involving, of course the wrong sister -- were causing his previously relaxed and dangling dick to stiffen to flag pole position before him.

Settle down, boy, he tried to tell it ... but that wasn't working. It simply wasn't possible to turn these fantasies off ...

 

[lonelycollegegirl]

Elayna

It was late afternoon when Elayna finally made her walk of shame into the house. She'd spent the evening, and most of the morning, with some guy she'd met at the club the night before. He was hott, and not a total tool, so she'd decided he was good enough to entertain her for a few hours. But, it ended up being more because it turns out, Mike .. or Adam maybe .. she couldn't remember, was pretty good in bed.

Her parents were out of town for the weekend, so she was surprised to hear noises when she came home. It was coming from upstairs, and she quickly realized it must be here sister with her new boyfriend thing. She'd vaguely remembered Alex telling her she was having him over, but like everything she said, it slipped her mind.

She tried to be quiet as she made her way to her bedroom and pulled off her jeans and her top. She grabbed some clean things from her closet and made her way to the bathroom. Unable to keep quiet she tripped over one of the dogs toys and slammed into the wall as she caught herself. "Shit," she cursed under her breath, pausing and waiting to see if they'd heard her. When no one came out she thought she was safe, but just as she opened the bathroom door she heard a male voice calling what he must have thought was the dog.

"C'mere girl. It's all good now. You can come--"

"Can I come really?" Elayna said playfully with a grin and a wink as she looked the guy up and down, paying extra close attention to what he was packing down below. Impressive, she thought to herself as she licked her lips. She giggled as he slammed the door and jumped back inside, her clothes, or lack there of, no doubt having an effect on him.

Too bad Allie got to him first, she thought as she stepped into the shower. She couldn't help her mind from wandering about all the fun things she could do with him.

 

[lonelycollegegirl]

Alexandra

Alexandra took in a deep breath as Jacob rolled off of her. She giggled as he fought to catch his breath while complimenting her on how amazing their afternoon had just been. When her breathing slowed momentarily she rolled towards him and kissed his chest just above his nipple as she traced lines over his stomach with her finger.

"That was amazing Jake," she whispered against his skin. She felt like she was on top of the world when she was with Jake, and he made her feel like she was the only girl in the world. Though it'd only been a month, she'd found herself falling for him pretty hard. She couldn't stop herself from constantly wondering when he was going to ask her to make things official. Alex wasn't really into labels, but she'd like a little affirmation that he felt the same way about her, and that he wasn't sleeping around with other people.


He kissed her forehead as he got up and walked across the room to grab his water. As he walked she admired his body; his hard chest and abs, and then his tight and firm as, and his cock ... boy how she loved that cock. She bit her lower lip as she stared at him, and already she was getting turned on again.

Even after a month she still couldn't believe that she actually had Jacob. She'd wanted him all through high school, but they're groups never really crossed paths. Now, in college and almost 21 years old she finally had the boy she'd fantasized about in high school. Who knew he'd had the same lustful feelings for her all along? She felt so lucky, and she was genuinely happy with him. She smiled as he took another huge gulp of water.

Her parents had gone out of town for the weekend, and her youngest sister, Elizabeth, had gone to a friends for the night. Elayna was God knows where last night, probably with some random guy, and she was happy to have the house to themselves. They were free to be loud and have fun without the fear of being caught by her parents or one of his three roommates.

Her thoughts were interrupted as she heard Jake gasp and slam the door. She shot up from her bed and looked at him with confusion. "What the hell?" she said with a smile. He looked as if he'd just seen a ghost.

"Nothing," he answered. "The, uh ... the dog ... what's her name...? She jumped up on me ... startled me. Claws, you know--" He gestured toward his nude body. "Could'a hurt. No worries, everything's cool."

She laughed at his response. "You're really afraid of a two foot dog?" she asked teasingly as she got up from her bed and walked towards him, taking a drink of his water. She smiled as she looked down and saw his cock hardening.

"Ready for round four?" she asked, biting her lower lip and pressing her body against his. She slid a hand down his stomach and to the base of his cock. "Your friend down here seems to be," she whispered in his ear, giving it a little nibble.

"Let's take a shower, I have my own bathroom. Nobody will interrupt us."

 

[Lustful_Male]

Panic began to set in -- more panic, that was -- when she said shower. The door Alex's sister Elayna had been standing at was the bathroom, and Jacob thought he could hear the water shaking the old house's pipes and was afraid Alex would hear them soon, too; she'd know they weren't alone, she'd know her sister had seen him naked, she'd know this erection was for the goddess in the family!

Fuck! was the word bouncing about inside his skull. What does she mean by HER bathroom...? Does she mean the one in the hall...? If she does, we sure as hell can't go out there. But if she doesn't, and we go to a different one, and the water is running in both ... she's gonna know we're not alone, TOO!

He knew what he wanted to do, of course -- flop her back down on the bed and go for her round four, here and now. But again, if she realized he was swollen because he'd seen Elayna ... Fuck!

He was damned if he did and damned if he didn't ... so he figured he might as well be damned while getting laid. He grabbed her and directed her back to the bed rapidly, forcing her playfully to her back and falling in between her legs. As he pressed his mouth to hers, engaging her in a deep, wet kiss, he shifted his hips back and forth until he met her wet, warm hole with his now rock-hard dick ... and pushed.

 

[lonelycollegegirl]

Alex worried for a moment at his hesitation as she felt his heartbeat quicken, knowing it wasn't from his arousal. He suddenly seemed .. nervous? What;s that about? she asked herself as she continued kissing his neck. She then thought perhaps he was nervous because he was finally going to make their relationship exclusive as people liked to put it. Her smile grew bigger as the thought occurred to her.

"Jake!" she yelled as she laughed as he tossed her on the bed. Her high pitched scream was sure to have been heard by the neighbors, which only made her laugh more. She tugged at his hair, pulling her close to him as she pressed her lips against his. His mouth against hers felt incredible; kissing him was always one of her favorite things. His tongue dancing with hers turned her on and caused her to grind her hips upward and against him.

As they kissed she spread her legs farther, welcoming him into her warm, wet pussy. She let out a whimper as he entered her. No matter how many times they had sex, she was still overwhelmed at his size inside of her. As they found a rhythm, she worked her hips with his to feel him deeper inside of her. Her nails dug into his back as he pushed in and out of her, and she let out a deep moan.

While he was moving in and out of her, Alex couldn't help but swear she heard water coming from the bathroom ... Is Elayna home already? she asked herself. She thought Elayna would at least have called or something first.. she knew that Alex was having company today. But she figured it was just like Elayna not to care about anyone but herself.