the beginning of a story--feedback req'd

emanuellevinas

Experienced
Joined
May 21, 2011
Posts
40
Mary loved her job. She really did. The hours sometimes dragged on. She worked late and often wanted to just be wrapped up on her couch reading, the one she loved more than anything was the feel of a book in her hands, a fireplace, her dog closeby.

It was Tuesday. 9 p.m. was approaching. Soon, it would be time to lock up and head out.

Just a little longer. Fifteen minutes or so.

No one much was in the library, at least not in her section. It was dark outside, getting dark inside.

A lone woman sat reading in a far corner, taking notes. In her own little world.

Someone had come into a thick section of stacks earlier. He looked a little rough, not really her style. Unshaven. An oxford untucked. Longer hair. He looked to be her age.

She was not sure where he was, anymore. He had probably left without her noticing. But she is pretty sure she would have noticed. There was something about him that made her pay attention, take notice.

She started thinking about her home life. It was relatively uneventful. Not a lot of romance, even though her boyfriend was perfectly respectable. They had fallen into something of a rut. She patted her skirt, noticed her legs. She was trim. Five years out of college. Dark, dark brown hair. Glasses that she liked. She noticed that her skirt had crept up a little bit. Her blouse’s buttons were tight.

She decided to get up. There was an uneasiness about her. She was a little tingling for no good reason.

---

She found him in the stacks, pulling one book out after another. He was not her type. She kept reminding herself. This is not my type. This is not my type.

But there was something about the way he carried himself. He looked at her, longingly.

“I’ve noticed you before. I like the way you look. What is your name?”

He spoke with such authority and confidence that she just answered him.

It was 9. Everyone was gone. She walked toward him.

“It is time for you to leave.”

“Yes, I imagine it is. Come with me.”
They walk to his Jetta wagon. They slide into the front and begin to talk.

He asks her all kinds of questions. She is amazed that she answers and asks him questions. They talk as if they’ve known each other forever.

He starts the car and drives to the local Hampton Inn.

“What are we doing?” Mary asks.

“You’ll see.”

--

He pulls out some oil, some lotion.

--

They kiss.

--

He takes off her blouse. Pulls down her skirt.

--

He kisses her. Puts her on her stomach.

Kisses her shoulderblade. Kisses down her spine.

She has no idea what she is doing here or why but it feels to good to stop.

--

He puts oil on his finger. Kisses her lower back.
 
Hi,

I'm gonna give you my thoughts as I read. I hope they help. :rose:

You have too many extra words: Mary loved her job. She really did.-- Do you honestly need 'she really did'? Its redundant b/c you've just told us & you sound as if you're trying to convince us (readers) of this fact and failing. (see below)

paragraph: does Mary really love her job? You seem to focus more on what she dislikes-- she often has to work late & she'd rather be curled up on her sofa with a good book-- what does she like about it?

This 'lone woman' in the library-- @ first I thought you were still talking about Mary. You need to find some way to make that less confusing.

I've inserted comments into the body of this story as I read it--I have no idea how to break these things up so I could comment outside in the little box so my comments would separate from your story. I hope thats ok?


Mary loved her job. She really did. The hours sometimes dragged on. She worked late and often wanted to just be wrapped up on her couch reading, the one she loved more than anything was the feel of a book in her hands, a fireplace, her dog closeby.

It was Tuesday. 9 p.m. was approaching. Soon, it would be time to lock up and head out.

Just a little longer. Fifteen minutes or so.

No one much was in the library, at least not in her section. It was dark outside, getting dark inside. (wait, is it dark outside? Or getting dark? It can't be getting dark if its already dark)

A lone woman sat reading in a far corner, taking notes. In her own little world.

Someone had come into a thick section of stacks earlier. He looked a little rough, not really her style. Unshaven. An oxford untucked. Longer hair. He looked to be her age. (how does she notice this rough looking guy if she's taking notes in her own little world? perhaps she happens to glance up and spot him?)

She was not sure where he was, anymore. He had probably left without her noticing. But she is pretty sure she would have noticed. There was something about him that made her pay attention, take notice.

