So....is this incest?

MinkSoul

Monkey
Joined
Oct 13, 2000
Posts
4,878
from CNN

PARIS, France -- A 62-year-old woman who gave birth last month says her brother is the father of the child, the Associated Press reports.

The unnamed French woman -- who is one of the oldest women ever to give birth -- says the pregnancy was achieved using her 52-year-old brother's sperm and a donor egg. She says a second baby fathered by her brother -- a girl -- was born to a surrogate mother.

According to a 1994 French law, only couples can have "medically assisted procreation."

The woman has been identified in French media only as "Jeanine," says she underwent treatment at a Los Angeles clinic and gave birth on May 14 in Frejus in southern France.

Christian Girard, prosecutor in nearby Draguignan, said officials were studying the baby's "family environment."

The woman, a retired teacher, told Le Parisien newspaper in an interview published on Wednesday that her child was conceived from her brother's sperm and an egg donated by an American woman.

She said her brother's sperm was used to conceive the second baby with the same egg donor, who acted as a surrogate, and that both babies live in Frejus with the woman, her brother and their 80-year-old mother.

The woman, who like her brother is single and had been childless, says she told the U.S. clinic that her brother was her husband.

"We are both healthy in mind and body," she was quoted as telling Le Parisien.

"I couldn't pass on my genes because of my age, so I wanted to pass on his and give life so our line could continue," the woman was quoted as saying.

In May, French Health Minister Bernard Kouchner said the birth was the first of its kind in France.

Kouchner told reporters then: "This poses the problem of fairly uncontrollable deviations in all our technical advances and scientific progress.

"It is not tragic but the very idea that this could become something with no limits, is obviously a problem."

The woman gave birth at the Lauriers Clinic in Frejus. The baby weighed three kilos (6.6 pounds).

The director of the clinic, Philippe Lavernhe, told LCI television in May that he and his staff had simply delivered the baby in accordance with their training. "The ethical problems arise afterward. It is certain that giving birth at 62 is very uncommon," Lavernhe said.

Guinness World Records 2001 lists two 63-year-old women who have given birth: Rosanna Della Corte of Italy in 1994 and Arceli Keh of California in 1996.
 
Nope, NOT incest.

Incest is SEX between two people too closely related toleagally marry. This is just procreation, and not even between siblings. This lady was just a surrogate/host mother for her brother and another woman.
 
What WH said

There's a huge diff between procreation and sex.
 
It's not incest, but you have to be concerned about the impact on the child psychologically. They obviously didn't care about the ethics involved since they lied to the US clinic.
 
No thats not incest. The egg that was fertilized was not even hers. Though damn a woman at that age going through that! I am impressed she must really have strong family loyalty. I actually think that is a great story.
 
I don't consider it incest,

but I would consider it the epitome of selfishness. This woman and her brother probably won't even be alive to see the child into adulthood. Who will take care of it then?

Not only that, but how are they going to support the child? There is just too many questions in my mind about why someone would want to go through with something like this.
 
incest gererally indicates that you are fuckin one of your family members, but in this case, i would have to say no. she would have only been a carrier, so i guess that doesnt make it wrong.....hell phoebe from friends did it............but i know, its fiction........
 
this is a terrible story
all they wanted, was to create an heir for the family fortune , there is no romance or love involved
 
The fact that they are both healthy does not insure in any way against birth defects, caused by inbreeding. Birth defects are the reason inbreeding is illegal. (*talking slowly*) The moral issue...well sounds like they were Gumps before they started mixing fluids.
 
Re: I don't consider it incest,

ChaoticLil said:
but I would consider it the epitome of selfishness. This woman and her brother probably won't even be alive to see the child into adulthood. Who will take care of it then?

Not only that, but how are they going to support the child? There is just too many questions in my mind about why someone would want to go through with something like this.


Ditto!!

Love your new avi, ChaoticLil!
 
Back
Top