Female protagonist, male author - kosher?

M

Mercurius

Guest
Hello all. I've been around here for awhile, just decided to get more involved recently.

I just started working on multi-part series featuring a female protagonist. I try to make my stories realistic, with a good amount of character development, so I'm wondering if anyone thinks it is a limitation that I am, in fact, not even remotely female. Do you feel that a guy can't write convincingly from a female point of view? Or is it not really an issue?

I find that I really only notice this when a lesbian story is involved, and then only when I feel the story wasn't very good or the characters weren't very well written. That's when I check to see if the author is a she or a he, and when it's a man, I nod knowingly. "Ah yes, he tried to write a convincing story about lesbians and failed because of his penis."

But truth be told, there have probably been dozens that were quite good, so I never even noticed that they were written by men. And now that I think about it, there were quite a few of those not-so-well-written ones that were ostensibly written by chicks.

I actually thought about creating a separate nom de plume and submitting this series under a female name, which leads me to my final point - since we don't really have any way of knowing if the authors are who they say they are, does it even matter at all?
 
scuse the drunken-ish post but
doesn't matter
as long as you can pull it off well
 
Mercurius said:
Hello all. I've been around here for awhile, just decided to get more involved recently.

I just started working on multi-part series featuring a female protagonist. I try to make my stories realistic, with a good amount of character development, so I'm wondering if anyone thinks it is a limitation that I am, in fact, not even remotely female. Do you feel that a guy can't write convincingly from a female point of view? Or is it not really an issue?

I find that I really only notice this when a lesbian story is involved, and then only when I feel the story wasn't very good or the characters weren't very well written. That's when I check to see if the author is a she or a he, and when it's a man, I nod knowingly. "Ah yes, he tried to write a convincing story about lesbians and failed because of his penis."

But truth be told, there have probably been dozens that were quite good, so I never even noticed that they were written by men. And now that I think about it, there were quite a few of those not-so-well-written ones that were ostensibly written by chicks.

I actually thought about creating a separate nom de plume and submitting this series under a female name, which leads me to my final point - since we don't really have any way of knowing if the authors are who they say they are, does it even matter at all?

It shouldn't.

If you are skilled, it shouldn't matter.

And I'm also posting while inebriated, but I look forward to reading your writings in this vein.

Welcome to the AH.

:rose:
 
sweetsubsarahh said:
It shouldn't.

If you are skilled, it shouldn't matter.

And I'm also posting while inebriated, but I look forward to reading your writings in this vein.

Welcome to the AH.

:rose:

Christ on a crutch, am I the only sober one here, what am I the designated driver tonight...oh...I miss your round glasses...
 
Male/Female - Human/Non-human, it doesn't matter. Just write it with conviction. People will read.
 
drksideofthemoon said:
Christ on a crutch, am I the only sober one here, what am I the designated driver tonight...oh...I miss your round glasses...
Nope, I'm sober as a church mouse!
 
sweetsubsarahh said:
Lemme hear more about this spur jingling.

:kiss:

Lucky was in town for a Friday night, him and the other hands at the Lazy 8 had just been paid. He had stopped off at Sal's Tonsorial Emporium for a well needed bath, and a shave.

As he walked along the sidewalk his spurs rang like little chimes. He stopped at the corner for a moment. Should he go to the card room and play a little Faro, or should he head on down to Lou's and see that girl.

Lou's won out. He may have a few coins left after Lou's for a couple of drinks and a few hands of Faro, but if he started at the card room first, he might not have any money left for Lou's.

The red light glowed dimly over Lou's place, he smiled as he walked through the door. The girl of his dreams would be here, ready for 30 minutes of heavenly bliss.

"Howdy Lucky," purred Lou, her expansive bosom threatening to break free from her dress at any moment, "Are you lookin' for her again."

Lucky smiled a smile that went from the Pecos to the Brazos, "You know I am."

"Well, you take them damn spurs off this time," Lou pointed at Lucky's boots.

"But Lou, she likes it with the spurs," complained Lucky.

Lou shook her head, "You fuckin' cowboys, well, it's a buck extry then, to replace the torn up sheets," Lou pointed to the stairs, "She's up there, your favorite love, the girl with the round glasses...."
 
Last edited:
drksideofthemoon said:
"But Lou, she likes it with the spurs," complained Lucky.

Lou shook her head, "You fuckin' cowboys, well, it's a buck extry then, to replace the torn up sheets," Lou pointed to the stairs, "She's up there, your favorite love, the girl with the round glasses...."

:heart:

I love it.
 
drksideofthemoon said:
I knew I could depend on you....
Yep, good ole Zeb, the old man is the staunch, steadfast, sober old guy sittin' at the bar laughing at all the tipsy ones. LOL! :D
 
zeb1094 said:
Yep, good ole Zeb, the old man is the staunch, steadfast, sober old guy sittin' at the bar laughing at all the tipsy ones. LOL! :D
shaddup
*lick*
 
zeb1094 said:
Yep, good ole Zeb, the old man is the staunch, steadfast, sober old guy sittin' at the bar laughing at all the tipsy ones. LOL! :D

Just smile and nod, nod and smile...that's the trick...tip your hat if they're pretty...if it's near closing time... tip your hat...and say darlin' to whoever walks by...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top