Series and categories

JuanSeiszFitzHall

yet another
Joined
Jun 30, 2019
Posts
1,098
I’m sure there’s been quite a lot posted here about writing series vs. writing standalone stories. Sometimes the development of a character (including the character’s exploration of a kink) must be done gradually, through several events and encounters with other characters, and a series could be the best approach. Sometimes that development can happen in a single narrative, perhaps with more impact for the reader if all events are included in a single reading. Well and good. I’ve had occasion lately, however, to wonder if one approach or the other is better for specific Lit categories.

Not very scientifically, I looked at the new-story hubs of most categories to see how many items in each are series. The only surprise under Novels and Novellas is that the total was 24 series, instead of 25. Turns out that the non-series was a story by a new writer who may not have figured out yet what the categories are.

I skipped a few categories which weren’t relevant to this (Audio, Reviews, etc.). The category with the fewest series is Humor and Satire, where basically everything posted is a joke or a shaggy-dog. There is, however, one series there. The next fewest, also understandably, is First Time. In fact, if everything there is ‘first,’ the seven series there might be stretching the point (unless the ensuing chapters deal with post-‘first’ development or consequences). The only other category with fewer than ten series (as of now) is Anal.

All but one of the other categories show 10 to 19 series (with Nonhuman and Exhibition/Voyeur at 19). The exception--and what I had a hunch was the case, and it’s why I looked into this--is SF/Fantasy, where 22 of the 25 hub items are parts of series.

Again, it’s no surprise, when one thinks about the fictional templates in this category: quests, world-building, depiction of aliens and fantasy creatures (probably a big factor in Nonhuman as well). Does anyone get the sense, however, that the dearth of standalones might turn away readers who might otherwise be interested in an SF/F story? Or, would an SF/F reader pass over a standalone in the belief that it doesn’t offer enough of what that reader wants?

https://www.literotica.com/stories/memberpage.php?uid=5116173&page=submissions
 
Does anyone get the sense, however, that the dearth of standalones might turn away readers who might otherwise be interested in an SF/F story? Or, would an SF/F reader pass over a standalone in the belief that it doesn’t offer enough of what that reader wants?

I have three stories in SF/F and they're all stand-alone stories. They're also my three least-viewed stories. I suspect that a lot of SF/F readers ignore standalones.
 
Again, it’s no surprise, when one thinks about the fictional templates in this category: quests, world-building, depiction of aliens and fantasy creatures (probably a big factor in Nonhuman as well). Does anyone get the sense, however, that the dearth of standalones might turn away readers who might otherwise be interested in an SF/F story? Or, would an SF/F reader pass over a standalone in the belief that it doesn’t offer enough of what that reader wants?

https://www.literotica.com/stories/memberpage.php?uid=5116173&page=submissions
Some authors are slaves to their readers "expectations" and continue to churn out content they think will attract readers, in formats they think will attract readers. Some readers want standalone stories, others want long endless stories. You can't satisfy both, so why bother even trying to second guess readers? You'll just get it wrong for the other half.

Other writers just write, and choose the format which suits them as a writer. Who cares if readers with prejudices and idealistic preferences are turned away by this format or that?

What suits the story or the author's intent best? That's what really matters, surely?
 
Some of us just write our stories as they drop into our imagination. And that's good enough for some of us.
 
My overthinking about stuff like this doesn't affect what I write or post. I've been here eight months, I'm still trying to figure things out.
 
My overthinking about stuff like this doesn't affect what I write or post. I've been here eight months, I'm still trying to figure things out.
My highest ranked story is the third chapter of a twelve part (including a prologue) novel in Sci-Fi and Fantasy, which 1700 people read through to the end. The last part is my third highest ranked chapter. My fourth highest ranked is a standalone, obviously unfinished (but at a satisfactory break point) in the same category with 6600 Views - so I figure maybe 1500 - 1700 Reads - the same number as for the novel.

My second and fifth highest ranked stories are chapters two and three of a Romance story, with 8,000 Views of the second chapter and 24,000 Views of the third. The first chapter had 30,000 Views, twice the number of Votes, and a slightly lower score. So go figure out that voting pattern - three times as many people opening chapter three compared to chapter two?? Or people reading it many times? I don't have a clue.

Other than saying, "Category matters, when it comes to the number of readers," there are few logical explanations for reader behaviour. Sure, there are patterns, but then there's just weird stuff, like the example just given.

And you're trying to figure all this out! You'll go mad, I tell you, quite mad :).
 
Back
Top