Red light cameras

No, it isn't. Legally, it's exactly the same. You should really try and get some eduction on a topic before you start a rant, you just look dumb otherwise.

If a court has ruled that these two things are exactly the same I have yet to hear about it. I'm sure you can refer me to it.
 
Presumably we don't want people ignoring all red lights and flouting the law, even the patriots among us, but on the other hand we also want a little leeway in the system, a little slippage. This is one of the main things people hate about the total surveillance society.

Anyway, in the case of traffic laws and red light cams, what's happening now is that we're in an interregnum where the state of technology is advanced enough to constantly keep an eye on drivers, but not quite advanced enough to move to a completely automated traffic control network which would obviate the problem by taking the decision out of the driver's hands. The two technologies are closely related--one is really an aspect of the other.

Stupid shit! In 5 years they'll mail you tickets for scratching your ass in public. They'll hire 1000s to sit and watch you and track the barcode on your boxers.
 
If a court has ruled that these two things are exactly the same I have yet to hear about it.

Hard to believe the Supreme Court didn't give you a call when they issued the opinion. Thank God every one of them are available on the internet. You don't even have to wonder where your local government built the public library.


I'm sure you can refer me to it.

He already did. Google "expectation of privacy." Read every frigging hit that is returned. You need it.
 
I dig red light cameras. Most of the people who have to pay fines due to them are those who feel the rules don't apply to them for one reason or another.

Besides, it is a lot more effective to use RLCs than post a LEO at an intersection with a high number of offenders. The LEO would never be able to stop everyone while the RLC records every offense for review and selection for a fine.

The main change I'd like to see with RLC use is a second camera set be installed so pictures of the driver are taken also at the time of the offense so points can be applied to the driver's license.
 
Last edited:
Hard to believe the Supreme Court didn't give you a call when they issued the opinion. Thank God every one of them are available on the internet. You don't even have to wonder where your local government built the public library.




He already did. Google "expectation of privacy." Read every frigging hit that is returned. You need it.

You'd need a warrant to track a car with GPS.
 
You'd need a warrant to track a car with GPS.

Which has nothing to do with whether authorities can photographically monitor an intersection and prosecute people shown committing traffic violations.

If you showed up on a bank security camera holding the place up, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Of course.

If an outside security camera showed you shooting someone as you fled the bank, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Also, yes.

If you stopped, pulled down your pants and pissed on the body, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Are you getting a clue yet?

Your "expectation" of privacy with respect to your breaking the law in the middle of a PUBLIC intersection is in no way legally "reasonable."
 
Which has nothing to do with whether authorities can photographically monitor an intersection and prosecute people shown committing traffic violations.

If you showed up on a bank security camera holding the place up, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Of course.

If an outside security camera showed you shooting someone as you fled the bank, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Also, yes.

If you stopped, pulled down your pants and pissed on the body, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Are you getting a clue yet?

Your "expectation" of privacy with respect to your breaking the law in the middle of a PUBLIC intersection is in no way legally "reasonable."

I adore explaining their own laws to US "patriots". :D
 
Which has nothing to do with whether authorities can photographically monitor an intersection and prosecute people shown committing traffic violations.

If you showed up on a bank security camera holding the place up, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Of course.

If an outside security camera showed you shooting someone as you fled the bank, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Also, yes.

If you stopped, pulled down your pants and pissed on the body, do you think that video image could be entered into evidence against you? Are you getting a clue yet?

Your "expectation" of privacy with respect to your breaking the law in the middle of a PUBLIC intersection is in no way legally "reasonable."

I'm aware that red light cameras work in different ways in different places. Where I am they take a picture of the car, not the person.

So to respond to your post, they don't have any visual evidence of who committed a crime.
 
Cams have been on red lights since shortly after 911, you just noticed!
 
My feeling on red light cameras depends on why they were put up.

IF they were put up where there have been accidents caused by people running red lights, I am fine with them. These are done in response to traffic safety issues.

But if they put them up just to generate revenue, I am not.

Also note that various agencies have been caught reducing the time on the yellow lights, helping to guarantee people will run the red. This, IMHO, is dishonest.

I believe most of them are done for revenue.
 
My feeling on red light cameras depends on why they were put up.

IF they were put up where there have been accidents caused by people running red lights, I am fine with them. These are done in response to traffic safety issues.

But if they put them up just to generate revenue, I am not.

Also note that various agencies have been caught reducing the time on the yellow lights, helping to guarantee people will run the red. This, IMHO, is dishonest.

I believe most of them are done for revenue.

Lengthen the yellow lite time.

But safety is a red herring because its a revenue generator. When the cams failed to make money we shortened the yellow lite time.
 
Not even the issue. I don't run red lights, because I don't drive a car. I refuse to surrender my rights in order to drive.

The point is that your privacy is invaded, & you don't get to face your accuser in court.

In my city, running red lights is a blood sport. The people who whine about red light cameras think it's their right to run red lights. It's sort of like shoplifting. They think if no one sees them do it, no harm, no foul. Security cameras catch shoplifters every day.

I am happy to learn you don't drive. There are enough self indulgent law breakers on the street, without you. Think of it as your contribution to public safety.
 
I'm aware that red light cameras work in different ways in different places. Where I am they take a picture of the car, not the person.

So to respond to your post, they don't have any visual evidence of who committed a crime.

Congratulations! You have finally stumbled upon the correct legal issue relevant to your original complaint. But it is not a privacy issue. If anything, it would be a Sixth Amendment issue, and at that, the U. S. Constitution is silent on the legality of "strict liability" criminal statutes within the various states.

Strict liability, if you did not know, is a legal standard that removes mens rea as a necessary component for successful prosecution. Your intent, negligence, carelessness and/or knowledge of the law are all irrelevant to your liability under the law.

Perhaps the most commonly understood example of the principle would be a parking ticket for a metered space whose time had expired. You're responsible for the violation regardless of who parked your car there. Technically, that may not be the best example because overtime parking is probably not statutorily "criminal" in most jurisdictions, but you get the idea.

In the vast majority of jurisdictions, traffic cam enforcement is directed at misdemeanor violations which have likely been written as strict liability statutes. The comparative seriousness of the offense being so low vis-a-vis other crimes and the widely varying ways states deal with the issue has so far resulted in little effort to harmonize strict liability nationwide.

I don't think you will see that changing anytime soon.
 
Back
Top