"Quiet" The Book

Recidiva

Harastal
Joined
Sep 3, 2005
Posts
89,726
Anybody read this? It's about introverted personality types and the scientific and social study of such.

I'm slammed pretty much full-on introversion on the Myers Briggs so I am interested in the book.

The author sounds a little PTSD-ey at times, as if some extrovert beat her up on the playground, but a lot of the stuff is interesting.
 
I've run through it today. Have you taken the Myers Briggs test? It's the definition of introvert I'm using. The author calls it introverted and also highly sensitive.

We had to take that test my freshman year of high school. I don't remember what I had, but I'm pretty sure it's changed a bit since then.
 
We had to take that test my freshman year of high school. I don't remember what I had, but I'm pretty sure it's changed a bit since then.

I've pretty much always been an INFP every time I take it. Close to 90-100 in each category so I get the extreme angle.
 
I'll have to take that test again.

My sister always complained that I was a hamster in a habitrail, in my room with my books and music. I had plenty of friends, and I'm not socially shy (can you tell?) but I do match the introvert definition.

She always had to bribe me to go out shopping or to the movies with her. Made her nuts.

I always thought that it was better to be me on the whole. Extroversion seems...exhausting...and requiring...other people.
 
I heard a conversation about it on CBC Radio 1 a month or so ago...as I understand it, the book says that most interactions (business and social) are "designed" for extroverts and that we should all make more "room" for introverts.

Like quiet time in business meetings so we can wait for the intros to muster up the stones to say their 5 words, that sort of thing.

It has some validity.
 
Anybody read this? It's about introverted personality types and the scientific and social study of such.

I'm slammed pretty much full-on introversion on the Myers Briggs so I am interested in the book.

The author sounds a little PTSD-ey at times, as if some extrovert beat her up on the playground, but a lot of the stuff is interesting.

It was made into a lifetime movie. The main character 'Dot' is deaf. Go on youtube and type in 'The quiet.' I believe Eragonthedragon1 is the one who posted the movie...


us
 
I heard a conversation about it on CBC Radio 1 a month or so ago...as I understand it, the book says that most interactions (business and social) are "designed" for extroverts and that we should all make more "room" for introverts.

Like quiet time in business meetings so we can wait for the intros to muster up the stones to say their 5 words, that sort of thing.

It has some validity.

Yeah, it has some interesting parts about how many business models are based on extroverted ideals, and how Harvard Business School is Extroversion Central. How we are primed socially to listen to the most confident or the loudest (at least extroverts are) and introverts can have trouble getting their thoughts heard or sold not because their ideas are not good, but because the method of delivery is wrong when addressing an extrovert. Different set of priorities and often the extroversion pattern is the one most adopted.

Also that background noise is good for an extrovert and distracting for an introvert, when the reverse is true also. Cool experiments.

I work at home and I love that, I have no problems with discipline or loneliness. It's perfect for me. I know for many other personality types, they'd be ready to chew off their wrists at the end of the day.

I am in a minority, so I understand extroverted customs and I respect them or else I know I get the hose.

But it's nice to see a book about people like me. Some cool research about following babies throughout their lifetimes and tracking responses as a baby and classifying reactions as "highly sensitive" or otherwise, and then following their social development.
 
Anybody read this? It's about introverted personality types and the scientific and social study of such.

I'm slammed pretty much full-on introversion on the Myers Briggs so I am interested in the book.

The author sounds a little PTSD-ey at times, as if some extrovert beat her up on the playground, but a lot of the stuff is interesting.

Nope but I will...right up my ally.

Have you read; The Enneagram: Understanding Yourself by Palmer, Helen?

Awesome book!
 
Yeah, it has some interesting parts about how many business models are based on extroverted ideals, and how Harvard Business School is Extroversion Central. How we are primed socially to listen to the most confident or the loudest (at least extroverts are) and introverts can have trouble getting their thoughts heard or sold not because their ideas are not good, but because the method of delivery is wrong when addressing an extrovert. Different set of priorities and often the extroversion pattern is the one most adopted.

Also that background noise is good for an extrovert and distracting for an introvert, when the reverse is true also. Cool experiments.

I work at home and I love that, I have no problems with discipline or loneliness. It's perfect for me. I know for many other personality types, they'd be ready to chew off their wrists at the end of the day.

I am in a minority, so I understand extroverted customs and I respect them or else I know I get the hose.

But it's nice to see a book about people like me. Some cool research about following babies throughout their lifetimes and tracking responses as a baby and classifying reactions as "highly sensitive" or otherwise, and then following their social development.

Yeah...it all seems pretty obvious when you think about it.

And the truth is that a really good leader makes room for everyone to contribute, be heard, etc on terms that work.
 
Yeah...it all seems pretty obvious when you think about it.

And the truth is that a really good leader makes room for everyone to contribute, be heard, etc on terms that work.

Yes. I think this behavior is pretty hardwired.

Myers Briggs does help people understand other processing styles and approaches.

My sister had me take it first and when it explained me to her, even though I'd been saying the same thing for years, she finally got it. She had to take hers at work. It's a little insulting to not be trusted unless I can be found in a book, but at least I found that book.

I think the worst prevalent extrovert thing that works for them and not us, is the whole "You shouldn't stay in the house, it's unhealthy. You should go out!" I'd rather drip lye in my eyes. The absolute last thing I should be doing if I'm not feeling well is to go out into a crowd of loud people.

