Reading list privacy setting not working

[AnotherSelf]

Several of my reading lists that were previously private are now public and there is no option to change it. Can someone help with this?

 

[lilshymynx]

Several of my reading lists that were previously private are now public and there is no option to change it. Can someone help with this?

There should be a gear icon next to the padlock on your created lists, select that and you can change it there. Does that icon not appear for you?