Seasteading

What happened to those Whiskey rebels you call "thieves" and who were tyrannically charged and sentenced to death?

24 were indicted for treason; 10 of those tried (the rest jumped bail); two of those convicted and sentenced to hang; Washington pardoned them.

What happened to the tax they rebelled against?

There's still a federal excise tax on whiskey. It is evaded by moonshiners, but never openly resisted.

What happened to not only the individual who was most responsible for the statist tax but the political Party he basically created?

Aaron Burr killed him in a duel (it had nothing to do with whiskey or taxes). The Federalist Party lasted until 1816.

In the end, it all worked out all right.

Legacy

The Washington administration's suppression of the Whiskey Rebellion met with widespread popular approval.[99] The episode demonstrated the new national government had the willingness and ability to suppress violent resistance to its laws. It was therefore viewed by the Washington administration as a success, a view that has generally been endorsed by historians.[100] The Washington administration and its supporters usually did not mention, however, that the whiskey excise remained difficult to collect, and that many westerners continued to refuse to pay the tax.[28] The events contributed to the formation of political parties in the United States, a process already underway.[101] The whiskey tax was repealed after Thomas Jefferson's Republican Party, which opposed Hamilton's Federalist Party, came to power in 1800.[102]

The Whiskey Rebellion raised the question of what kinds of protests were permissible under the new Constitution. Legal historian Christian G. Fritz argued, even after ratification of the Constitution, there was not yet a consensus about sovereignty in the United States. Federalists believed the government was sovereign because it had been established by the people, so radical protest actions, which were permissible during the American Revolution, were no longer legitimate. But the Whiskey Rebels and their defenders believed the Revolution had established the people as a "collective sovereign", and the people had the collective right to change or challenge the government through extraconstitutional means.[103]

Historian Steven Boyd argued that the suppression of the Whiskey Rebellion prompted anti-Federalist westerners to finally accept the Constitution, and to seek change by voting for Republicans rather than resisting the government. Federalists, for their part, came to accept that the people could play a greater role in governance. Although Federalists would attempt to restrict speech critical of the government with the Alien and Sedition Acts in 1798, after the Whiskey Rebellion, says Boyd, Federalists no longer challenged the freedom of assembly and the right to petition.[104]

Soon after the Whiskey Rebellion, actress-playwright Susanna Rowson wrote a stage musical about the insurrection entitled "The Volunteers", with music by composer Alexander Reinagle. The play is now lost, but the songs survive, and suggest that Rowson's interpretation was pro-Federalist. The musical celebrated the militiamen who put down the rebellion, the "volunteers" of the title, as American heroes.[105] President Washington and Martha Washington attended a performance of the play in Philadelphia in January 1795.[106]

In L. Neil Smith's alternate history novel The Probability Broach (1980), Albert Gallatin convinces the militia not to put down the rebellion, but instead to march on the nation's capital, execute George Washington for treason, and replace the Constitution with a revised Articles of Confederation. As a result, the United States becomes a libertarian utopia called the North American Confederacy.[107][108]

In the satirical novel Joyleg, A Folly by Avram Davidson and Ward Moore, a veteran of both the American Revolutionary War and the Whiskey Rebellion is found alive and very well in the Tennessee backwoods, having survived over the centuries by daily soaks in whisky of his own making, to hilariously face the world of the 1960s.
 

So every one of those "thieves" was either acquitted or fully pardoned? Is that correct?

And the big guy who went after them with baby buddha's "Army" is the same guy who fully pardoned them? What's up with that?

There's still a federal excise tax on whiskey. It is evaded by moonshiners, but never openly resisted.

What happened to your statist hero's Whiskey tax, hotdog? How long did it last? (Answer: not even as long as your hero's short stay.)

Aaron Burr killed him in a duel (it had nothing to do with whiskey or taxes). The Federalist Party lasted until 1816.

What happened to your hero's Federalist Party? How come it died a statist death and never resurrected (just like him)?


Worked out great for the rebels, who protested against a tax which was finally repealed and the political Party which was responsible for implementing it was totally defeated and shortly thereafter disappeared forever.

But life just didn't work out "all right" for your statist hero, did it?

BTW, King0:

I read another thread where you were flirting politically with another poster, and you stated that you don't so much favor social democracy as you really do "democratic socialism"...

...so why did you very recently make a huge effort of intentionally labeling yourself a Social Democrat and instead of the Democratic Socialist tag you admittedly prefer?

Why are you and all your other bozo buddies on this Board scared to stand up and fight proudly for socialism?
 
So every one of those "thieves" was either acquitted or fully pardoned?

Or jumped bail, and was not hunted too hard. The important thing was that the rebellion was over.

And the big guy who went after them with baby buddha's "Army" is the same guy who fully pardoned them? What's up with that?

He had won, he put down the rebellion easily and made the point, the country was solidly behind him; I guess he saw no need to be vindictive.

What happened to your hero's Federalist Party? How come it died a statist death and never resurrected (just like him)?

It was gradually marginalized by (1) becoming a New England sectional party and (2) its opposition to the War of 1812. Its remnants were eventually more or less absorbed by the Whigs; whose remnants were later absorbed by the Republicans. Read up:

First Party System (1792-1824).

Second Party System (1828-1854).

Third Party System (1854-mid-1890s).

