Hi, Tim Ramm here

TimRamm

Virgin
Joined
Aug 31, 2007
Posts
2
I authored two short stories - Seasick (NON-consent) and A Weekend Retreat (Romantic Couplings). Before I begin this post, I want to thank those who took the time to submit GENUINE comments and critiques.

Obviously, like most of us, I am NOT using my real name. These two pieces were a "writing exercise" that was suggested to me for the purpose of stretching my writing abilities. I have never before truly written porn; I admit in some ways it was fun and sort of liberating.

I chose these two stories becasue they were on extreme ends - one was NON-consensual and bordered on pain, the other was pure enjoyment AND CONSENT for both parties. The idea behind choosing extremes is kind of like the actor who is typecast as Dudley DoRight suddenly tackling a villianous role.

As far as A Weekend Retreat, I enjoy sex, but as I said earlier, I had never written something quite so graphic. A few readers made valid points regarding character building - thank you, re-reading it, I agree that the male should have been more 3-dimensional.

As far as Seasick - hah, this one was a challenge! Personally I believe that ALL NON-consent is vile (as one reader commented regarding the "torture"). Now for uncomfortable truth, this writer is female and has in real life been at the receiving end of NON-consent. No matter whether a weapon is used or not, it IS torture and there are NO fond memories. Any "orgasms" are full of humiliation and causes extreme guilt to the victim, there is no pleasure in this kind of reaction. I think this is why I found it easy to use true evil, torture and tears in this story.

While I guess in all honesty I have mixed feelings about perpetuating stories on NON-consent, I also know that there are some really decent people who can find themselves "getting off" on the fantasies. So I am not passing judgment on the writers or readers of such stories SO LONG AS ALL IT IS REMAINS FANTASY.

Again, I thank you for having made valid comments on these stories. I sincerely doubt that I will be posting anymore; as I stated earlier, this was merely an exercise and not my usual type of writing. I also want to say that I hope I have not offended anyone by using the board in this way.

(aka) Tim
 
How about posting links for us lazy people. (we know who we are.)

And welcome to the rubber rooms. Stick around you might find us a pretty good bunch on the whole.
 
<< Looks around in a Paranoid state.>>

Do you think he's with the Thought Police? Or maybe the bible-thumping God Squad sent her to spy on us or possibly get some new ideas.

Ahem... Welcum to the Padded Room :p
 
w00t! Links to porn...

*tries to contain self*

Welcome to the boards and may you watch your step on last. . . :D
 
Seasick

Okay, I admit it. I'm a stickler for getting the first paragraph right, because I know that's where your story hooks the reader and prevents the ever-present "Back Click".

Yours:
She was terrified. Being the only woman with more than 40 men couldn't be good. She had been grabbed on the dock during the night. She knew she couldn't have been there but she needed to get pictures. No one believed her about the illegal shipments they were making.

Two things about this paragraph. The twelvth word "couldn't" should be "shouldn't". If she couldn't be there she wouldn't be there.

The other thing, you've dropped us right in the middle of the story. It would have been nice if you'd given us a little background on what she was doing there before she was captured. You do that in the next sentence, but you've missed a great change to expand this story from the viginette it is to something more.


The next paragraph as the same sort of stumbles.
The Captain had her in the office and told her she had to service his men. Of course she refused. He had 2 of his men strip her and hold her still. Then he repeated his demands as he pushed his fingers into her pussy. She squirmed, cried and pleaded with him to let her go. He asked her if she was going to do as she was told. She couldn't look at him as she shook her head no.

Both of these paragraphs consist of "he", "she", "you", and "her". Who are they? Don't they have names? Why would I care about these characters? I find them flat, unappealing and disinteresting. You need to intro your characters, fill them out and make me hate, love or empathise with them.

And I'm confused. I guess the captain and crew are smugglers or something (I'm not quite sure) so why would they want to tell her they are going to run a train on "her"? Wouldn't they either just kill her or do it? This is not very believable. You need to learn to make your characters real and act like real people. Thus far, your story is driving your characters. You need to do it the other way around and have the characters drive the story.


From this point on, this thing devolves into some torture story that will get you nothing but hate maile from the Trolls and Sexual Purity group.

You had a good idea, but unfortunately, this leaves me flat and uninterested in reading anything else you write, partly because of the subject matter, but mostly because of the flat, disinteresting prose.

On the up side, your writing style isn't bad for a first timer. Your story could have been told a lot better if you had expanded it beyond a single scene (viginette) and given your characters some life. Try again. You'll get the hang of it.

JJ
 
Welcome and even if you don't ever write erotica again I thought your second story was well done for a newbie. Hope you try it again sometime.
 
Back
Top