T-a-t-u

TheEarl

Occasional visitor
Joined
Apr 1, 2002
Posts
9,808
And the wonderful English God of Political Correctness.

For those who don't live here, there's now a huge media furore about T-A-T-U because their video shows two schoolgirls kissing. This has been described in the great English tradition of finding Everest in a small pile of earth as tantamount to paedophilic pornography and exploiting the scene to sell the record.

How can so many people completely miss the point? First of all, the girls are 17 and 18 and so are not underage by English law. So that would mean its not paedophilic in any way shape or form. Secondly, the two girls in question are actually lesbian partners (T-A-T-U stands for 'This girl loves that girl' in Russian), so they're not exactly changing their sexuality for the express purpose of selling records. And thirdly, of course sex is being used to sell music. It always is. Why else did Britney Spears dress up in a white blouse, tie and pleated skirt and fuel a thousand male fantasies - for artistic integrity?

Sometimes the sheer stupidity of people astounds me.

The Earl
 
They are targeting Paedo market deliverately.

Where do you drow the line?
 
Well, I'd draw the line at 16. Which is the age of consent in England. As both girls are over 16, I don't see what the problem is.

The Earl
 
TheEarl said:
Well, I'd draw the line at 16. Which is the age of consent in England. As both girls are over 16, I don't see what the problem is.

The Earl
Yes. I agree. But are the artists responsible for moral corruption of their audiences.

Does Sharlock Holmes corrupt the readers to commit crimes?

The above is a stopid question. However, Tatu's manufacture, the former child psychologist, morally responsible?

I don't really care. I'm not interested in lesbians.
 
Don't believe the hype. They'll be gone faster than you can say "Cheeky Girls (Touch My Bum)".
 
Must be one hell of a furore, first I heard of it was on here.

I take it media frenzy is in the Sun not in a real newspaper?
 
bluespoke said:
Must be one hell of a furore, first I heard of it was on here.

I take it media frenzy is in the Sun not in a real newspaper?
6 o'clock news ITV

Richard and Judy (Channel4)
 
I wouldn't have heard about it if it was only in the Sun. I saw it on the 6 o'clock news with a clip of Judy Finegan being very serious about something she doesn't quite understand.

They're quite good at doing that.

Bluespoke: This is just the start of it. R&J go off on one. Then the ITV news pick up on it and run a long feature. Then the other news programs. Then the newspapers (and by that I mean newspapers that actually include news). All part of the wonderful big hand-wringing that will start over whether it's immoral to watch two lesbians kissing and whether lesbians should kiss on television and whether we can expose our children to this kind of filth.

The moral majority worry me sometimes. They really do.

The Earl
 
Last edited:
they are under the age of consent for homosexuals so in that way they are breaking the law although i don't agree with the law

also they aren't lesbians ... its a manufactured band and these two girls are actually the second pair of girls to be in tatu ... they aren't lesbians


the bands manager actually got rid of the first two girls because he caught them talking to boys in a club which he had banned them from doing

the manager is exploiting the two girls to make money ... its trash and gives lesbians a bad name ... and yeah it probably is pedo'ish with the school girl stuff
 
I was under the impression that the two girls were lesbian partners (I think allegedly has got to be used under most of your claims though. Proof?).

It's just the fact that people are going hyper over two girls kissing in fancy-dress. Big fucking deal, why should that bother people? Or would it be alright if it was a bloke kissing a girl?

Cynical? Moi?

The Earl
 
Truly it is a great testament to the quality of their 'music', that no one is talking about that, only the girly smoochy paedo video...
 
It's a nice song though. Although that probably misses the point; I should have been too enveloped by the evil video that showed schoolgirls kissing to have noticed the actual song.

On a side note, although the age of consent for lesbians is 18 (I apologise, forgot about the weird and wonderful English laws regarding homosexuality), does that count for kissing? Just curious.

The Earl
 
TheEarl said:
I was under the impression that the two girls were lesbian partners (I think allegedly has got to be used under most of your claims though. Proof?).

It's just the fact that people are going hyper over two girls kissing in fancy-dress. Big fucking deal, why should that bother people? Or would it be alright if it was a bloke kissing a girl?

Cynical? Moi?

The Earl


allegedly doesn't have to be used do a search on the web for TATU i did it a few weeks ago when i first heard of them being that im a lesbian i have an interest in the matter they are very well known from russia and all the storys have been out there for a while

and yes there is something wrong with it because they are under the age of consent and they are exploited and it gives lesbians a bad name and its just damn tacky :)
 
Bluespoke: Bet you that at least one broadsheet will pick it up tomorrow though. And this is where the whole self-defeating exercise starts.