Fourth Party System (1896-1932).

Fifth Party System (1933 -- ?). (Controversial; some say we're still in it, some say we're already in the Fifth -- I would date that from 1972. And I think we're on the cusp of the Sixth now.)

But life just didn't work out "all right" for your statist hero, did it?

Which one? Washington retired from office after two terms (he might have had as many as he liked) and died a beloved national hero. Hamilton served as Washington's Treasury Secretary and de facto prime minister for both terms, brilliantly and successfully; and continued in public life thereafter, serving as a Major General under Adams, in the Quasi-War (against Revolutionary France) of 1798-1800. He died in a duel in 1804; his party was out of power (and Jefferson's was in) at the time, but he might well have become POTUS some day if he had not crossed Burr (which was not about anything political as such; personal slight). (One of only two occasions in American history, AFAIK, when anyone was shot by a sitting Vice-President.) I'd say it worked out "all right" for both of them, all things considered.

BTW, King0:

I read another thread where you were flirting politically with another poster, and you stated that you don't so much favor social democracy as you really do "democratic socialism"...

If you mean this, I was merely trying to draw the distinction between the two. Frankly, I've wavered; I often call myself a "socialist," but usually mean that in a sticking-it-to-the-man sense, it sounds scarier. I like the DSA, have been a member (keep meaning to renew), but I'm still waiting to see an instance of democratic socialism in the real world, and progressivism/social democracy is a more realistic (by comparison) goal in an American setting anyway. Vote Working Families Party! (If it exists in your state.) It's not socialist, but it'll do! :)
 
Last edited:
So, I first read about this group of libertarian entrepreneurs dream of automomous floating cities in the Wealth section of the Financial Times. They are led by Milton Friedman's grandson Patri. Can something come of it? Who knows. The website is interesting.

http://www.seasteading.org


I had always thought libertarian ideologues were myopic pie-in-the-sky pseudo-intellectuals whose heads were so far up their own asses that they utterly failed to take note of reality.

But having read all this, I must now admit that...uh, I've been dramatically understating things.
 
Frizzle's some combination of dead wrong and a dreamer. I suppose if you want to attempt to make the argument that we've come so far as humans that we no longer need each other to survive that's. . .I don't know what it is but it's something.

Please, give me one reason I need the state to take part of my wealth, write arbitrary bull shit laws, and create endless bullshit government programs to make a living?

I don't need food stamps, KFC, grocery stores or a dining facility of any sort to feed myself. Nor some politician to write some law entitling me to food.

I don't need any government support to provide myself shelter.

I can decide my level of socialization on my terms.

I don't need planned parent hood to fuck and reproduce.

Mankind did fine for thousands of years through prosperity and desperation both without the nanny state my friend.....
 
Please, give me one reason I need the state to take part of my wealth, write arbitrary bull shit laws, and create endless bullshit government programs to make a living?

Because you don't want to live in a society resembling Somalia. Everything that makes your life bearable (the police, for instance) depends on government whether you notice it or not; if it went away, you would miss it sorely.
 
I had always thought libertarian ideologues were myopic pie-in-the-sky pseudo-intellectuals whose heads were so far up their own asses that they utterly failed to take note of reality.

But having read all this, I must now admit that...uh, I've been dramatically understating things.

And they call lefties "utopians." :rolleyes:
 
Because you don't want to live in a society resembling Somalia. Everything that makes your life bearable (the police, for instance) depends on government whether you notice it or not; if it went away, you would miss it sorely.

That's pretty presumptuous...I've actually lived in the 3rd world, there is something to be said about being able to do literally whatever the fuck you want. Not worrying about bills, shopping, politics, money, none of that shit.....it has it's silver linings.

Further more you are presuming I was talking about necessary things to have a functioning society....none of what I listed was a necessity. I'm not talking about infrastructure and public safety/welfare. I'm talking about ALLLLLLLLLL the other shit the government has it's grubby fingers all over. Private industry, the countless victimless criminal laws on the books....EPA reg's that don't have jack or shit to do with protecting the environment, the corrupt money funnel into the pockets of the 1%, Absolutely broken and worthless programs/systems that need to be scrapped and rebuilt. On and on and on...

Now once again, a legit answer as to why it is necessary to have the government in every aspect of my personal business, my bank account, my bedroom and my body.

There is a mountain of bullshit government that we would all be better of without...or at the very least could use a ground up cleaning/restructuring. I'm not an anarchist, but if the gov is going to have a program/dept the tax payer deserves max return on their dollar.
 
Last edited:
That's pretty presumptuous...I've actually lived in the 3rd world, there is something to be said about being able to do literally whatever the fuck you want. Not worrying about bills, shopping, politics, money, none of that shit.....it has it's silver linings.

Further more you are presuming I was talking about necessary things to have a functioning society....none of what I listed was a necessity. I'm not talking about infrastructure and public safety/welfare. I'm talking about ALLLLLLLLLL the other shit the government has it's grubby fingers all over. Private industry, the countless victimless criminal laws on the books....EPA reg's that don't have jack or shit to do with protecting the environment, the corrupt money funnel into the pockets of the 1%, Absolutely broken and worthless programs/systems that need to be scrapped and rebuilt. On and on and on...

Now once again, a legit answer as to why it is necessary to have the government in every aspect of my personal business, my bank account, my bedroom and my body.

