The Godless

Purple Haze said:
Does "agnostic" mean you're not quite sure, but you're open to possibillities?


Pretty much. I am sure. I believe in God. I just don't believe in religion. I think the idea is rediculous.
 
AngelBoy said:
As for those with "political power", I think a "don't ask-don't tell" policy on religion could hide very important information as to how the leader would perform his or her job, because someone who follows a particular religion will practice its principles in every aspect of their life, not just their private life. The leader's decision's would be affected by his/her religious beliefs. Therefore, the public would be affected by these religious beliefs.
I disagree to a certain extent. For one thing I think that the problem is not that these people would practice their religion, but rather that they would let that practice or more likely an alliegance to their religious ties interfere with the execution of their duties. I am not saying that we should practice "don't ask/don't tell", but rather we should look at whether the candidate can/will execute their duties regardless of their religious beliefs.

I am a fundamentalist Christian, but if I was elected to office I would support a lot of policies that many fundamentalists would not like, such as not teaching Creationism except as a religious teaching, I would support removal of government interference in the bedroom and marital institutions (gay marriages would be legal and recognized), and so on.
 
Purple Haze said:
"Those Muslims, they think their way is the only right way."

"Those cults, thay start teaching their beliefs to children from the time they can talk."
But, but.... that's different! ;) :D
 
Just skipping right to my two cents worth, [god] forgive me if it's a repeat......


God's okay. Other than that stuff about idolatry and taking his name in vain, no other god before him, it all boils down to

Be Nice!

Religion on the other hand sucks. They ALL pervert that basic idea. One way or another.

More people have been killed in the name of God, than for any other reason. Religions do that!
 
ozme52 said:
More people have been killed in the name of God, than for any other reason. Religions do that!
Here we go again! :rolleyes:

In the 20th century alone, 163 million innocent civilian people have been murdered in the name of governmental regimes, mostly atheistic socialism. Source: "Death by Government" - Rummel (an authoritative and widely respected academic in the area of genocide).

How many have been murdered in the name of religion? Back up your claims with numbers and authoritative sources. People keep repeating this assertion without really knowing the facts or being able to backup their assertions. It just goes to prove the old adage about repeating the big lie often enough and most people will believe it.
 
Um. I didn't know that Protestants had adopted the Apocrypha into their version of the bible.

Other than that...I think I've said all I can say.
 
The Heretic said:
Here we go again! :rolleyes:

In the 20th century alone, 163 million innocent civilian people have been murdered in the name of governmental regimes, mostly atheistic socialism. Source: "Death by Government" - Rummel (an authoritative and widely respected academic in the area of genocide).

How many have been murdered in the name of religion? Back up your claims with numbers and authoritative sources. People keep repeating this assertion without really knowing the facts or being able to backup their assertions. It just goes to prove the old adage about repeating the big lie often enough and most people will believe it.

Hey! Quit using statistics. 70% of statistics are wrong! Heh!

I have "LORE" on my side. :D
 
ozme52 said:
Besides, just because it's "government mandated" doesn't mean they didn't use religion or god as a rallying cry.

http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/welcome.html
Read your own references - it contains the numbers I referred to. Of all of those regimes, how many used religion? Surely not the USSR which murdered 62 million, not Communist China which murdered 35 million, not even Nazi Germany which murdered 20 million.

An argument can be made for Japan which murdered 6 million in the name of their god; their emperor. But when you add up all the available numbers, many many more people have been murdered in the name of "godless" governments than in the name or religon or God, which totally disputes your claim that "More people have been killed in the name of God, than for any other reason. Religions do that!".

Thank you for providing a URL to prove my assertions.
 
The Heretic said:
Read your own references - it contains the numbers I referred to. Of all of those regimes, how many used religion? Surely not the USSR which murdered 62 million, not Communist China which murdered 35 million, not even Nazi Germany which murdered 20 million.

An argument can be made for Japan which murdered 6 million in the name of their god; their emperor. But when you add up all the available numbers, many many more people have been murdered in the name of "godless" governments than in the name or religon or God, which totally disputes your claim that "More people have been killed in the name of God, than for any other reason. Religions do that!".

Thank you for providing a URL to prove my assertions.

