The Dare

BlueEyedLady

Literotica Guru
Joined
Jul 1, 2003
Posts
1,893
OOC: Been role playing with some wonderful people on some threads with some heavy duty plots and I thought I would take some time to play a lighter role.

I was thinking of a story about a girl in college who takes a dare to go into a supposidly haunted house which had been the property of a wealthy and eccentric elderly man who has died. The man had gotten the reputation for being a loner and, as these things go, stories popped up about him and they grew until, after his death, it is said that the house was haunted.

Unknown to my char and her friends who put the dare to her in a moment of drunken relvery, the grandson of the man who died has inherited the place and has come to take inventory, etc and has decided to spend the night in the house instead of getting a motel room. And, as you might guess, my char is caught in the act of breaking and entering.

Knowing that her scholorship to college will be in danger if she is arrested, she begs him to consider an alternative to calling the police. What that altrenative is will be reached IC by myself and whatever male would be willing to pick up the role of the grandson.


IC: I took another drink of beer and peered bleerily around at my companions. How many cans of the stuff had I had? I had lost count. But who cared? It was the weekend, the mid finals were done and we had all passed. Some had just squeeked by but they were still passing grades. In celebration, I and some of my college friends had decided that a beach party was in order. The beach party soon became a drinking bash with most of the guys gettng into a macho contest while the girls sat around and bet on one or the other and laughed.

When they couldn't see the glasses or cans of alcohol clear enough to make it to their mouths, they called a halt and sat around the bonfire someone had built. Damned if I could remember who or when. Then, as things usually go in these situations, the guys had pulled out the ghost stories to try and scare the girls, who were too drunk to be scared anyway, and get them to snuggle close and, maybe, go from there.

As ghost stories go in this town, talk turned eventually to Old Man Withers who owned the huge house on the edge of town. Didn't ghosts always live in old houses on the edge of town? I rolled my eyes and then tried to regain my balance before I fell off the deadwood log as I was unbalanced by the change of eyesight.

"It's true," Kevin was saying in a spooky voice which had most of the girls giggling,"He haunts that damn house. I've seen his ghost in the window at midnight. He stares out with that mean look he always gave anyone who approached his property and you could swear that he was going to come down and chase after you!"

Mike snorted and slapped Kevin on his back, unbalancing him and making him fall on his knees from the log he was sitting on.

"You never went near that house," His roommate said,"I saw you turn white as a sheet a mile from it and turn tale the day you came back and said that you had been there. I was right behind you, remember."

On of the girls, a new one on campus and, I thought, from out-of-town, was the only one looking scared.

"Is it true that he grabbed kids who came onto his land and chained them up in the basement?" She said in a small whisper.

Kevin, getting to his feet and brushing himself off, glared at Mike and then nodded, seeing a chance to make it with the new girl.

"Yup," He said, relishing the tale. "And he would only feed them bread and water and make them work for him until they collapsed from exahustion and hunger. Then he would feed them to his dogs who he had trained to attack kids on sight."

"Bullshit!"

Had that come from me? What the hell, I didn't believe in that crap anyway.

The others turned to me and I pointed with a waivering finger at them all.

"Bullshit," I repeated with a smile,"Stories and...and...other stuff." I wished I could think straight enough to form a better argument. "He was an old man who hated people. That's it. And he's dead. Which means there's no one and nothing in that house but old furniture and stuff covered under blankets. The family didn't even care enough about him to come to see him or get his stuff. It's going to rot there just like Old Man Withers."

I nodded, knowingly, my long chestnut hair falling in my eyes and sat down on the sand heavily, the log under me suddenly disappearing as I tried to make my point with the heavy headshake.

Mike leaned forward and looked at me with a grin. Oh shit! What did he have in mind? The group practical joker and tormenter, he always had something up his sleeve to make the others wince and throw things at him.

"Okay, Deb," He said, his grin widening,"If you're so sure that there's nothing there, than why don't you go in there yourself?"

"Yeah," Said Kevin, taking up his friend's cause,"Go in there and prove it to us."

Sherry, the one person that I thought was my friend piped in. "But, how will we know if she really goes in there? She could pretend to and no one would know."

"Thanks, Sherry," I thought with a scowl,"I'll return the favor some day."

