Overrated movies? Underrated movies?

[RastaPope]

Overrated--Everything Tarantino

Underrated--The Hudsucker Proxy. Excellent flick.

 

[BigDawg69]

Overrated: Anything with Al Pacino (except Godfather I and II)

Underrated: Most Paul Newman movies

 

[Willing and Unsure]

Overrated: Titanic

 

[brokenbrainwave]

overated: the box covers to porno movies, most read like they have a plot!

underated: Awakenings and Dead Poets Society...along with This Boys Life.

 

[RastaPope]

Overrated: Tim Burton movies, specifically "The movie that is kinda sorta similar to this guy named Batman" movie (1989)

Underrated: The Rocketeer

 

[mischeviousmisti]

overrated: a beautiful mind
underrated: original sin

 

[Star of Penumbra]

Overrated--Everything Tarantino

Underrated--The Hudsucker Proxy. Excellent flick.

I couldn't agree more. Tim Robbins was great ("You know, for kids!"). And after watching some Tarantino movies, I for the life of me couldn't figure out what everybody else saw in them.

Overrated: Austin Powers: Goldmember. I thought it was funny, but not nearly as good as the first one, or even the second.

Also Overrated: Star Wars, Episode 2. Just not a good movie, even though it was infinitely better than Episode 1. I don't think I'll bother with Episode 3 after being let down twice in a row.

Underrated: Mystery Science Theater 3000, The Movie. Yeah, it had a low budget, but it's still hilarious. ("So they worship the Everlasting Gobstopper?") Too bad they stopped production on the series.

 

[april-wine]

Overrated.......Eyes Wide Shut

Underrated.....My Life As A House

 

[trixiefirecracker]

Underrated.....Long Time Dead

 

[Anais Dahl]

Overrated- Training Day

Underrated- Shallow Grave

 

[Marquis]

Overrated: Traffic

HUUUUGELY Underrated: Requiem for a Dream

 

[modest mouse]

Overrated - Good Will Hunting

Underated - Drugstore Cowboy

*

Overrated - Mulholland Drive

Underrated - Crash

*

Overrated - Magnolia

Underrated - Hard Eight

*

Overrated - The Age of Innocence

Underrated - After Hours

*

Overrated - Malcolm X

Underrated - Clockers



*****


Overrated - American Beauty

Underrated - The Ice Storm

*

Overrated - Sixth Sense

Underrated - Stir of Echoes

*

Overrated - Saving Private Ryan

Underrated - The Thin Red Line

 

[Lasher]

underrated: Bob Roberts