She started thinking about her home life. It was relatively uneventful. Not a lot of romance, even though her boyfriend was perfectly respectable. They had fallen into something of a rut. She patted her skirt, noticed her legs. She was trim. (lol, I'm sorry but did she just realize she's trim? That's what it sounds like. Why is she patting her skirt? Does she have pockets & looking for a pen or something?)

Five years out of college. Dark, dark brown hair. Glasses that she liked. She noticed that her skirt had crept up a little bit. Her blouse’s buttons were tight.

She decided to get up. There was an uneasiness about her. She was a little tingling for no good reason. :confused: (not sure what you're aiming for-- she was uneasy & felt tingly-- a little out of the blue, needs more set up so its not so jarring for the reader)

---

She found him in the stacks, pulling one book out after another. He was not her type. She kept reminding herself. This is not my type. This is not my type. (hmmk, if there's something about this guy that makes her take notice, why is she fighting with herself about this guy being her type?)

But there was something about the way he carried himself. He looked at her, longingly. (puppy--begging)

“I’ve noticed you before. I like the way you look. What is your name?”

He spoke with such authority and confidence that she just answered him. (this contradicts the image of him looking at her longingly in the above. see comment above. his speaking with authority & confidence suggests a dominate personality--in which case he would have approached her earlier)

It was 9. Everyone was gone. She walked toward him. (Is everyone gone? Where's Mary? Isn't she supposed to do a final walkthrough before locking up?)

“It is time for you to leave.” (Oh wait, is this Mary? I'm really confused)

“Yes, I imagine it is. Come with me.” (Yeah, I don't think so. She was uneasy about this guy that she just met, why would she then go with said stranger who makes her uneasy? If he's the reason she's feeling all tingly, you should set up better in the beginning)
They walk to his Jetta wagon. They slide into the front and begin to talk. (switched tense here)

He asks her all kinds of questions. She is amazed that she answers and asks him questions. They talk as if they’ve known each other forever.

He starts the car and drives to the local Hampton Inn.

“What are we doing?” Mary asks. (hmm... not believable-- shouldn't she have asked that question b4 she got in the car?)

“You’ll see.”

--

He pulls out some oil, some lotion. (whoa! back up! what on earth?? how did they go from the car to naked? to him reaching for oil or lotion?-- you should choose b/t the two, oil & lotion are different & just where did this magical liquid come from?)

--

They kiss.

--

He takes off her blouse. Pulls down her skirt.

--

He kisses her. Puts her on her stomach.

Kisses her shoulderblade. Kisses down her spine. (Why are all these little sentences in different paragraphs-- starting from 'they kiss'?)

She has no idea what she is doing here or why but it feels to good to stop. (this whole sex section-- okay right now this mystery woman/Mary?-- Is not a believable character, nor a likeable one. Doesn't she have a boyfriend? Shouldn't there be some internal struggle for her attraction to this guy and her loyalty to her boyfriend? Right now she's just a dumb slut who doesn't know her mind... also there should be some trepidation on her part about going to a hotel room)

--

He puts oil on his finger. Kisses her lower back.

I think this could be a very good story, it just needs a lot of clean up, restructuring and a plot-- which an editor can help you with. The tingling & uneasiness leads me to believe this is a nonhuman story. That would be pretty cool b/c I love that category :rose:
 
emanuelle

I think you have the start of a good story but it needs a bit of sprucing up. Readers have to be trapped in the first few lines.

The start surely should be;

She found him in the stacks, pulling one book out after another. He was not her type. She kept reminding herself. This is not my type. This is not my type.

You get us wanting more - who is this guy? We sense the action.

The bit about waiting for the clock to turn can be relegated into the fact her clock--watching vanished after she saw the guy.

In a short story you have to jump in and, as avid said, keep the action moving. I think you go into far too much back-story before you come to the 'encounter'.
 
tbh, i feel kinda rail-roaded on this one. can't quite get your heroine's motivation-- following the strange guy to his car and then getting in it? sounds like the setup of a bad rape scene.

gotta slow it down some. there's that old writer's adage of show, don't tell and i think your story could benefit from some of that-- and i do realize it isn't a finished story, but i think it probably needs to be more finished than this for a proper critique.
 
I agree... you should not be redundant. Same goes with words.. cock, dick and hard shaft.. all need to be alternated to induce a lovely warm erotic feeling. =)
 
Back
Top