Songcatcher
Stud Muffin
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2002
- Posts
- 25,989
What If?
by Theodore Lustig
Morgantown, West Virginia
I received my discharge papers on April 25, 1946. I had survived three years of army service in World War II, and now I was heading home on a train to Newark, New Jersey. The last thing I'd done at the base in Fort Dix was to buy a white shirt at the post exchange - a symbol of my return to civilian life.
I was eager to put my grand plan for the future into action. I would return to college, launch my career, and look for the girl on my dreams. And I knew exactly who that girl would be. I'd had a crush on her ever since high school. The question was: How could I find her? We hadn't been in contact for four years. Well, it might take some time, I thought, but find her I would.
When the train pulled into the station, I gathered up my bags, tucked my new shirt under my arm, and headed down to the bus platform - the last leg of my journey home. And then, miracle of miracles, there she was, just as I had remembered her: a short, slim, dark-haired winsome beauty. I walked up to her and said hello, hoping she hadn't forgotten me. She hadn't. She threw her arms around my neck and kissed me on the cheek, telling me how glad she was to see me. Fortune was truly smiling on me, I thought.
It turned out that she had been on the same train, coming home for the weekend from Rutgers University, where she was studying to be a teacher. The bus she was waiting for wasn't mine, but that didn't matter. I wasn't about to let my opportunity slip away. We got on the same bus - hers - and sat together reminiscing about the past and talking about the future. I told her of my plans and showed her the shirt I had bought - my first step toward making my dream come true. I didn't tell her that she was supposed to be step two.
She told me how lucky I was to have found that shirt, since men's civilian clothing was in such short supply. And then she said, "I hope my husband will be as lucky as you when he gets out of the navy next month." I got off at the next stop and never looked back. Alas, my future was not on that bus.
Thirty-one years later, in 1977, I met her again at a highschool reunion - not quite so dark-haired, not quite so slim, but still winsome. I told her that my career was going well, that I was married to a wonderful woman, and that I had three teenage children. She told me that she was a grandmother several times over. I thought enough time had passed for me to mention that meeting three decades before - what it had meant to me, and how every detail of it was etched in my memory.
She looked at me blankly. Then, putting a coda to half a lifetime of "what ifs," she said, "I'm sorry, but I don't remember that at all."
by Theodore Lustig
Morgantown, West Virginia
I received my discharge papers on April 25, 1946. I had survived three years of army service in World War II, and now I was heading home on a train to Newark, New Jersey. The last thing I'd done at the base in Fort Dix was to buy a white shirt at the post exchange - a symbol of my return to civilian life.
I was eager to put my grand plan for the future into action. I would return to college, launch my career, and look for the girl on my dreams. And I knew exactly who that girl would be. I'd had a crush on her ever since high school. The question was: How could I find her? We hadn't been in contact for four years. Well, it might take some time, I thought, but find her I would.
When the train pulled into the station, I gathered up my bags, tucked my new shirt under my arm, and headed down to the bus platform - the last leg of my journey home. And then, miracle of miracles, there she was, just as I had remembered her: a short, slim, dark-haired winsome beauty. I walked up to her and said hello, hoping she hadn't forgotten me. She hadn't. She threw her arms around my neck and kissed me on the cheek, telling me how glad she was to see me. Fortune was truly smiling on me, I thought.
It turned out that she had been on the same train, coming home for the weekend from Rutgers University, where she was studying to be a teacher. The bus she was waiting for wasn't mine, but that didn't matter. I wasn't about to let my opportunity slip away. We got on the same bus - hers - and sat together reminiscing about the past and talking about the future. I told her of my plans and showed her the shirt I had bought - my first step toward making my dream come true. I didn't tell her that she was supposed to be step two.
She told me how lucky I was to have found that shirt, since men's civilian clothing was in such short supply. And then she said, "I hope my husband will be as lucky as you when he gets out of the navy next month." I got off at the next stop and never looked back. Alas, my future was not on that bus.
Thirty-one years later, in 1977, I met her again at a highschool reunion - not quite so dark-haired, not quite so slim, but still winsome. I told her that my career was going well, that I was married to a wonderful woman, and that I had three teenage children. She told me that she was a grandmother several times over. I thought enough time had passed for me to mention that meeting three decades before - what it had meant to me, and how every detail of it was etched in my memory.
She looked at me blankly. Then, putting a coda to half a lifetime of "what ifs," she said, "I'm sorry, but I don't remember that at all."