Girl seduces reluctant man

[HughJae]

Story where the girl seduces the man, and the man is reluctant to this seduction/teasing (it's wrong/it's a sin, etc.), but after she seduces him he eventually goes along. She seduces him by rubbing herself "accidentally", teasing with a camel toe, etc. I really like the build up in seduction stories. I'm OK with slightly taboo subjects, but not incest.

The perfect example of a storyline like this is Our Daily Head (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00P87FGYA/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_hsch_vapi_tkin_p1_i0). Basically a 19 year-old girl is staying with a minister and his wife while her foster parents are away. One day she teases him just to mess with him and get some new clothes as a bribe, but things end up escalating and she seduces him into giving her oral sex and having sex with her. The buildup is awesome, and I've been looking for something like this with no success.

 

[sirhugs]

try the nonconsent/reluctance list on the story index.
the the Story Search tool on the Story index
try the Looking for a Story Forum

 

[Carnevil9]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

 

[sirhugs]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

agreed, which is why if it works, it could be a great story.

 

[HughJae]

try the nonconsent/reluctance list on the story index.
the the Story Search tool on the Story index
try the Looking for a Story Forum

Thanks for the suggestion! I'll give it a try

 

[HughJae]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

agreed, which is why if it works, it could be a great story.

Thank you both! Yeah, it needs to have a good context/reason behind it otherwise it doesn't work out... I'll try to give it a go anyway

 

[EggplantParmesan]

Easiest situations to imagine:

One or both of them is married: for example, a happily married man is seduced by his best buddy’s wife.
The man is super-religious.
There is some impropriety involved: for example, one of them supervises the other, and intra-office fucking is a big no-no.
She’s not conventionally attractive: for example, a plain-looking girl steals her hot friend’s handsome guy.
Big age difference either way that freaks out the guy.

 

[Yerkiddin]

Religious couple have a wayward young adult daughter who has a baby, but leaves it with her parents (the Religious couple) to raise. The father of the baby is worthless, and tells everyone he's the daddy, then leaves. The sister of the baby's father just turned 18, and is in love with her new niece-or-nephew. Of the Religious couple, the wife is a nurse, and frequently away from the house, and the husband is a preacher, but is spending rather a lot of his time at home with the new baby, since he has a home office for his church, and hiring the child's aunt seems to lead to distraction...

 

[MILFYMelons]

Hot!

 

[anopheles_leet]

Here's a question it might be fun to explore: does she expect her seduction to work?

There are lots of scenarios I can think of where I guy really wants what she's offering, but knows there will be some kind of really bad consequences if he goes for it. Maybe she's his bosses daughter, or she has a really possessive and violent brother. Or heck, maybe he's gay (but is starting to discover he might actually be bi), and is just impervious to her seduction (until he isn't).

Anyway, maybe she thinks there's no way he'll ever say yes, but is getting off on being seductive and watching him squirm over it. Or maybe she's always been a straight-laced goodie two-shoes, and only feels like she explore her sexually provocative side because she knows there's absolutely no chance he'll ever take her up on it. Except maybe he's closer to saying yes than she thinks he his...

Either way, there might be scope for a really good "oh, fuck" moment when she realises she's finally pushed him over the line.

 

[EggplantParmesan]

I like the idea of a woman flirting heavily with one of her gay male friends, who turns out to be increasingly bi. But not only is he uncomfortable with how attracted he is to her, his husband is 100% gay and would never understand. But her "flirting" turns into flirting, as she realizes that she actually has a shot at him. He tries to resist, until one night, after the party, with a few drinks in him.....

 

[J0line]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

True story: (Requires at least two women.) Reason for reluctance "important game on television" the guys wanted to watch.
Solution: Two of the gals get undressed in front of everyone, and start making out with each other. Then they leave the living room for a bedroom saying they are starting with or without the guys.
Result: The guys figured out how to set-up and program a DVR in 90 seconds.
Nope, not hard.

