On my own, pretending he's beside me. All alone, I walk with him 'til morning. In the darkness, the pavement shines like silver, and all I see is him and me forever and forever. And I know, it's only in my mind. That I'm talking to myself and not to him, and although I know that he is blind, still I say there's a way for us. I love him, but everday I'm learning, all my life I've only been pretending, without me, his world will go on turning, a world that's full of happiness that I have never known. I love him, I love him, but only on my own.
Les Miserable. I've seen it twice in person, once in NY and once in London. London was better, but that can get expensive just to see a good musical.
My favorite musical...sorry I have several..Cats, South Pacific, and Madame Butterfly. Favorite song from a musical Eidel Weiss from the Sound of Music.
I like "Superstar", but I'll never forget what a reviewer once wrote regarding Tim Rice, that he doesn't actually write lyrics so much as he sets bits of information to music.
I have too many favorites. Almost anything by Sonheim ("I Remember Sky...."), Kander & Ebb ("It's a quiet thing..."), Meredith Wilson ("Lydia Rose, I'm home again, Rose..."), Lerner and Lowe, Rogers and Hart, Rogers and Hammerstein, Berlin, Kelmar and Ruby, Porter, Gershwin, etc. etc., etc. ad infinitum.
Techincally "My Fair Lady" and "Gypsy" are the most perfect American Musicals. (Though I've always loved Woody Allen's 60's stand-up bit about how they've just spent a year removing all the music and lyrics from "My Fair Lady", turning it back into "Pygmallion").
"Godspell" is kick-ass to perform or direct.
I suppose I don't need to convince anyone how great Gilbert and Sullivan were. "With Cat-Like Tread" sung at the top of your lungs -- brilliantly ironic and self-aware stylization. And "The Mikado"..! What music..
But I can enjoy even bad musicals. I enjoy the hell out of the splashy British mega-musicals, even if the music is tinny, the narrative is vacant, and the staging more Vegas than Broadway. "Chess", "Les Miz", "Cats" all have their great, great moments (okay, maybe not "Cats"), but as whole works the style way overcomes the substance. Still, "I Know Him So Well" and others are great cabaret numbers.
"Barnum" is not at all great, but very fun.
Probably the worst musical I've ever seen on Broadway was "Late Night Comic". It ran for two months. (I saw it twice, if you can beleive it, because I got free tickets). It was the only major musical I ever saw that received a two-line review in a major NY paper. The Daily News said something to this effect: "The only thing more cruel than forcing an audience to watch is this show is letting it run and forcing the actors to continue doing it." That was the second line. I think the first line was something like "It sucks."