Interesting Feedback

[MelanieShaman]

I got an email today with feedback for my "Teach Me" story series. It's about a teacher and student forming a relationship. They asked me not to put the student in an actual class with the teacher due to the repercussions They spoke of how having the student in an actual class with the teacher could be really bad, because it would ruin the school of active were to find out. They mentioned how they reinforced no sex/ relationship must ever happen between staff and student. They mentioned the years they worked in education and took a a viewpoint of how serious it is and to not to add that aspect.

I responded that it's just a story and that series was middle of the road compared to my other stories, especially the lesbian incest series I wrote.

It's a very curious course of feedback. Has anyone ever been asked not to write a story?

 

[lovecraft68]

Happens a lot. Even though this is fiction, and people know its fiction, they seem to be unable to refrain from pushing their personal beliefs/ideas into a story.

Teacher/student is one of the most common erotica plots out there (I've written 3 myself) and they're not written with real life repercussions in mind, just fantasy.

But obviously since that person was a teacher, they're putting too much reality into it...or they're mad it never happened for them so it shouldn't happen to make believe people either.

 

[LAHomedog]

I'm with LC. Sounds like it came from an educator. Since the reader seems not to like stories like this, you have to wonder why they read it in the first place...

I got an interesting comment on my "I Posted Ad Story" -- the "Mrs. Robinson-type" story. It has high scores and all of the comments have been positive and strong. Ths one reads, "It started out sucking and never got better." Hmmmm.

On my last story, I got only one negative comment. It read, "This is an unbelievable piece of shit. Unreadable." I'm starting to think it is the same person who is now trolling me.

Back to yours, I'm not an educator, but I was the Chair of the Board of Trustees of a school for eight years. A lot of folks have thin skins about their schools and the image of education. I think it is a personal agenda.

 

[BiscuitHammer]

I get those types with the Alexaverse rather constantly. I've had a few tantrums thrown my way about the fact that Mike and Karen have sex with select students from the university courses they teach. And commenters leaving the feedback are always insisting they're doctorate people themselves, and how deadly it is.

I boffed one of my university professors and nothing happened, because neither of us ever said anything. Seemed fairly obvious.

It's a freaking story, dude. Why on earth are you here reading erotica if these concepts are so anathema to you? Same sort of people who angrily announce that 'incest doesn't share' in all caps.

Did he offer to pay you to stop writing or alter the story? Or was this just asked as a personal favour?

Hit the road, egghead.

Some feedbackers are just backfeeders. Never get them confused. They'd pay you if it really meant something. He just wanted to hear himself pontificate.

Keep moving forward with YOUR story as you like it, OP.

 

[Djmac1031]

My first story was about a woman doctor giving a male patient a not absolutely necessary prostate milking.

In chapter two, she does muse a bit about the possible ramifications.

But if and when I get around to chapter 3, it's certainly NOT gonna dwell on real world consequences lol.

I mean, these people DO know what site they're on, right?

RIGHT...???

 

[LAHomedog]

I boffed one of my university professors and nothing happened, because neither of us ever said anything. Seemed fairly obvious.

I slept with my college biology professor. She gave me the clap!!!! My college biology professor!! I've always found that amusing.

The only STD of my life.

 

[MajorRewrite]

I mean, these people DO know what site they're on, right?

Nope. There is a real segment of the population that doesn’t understand the difference between fiction and reality. They take everything literally.

 

[SimonDoom]

This sort of thing is very common, and not just about teachers, but about everything. It's always been a puzzle to me that readers who come to an erotic story site can have this attitude, "You shouldn't write X because it's not like this in the real world." But many do.

 

[BiscuitHammer]

I slept with my college biology professor. She gave me the clap!!!! My college biology professor!! I've always found that amusing.

The only STD of my life.

Sorry that happened, dude, but you've gotta love the irony, eh?

 

[LAHomedog]

Sorry that happened, dude, but you've gotta love the irony, eh?

Yeah, private tutoring in the biology of STDs. I have always enjoyed the irony. Imagine what it felt like to be 19 years olf and have to tell you college biology professor that she gave you the clap!

 

[BiscuitHammer]

Yeah, private tutoring in the biology of STDs. I have always enjoyed the irony. Imagine what it felt like to be 19 years olf and have to tell you college biology professor that she gave you the clap!

Was the cure still the blunt needle in the dick at that point?

 

[lovecraft68]

I mean, these people DO know what site they're on, right?

RIGHT...???

One would think. Its not just here, and not limited to stories. I watched a video on pornhub where a hotel maid comes in and catches a guy masturbating. She starts going down on him, and her phone rings, she answers, its her boyfriend she says she's busy tells him she loves him then resumes going down on the guy.

In the comments someone said, "I hope her boyfriend finds out she's a cheating whore and breaks up with her"

I know some things aren't for everyone. I'm not going to say I've never read a story, or watched a video where something happens that I'm not a fan of for whatever reason. But at that point I click off and move on, I'm not going to get indignant over it, I'm certainly not going to comment about it because end of the day, its not even real

 

[Salacious_Scribe]

Always remember there are more than a few people who don't understand or realize that fiction is not reality. There were people sending the USCG telegrams demanding that the Coast Guard go rescue the survivors of the SS Minnow (Gilligans Island)