 

[ericrodman101]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

There's a Mick Blue porno, I think with Nina North, in which he plays the school girl's tutor and is very reluctant, completely opposite to his usual porn style, to fuck her even as she asks him to, undresses him, fellates him under the table with her parents in the room to check up on how the tutoring is going, and so on. In the end, of course, he gives in and fucks her hard in every hole as you would expect, but as a reluctant teacher/willing student story it works well.

 

[J0line]

An early episode of Shameless where Karen is under a tableclothed dining table blowing Lip with her parents at the table.

 

[sirhugs]

An early episode of Shameless where Karen is under a tableclothed dining table blowing Lip with her parents at the table.

but IIRC Lip was not reluctant, just afraid of beung caught. I loved Karen and was sad when they wrote her out. Also her crazy mother.

 

[J0line]

but IIRC Lip was not reluctant...

I don't know all that many guys (okay, ANY guys) that are all that reluctant.

....just afraid of being caught....

Given the circumstances THIS is far more realistic.

 

[Whispor]

The sister-in-law to a man (his wife's sister) can work well as a seductress in this scenario. The desire to be faithful to one's wife is a very powerful source of reluctance for a man, despite his own sexual desires. Cheating with a woman's sister is a huge betrayal to her by both her husband AND her blood relative:

- His wife's much younger sister is down on her luck (e.g. broke, newly divorced, addict, etc.)
- For years his wife has told her sister how wonderful he is, kind, good in bed, wealthy, etc.
- The sister moves in with them at their invitation to get back on her feet.
- She sees what they have, and decides she wants that, too.
- She becomes verbally forward with sexual innuendo toward him, becomes an exhibitionist.
- It becomes readily apparent to him that she wants to fuck him.
- He is torn between staying faithful vs. fucking the younger sister who wants to be his personal slut.

 

[J0line]

The sister-in-law to a man (his wife's sister) can work well as a seductress in this scenario. The desire to be faithful to one's wife is a very powerful source of reluctance for a man, despite his own sexual desires...

Full disclosure, mom and dad did not give me any siblings so I adopted my best girlfriends as sisters... Maybe that isn't sexy. It plays better in stories here if all the characters are blood relatives. (Whispor's original is in red.)

Cheating with a woman's sister is a huge betrayal to her by both her husband AND her blood relative:

To me betrayal isn't hot. But coming up with unique (elegant even) solutions is...

- His wife's much younger sister is down on her luck (e.g. broke, newly divorced, addict, etc.)

So the older sister wants to help her beloved little sis out.

- For years his wife has told her sister how wonderful he is, kind, good in bed...etc.

So since she and hubby actually talk, they talk about lil' sis'

- The sister moves in with them at their invitation to get back on her feet.

She already "knew" from talking to her sister, but post card pictures of O'ahu and sitting on the sand on O'ahu aren't exactly the same. - She sees what they have, and decides she wants that, too.

- She becomes verbally forward with sexual innuendo toward him, becomes an exhibitionist.

Husband and wife have a good laugh-- together privately. They see what is going on. - It becomes readily apparent to him that she wants to fuck him.

- He feigns being torn between staying faithful vs. fucking the younger sister who wants to be his personal slut.

She is naked in the living room, playing with his chest hair. He takes his pants off--

And big sister walks into the room. She is also naked.

"You have much to learn," big sis' says.

"But we will teach you," hubby says, leading lil' sis' to the very sturdy coffee table.

Big sis removes the "junk." She and hubby gently lay lil' sis' back on the table.

"We don't lie or hide, we talk, we agree, we fuck," big sis' says.

"Especially fuck," hubby says right before her kneels down and starts on lil' sis's pussy.

"You can have it all," big sis' says as she straddles lil' sis's face.

"Really?" lil' sis' says as she wraps her legs around hubby's neck.