There is a mountain of bullshit government that we would all be better of without...or at the very least could use a ground up cleaning/restructuring. I'm not an anarchist, but if the gov is going to have a program/dept the tax payer deserves max return on their dollar.

Well, I AM an anarchist, and I approved this message. ;)

Check my sig line, btw. It summarizes my thinking pretty clearly.
 
Well, I AM an anarchist, and I approved this message. ;)

Check my sig line, btw. It summarizes my thinking pretty clearly.

So I'm not pushing that far, I will admit I do enjoy infrastructure, security and the ability to do commerce in a civil manner. Despite being far from necessary I support support health care and education because I think they are good things that benefit society on a number of levels. However I don't even come close to supporting our current systems. I think they are both broken wastes of money among many other programs.

And I don't think the right's idea of restricting and strangling the fuck out of everything to force their profit out of every market nor the left's idea that writing everyone everywhere blank checks for whatever amount they want will fix any of it.

Our leaders and best minds need to sit down and hash this shit out from square 1 to deliver top notch goods and services at a rock bottom price. We should be doing it better, cleaner, cheaper and more efficiently than everyone else.
 
Last edited:
So I'm not pushing that far, I will admit I do enjoy infrastructure, security and the ability to do commerce in a civil manner. Despite being far from necessary I support support health care and education because I think they are good things that benefit society on a number of levels. However I don't even come close to supporting our current systems. I think they are both broken wastes of money among many other programs.

And I don't think the right's idea of restricting and strangling the fuck out of everything to force their profit out of every market nor the left's idea that writing everyone everywhere blank checks for whatever amount they want will fix either.

I do not expect others to agree with me. Just to give me a fair hearing. You and KingOrfeo both have done that. You earnestly hold different positions, which I can respect. You have minds and consciences of your own and must answer to the latter for the courage of your convictions. To expect others to agree with me at all times would be arrogant in the extreme. I agree when I honestly agree and I disagree when that is called for as well. I must answer to my conscience, too.

Sean Renaud is another honest person whose views I do not always share.

That's just how it is. I know a lot of folks on other sites of whom that is true as well. And other boards of Lit, for that matter.
 
I do not expect others to agree with me. Just to give me a fair hearing. You and KingOrfeo both have done that. You earnestly hold different positions, which I can respect. You have minds and consciences of your own and must answer to the latter for the courage of your convictions. To expect others to agree with me at all times would be arrogant in the extreme. I agree when I honestly agree and I disagree when that is called for as well. I must answer to my conscience, too.

Sean Renaud is another honest person whose views I do not always share.

That's just how it is. I know a lot of folks on other sites of whom that is true as well. And other boards of Lit, for that matter.

We can respect one another's opinions, or at least one another's right to have different opinions. But at the end of the day, we all have to live in the same society, and there can be only one system in place and one set of public policies in effect at any given time, and you can have your way or I can have mine, but not both. That's where the conflict begins. That's politics.
 
We can respect one another's opinions, or at least one another's right to have different opinions. But at the end of the day, we all have to live in the same society, and there can be only one system in place and one set of public policies in effect at any given time, and you can have your way or I can have mine, but not both. That's where the conflict begins. That's politics.

Well, actually, on some issues, we can both have our way. The conflict is on the other issues (economic ones, generally).
 
A large part of the conflict comes from a fact that a lot of people believe things that aren't true. And while I'll get called a benighted jackelope or that my foundations are wrong rarely are specifics made.

Frizzle is clear (at least for times someone quotes him, I have him on iggy for reasons obvious to those that can read) that he's not against infrastructure. It's all the other bullshit. But we hear this all the time from the RWCJ. "I'm not against NASA, the Internet, Police, Nuclear Power or the Highways, it's solar power and wind energy that I'm against!" Please someone tell me what exactly is so different or is that the only reason for us to work together is to be threatened with death? If that's what it takes then I hope a new Super Power shows up, it's stupid but hey.

What EPA regs don't involve keeping the enviroment safe? Any victimless crime you can name I'm happy to help eradicate. I hate victimless crimes, however no small part of our "victimless" crimes laws aren't because of too much government, it's because of too little government. It turns out that when you run a for profit prison they WANT to run at max capacity at minimum costs. Once you factor in lobbyists it becomes a no brainer why you don't want private prisons. If these were public facilities and the public had a vested interest in keeping the number of facilities low, and the facilities themselves empty we wouldn't have the top incarceration rate on the planet.

What absolute crap programs that need to be scrapped and rebuilt? I'm not denying their existance but I want to know which ones and get something better than a well worded Neverendingme, Government isn't the answer, welfare queens you want the Obama to win! So what specifically and what do you offer as a superior option?

The government doesn't have complete control over every aspect of our lives. Unless your a criminal or govenment employee the government shouldn't be something you interact with regularly enough to hate, unless you really think street lights are an assault on freedom.
 
Frizzle is clear (at least for times someone quotes him, I have him on iggy for reasons obvious to those that can read) that he's not against infrastructure. It's all the other bullshit. But we hear this all the time from the RWCJ. "I'm not against NASA, the Internet, Police, Nuclear Power or the Highways, it's solar power and wind energy that I'm against!" Please someone tell me what exactly is so different or is that the only reason for us to work together is to be threatened with death? If that's what it takes then I hope a new Super Power shows up, it's stupid but hey.