I always see scenes in movies of a depressed person going to a bar and it just seems like suicide. What are you doing?!
 
Yes. I think this behavior is pretty hardwired.

Myers Briggs does help people understand other processing styles and approaches.

My sister had me take it first and when it explained me to her, even though I'd been saying the same thing for years, she finally got it. She had to take hers at work. It's a little insulting to not be trusted unless I can be found in a book, but at least I found that book.

I think the worst prevalent extrovert thing that works for them and not us, is the whole "You shouldn't stay in the house, it's unhealthy. You should go out!" I'd rather drip lye in my eyes. The absolute last thing I should be doing if I'm not feeling well is to go out into a crowd of loud people.

I always see scenes in movies of a depressed person going to a bar and it just seems like suicide. What are you doing?!


Getting out of the cave is the healthy part; you don't need to be around loud people.

Even a walk around the block for people who have cloistered themselves is important stuff.

Depending on when I take a MB test, I can test as INFP or ENFP, but I think that extroverts are often shy people wearing a compensating masque to some degree anyway.

Birth Order is also handy when balanced off against MB...I'm the eldest of 3 boys, for example, born to parents who were each the youngest of many, so in my family unit, I was the de facto Leader much of the time in terms of our social dynamic, buttressed by the fact that in a 3 bedroom house, I was the only person with his own room. To this day, the rest of my first family sees me as something of a leader/loner, which, if true, is true because of the way I was socialized in that group of people.
 
high 'I' checking in. the book sounds interesting. i retested myself a year or two ago (it had been 10+ years,) and found out i had changed from an INFP to an INFJ. the 'I' had just gotten stronger. quiet is nice.
 
Getting out of the cave is the healthy part; you don't need to be around loud people.

Even a walk around the block for people who have cloistered themselves is important stuff.

Depending on when I take a MB test, I can test as INFP or ENFP, but I think that extroverts are often shy people wearing a compensating masque to some degree anyway.

Birth Order is also handy when balanced off against MB...I'm the eldest of 3 boys, for example, born to parents who were each the youngest of many, so in my family unit, I was the de facto Leader much of the time in terms of our social dynamic, buttressed by the fact that in a 3 bedroom house, I was the only person with his own room. To this day, the rest of my first family sees me as something of a leader/loner, which, if true, is true because of the way I was socialized in that group of people.

Well, I get exercise at my desk, I use my pedometer for 10,000 steps a day, I talk to you guys sometimes and I also keep up with the news and crap TV. I feel I've done my part to be engaged.

I have a husband and kids and that certainly socializes me. Ulaven is also introverted and we do well just hanging out doing our things, including video games. Both kids are gamers also. It's an introvert haven that is socially suspect. My daughter is extroverted, my son has Asperger's, so he's a study of sensitivities, but he has extroverted and introverted tendencies in different situations, many may just be sociallly inhibited and not based on his preference.

Some research was mentioned that I had heard before and I find fascinating. A control group is given the opportunity to answer fairly obvious questions alone, and they get it right. When a confident, forcefully expressed opinion that is obviously wrong enters the mix, the numbers change. From a series of experiements, this and others, it appears that 75% of the population will agree with the wrong opinion and about 25% will dissent. It gets confusing in the interpretation, are they intimidated, are they going with the group to protect themselves, what is it? Her conclusion (and I think there was FMRI involved, which I find very suspicious, even before a dead salmon in an FRMI started giving off signals) is that people become "inspired" by the speaker and feel they've broken through some sort of barrier and solved a problem.

Do you find the INFP or ENFP description matches you?

The book does progress into more PTSD every now and then. She pretty much blamed the global commerce collapse on Extroverts. I prefer "assholes."

I was the youngest. So I get to do the humor and lack of set responsibility thing to go along with the reality that I'm usually one of the 25% dissenting and getting the "look." I'm pretty assured that I will have no influence over a group, though I may have influence over individuals over that group if I express myself clearly.

My sister was the eldest and I do believe she tried to herd and protect and was frustrated by my "me" ness.

The social mask was always an issue for me, I was frustrated about it until I realized people aren't necessarily lying to me, so much as lying to themselves about what they think I want to see. True Believers who manage to lie to themselves and then lie to others defeat all attempts at lie detection, but it's still a lie. Once I figured that bit out I relaxed a lot more socially and stopped trying to fix or help so much as just let people be who they want to appear to be if at all possible and it's not really doing any harm. I think the internet sort of forces everyone into that space and I'm pretty comfortable there. Truth becomes unknowable and therefore it's not really not my responsibility to point it out.
 
high 'I' checking in. the book sounds interesting. i retested myself a year or two ago (it had been 10+ years,) and found out i had changed from an INFP to an INFJ. the 'I' had just gotten stronger. quiet is nice.

There are a LOT of INFP's online. I think a survey of the Author's Hangout once took on a huge percentage proportionally. We're supposed to be about 1% of the overall population, but the online population is weighted heavily with that type.
 
One cool thing she mentioned that I'd noticed, different metaphors for the same exact thing interpreted across social strategies and cultures.

Western Metaphor: "The squeaky wheel gets the grease." i.e. "If you are loud about what you need, you will get it."

versus

Eastern Metaphor: "The tall nail gets the hammer." i.e. "If you are loud about what you need, you will garner the most abuse."

The association of European and American societies being individualistic and extroverted and the Asian cultures being group oriented and introverted aren't new, but it is kinda cool to see the breakdown in how that plays out in practice.
 
Back
Top