"Sure," big sis' says as lil' sis' licks her, "we are pretty busy, you can stay here with us forever if you choose. But it's our rules. I'll share, but we do everything in the open."

"Mrrumph," says lil' sis'.

"You can take care of the house, and the babies--" says hubby.

"Mrrum... Babies?" says lil' sis'.

"Yes, the ones my husband is going to put in you," says big sis. "Maybe today, maybe in a month or two."

 

[lovecraft68]

I don't want to discourage you, but I want to point out that this is a difficult sell. Most men don't need much to be seduced. "Hey, you wanna fuck me?" is usually enough to do the trick.

If you want to base the drama of your story on the reluctance of the man, you really have to sell the reason for his reluctance.

That's why you need to have a valid reason for the guy to resist. Man of God....or, hold on to reality for this one, a happily married loyal man with a good wife and a good sex life.
I've had women hit on me, and brushed it off because I abhor cheating, and I'm happy with my life and wife. I can't be that rare of a breed.
Or she could be his best friend's daughter, his daughter's best friend he's known since she was a child.
There are a lot of taboo-non incest taboo-reasons you could create.
I get what Sirhugs and you are saying, and hey you can't rape the willing, but we're not all that easy.
This is easy for a good writer

 

[ericrodman101]

There's a Mick Blue porno, I think with Nina North, in which he plays the school girl's tutor and is very reluctant, completely opposite to his usual porn style, to fuck her even as she asks him to, undresses him, fellates him under the table with her parents in the room to check up on how the tutoring is going, and so on. In the end, of course, he gives in and fucks her hard in every hole as you would expect, but as a reluctant teacher/willing student story it works well.

Another porno worth watching for plot devices is James Deen washing his truck in the drive and the three girls from next door turn up to help but really to seduce him. He plays a reluctant faithful husband who is worn down by these three girls inserting themselves between him and the truck until eventually he caves and fucks them.

 

[J0line]

Another porno worth watching for plot devices is James Deen washing his truck in the drive and the three girls from next door turn up to help but really to seduce him. He plays a reluctant faithful husband who is worn down by these three girls inserting themselves between him and the truck until eventually he caves and fucks them.

Which of course happens every day.

 

[ericrodman101]

Which of course happens every day.

Exactly. It's a documentary on the challenges of a married man washing a truck in a suburban driveway in sight of horny young women.

 

[J0line]

Like the episode of 'Friends' where Joey and Chandler are surprised that life is not like a porno.

 

[Carnevil9]

That's why you need to have a valid reason for the guy to resist. Man of God....or, hold on to reality for this one, a happily married loyal man with a good wife and a good sex life.
I've had women hit on me, and brushed it off because I abhor cheating, and I'm happy with my life and wife. I can't be that rare of a breed.
Or she could be his best friend's daughter, his daughter's best friend he's known since she was a child.
There are a lot of taboo-non incest taboo-reasons you could create.
I get what Sirhugs and you are saying, and hey you can't rape the willing, but we're not all that easy.
This is easy for a good writer

You reminded me of a great reluctant man story: the movie Blame It On Rio. Michael Caine and Joseph Bologna (both divorced) are on vacation in Brazil, with their beautiful teenage daughters. Joe's daughter has always had a crush on Michael Caine, and she decides to seduce the fuck out of him. He is hugely reluctant, because he knows his best friend would kill him.

She eventually succeeds, and they both live to regret it.

 

[Whispor]

You reminded me of a great reluctant man story: the movie Blame It On Rio. Michael Caine and Joseph Bologna (both divorced) are on vacation in Brazil, with their beautiful teenage daughters. Joe's daughter has always had a crush on Michael Caine, and she decides to seduce the fuck out of him. He is hugely reluctant, because he knows his best friend would kill him.

She eventually succeeds, and they both live to regret it.

Oh man, that brings back some memories! That was the first time I ever saw a woman's pubic hair on screen!