Rape fanfic is " ethics in gaming journalism"

badbabysitter

Vault Girl
Joined
Jul 6, 2002
Posts
19,179
http://techcrunch.com/2014/12/19/gamergate-e-book/

GamerGate has not bottomed out quite yet. The pent-up rage of a group of disenfranchised misogynists has found a new digital outlet for harassing one of their targets, games developer Zoe Quinn, in the form of Amazon Kindle e-books.

If you are one of the handful of people still bleating that GamerGate is about ‘ethics in games journalism’, then a 3,000+ word e-book [which now looks to have been taken down] about five men raping a “controversial video game designer” — with the thinly veiled fictional name of Zada Quinby — really isn’t going to help your cause.

The real life Quinn is the developer of an interactive game about depression, called Depression Quest.

This e-book is just another example of the highly unpleasant trolling that has characterized GamerGame, much of it playing out on Twitter, where hate speech has been allowed to flow free. And where rape and death threats have driven multiple women in the games industry out of their homes, or forced them to cancel speaking engagements.

The underlying agenda of GamerGate has always been an attempt to intimidate and drive women out of the games industry. While the threats of violence have been exceptionally crude, the tactics have been relatively sophisticated, with co-ordinated online attacks aimed at amplifying the impact and noise, and exerting commercial pressure on digital advertisers.

Tactics that I and others have argued requires mainstream social platforms to up their own game when it comes to combating co-ordinated hate mobs by giving users more granular controls for filtering their feeds. Bottom line: this is an online bullying issue, not a free speech issue. And indeed, earlier this month, Twitter launched a suite of new anti-harassment tools to make it easier for users to block or report bullies on the network.

Penning 11-pages of hate speech and publishing it as an e-book on a mainstream ecommerce platform is just the latest GamerGate attempt to bully Quinn and amplify minority views. Albeit, in this instance, the harassment might well be the work of a lone supporter with too much time on their hands, rather than another orchestrated attack.

The book is also priced at $3.08 so an even more cynical take is this is an opportunistic GamerGater attempting to cash in on fellow GGer’s hate.

Truly trolling has reached a new low. But has my TC colleague John Biggs has noted, the goal of the troll isn’t to make a point. The goal is to bother someone and watch them squirm.
 
I must live in a completely different world. I do not know what any of that means.
 
Seriously, what is so fucking hard to understand about the word "excerpt"?
 
It's a controversy at the intersection between video games and journalism.

I don't play video games but I understand they are a thing. I have this image of jules from pulp fiction about to explain it to me.."But you know there are these things called video games, right?"

How do you get from there to journalism? Like news right?

I am on the road for work all the time and the company puts us up in these by the week chain hotels. Clean and comfortable enough, but basic. Maybe they have HBO. Usually like 20 channels no one watches. I get in these conversations in bars and cafes and people talk about things that I have no idea about. Not like I don't read the paper, surf the web. Feels like theres this whole other world going on on some other channel.
 
I don't play video games but I understand they are a thing. I have this image of jules from pulp fiction about to explain it to me.."But you know there are these things called video games, right?"

How do you get from there to journalism? Like news right?

This may come off as condescending but it's not at all intended to be, and I think you've connected the dots anyway, but I feel compelled to make certain, so here goes:

It's not "like" news. It is news. Unless you meant "like" in the Southern California sense, which I politely yet firmly and eternally reject.

Okay, that bit was slightly condescending. Anyway...

Video games as an industry generate(s?) revenue that rivals Hollywood. You get from there to journalism in much the same way that you get from movies to news: an extremely popular and lucrative form of entertainment for those reasons alone becomes generally newsworthy.

So yes, there are people who professionally write about video games in various ways, from rumors of games in early development thru reviews of released products to real-time and other reporting on "esports" (video games played professionally, with team sponsors to boot).

There are a multitude of views on the GamerGate controversy, but it seems to me that for the most part people fall into one of two camps:

1) #GamerGate is a legitimate social media movement to demand greater integrity in gaming journalism (i.e. less corruption and incest)

b) #GamerGate is a thin guise for misogynists to harass and threaten women, especially those who work in the video game and gaming journalism industries


I am on the road for work all the time and the company puts us up in these by the week chain hotels. Clean and comfortable enough, but basic. Maybe they have HBO. Usually like 20 channels no one watches. I get in these conversations in bars and cafes and people talk about things that I have no idea about. Not like I don't read the paper, surf the web. Feels like theres this whole other world going on on some other channel.