Regardless of the official state doctrine, Nazi Germany killed many its citizens because of their religions. Many more for ethnic purity "because god made the Aryan race superior." They did likewise to many conquered people as in Poland. In other conquered states, they employed locals who had their own "grudges" such as Croatia, Serbia, Macedonia, et.al. where many moslems, jews, and the wrong kinds of Catholics died at the hands of the collaborators.

We'll have to agree to disagree.
 
ozme52 said:
Regardless of the official state doctrine, Nazi Germany killed many its citizens because of their religions. Many more for ethnic purity "because god made the Aryan race superior." They did likewise to many conquered people as in Poland. In other conquered states, they employed locals who had their own "grudges" such as Croatia, Serbia, Macedonia, et.al. where many moslems, jews, and the wrong kinds of Catholics died at the hands of the collaborators.

We'll have to agree to disagree.
Actually I do agree - nazi Germany did murder in part due to their religion, but their religion was a strange mixture of belief in Aryanism, Thulism, National Socialism and patriotic fervor. But even if you include Nazi Germany on the side of religion, the numbers still add up lopsidedly in favor of "godless" governments - that is unless you argue that Socialism in the USSR was a religion, and I don't think you can seriously make that argument, not even in Communist China.

If you read any of Rummel's writings, you will see what is the true problem; not government nor religion, but rather concentrated and totalitarian power. Power does corrupt, and it also murders. Religion used to have a lot more power than it does today. Now governments have a lot more power and have far surpassed religions in their ability to repress, oppress and murder - by several orders of magnitude.

The lesson/moral? Not that religion or government is to blame, but rather the common factor they both share or shared; power, especially totalitarian power. Therefore, governments should be constituted such that they cannot accumulate such totalitarian power, and such that an individuals Natural Rights are always respected and protected by both convention and law. Therefore religions should remain private institutions and not government institutions.
 
Holy crap. I didn't think this thread would grow legs. I swear to God this was a porn board when I got here.
 
The Heretic said:
Actually I do agree - nazi Germany did murder in part due to their religion, but their religion was a strange mixture of belief in Aryanism, Thulism, National Socialism and patriotic fervor. But even if you include Nazi Germany on the side of religion, the numbers still add up lopsidedly in favor of "godless" governments - that is unless you argue that Socialism in the USSR was a religion, and I don't think you can seriously make that argument, not even in Communist China.

If you read any of Rummel's writings, you will see what is the true problem; not government nor religion, but rather concentrated and totalitarian power. Power does corrupt, and it also murders. Religion used to have a lot more power than it does today. Now governments have a lot more power and have far surpassed religions in their ability to repress, oppress and murder - by several orders of magnitude.

The lesson/moral? Not that religion or government is to blame, but rather the common factor they both share or shared; power, especially totalitarian power. Therefore, governments should be constituted such that they cannot accumulate such totalitarian power, and such that an individuals Natural Rights are always respected and protected by both convention and law. Therefore religions should remain private institutions and not government institutions.

I'll come, say about half way, and meet ya somewhere (unspecified) in the middle.

Shake?
<<==hand outstretched.
 
Dixon Carter Lee said:
Holy crap. I didn't think this thread would grow legs. I swear to God this was a porn board when I got here.

How about this Dixon?

Religion covers us up. :(

God meant us to be nekkid and screw around. :p

But God never meant us to screw like minks, :mad:


That's only twice per year!! :eek:

:devil:
 
ozme52 said:
I'll come, say about half way, and meet ya somewhere (unspecified) in the middle.

Shake?
<<==hand outstretched.
Oh alright, if you insist. ;)
 
Dang! I go to work and miss out on the fun. Well, I have something I feel like adding, so I will. (I hope JMJ won't mind if I snag his argument.)

There are a lot of different bibles out there. Maybe some were translated sloppily or in favor of particular tenets of belief, but I think it's safe to say that in all cases, the translators believed they were guided by God. What they produced would be considered inspired despite what any other equally reverent translators came up with.

So now a person develops beliefs, then shops for and chooses the bible that conforms to those beliefs. No other bible is relevant to that person. That person may claim that one particular bible provides the words he or she was meant to have, and that one particular translation is inspired by God, and no other.

But anybody that thinks this way should perhaps reflect on the story of the Tower of Babel. It seems clear from the story that God's intent was to keep humans from understanding each other. The evidence of various ostensibly-inspired biblical translations suggests that He's still pursuing that course.
 
Back
Top