IDK why you have me on iggy, do you think I'm someones alt or something? Have I attacked you personally? Maybe you take my jokes seriously or something.

Anyhow I never even said I was against green energy (as long as it's really green and not well blown, grotesquely over priced sunshine) and I'm not part of the right wing, I have enough opposing views most of them call me a commie.

I hate victimless crimes, however no small part of our "victimless" crimes laws aren't because of too much government, it's because of too little government.

Are you seriously trying to say that 180+ billion a year spent entirely on the "war on drugs" with various federal agencies is not enough government? The government is the one feeding the machine.

It turns out that when you run a for profit prison they WANT to run at max capacity at minimum costs. Once you factor in lobbyists it becomes a no brainer why you don't want private prisons. If these were public facilities and the public had a vested interest in keeping the number of facilities low, and the facilities themselves empty we wouldn't have the top incarceration rate on the planet.

Exactly....so cut the money flow to private prisons off. It's really just that simple.

What absolute crap programs that need to be scrapped and rebuilt? I'm not denying their existance but I want to know which ones and get something better than a well worded Neverendingme, Government isn't the answer, welfare queens you want the Obama to win! So what specifically and what do you offer as a superior option?

Our entire dept of education for one. It's obviously broken and I doubt few would argue that outside those who recive funding from it. A different approach....get a board of people together to figure out a better system that provides better education for less. Shit...copy some other nation that's doing it better anything that would be a real change away from the broken system we have.

Healthcare....get rid of the private insurance involvement and own the HCS or GTFO. The laundering of tax payer money through hospitals, big pharm etc. needs to stop. For what we pay currently there is NO reason why we can't have a universal healthcare system that will handle boo boo's to brain surgery. What's the problem? Gov. funding +private industry = corruption....every fucking time. So they either need to do it and own it or let market competition drive prices down.

DEA gone, DHS gone, private prison biz..gone, I would send a squad of tight wad accountants to go rape the military budget and put a leash on those fuckers spending. Great we can wipe the earth clean 15x over....enough. Same with the DOT/DPS/DMV, send accountants in to put some over inflated budgets in check.

The government doesn't have complete control over every aspect of our lives. Unless your a criminal or govenment employee the government shouldn't be something you interact with regularly enough to hate, unless you really think street lights are an assault on freedom.

Seriously? You can't even flex you 1st amendment rights without buying a permit from the gov. WTF? censorship runs wild all over the place in just about every form of media...MPAA, FCC, ESRB

I won't start on 2A rights...

Due process...they just torched it recently. All the gov has to do is say "you're a suspected terrorist!" rights are gone...

PATRIOT act..same shit

10th..the federal gov doesn't give a shit about states rights. Medical MJ for example..prostitution in NV, nutter abortion laws in KS etc etc.

14th amendment...why can't gay people fuck there lives up with marriage just like straight people? We are mission out on lots and lots of money/business!! Want to stimulate the economy? let the gay people have weddings!!

Further more why is ANY business of the governments who is fucking who? Or what products they consume? Consenting adults should be able to do whatever they want as long as they don't violate others. Want to smoke crack and fuck your mom in the ass while sucking off your boyfriend? fine....as long as they are all cool with it, no problem. One can never escape the ridicule of society so keeping it to yourself might be a good idea but the cops wont drag you into a courthouse in front of the evening news to be sent to prison for it either.

I realize most of these things are illegal/ignored laws because they threaten someones income somewhere somehow. Lose lobbyist, term limits, do what's right for the people and the economy as a whole, not a specific industry/corporation. If one industry is the wave of the future you have to let whatever it's replacing die....it will suck but it's far less painful than trying to indefinitely protect dying/dead industries/companies because their lobbyist got some law written for them.

Big pharma scared of weed? Competition is a bitch...make a better product cheaper or die.
 
Last edited:
IDK why you have me on iggy, do you think I'm someones alt or something? Have I attacked you personally? Maybe you take my jokes seriously or something.

You got on it a few weeks ago. I think for a combination of often adding nothing to a conversation and just making a lot of noise but I'll admit I don't know either wh you're on ignore. You'd have to wage a serious war on me personally to get ignored for that however. Kinda like I don't remember why I have SeaUrchin STG on iggy other than she's obnoxious.

Anyhow I never even said I was against green energy (as long as it's really green and not well blown, grotesquely over priced sunshine) and I'm not part of the right wing, I have enough opposing views most of them call me a commie.

Didn't say you were against Green energy specifically. I said I'm not hearing a specific thing that the government is wasting money on, nor how do we define wasted money. A lot of the government project I mentioned like nuclear power or space travel might well have been impossible but that didn't stop us from sinking tons of cash into it. Nobody likes wasted money but we need a clear definition on what's waste and what's within the acceptable range of Research and Development actually means Trial and Error.



Are you seriously trying to say that 180+ billion a year spent entirely on the "war on drugs" with various federal agencies is not enough government? The government is the one feeding the machine. Exactly....so cut the money flow to private prisons off. It's really just that simple.

I'm saying, first that your 180 billion a year is bullshit number pulled fully out of your ass. I suppose if you factor in the states you might get it near that number. You're however ignoring the simple fact that nobody will run a prison (or any business) that isn't making them money except the government who's purpose is to govern and not make a profit. IF you want to cut the flow to private prisons off you have to eliminate the private prisons. Sadly that's gonna take some of your wealth to fund. Since you (and many others) are unwilling to pay we have to find a way to profit from this.

