Roman Polanski

Really interesting read!

I think it's spot on, but I find the reference to Facebook interesting. I see it mentioned a lot in tandem with Twitter as representative of a miasmic "social media" that forces us to simplify the truth and texture out of our news stories. But is this a new phenomenon? Surely we've been casting heroes and villains since before 2004. Was Roman Polanski given "nuanced" coverage at the time of the initial incident?

I also thought the bit about the therapist on Oprah being patronizing was of note. Granted, therapists who appear on Oprah and hypothesize about people they've never met are not exactly the types of people I listen to anyway, but I think that the idea of "victim blaming" has become knee-jerk at the expense of its effectiveness. I think there's a world of difference between acknowledging putting yourself in a dangerous situation and accepting partial blame for your attack. It's a really, really grey area though, and yes, nuanced. Needs to be something we can examine openly, honestly, thoughtfully, and safely, and that article is a great starting point.

Thank you for posting :kiss:

this

we live in a world where everyone has a story. some are violent and horrific, some filled with the beauty of naivety. that does not excuse our actions. it does not excuse the rape of innocence. i loved the pianist. there is truth in morbid beauty. layering of pain and sound into a song which makes your heart soar. we oversimplify, trying to allow ourselves the ease of black and white in a grey world. personal responsibility. truth. if i could tell the girl anything, it would be that it is not her fault for trusting a man she had permission to trust.

this, too

the required premeditation paints it close enough to black to be black. it was not a date night fumble that went too far, it was not a foolish man imagining that 'nice' girls say no when they mean yes. it is patronising to me to tell me that i'm making an immature, kneejerk, black & white judgement.

and this, as well

Interesting I didn't read it like that. I didn't get that she didn't think it was exactly what is was - anal rape of a child. The most horrendous of things to do.

I have always believed that he should be absolutely judged by what he did. The article didn't change my mind but it made me think about the grayness if you like. The complicating factors which make it impossible for us to only look at things from one angle.

I thought she used this example to explain this, to make me think about it differently, rather than excuse his behaviour. That is how I read it anyway.

to be sure, it's an interesting topic of discussion.
however, by using the polanski rape as the primary vehicle to express her message, the author absolutely implies that we the readers should reconsider the backstory factors of this case before 'rushing' to judgment, she's asking us to pause and lessen our contempt for him.

fuck. that. shit.

the guy drugged and raped an innocent little girl. the facts are clear, and incontrovertible. what's more, for over 30 years he's refused to accept responsibility for his actions and fled from justice.

fuck him and his movies. trying to redeem himself thru his "art" is a cop-out, a cowardly, despicable choice.
 
self punishment is a part of the cycle. to dream you could have had control. it is a normal part of the healing process. there is no shame in her truth the way she goes through it. i used to blame myself for wearing a swimsuit, when i was just a swimmer. i blamed myself by hiding my body. i blamed myself for everything. it gave me the illusion of control. to forgive myself for hating and hurting myself was harder than forgiving him.

:heart:

I was the 11 year old girl having to tell a grown man to leave me alone.
he didn't care, all he saw was a hot body in a bikini
 
self punishment is a part of the cycle. to dream you could have had control. it is a normal part of the healing process. there is no shame in her truth the way she goes through it. i used to blame myself for wearing a swimsuit, when i was just a swimmer. i blamed myself by hiding my body. i blamed myself for everything. it gave me the illusion of control. to forgive myself for hating and hurting myself was harder than forgiving him.

Ok...

...I did not realize we were talking about you in this thread, or that you are somehow qualified as to speak for all women re: "the healing process" just because you happen to be one.

Of course, I could be totally wrong, and every woman does, in fact, blame herself first and foremost...

...but, that really can't be because some of the women I've met who've been victims of rape certainly don't "blame" themselves like you do.

Must be an individual thing...

...huh?
 
No comments on Jack Nicholson's possible connection to any of this?


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/07/27/edith-vogelhut-roman-pola_n_661194.html

13-year-old Samantha Geimer...

...21-year old Edith Vogelhut, 16-year old Charlotte Lewis.

Oh, Nicholson was no doubt aware, at the very least, of his bud's fondness for juicing-up and then sodomizing underage girls and young women...

...but, for a myriad of illegitimate reasons, Nicholson's participation has also been tolerated.
 
Ok...

...I did not realize we were talking about you in this thread, or that you are somehow qualified as to speak for all women re: "the healing process" just because you happen to be one.

Of course, I could be totally wrong, and every woman does, in fact, blame herself first and foremost...

...but, that really can't be because some of the women I've met who've been victims of rape certainly don't "blame" themselves like you do.

Must be an individual thing...

...huh?

everyone reacts differently. the way the author of the article read through her glasses, i read through mine. and no. not every person reacts in the same way. there are many ways of coping with trauma. yes. self blame is one way. the quote YOU quoted...

I did something wrong, I was stupid… To pose topless, and to drink and to take the [sleeping] pill.

i was stupid. you commented on how she, as an adult, was punishing the little girl. that was my story as well, so i commented. i agree with you that rape is rape and it should be punished. there is also process of healing. not all people go through the exact same process or cycle, but there are patterns. that is one. not the only one, but definitely one worth noting, as you yourself noted first.
 
everyone reacts differently. the way the author of the article read through her glasses, i read through mine. and no. not every person reacts in the same way. there are many ways of coping with trauma. yes. self blame is one way. the quote YOU quoted...



i was stupid. you commented on how she, as an adult, was punishing the little girl. that was my story as well, so i commented. i agree with you that rape is rape and it should be punished. there is also process of healing. not all people go through the exact same process or cycle, but there are patterns. that is one. not the only one, but definitely one worth noting, as you yourself noted first.

I agree with you...
 
Back
Top