"We'll be watching," Mike said with a shrug and then Kevin piped in. "Nuh huh! That place has a long, winding driveway and I'm not going any closer to that place than I have to. Sherry's right. She oculd go up the driveway, stand there, come back and tell us she went in and we wouldn't know."

I started to protest but Mike was speaking again. "Okay, the house is full of stuff like Deb said. All she has to do is go in, get something of the Old Man's and come back. It has to be something that she can only get while inside the house though so she can't cheat."

Again I tried to protest but Sherry cut in again. "Ohhh! How about a picture or a candlestick or something?"

"I don't care what," Mike said with a shrug,"But I bet she is too chicken to do it."

Okay, I didn't want to do this in the first place but the alchol had pretty much dulled any senses I had left to make a good decision. So I made a bad one.

"You're on!" I said and stumbled to my feet and made my way to one of the cars, got in, realized it wasn't mine and then got out.

"Woah," Mike said coming up behind me,"You can't drive like that."

"You can't drive when you're sober," I retorted to the giggles of the girls,"So whose going to do it?"

"I will," Volunteered the new girl and I added her to my list of people to get back at once I was sober.


So it was that we all came to be at the gates of Wither's house. The place was dark and, I had to admit, spooky, but I wasn't going to let this bunch see that I was even the tiniest bit scared. Bravely, if unsteadily, I walked up the drive, leaving them behind and made my way to the cellar door which most of us knew had had the lock broken a long time ago when some kids tried to get in and steal some things after Withers died. They were caught and, as far as we knew, no one had tried again. But the lock hadn't been replaced and I found myself in the basement in short order.

Hanging onto the handrail, I made my way down stairs without killing myself and then up the stairs to the main house. Pushing the door open, I peered out into complete darkness. Taking a deep breath and trying to get my head to stop swimming, I entered the place and looked around.

Sure enough there were paintings, furniture and other things covered by dust clothes. Nothing to be afraid of I told myself. Still, it was on tiptoe that I went across the room to the mantelpiece and looked for a photograph. There was none. Damn! No candle holders either. Leaning against the mantlepiece, I looked around. There were lots of heavy furniture but no little pieces that I could carry easily. Maybe someone had come and taken things after those guys who broke in.

Then I saw it on the floor, the glint of metal in the moonlight coming in from the window. Going over and picking it up, I looked at it, turning it over in my hands. It was an old fashioned pocket watch andl, when I opened it, I could see faint engraving in it. I thought I made out some initials and the last one looked like it was a 'W' so it probably belonged to the old man.

With a girn, I clutched my prize and started back out the way I had come. Only I had gotten turned around and stumbled over a footstool that crashed as I hit the floor with a curse.

Scrambling to my feet the best that I could, I made to run out the front door when I head something overhead from the second floor. It was a creaking and sliding noise. My face when pale and I could feel myself start to shake. Maybe the guys were right, maybe the place was haunted and I had just disturbed the ghost of Old Man Withers!

Making my stiff legs move, I was halfway to the front door when I heard a voice behind me.

"Stop right there!" It commanded and I felt ice running down my spine,"Who are you and what are you doing in my house?!"
 
Last edited:
Caleb Withers:

I was asleep in the only room I'd begun to clean up, Granddad's bedroom, when I heard the clomping around downstairs.

I got out of bed, in just a pair of pajama bottoms and picked up my Louisville slugger, my home run hitter, and headed down stairs bare foot.

I'd just reached the bottom of the stairs when the silouette came from the living room staggering unsteadily toward the front door.
The person was shorter, smaller framed than I am, but had something in their hand that glinted in the moonlight coming through the dirty windows over the door.

Hefting the bat, "Stop right there!" I commanded as I got ready to hit another home run if necessary, with their head that is,"Who are you and what are you doing in my house?!"


OOC: I waited almost an hour to take the part to give others a chance. *g
 
Debra Cassidy

OOC: LOL Well, thanks for picking up the part. As always, a pleasure to post with you once again.

IC: I stood frozen. My mind said run, my legs said 'no way' and the alcohol had my head so dizzy that the door was swimming. Where there had been only one door there were now three.

Swallowing hard, I listened for some other noise to go with, what seemed to be, a disemodied voice.

"Turn around, Deb," I whispered to myself,"Turn around and you will see there's nothing there. It's the alcohol or the guys are playing a trick and trying to scare you."