I'm all for ending the war on drugs. If not legalizing damn near everything simply doing like we've done with sodomy laws and pretending their not on the books until some idiot gets the governer's daughter high, pregnant and with a sore rump in which case he's just lucky the cops didn't think he had a bag of skittles in his pocket.



Our entire dept of education for one. It's obviously broken and I doubt few would argue that outside those who recive funding from it. A different approach....get a board of people together to figure out a better system that provides better education for less. Shit...copy some other nation that's doing it better anything that would be a real change away from the broken system we have.

We don't really have a department of education. You are aware of that right? They don't have any real power, the states get to set the majority of the rules. The Federal Government doesn't have much power at all which is why there was so much hoopla a few years back when Texas wanted to change it's text books. They are a large economy and the retailers weren't going to make a special Texas edition, their decisions would have effected a large part of the nation. I'm not certain a better education can be provided for less but I'm open to looking at it and I'd love to copy another nation that's getting better results.



Healthcare....get rid of the private insurance involvement and own the HCS or GTFO. The laundering of tax payer money through hospitals, big pharm etc. needs to stop. For what we pay currently there is NO reason why we can't have a universal healthcare system that will handle boo boo's to brain surgery. What's the problem? Gov. funding +private industry = corruption....every fucking time. So they either need to do it and own it or let market competition drive prices down.

While I'm all for UHC market competition won't drive down prices in medicine. It turns out that when you have a heart attack you're not about to shop around, you're going to whatever place is closest.

DEA gone, DHS gone, private prison biz..gone, I would send a squad of tight wad accountants to go rape the military budget and put a leash on those fuckers spending. Great we can wipe the earth clean 15x over....enough. Same with the DOT/DPS/DMV, send accountants in to put some over inflated budgets in check.

You'd put hundreds of thousands if not millions of people out of work in a heart beat with no clear path to employment. We're not just talking high school grads with no prospects we're talking top of the line engineers who get paid to make sci-fi into reality. What we're really talking about when we cut a multi-million dollar project to build an amphibious assault vehicle is firing scientists doing breaking edge research, factory workers building it and all the people in between. Say what you want about Halliburton but don't deny they employ a lot of people directly and in-directly. After all that McDonalds just outside the gates might not be actual employees but they are dependent on it.

Even under good times we have a LOT of peopl who are employed by the military and gutting their resources is not going to stimulate the economy and unless it's done very carefully it's not going to lower the debt either. Bitch all you want about who made what money off of Haliburton or any other military deal but remember the top 10% pay the majority of the taxes in this country. Them making significantly less money isn't going to solve our deficiet problem at all.





Seriously? You can't even flex you 1st amendment rights without buying a permit from the gov. WTF? censorship runs wild all over the place in just about every form of media...MPAA, FCC, ESRB

I won't start on 2A rights...

I've never been censored in my life. What censorship you're talking about is on the professional level and yeah I think my right not to have to actively avoid obscenity and to know what I'm watching outranks your right to run about naked.

As for the 2nd amendment. That just falls under the fact that we don't live in 1776 anymore and we need to take a fresh and honest look at most of the constitution to be honest. I'm quite glad that Tupac and Biggy had to "make due" with what they could scrounge together instead of strolling into the local Wal-Mart and picking up a .50 cal Machine gun and a case of grenades. I'm glad that when celebrities get drunk they drive around in soft squishie sports cars and not tanks (though there have been cases of tanks in the streets).



Due process...they just torched it recently. All the gov has to do is say "you're a suspected terrorist!" rights are gone...

PATRIOT act..same shit

This shit needs fixing. That's agreed.

10th..the federal gov doesn't give a shit about states rights. Medical MJ for example..prostitution in NV, nutter abortion laws in KS etc etc.

It's an outdated idea. We don't live in 1776. We're not 50 countries in a loose alliance, we're one country and we should have one set of laws. If there is something so radically diffferent about some part of the country that it warrents making an exception so be it.

14th amendment...why can't gay people fuck there lives up with marriage just like straight people? We are mission out on lots and lots of money/business!! Want to stimulate the economy? let the gay people have weddings!!

That's quite the typo there buddy. While I haven't followed each and every lawsuit on the subject the official reason seems to be that marriage is a privelege not a right. I dunno how that worked out. I'm for gay marriage though.

-snip-​

I realize most of these things are illegal/ignored laws because they threaten someones income somewhere somehow. Lose lobbyist, term limits, do what's right for the people and the economy as a whole, not a specific industry/corporation. If one industry is the wave of the future you have to let whatever it's replacing die....it will suck but it's far less painful than trying to indefinitely protect dying/dead industries/companies because their lobbyist got some law written for them.

Big pharma scared of weed? Competition is a bitch...make a better product cheaper or die.

I don't think big pharma is scared of weed. That's just good ole fashioned conservatism.
 
Well, actually, on some issues, we can both have our way. The conflict is on the other issues (economic ones, generally).

Yes. No two (sane) people disagree on every single point of public policy or principles. And on some points where we do disagree, perhaps we can compromise. And compromise is also politics.

