When a contradiction is impossible to resolve except by a lie, then we know that it is really a door.
-- Simone Weil, First and Last Notebooks, tr. Richard Rees
My grandfather and her grandfather fought an illegal duel. My father and her father were bitter rivals in politics and war. We were lovers. The hatred is bred in the bone.
I knew her so long ago. Madame C----, who had learnt her piano from Saint-Saens, schooled us in music. I was a listless pupil. My posture was never good. My hands were too small. Worst of all, I had no ear and never practised. Her playing was more advanced than mine, and she took pride in her superiority. Still, twice a week, we forged an uneasy truce in opposition to Madame C----.
I knew her also in Trieste, Zurich, Vienna before the War, Paris with its lights. But it was here that we loved and quarrelled. The city that brought us together now throws us apart. Twice before, I have essayed rapprochement. My letters were returned unopened each time.
It is inevitable that we see each other from time to time. People of a certain rank cannot deflect these encounters, even here. The patterns of my work displace me from certain obligations, but others remain. We are stiffly formal in these meetings. A curt nod carries voluminous expression. Or perhaps I only imagine this.
The lives of others are always enigma. The things we infer are but suggestions. We invent ourselves daily when we wake and reinvent ourselves again in dreams. We invent others also. This city is my contrivance. I will lie to you.
The rain falls in great planes. The sun is sequestered this day behind clouds.
In the post there is but one letter of any importance. M. will be arriving by land tomorrow. The last time she was here, M. stayed for three weeks. This time she is bringing R. The city has a magnetism that gathers us all.
-- Simone Weil, First and Last Notebooks, tr. Richard Rees
My grandfather and her grandfather fought an illegal duel. My father and her father were bitter rivals in politics and war. We were lovers. The hatred is bred in the bone.
I knew her so long ago. Madame C----, who had learnt her piano from Saint-Saens, schooled us in music. I was a listless pupil. My posture was never good. My hands were too small. Worst of all, I had no ear and never practised. Her playing was more advanced than mine, and she took pride in her superiority. Still, twice a week, we forged an uneasy truce in opposition to Madame C----.
I knew her also in Trieste, Zurich, Vienna before the War, Paris with its lights. But it was here that we loved and quarrelled. The city that brought us together now throws us apart. Twice before, I have essayed rapprochement. My letters were returned unopened each time.
It is inevitable that we see each other from time to time. People of a certain rank cannot deflect these encounters, even here. The patterns of my work displace me from certain obligations, but others remain. We are stiffly formal in these meetings. A curt nod carries voluminous expression. Or perhaps I only imagine this.
The lives of others are always enigma. The things we infer are but suggestions. We invent ourselves daily when we wake and reinvent ourselves again in dreams. We invent others also. This city is my contrivance. I will lie to you.
The rain falls in great planes. The sun is sequestered this day behind clouds.
In the post there is but one letter of any importance. M. will be arriving by land tomorrow. The last time she was here, M. stayed for three weeks. This time she is bringing R. The city has a magnetism that gathers us all.
Last edited: