NC passes Admendment 1

i do not know why someone who has such a hard time with abstract ideas feels so compelled to dwell in them.

perg was pondering the source of rights.

that is a great ponder. philosophers have done it for centuries. our constitution and laws draw heavily from them.

so--i pointed out to perg other, more recent, articulations of rights. other places define fundamental rights differently. south africa's constitution is one of the most recent available.

i did not suggest it was superior or inferior. south africa, though, did just what our forefathers did. it considered the wisdom and experience of other places.

Yes, primarily from John Locke the first of the English empiricists. Locke developed the notion of 'natural rights' and those natural rights were derived from God. And virtually everything in that day and age was ascribed to God in one form or another. And as such those rights were outside the sphere of government.

However a careful reading of Locke shows that God can be removed from the logical train of thought that leads to the notion of 'natural rights' without damaging the core philosophy. In other words Locke's philosophy could be re-written today with the notion of "No God Required."

Ishmael
 
Yes, primarily from John Locke the first of the English empiricists. Locke developed the notion of 'natural rights' and those natural rights were derived from God. And virtually everything in that day and age was ascribed to God in one form or another. And as such those rights were outside the sphere of government.

However a careful reading of Locke shows that God can be removed from the logical train of thought that leads to the notion of 'natural rights' without damaging the core philosophy. In other words Locke's philosophy could be re-written today with the notion of "No God Required."

Ishmael

i've been reading about edward coke and his standoff with king james over whether the king IS the law is subservient to the law. coke won.

sure were a lot of big brains thinking back then.
 
i've been reading about edward coke and his standoff with king james over whether the king IS the law is subservient to the law. coke won.

sure were a lot of big brains thinking back then.

If you research Coke in depth you will find that he too was deeply influenced by the writings of Locke. However he worked within the European notion of the flow of power which was originally from God, to the Monarch, and then to the people permissively. Coke redrew those lines, or at least set in motion the redrawing by the assertion that power flowed from God, to the Parliament, and then to the people permissively. Which remains the European model to this day (go read the Bill of Rights in the aborted EU Constitution). And yes, I know that Coke was a champion of Common Law, but only to a point and one has only to look at the UK today to see the trajectory they're on.

The American experiment turned all of that on it's head by the assertion that power flowed from God, to the people, which in turn loaned that power to the government. Needless to say we've drifted far from that notion as well and are beginning to look more like the Europeans year by year. The only saving grace is the constitution, the one that Obama (along with many others) don't seem to like at all in that the document is a restrictive document, not a permissive document, when it comes to the powers of government.

Ishmael
 
If you research Coke in depth you will find that he too was deeply influenced by the writings of Locke. However he worked within the European notion of the flow of power which was originally from God, to the Monarch, and then to the people permissively. Coke redrew those lines, or at least set in motion the redrawing by the assertion that power flowed from God, to the Parliament, and then to the people permissively. Which remains the European model to this day (go read the Bill of Rights in the aborted EU Constitution). And yes, I know that Coke was a champion of Common Law, but only to a point and one has only to look at the UK today to see the trajectory they're on.

The American experiment turned all of that on it's head by the assertion that power flowed from God, to the people, which in turn loaned that power to the government. Needless to say we've drifted far from that notion as well and are beginning to look more like the Europeans year by year. The only saving grace is the constitution, the one that Obama (along with many others) don't seem to like at all in that the document is a restrictive document, not a permissive document, when it comes to the powers of government.
Yes, but you forgot to capitalize "Constitution." Again.

We don't say "magna carta," do we?

Many countries have constitutions, but there is only one US Constitution.

It is my belief that it ought to be capitalized.
 
Yes, but you forgot to capitalize "Constitution." Again.

We don't say "magna carta," do we?

Many countries have constitutions, but there is only one US Constitution.

It is my belief that it ought to be capitalized.

You can edit.

Ishmael
 
Yes, but you forgot to capitalize "Constitution." Again.

We don't say "magna carta," do we?

Many countries have constitutions, but there is only one US Constitution.

It is my belief that it ought to be capitalized.

Well, one can also fairly speak of the "constitution of the United States" in the lower-case and British sense, to mean the biology of the system, as it were, and the whole body of customs and understandings about it.
 
Have you read Section 5 of the 14th Amendment? Congress has the power to enforce by appropriate legislation the provisions of the article. So why don't you go to your congressman and ask him to introduce specific protection for gay people
Because I'm not interested in "specific protection" for people.
I'm for not arbitrarily denying rights to a certain class of people, rights that the general populace enjoys, just because they have some physiological "difference" that some people don't approve of.
That doesn't require special laws as it's already covered by the Constitution.
 
Because I'm not interested in "specific protection" for people.
I'm for not arbitrarily denying rights to a certain class of people, rights that the general populace enjoys, just because they have some physiological "difference" that some people don't approve of.
That doesn't require special laws as it's already covered by the Constitution.

It's interesting how well some of these vitriol-spewing knuckle-dragging Neanderthals (using words like faggots and cocksuckers) can type.
 
Yes, but you forgot to capitalize "Constitution." Again.

We don't say "magna carta," do we?

Many countries have constitutions, but there is only one US Constitution.

It is my belief that it ought to be capitalized.

Yes, but he "researched" these things in depth.

That's got to mean something, right?
 
Back
Top