But, anyone who cares about politics at all almost certainly holds some points so dear that compromise is subjectively indistinguishable from defeat. Conflict is inevitable.

I once had a Unitarian pastor who noted that when people who hold opposing views focus on the practical results, usually they can compromise. E.g., if you're against abortion, and you manage to train yourself to think in terms of reducing the number of abortions performed every year, you can probably come to some accommodation with pro-choicers on policies that can provably do that, like good sex-ed in schools that isn't "abstinence-only."

But, when the conflict involves one side holding to a high moral principle, and the other side holding to another, competing high moral principle, historically, the result has always been tragedy. E.g., the Civil War. Both sides knew they were in the Right with a capital "R."
 
A lot of the government project I mentioned like nuclear power or space travel might well have been impossible but that didn't stop us from sinking tons of cash into it. Nobody likes wasted money but we need a clear definition on what's waste and what's within the acceptable range of Research and Development actually means Trial and Error.

I understand there will be some wasted money, but we can do a lot more to limit it than we are now. Also if we don't have the money for EVERYTHING I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to say "hey folks times are rough we are going to have to cut back on some shit and really think about where we put tax payer money and why." as opposed to just handing out however much is asked for.

I'm saying, first that your 180 billion a year is bullshit number pulled fully out of your ass. I suppose if you factor in the states you might get it near that number.

That number I got from an NBC or ABC documentary about weed...that was state, local, federal, incarceration, court cost....all of it from investigation to probation/parole. I watched it a few days ago it should still be instant play on netflix.

You're however ignoring the simple fact that nobody will run a prison (or any business) that isn't making them money except the government who's purpose is to govern and not make a profit
IF you want to cut the flow to private prisons off you have to eliminate the private prisons. Sadly that's gonna take some of your wealth to fund. Since you (and many others) are unwilling to pay we have to find a way to profit from this.

Oh I know....but is there really less money spent on private prisons than state/federal pens? It's something I would like to know more about, b/c I honestly think the state could do it cheaper considering they don't need nor want to make a profit off it. There is no reason they couldn't do it cheaper.

I'm all for ending the war on drugs. If not legalizing damn near everything simply doing like we've done with sodomy laws and pretending their not on the books until some idiot gets the governer's daughter high, pregnant and with a sore rump in which case he's just lucky the cops didn't think he had a bag of skittles in his pocket.

Werd.

I'm not certain a better education can be provided for less but I'm open to looking at it and I'd love to copy another nation that's getting better results.

Maybe not for less....but I know for certain we should be getting a hell of a lot more for our dollar than we are now. I know the voucher system is working quite well in a number of EU countries, attaching the money to the kid and not the school has a dramatic impact of that schools desire to produce results.

While I'm all for UHC market competition won't drive down prices in medicine. It turns out that when you have a heart attack you're not about to shop around, you're going to whatever place is closest.

No but it will drive down cost in insurance, which is the only reason the cost of medicine is so high. I paid for a CT scan out of pocket and it cost me a little over 600 bucks. When I gave my gov. insurance info to the hospital, 12,000 fucking dollars.......why??:confused: some corrupt politician hop in bed with the insurance company? I think so....lol

There are other examples....why does a pill made in the US cost Americans 20-50- 300 bucks each when you can get the same pill from the same factory across a border for 1/10th the price? Government subsides.....if the gov will buy your aspirin pill for a hundred bucks why would you charge any less? The profit margins on big pharma and the medical industry are just astronomical.

You'd put hundreds of thousands if not millions of people out of work in a heart beat with no clear path to employment. We're not just talking high school grads with no prospects we're talking top of the line engineers who get paid to make sci-fi into reality. What we're really talking about when we cut a multi-million dollar project to build an amphibious assault vehicle is firing scientists doing breaking edge research, factory workers building it and all the people in between. Say what you want about Halliburton but don't deny they employ a lot of people directly and in-directly. After all that McDonalds just outside the gates might not be actual employees but they are dependent on it.

Even under good times we have a LOT of peopl who are employed by the military and gutting their resources is not going to stimulate the economy and unless it's done very carefully it's not going to lower the debt either. Bitch all you want about who made what money off of Haliburton or any other military deal but remember the top 10% pay the majority of the taxes in this country. Them making significantly less money isn't going to solve our deficiet problem at all.

Here you go with extremes again....I wasn't getting at cutting edge development, or even contract work. I was getting at how many hundreds of useless bases does the US have that serve NO purpose? Maybe ditch a few of those eastern European air bases that soak up billions protecting us from the eminent soviet threat? Here is one...END THE WAR, we can't afford it anymore.

Root out some of those 300 dollar hammers, 2000 dollar toilet seats and 100 dollar rolls of toilet paper....and end those contracts.

I still think the DEA/DHS are tit's on a bull...

I've never been censored in my life. What censorship you're talking about is on the professional level and yeah I think my right not to have to actively avoid obscenity and to know what I'm watching outranks your right to run about naked.

You really should check out what those organizations are capable of with regard to influence over major industry. MPAA can financially destroy a film with an NC-17 rating for two girls kissing...or a few seconds of pubic hair. 280 people shot and killed? only one "fuck"? PG-13. Their ratings are arbitrary and behind closed doors. It's not right.

Same with the ESRB.