The Earl
 
Fair nuff, if they aren't actually lesbians, then it is slightly tacky. But no more than Britney Spears dancing in a school uniform or Holly Valance dancing naked in her video.

I just don't see what's so morally reprehensible about two women kissing. It happens on Buffy the Vampire Slayer and there's never any complaint about that.

The Earl
 
TheEarl said:
Bluespoke: Bet you that at least one broadsheet will pick it up tomorrow though. And this is where the whole self-defeating exercise starts.

The Earl

Probably!

Where ITV leads, the sheep will follow!:D
 
peachykeen said:
there you go, that about sums it up.


lol yeah i didn't really need to say any of the other stuff


the earl its not really the moral issue ... i mean im a lesbian i like kissing girls ... and i met my girlfriend when i was under the age of consent

i didn't exactly like britney spears dressing as a school girl either but at least she was insulting my sexuality as well :)

i just think its stupid


i liked the buffy girls kiss because it was realistic and done for a reason
 
i thought i tossed you after the accident! you know, the one involving me, you (the toaster) and a 10 lb. lump hammer!
 
Underage characters/actors kiss one another on television all the time...the issue is that they are two girls. It's a publicity stunt that's working out in the band's favor. One it wonders, but they'll have that one hit...
 
That was no accident. That was first degree toastercide.

The Earl
 
Feisty brunette Julia and soulful redhead Lena, two teenage girls from Moscow known as t.A.T.u, are the Russian equivalent of pop-meets-Prodigy.

"People love us or hate us but nobody thinks nothing about us," says Lena Katina, the older of the striking singers. Tearing down walls of all sorts throughout the brave new world, t.A.T.u became the most explosive and controversial act in Eastern Europe last year with the scandalous single "Ya Soshla S Uma" ("All The Things She Said"), the story of a love affair between two young girls, whose evocative video was named MTV Russia's Video of the Year. 200 km/h in the Wrong Lane, t.A.T.u's 2001 debut album on Universal Music Russia, sold more than 1,000,000 copies and t.A.T.u's concert appearances at huge clubs and stadiums draw upwards of 50,000 fans.

Now t.A.T.u's tempestuous teens are readying to conquer America. Just don't expect very close friends and flirtatious Julia and Lena to tone down their bold, fearless sense of freedom.

"Our songs are not silly," says Lena. "t.A.T.u is more sincere, more honest about ourselves and others. We don't shape ourselves for the audience. In Russia, life is not polite. If we don't like something, we say we don't like it. If we don't agree, we say 'fuck you.'"

Even t.A.T.u's pop electronica has an edge. That's what enticed esteemed producer Trevor Horn to work with t.A.T.u on English-language versions of 200 km/h in the Wrong Lane to be released via Interscope Records. Horn, whose credits include membership in The Buggles ("Video Killed The Radio Star"), prog-rock's Yes and the acclaimed The Art Of Noise as well as producer for The Pet Shop Boys, Grace Jones, Seal, Simple Minds and Frankie Goes To Hollywood, compares t.A.T.u's sound not only to Prodigy but also a group he worked with in the '80s, Propaganda.

In the end, however, t.A.T.u is unlike any other in the East or the West. "Russians are not dark but we are not light either," says Julia Volkova. "We have a different view, maybe deeper, because life is more difficult in Russia."

Julia and Lena had already known each other for several years while in another music group when they came together for t.A.T.u two years ago. Both had also studied music formally for 8 years. But that's where their commonality ends.

Julia is an only child of middle-class parents; Lena, the youngest of three, is the daughter of a well-known musician/pop-songwriter father. "We love each other very much but Lena is totally different from me," says Julia, who has also acted in small films. "She doesn't like to party; I like to party. She's more quiet, reads a lot. I don't like reading." Yet the contrasts between sweet, dramatic Lena and energetic, in-your-face Julia complement each other in t.A.T.u

The video for "Not Gonna Get Us" (t.A.T.u's second Russian hit "Nas Ne Dagoniat") has Julia and Lena commandeering a huge fuel tanker, speeding across a snowy Siberian road past anyone who would stop them, triumphant.

"t.A.T.u is about saying what you feel, not what others expect," says Lena. "Be in love. Be yourself. We are."
http://www.clubclassic.net/servizi/fashion/tatu/022.jpg

http://www.tatugirls.com/
 
Back
Top