And doing a damn good job of it too, if that were the case. Turning slowly, I brought my eyes up and around the room, nothing. No one by the mantal piece, that was good. My heart was just about to settle down when my gaze swung to the stairs.

There, at the bottom of the stairway was, to my mind, a HUGE shadow with something raised as if to strike. My God! The rumors were true. Old Man Withers was haunting the house and ready to do damage to anyone who crossed his threshold.

With a strangle scream, I backed away from the 'ghost' and stumbled toward the door, catching my heel on the rug on the floor and crashing down hard on my backside.

Scooting across the floor, my white shorts probably a dirty mess as I pushed my way through the dust and dirt there, I cried out something like,"Nooo! I'm sorry! It's just a watch. I'll put it back! Just don't hurt me!"
 
Last edited:
Caleb Withers:

"You will stay right where you are.
"You will not move an inch. You're a burlar and a thief that's what you are and I'm calling the cops," Cleb says as he moves closer now aware it's a drunk girl, probably from the local college, who's sitting on his floor.
 
Debra

I looked up as the figure approached. When it came into the light I got a shock. It was definately not Old Man Withers. For one, he wasn't old even if he definately was a man. But he had the same look on his face that Withers always had when we trespassed on his property.

Through the alcohol haze, I could dimily make out what he was saying. It took a minute for it to sink in. When it did, my heart dropped into my stomach. If he called the cops, if he had me arrested my scholorship would go down the drain. I would have to call my parents and tell them that I was kicked out of the college and that I was in jail. My eyes widened in more horror than the thought of Old Man Withers coming after me. Actually, I probably would have preferred that to having to call them from jail.

"N...n...no!" I said thickly,"No, please, you can't...I wasn't taking anything...not really...I just...I just..."

I held out the watch and let it dangle from my hand, thrusting it at him. "It was just to prove I was here." I tried to explain though it didn't seem like I was making much sense even to myself. "The guys...they said I had to prove I was here...I...I wasn't going to keep it or sell it or anything..."

Well, of course I would have kept it. It would have been the prize of the dorm. Something from the Withers' house and stories of how I had gone in to get it. But things had turned wrong. Terribly, terribly wrong.

"Please," I begged him,"Don't...don't call the police. I can't lose my scholorship. I can't face my parents if I did that!"
 
Caleb Withers:

"Bullshit!" he blurts out, "You damned sure would have kept it bitch and we both know it!"

"Nah, it's the cops and jail for you. That'll teach the college kids not to screw with my house and property unless they're willing to pay the price," he says as he stands towering over her as she's still on the floor.
 
Debra

Damn, damn, damn. I wished I was a million miles away right now. I wished I had never taken that damn dare. I wished I had my hands on Mike's neck right now. I bet they had heard me scream and had high tailed it out of here without looking back. Cowards!

"Please," I begged him,"I didn't know the house was sold. We thought...the guys thought that the house was haunted by Old Man Withers. I wanted to prove them wrong. I was just trying to prove I was in the house."

I swallowed hard and reached a trembling hand up to push the strap of my tank top back on my shoulder. Sometime during the whole episode it had fallen down, probably while I was trying to scoot to safety.

"Please," I said again in desperation,"I'll...I'll make it up to you. If you don't call the cops I'll make it up to you somehow. I promise. N...name it and...and I'll do whatever you want. I'll come by and help clean up the house or something. Just...please...don't call the cops."
 
Caleb Withers:

He reaches down and pulls her to her feet as she begs and pleads with him not to call the cops on her and have her arrested.

Once she's standing Caleb drags her into the library and over to a desk. He puts her in the desk chair, opens a drawer and takes out a pen and paper.

"Write out a confession. Confess to breaking into Old Man Withershouse, my grandfather's house that's now my house while I slept upstairs, and how you did it. Confess to the fact you were stealing his gold pocket watch, taking it out of the house when you were caught in the act.
"Then date it and sign it and we'll talk about maybe giving you a break."
 
Debra

I stumbled along behind him while he dragged me along. The thought going through my mind was that he was very strong. There was no way I was getting out of this if he didn't want me to.

I was sat down in the chair with a small 'oomph' and a pen and paper thrust into my shaking hands. I looked at it with a dazed expression, trying to remember what these things were used for. He spelled it out very plainly for me and my jaw dropped when I heard that he was a relative of Old Withers. Dear God, could it get any worse?