I am all for putting a label on a product to know what you are getting yourself into. But their needs to be set standards that are public information beyond the vague descriptions of what make an R film an NC-17 or PG-13 film.

As for the 2nd amendment. That just falls under the fact that we don't live in 1776 anymore

So it's not 1776 anymore...so as an otherwise law abiding citizen one does not have the right to defend ones self or even enjoy marksmanship/shooting sports?

I'm all for mandatory safety class's and training, not selling guns to felons or the mentally unstable. But otherwise whats the big deal? You can't stop insane people from doing insane shit by writing insane laws. If someone want's to kill they are going to kill...just as easy with any number of other tools. Give me a pitch fork and I can rob/kill someone just the same as with a gun. I have the supplies to make a BOMB in my garage....I could use that to rob a bank just the same as with a .380 pea shooter. Hell cigg's kill like what, 40 or 50 times as many people each year? Out law that shit first....


It's an outdated idea. We don't live in 1776. We're not 50 countries in a loose alliance, we're one country and we should have one set of laws. If there is something so radically diffferent about some part of the country that it warrents making an exception so be it.

Agreed, some laws really need to be set standard at a national level for simplicity reasons alone for many things. However there are a lot of them that I think need to be at a state/county level just to allow our diversity, and freedom. People in NJ may not want to live the same way as people in TX....we need allow them the freedom to do that. Esp on a social/cultural level. (like the use of medical MJ) and as long as those laws are not unconstitutional or violating others rights....the federal gov needs to let them do it.

That's quite the typo there buddy.

I don't think big pharma is scared of weed. That's just good ole fashioned conservatism.

Sorry, I'm on my phone and auto correct fucked it up. I mean't we are "missing" out on a lot of money. And yea the weed thing is good old conservatism but it threatens a lot of industries....that's why Hemp is illegal to produce as well despite it's lack of narcotics.
 
Last edited:
I understand there will be some wasted money, but we can do a lot more to limit it than we are now. Also if we don't have the money for EVERYTHING I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to say "hey folks times are rough we are going to have to cut back on some shit and really think about where we put tax payer money and why." as opposed to just handing out however much is asked for.

Except that just makes things rougher.


Oh I know....but is there really less money spent on private prisons than state/federal pens? It's something I would like to know more about, b/c I honestly think the state could do it cheaper considering they don't need nor want to make a profit off it. There is no reason they couldn't do it cheaper.

They can do it cheaper, so could the for proft ones. However there is a static cost just to having one in the first place and people don't want to pay taxes, expecially not for big buildings with few people in em.


Maybe not for less....but I know for certain we should be getting a hell of a lot more for our dollar than we are now. I know the voucher system is working quite well in a number of EU countries, attaching the money to the kid and not the school has a dramatic impact of that schools desire to produce results.

New York and a few other places aside we don't have the same options as Europe. We don't have the kind of public transit to get people around to different schools and most families both parents work these days.



No but it will drive down cost in insurance, which is the only reason the cost of medicine is so high. I paid for a CT scan out of pocket and it cost me a little over 600 bucks. When I gave my gov. insurance info to the hospital, 12,000 fucking dollars.......why??:confused: some corrupt politician hop in bed with the insurance company? I think so....lol

There are other examples....why does a pill made in the US cost Americans 20-50- 300 bucks each when you can get the same pill from the same factory across a border for 1/10th the price? Government subsides.....if the gov will buy your aspirin pill for a hundred bucks why would you charge any less? The profit margins on big pharma and the medical industry are just astronomical.

There is no reason to think competition would drive down th cost of insurance. You're logic here isn't even earth logic as far as the CT scan goes. There are a number of reasons you can get stuff cheaper across the border, at least part of it is that they didn't do the RnD part and just skipped to the profit part. But that's ultimately the difference between socialized medicine and our system.


Here you go with extremes again....I wasn't getting at cutting edge development, or even contract work. I was getting at how many hundreds of useless bases does the US have that serve NO purpose? Maybe ditch a few of those eastern European air bases that soak up billions protecting us from the eminent soviet threat? Here is one...END THE WAR, we can't afford it anymore.

Root out some of those 300 dollar hammers, 2000 dollar toilet seats and 100 dollar rolls of toilet paper....and end those contracts.

Those "useless" bases over seas are staffed by Americans, many fresh out of high school with no marketable skills. Not just the military personell either. The barbers, the tailors, the cooks, the maintenance, car manufactuer stocking them with Hummers. Those bases are also where a lot of that cutting edge stuff gets built.

As for those 300 dollar hammers and 2000 dollar toilet seats I'm highly skeptical that happens on a regular basis. I think it's a lie that we're told and nobody questions it. As much as I know that people in general are corrupt if hiring accountants to make sure nobody buried a four hundred dollar tooth brush on page six hundred of his budget proposal wasn't more expensive (or similar enough in cost) than just ignoring it someone would have done it by now and came out looking like a hero.

I still think the DEA/DHS are tit's on a bull...

Agreed.



You really should check out what those organizations are capable of with regard to influence over major industry. MPAA can financially destroy a film with an NC-17 rating for two girls kissing...or a few seconds of pubic hair. 280 people shot and killed? only one "fuck"? PG-13. Their ratings are arbitrary and behind closed doors. It's not right.

Same with the ESRB.

I am all for putting a label on a product to know what you are getting yourself into. But their needs to be set standards that are public information beyond the vague descriptions of what make an R film an NC-17 or PG-13 film.