There always is, no matter where you are and how much or how little you travel.

But I can see how you feel that way more so than most would. I've been in similar circumstances.
 
No offense taken. I don't like like used like that either, like you know?

I kind of meant that I was having trouble seeing it on places like news broadcasts or newspapers. I never watch entertainment news, but I understand that its popular so what you say makes sense. From what you were saying it makes sense (well not to me) there are probably celebrity gamers. Maybe I went into the wrong line of work.

I get the idea of when "news" whether its paper or the TV sometimes is not news but kind of advertising. Like when they swallow a press release whole. I could see where journalists could help puff something, but isnt that what entertainment news kind of does? Makes a movie look interesting so that matt damen or whoever will give them the interview?
 
This may come off as condescending but it's not at all intended to be, and I think you've connected the dots anyway, but I feel compelled to make certain, so here goes:

It's not "like" news. It is news. Unless you meant "like" in the Southern California sense, which I politely yet firmly and eternally reject.

Okay, that bit was slightly condescending. Anyway...

Video games as an industry generate(s?) revenue that rivals Hollywood. You get from there to journalism in much the same way that you get from movies to news: an extremely popular and lucrative form of entertainment for those reasons alone becomes generally newsworthy.

So yes, there are people who professionally write about video games in various ways, from rumors of games in early development thru reviews of released products to real-time and other reporting on "esports" (video games played professionally, with team sponsors to boot).

There are a multitude of views on the GamerGate controversy, but it seems to me that for the most part people fall into one of two camps:

1) #GamerGate is a legitimate social media movement to demand greater integrity in gaming journalism (i.e. less corruption and incest)

b) #GamerGate is a thin guise for misogynists to harass and threaten women, especially those who work in the video game and gaming journalism industries




There always is, no matter where you are and how much or how little you travel.

But I can see how you feel that way more so than most would. I've been in similar circumstances.

This doesn't come off as condescending it IS condescending in it's entirety. While I'm sure this is absolutely fascinating news to those immersed in the gaming world some of us only have a faint passing interest in such drama.

Before you get all bristled consider: News to me is the new Kawasaki H2 and the fact that Ricky Gadson did a few minor mods on it and pulled an 8.2 ET. Don't know what I'm talkin' about? Well to paraphrase a line form a cool old movie,"...it depends on what small area of knowledge you care for just how dumb you are."

Ask a farmer about farming and you'll glean some really great information. Ask him about hedge funds and most times you're going to get a blank stare.



'nuff said



Comshaw
 
This doesn't come off as condescending it IS condescending in it's entirety.

While I'm sure this is absolutely fascinating news to those immersed in the gaming world some of us only have a faint passing interest in such drama.

Before you get all bristled consider: News to me is the new Kawasaki H2 and the fact that Ricky Gadson did a few minor mods on it and pulled an 8.2 ET. Don't know what I'm talkin' about? Well to paraphrase a line form a cool old movie,"...it depends on what small area of knowledge you care for just how dumb you are."

Ask a farmer about farming and you'll glean some really great information. Ask him about hedge funds and most times you're going to get a blank stare.



'nuff said



Comshaw

Is that post supposed to be ironic? The part of my post referencing condescension was intended to be humorous.

Ask a gamer who has been following the GamerGate stories about it and you will hear about GamerGate. Whether it's faint and in passing or not, interest is still interest. If Conager weren't interested at all I think he would not have asked. In contrast, I didn't ask you about motorcycles.

He already said "no offense taken" so what business is it of yours to take offense in his behalf? Bristled indeed.
 
I'm more concerned about ethics in real journalism. Get that taken care of and maybe I'll give a fuck that some strumpet is banging guys for a good review.
 
I'm more concerned about ethics in real journalism. Get that taken care of and maybe I'll give a fuck that some strumpet is banging guys for a good review.

The story that started it isn't even true. She was dating a guy who worked for the same development company as a game she reviewed but he never worked on the game in question.

That's how much bullshit is swirling around this.
 
Back
Top