The Chicago Killing Fields

Violence involving guns is an issue within the broader issue of violence in general. It's all about sets and subsets and all that. Oftentimes, compartmentalizing an issue has value, which is also why we distinguish between gun-related homicide and gun-related suicide. They're different and need to be treated as such.
My suggestion is that guns and violence are different and need to be treated as such.

And I don't think I've said that we have an American Gun Problem (if I did, it was a mistake). I said we have an American Gun Violence Problem. That's carries an entirely different connotation.

And yes, if people were running around whacking eighty people in a major city with hammers, and killing eight of them in a single weekend, and hundreds every year, then I would say we have an American Hammer Violence Problem.

In neither case am I blaming the tool. I'm just identifying the tool used most prominently because that has to factor into any solution. The violence itself is the problem, of course. And as kbear said, it's the gangbangers who must bear the brunt of the blame in this instance.
And if there were an American Hammer Violence Problem, how would hammers factor into a solution to the violence?
 
Byron, what percentage of women in the United States choose nylon hose for committing suicide? Without that number, there's nothing to compare with your statistic of 35% using guns. Are there any other tools used for suicide by women more often than guns? That too is important to know. My best guess would be deliberate overdose but that's hard to define precisely because a high percentage of those attempts faily so it begs the question if it's actually an attempt at suicide, or a call for help.

Anyway, it's a silly discussion. I told you why I mentioned guns and suicide together. There was no intent of inferring a nefarious anti-gun message. It's just what we happened to be talking about at the time. kbear mentioned prescription drugs in relation to violence involving guns. I suggested it was a factor in suicides, perhaps, but not so much so in gang shootings. That's all. No hidden agenda.

And I have no doubt that if guns were not available, that people who really want to kill themselves would manage without them. I never suggested otherwise, nor did I suggest that guns lead to a higher rate of suicide.
 
My suggestion is that guns and violence are different and need to be treated as such.

And if there were an American Hammer Violence Problem, how would hammers factor into a solution to the violence?

And my suggestion is that gun violence is a subset of violence, and needs to be treated as such. Guns themselves are a non-issue to me. People using guns to kill other people is an issue.

And if hammers replace guns as the weapon of choice in gangland killings, then we should all celebrate because their effective range is so much less.

To answer your question, we should do the studies identified in Perg's link (which is where I got involved in the discussion), only focusing on the culture of hammer-killing rather than gun-killing. Are hammers showing up in violent video games? Do the summer blockbusters and a plethora of TV dramas involve hammer-throwing rather than shootouts and what effect if any does that have in the use of hammers to kill nationwide? Are educational efforts aimed at youth in an attempt to reduce hammer killing effective? Does hammer control actually work? Would background checks required to buy a hammer actually reduce hammer-related crime? That sort to thing.
 
Byron, what percentage of women in the United States choose nylon hose for committing suicide? Without that number, there's nothing to compare with your statistic of 35% using guns.
Poisoning 31%, hanging 17%. Those three are 83%. The rest I don't know, but I can find out if you're interested.

Are there any other tools used for suicide by women more often than guns?
Not singly, but poisoning and hanging account for 48%, all non-firearm suicides for 65%.

That too is important to know. My best guess would be deliberate overdose but that's hard to define precisely because a high percentage of those attempts faily so it begs the question if it's actually an attempt at suicide, or a call for help.
The 31% are dead bodies. Attempts which fail would certainly be higher than for firearms or hanging, both of which have better success rates than poison.

Anyway, it's a silly discussion. I told you why I mentioned guns and suicide together. There was no intent of inferring a nefarious anti-gun message.
No, not on your part: it was Sean Renaud that picked up that ball and ran with it, as I was sure someone would.

It's just what we happened to be talking about at the time. kbear mentioned prescription drugs in relation to violence involving guns. I suggested it was a factor in suicides, perhaps, but not so much so in gang shootings. That's all. No hidden agenda.
No worries; it's just a really common anti-gun propaganda item. Four out of five doctors say people will shoot themselves if they get hold of a gun, y'know?

And I have no doubt that if guns were not available, that people who really want to kill themselves would manage without them. I never suggested otherwise, nor did I suggest that guns lead to a higher rate of suicide.
Yes. As I mentioned, Renaud insisted on that derailment, although, to be fair, it was probably just a pre-programmed autonomic response.
 
Rahm Emanuel Blames Chicago’s Warzone Violence On Lack Of Gun Control…




It’s not easy being this clueless, he must practice at it.

Via Chicago Sun-Times:


Calling gun control the “weak link” in Chicago’s public safety chain, Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Tuesday renewed his pitch for stiffer sentencing, background checks before gun purchases and a revised and strengthened assault weapons ban.

The mayor’s political call to arms follows a Fourth of July weekend bloodbath that saw the Chicago Sun-Times tally 38 separate shooting incidents from Wednesday evening through Sunday afternoon, including 10 homicides.

“Gun control . . . is the weak link in the chain of public safety for the city of Chicago,” the mayor said.

“Our police are doing an effective job. They need to do better. But, they are doing an effective job. We are investing in our kids by making sure they have the type of after-school programs and summer jobs at an unprecedented level. Each year, we’re growing each of those investments for our kids to be in a safe, secure area. We also challenge our parents to do the right thing. . . . The city of Chicago, to further drive its shooting and homicide rate down, needs a number of things.”
:rolleyes:
 
Rahm Emanuel Blames Chicago’s Warzone Violence On Lack Of Gun Control…




It’s not easy being this clueless, he must practice at it.

Via Chicago Sun-Times:


Calling gun control the “weak link” in Chicago’s public safety chain, Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Tuesday renewed his pitch for stiffer sentencing, background checks before gun purchases and a revised and strengthened assault weapons ban.

The mayor’s political call to arms follows a Fourth of July weekend bloodbath that saw the Chicago Sun-Times tally 38 separate shooting incidents from Wednesday evening through Sunday afternoon, including 10 homicides.

“Gun control . . . is the weak link in the chain of public safety for the city of Chicago,” the mayor said.

“Our police are doing an effective job. They need to do better. But, they are doing an effective job. We are investing in our kids by making sure they have the type of after-school programs and summer jobs at an unprecedented level. Each year, we’re growing each of those investments for our kids to be in a safe, secure area. We also challenge our parents to do the right thing. . . . The city of Chicago, to further drive its shooting and homicide rate down, needs a number of things.”
:rolleyes:

Seems like they like to waste money. Keep tossing money at the problem and let the gangs remain untouched. :cool:
 
38 separate shooting incidents and only 10 homicides.


The only thing they need is more range time.
 
Back
Top