It could. I now had the choice of dragging my friends into this by including the dare in my confession or shouldering all the blame, and the concequences myself. I decided to not mention the rats. I would deal with them later.

Squinting my eyes, I focused enough to write out that I had broken in through the cellar door and come in the house with the intention of taking something from it. That I had found the watch and was going to take it out of the house.

Putting the date on the corner and scrawling my name on it the best I could, I shoved it over to him and put my head on my arms on the desk, feeling a wave of dizziness come over me and my stomach churn. Too much booze and excitement will do that to you.
 
Caleb Withers:

He picks up the paper, grips her arm again and leads her upstairs to a bathroom, the only other habitable one in the house. It's spotless.

"Use the toilet don't heave on the floor. I'll be right outside waiting."

He goes out and closes the door behind him.
 
Debra

Only moments after the door shut, I was gripping the edge of the toilet and heaving the contents of my stomach into it. I don't know how long I knelt there groaning over it but the spasms didn't seem to quit soon enough.

Once I knew that I wasn't going to be able to bring anything else up, I reached up with an arm that seemed numb and flushed the toilet, sliding down to the floor and putting my head against the wall. I could feel the sweat cooling on my brow.

Looking around, I found a towel and wiped my face with it. He would probably bitch, this young Withers, but I would replace it when I could.

Dragging myself to my feet, I stumbled to the door, dragging the towel. Opening it, I looked up at him.

"Okay," I croaked out,"I'm done." Holding up the white towel like it was a flag of surrender, I added,"I used this. Do you want me to write out another confession promising to replace it?"
 
Caleb Withers:

When she opens the door he takes a good look at her and turns her around as soon as she spoken. Back in the bathroom again he closes the door saying, "No, you're not done.
"You look like hell. You smell like stale beer and vomit.
"Undress and get into the tub and shower."

"No bullshit about it. Just do it and stay there til I get you a robe to wear," he says holding up her confession where she can't help but see it.
 
Debra

My jaw dropped and I looked at him. Hey, I said I would help him clean house, not strip for him. I looked at the confession though and knew that he had me where he wanted me and he was right, I did stink.

With a sigh, I began to remove my clothes. Sliding my tank top off and dropping it to the floor, I fumbled with my bra, finally getting the latches undone. Sand from the beach spilled out of it along with my firm, if a bit large tits whose nippled hardened the minute they hit the air. It wasn't only my friends who were being traitors tonight.

Unzipping my shorts, I hooked two fingers into the waistband and shimmied out of them. My panties, white lace, were next their removal revealing a firm, rounded ass with a small butterfly tatoo on the small of my back just above my right buttock.

Now my clothes were in a pile on the floor along with a good helping of sand. I looked down numbly at my feet where there was only one sandal. I must have lost the other one somewhere between the car and the bathroom. Damned if I would retrace my steps in the nude to find it.

Stepping in the shower, ignoring the man that stood there watching me, I turned on the shower and yelped as icy cold water hit me. Quckly turning the knobs to adjust for a warmer temperature, I let it wash over me as I leaned my arms against the cool tiles.

Washing my hair with some shampoo I found, I was almost feeling better. I did what he said and lathered up slowly, enjoying the feeling of getting clean, even under the circumstances.

"Hey!" I said as the thought struck me,"I don't have any clean clothes! How am I supposed to go outside like this? Or is the object to get me washed up and back into my dirty things?"
 
Last edited:
Caleb Withers:

Caleb leaned against the bathroom wall watching as she unveiled one sexy as hell and tight body as she undressed.

He chuckled when the cold water hit her wondering why she didn't adjust the water first, but chalking it up to drunk and perhaps embarrassment not letting her think straight.

When she says, "Hey! I don't have any clean clothes! How am I supposed to go outside like this? Or is the object to get me washed up and back into my dirty things?" he just chuckles as his eyes travel all over her naked and now wet body.

"Outside naked? Who said anything about going outside tonight? I didn't.
"Keep washing. Get all of you squeaky clean and shampoo too.
"I could hardly stand being in the same room with you smelling as bad as you did a minute ago."
 