One there are set standards and while they might not be publicly known that's because ultimately everything is a matter of personal opinion when it comes to ratings. They are pretty consistent as well. While I suppose they COULD give a movie NC-17 for two girls kissing can you name a time when it happened?

The ESRB isn't government. That's run by the industry.

What (I think) actually has you frustrated here isn't the potential for censorship. It's that the censors are from time long ago and they haven't done a good job keeping pace with America. And that's for both ratings boards. In a world where the Muppets can't get a G rating it's time to move the fucking goal posts and recalibrate it for the modern world.

We actually get more actual censorship out of groups of people who got offended about one thing or another.

So it's not 1776 anymore...so as an otherwise law abiding citizen one does not have the right to defend ones self or even enjoy marksmanship/shooting sports?

I'm all for mandatory safety class's and training, not selling guns to felons or the mentally unstable. But otherwise whats the big deal? You can't stop insane people from doing insane shit by writing insane laws. If someone want's to kill they are going to kill...just as easy with any number of other tools. Give me a pitch fork and I can rob/kill someone just the same as with a gun. I have the supplies to make a BOMB in my garage....I could use that to rob a bank just the same as with a .380 pea shooter. Hell cigg's kill like what, 40 or 50 times as many people each year? Out law that shit first....

No you can't. You cannot kill just as easily with a pitch fork as you can gun. You simply cannot. I don't care how bad ass you are the history of the world has shown that whether it's organized groups or individuals guns make killing much easier. When was the last time you think someone was accidently killed in a drive by melee weaponing? Sure you can sneak up on someone and slit their throat but it's way easier to pick someone off from two blocks down. While I'm sure it's happened I've never seen a news story about a kid hurting himself or his friend (severely) when he decided to go play with Daddy's sword or got into the kitchen knives, or played with a pitch fork. Your cigs thing isn't a fair comparison. Ciggs you do to yourself, weapons you do to others.

I did not however claim we should outlaw guns. I didn't say you don't have a right to defend yourself either. I like going out and shooting, it's fun. In perfect world the NRA would write gun laws. I figure if a bunch of gun nuts look at something and say, this is not something you should be able to just waltz into the local store and walk out with, maybe it's too much gun. However I would suggest that removing guns from the situation as much as possible has a domino effect. I neither of us NEED to bring a gun to a knife fight if we can be reasonable certain that the other guy only has a knife. Arms races works the same in reverse as long as you can enforce it.

You can also do a reasonably good job of keeping crazies from doing really crazy stuff by writing laws and making things more difficult. You can't stop 100% of people but tell me which school shooting involved the assailants gassing the school? Which one involved chucking grenades into class rooms? Rocket launcher? Surely there is a case of a claymore being set outside a post office? Can't think of when that's happened, especially outside organized terrorists? Because those things were made illegal and crazy people seem to be having a damn hard time acquiring them.




Agreed, some laws really need to be set standard at a national level for simplicity reasons alone for many things. However there are a lot of them that I think need to be at a state/county level just to allow our diversity, and freedom. People in NJ may not want to live the same way as people in TX....we need allow them the freedom to do that. Esp on a social/cultural level. (like the use of medical MJ) and as long as those laws are not unconstitutional or violating others rights....the federal gov needs to let them do it.

A lot of laws simply cannot be handled that way. Lets look at just a few. Ownership. Whether it's guns, porn, liquor, drugs or gerbils a law preventing you from owning something (especially on the East Coast) is next to meaningless if I can drive for minutes get whatever it is I want and come back without harassment. Not that I want to be harassed on the way to Pheonix. What about things like gay marriage? That's a legal contract, you can't have contracts being ignored because you happened to be in the wrong place. What about abortions. If abortion is murder (which we both know would happen in some states if the states were given the reins. What happens to someone who leaves the state and gets one?

I'd seriously like to know what specific issues, that the law would be involved in, would come up.



Sorry, I'm on my phone and auto correct fucked it up. I mean't we are "missing" out on a lot of money. And yea the weed thing is good old conservatism but it threatens a lot of industries....that's why Hemp is illegal to produce as well despite it's lack of narcotics.

I know what you meant that's why I just playfully made fun of it instead of trying to pretend I didn't know what you wer on about. While I've heard it threatens a lot of industries I'd love to see some studies proving that. It just has that inherent smell of bullshit.
 
But, when the conflict involves one side holding to a high moral principle, and the other side holding to another, competing high moral principle, historically, the result has always been tragedy. E.g., the Civil War. Both sides knew they were in the Right with a capital "R."[/QUOTE]

I doubt it will come to that. I'm an evolutionary rather than a revolutionary anarchist, but I believe that the end is near by default (anarchy by total systemic collapse...literally, the death of the State from its own weight). It's not the best outcome, because I prefer transitional phases that crowd out the State and make 100% privatization of the economy inevitable....but it's what we face, because the moral bankruptcy of the State is about to be joined by the financial bankruptcy of the State. Neither party can change the reality that the State is too big to get out of the way of its own downfall.

But that's must my forecast. In the meantime, I will side with you where I think you're right and oppose you where I think that you're wrong. Hang on, it's a bumpy ride.

For now, however, I must call it a night. Hasta manana. :cool:
 
Back
Top