Debra

I gave him a glare he couldn't help but catch when he eyed my body and went back to my shower, turning my back pointedly on the leetch. My body was kept in shape by running track and I knew it looked good. I had had the boyfriends to prove it. I had even encouraged looks when I passed guys at the college. However, this man's stares were not welcome or wanted.

"And I suppose you never went out partying with friends and drinking too much," I said over my shoulder.

Then I added pointedly,"And I'm not too drunk to make it back to the dorm. My car is at the beach. I can make it on foot and then drive from there."
 
Last edited:
Caleb Wither:

He laughs and replies, " Of course I did. I've prayed to the porcelin god several times, but that doesn't mean I like the smell of vomit."

"I think you're missing the point. Who said you were leaving tonight. I didn't.
"You're staying her until morning so I can think about what I'll have you do so I don't carry the confession to the district attorney and have a warrant issued for your arrrest."

"By the way, what's your name anyway? Can't be calling you hey you and I'm Caleb Withers so you don't either," he says with a little smile.
 
Debra

I turned to look at him over my shoulder. I had to admit he had a nice smile and he was rather good looking. If it had been under different circumstances....

I sighed, it wasn't and this wasn't a pleasure outing. He had caught me doing something stupid and now he had the goods on me as they say.

Making sure to clean every spot, I lather up and scrub my underarms and chest, letting the washcloth move down to my breasts, automatically as I ponder my situation. The flesh there moves with my hand as I run the cloth under and over them, the nipples tightening as the cloth rubs against them.

As he asks my name, I look at him a bit startled and then stammer out,"Deb...Debra Cassidy." I turn back to my washing, running the cloth between my legs, making sure to get all of the sand out of the creases there and then over my ass, wincing as I feel what will soon become a bruise, I assume from where I tripped and fell after seeing my 'ghost'.

Rinsing off, I reach up to squeeze the water from my hair and turn to look at him, my green eyes questioning. The hell with modesty, there was nothing left to keep him from seeing. He had pretty much seen it all.

"Can I get out now?" I asked with raised eyebrows,"I promise I don't stink anymore. And if you are going to insist that I stay here tonight, even if I promise not to run away, than I hope you have an extra toothbrush because I may smell nice and clean but I feel like something died in my mouth."
 
Last edited:
Caleb Withers

"Nope stay there and let the hot water give you a good rinse. While you shampoo and creme rinse your hair I'll get you a clean towel and a robe to wear."

He chuckles and says, "Yeah, I remember that taste and not fondly either.
"I got a new one today and haven't opened it yet. You can have it."

He goes to the vanity and picks it up and opens it then tosses away the wrapper and picks up the tube of tooth paste as Debra has turned and is leaning back a bit to wet her hair really well.

When he turns he stares momentarily as he drinks in the sight of her damned hot naked body arched back into the shower's spray, then he walks to the tub and holds out the tooth brush and paste saying, "Here you are. May as well get rid of that dead critter taste in your mouth too Debra."

Being so close he must have startled her because she made a little yelp sound and she turned quickly toward him. Her breasts swung and hit his extended hand leaving no doubt in his mind that they were as firm as they looked and all her too.

Her balance still wasn't the best and when the swayed and seemed about to fall his empty hand gripped her arm to steady her, forearm across a nipple and breast.

Looking at her face, not at what he was feeling with his forearm, "You okay? Have your balance again Debra?"
 
Debra

Being under the water, I didn't hear him come up and wasn't prepared for his voice right next to me. I must have jumped a foot in the air and, with the alcohol not worked out of my system yet and the slippery tub I somehow ended in his arms, our faces mere inches away from each other.

It took me a moment to realize he was talking to me. Damn, a woman would get lost in eyes and arms like this.. That thought jolted me back to where I was, who I was with and the position I was in. Swallowing hard, I pulled away from him and fumbled for the toothbrush and toothpaste.

"Um...yeah," I mumbled as I concentrated on connecting the tube and the bristles with my shaking hand,"Thanks for catching me."

Before I could say anything even remotely stupid, I shoved the toothbrush in my mouth and began to brush vigorously, trying to ingore the feeling along my breast where he had touched me.

Once I had assured that every pearly white was clean three times over, I began to shampoo my hair again, scrubbing hard enough to take skin off just to get away from the thoughts that burned into my mind. Another shampoo and cream rinse later, I was thoroughly clean and ready to get out of the, now, tepid water.
 
Caleb Withers:

He left Debra brushing her teeth with the bathroom door open and when to his bedroom and got is new mini camcorder. Back in the hall he leaned against the bannister and use it to record Debra as she shampooed her hair twice and creme rinsed it.

He didn't miss any movement of her tits as she stood eyes shut shampooing and even zoomed in to he got her from the breasts up before panning down to her pussy framed by her wide stance to keep her balance.

He got her as she leaned back, arching as she'd done before and got close ups and of her whole body. He got her when she turned, flipped her hair forward and bent over to rinse once more giving him a great view of her ass and pussy from the back.

When she stood up he returned to his room and put the camcorder on a shelf facing the bed and put it's remote, for recording or playing, on the night stand beside the bed. Then he got her a short terry robe from the closet, but took off it's belt and left it on the floor under the clothing.

Caleb returned with the robe to find her standing and waiting as he'd told her to do. The robe was hung on a hook on the back of the bathroom door and he got out two towels and walked to the tub carrying them, "Okay Debra come on out not. If you're not clean now you never will be and can't have a hot looking woman like you turning into a prune," he chuckles, "That body's not meant to have wrinkles nature didn't put there already."
 
Debra

I didn't know how to take what he was saying. As a compliment or an insult. I finally figured that, in the position I was in, I couldn't afford to be insulted and so took the towels, wrapped one around my hair and dried off briskly with the other one.

Tucking it around me, I began to dry my hair with the other towel, bending over to flip the back of my long hair down so that I could dry all of it. I knew that my ass could be seen from that vantage point, and I knew that my tits jiggled with every move I made while drying my hair. I was beyond the point of caring now. As I said before, there wasn't much he hadn't seen. Thank goodness no one would know about this night but him and me. If he decided not to go to the DA that is.

Finished with my hair, I gave him that, I'm-lost, look again. "A comb?" I asked him gesturing to my wet and unrully hair. On the best days I could untangle and calm my reddish brown locks to a symbolance of order. When it was wet it had a mind of it's own and now curled around my shoulder, neck and face in small tendrils. It was going to be hell to fight with tomorrow with no blow dryer, hair spray or gel.
 
Caleb:

"I think it looks hot that way Debra. Very natural and sexy," he says as he takes a comb and styling brush from a drawer and turns back.

"Take your pick," he says coming close to hand either to her.
 
Debra

I gave him a look that said I was catching the meaning underneathi his words. And it scared me. Taking the comb from him, being very aware at how close he was to me, I began to pull it through my hair, thankful he had the creme rinse or it would have been a complete mass of tangles that no comb could go through.

Swallowing and trying to gather my thoughts, I said quietly, "I wasn't aware that looking sexy and hot was part of our bargain."
 
Caleb:

"It may not have been if you were short, fat and ugly Debra, but we both know just how far from the truth that is, don't we?"

"You can choose which you want to use the towel you're wearing or the robe. Of course you also have another choice. Since I've already seen all of you, you can also choose neither one," he says leaning against the vanity and watching her brushing her hair, all of her.

Her lifted arms make her very full breasts rise higher and move like crazy under the towel as she brushes. The bottom of the towel lifts letting his see her smooth pussy clearly.

I'd chose neither personally, but it's up to you."
 
Debra

I finished combing my hair, not that it did any good...it still curled and wound around my face and neck, and then handed him the comb back and reached up to get the robe.

Slinging it over my shoulders, I said, "Well, thank you for letting me make that decision at least. I think I will chose both, thank you." Reaching around to tie the belt, I look down in surprise as my hands meet with nothing. I groaned. Oh great, now I would have to pin it to my body with my arms.

With a sigh, I grabbed both sides, pulled them sharply together and folded my arms across my stomach to keep it in place. Moving to the door, I held the robe with one arm and opened the door, quickly moving my arm back when it was open.

Looking around, I thought struck me. "Where do I sleep?" I said in puzzlement,"On the couch in the living room?" Frankly I couldn't see myself sleeping anywhere in this house. Especially alone. It still had the reputation of being haunted and the feeling of being quite creepy. Caleb Withers may not mind, not having been around his grandfather very much, at least as far as I knew, and not having heard all the stories, but I knew if I were to sleep on the couch, every sound would keep me awake and hudled under the covers.
 
Back
Top