Day at the fair by Polar Juice

daughter

Dreamer
Joined
Oct 22, 2001
Posts
1,561
Polar Juice--

Thanks for turning me on to your story. Liked the pacing. Not in a hurry in the beginning. Good background without overload. Believeable tone and, characterization? :) Well, maybe could have done more with Chris, but you did well with your male character. You illustrated his shyness well in both his actions and his narration. Some might have preferred you named him as well, but it worked for me that he focused on Chris. Not naming him, accentuated his shyness and his not wanting too much attention.

Like the care you took to describe their date. Created tension, anticipation. The flirting was way cool. I'm divorced and in that age range so I really identified with their circumstances. Might have given greater detail with the sex. On one hand, I thought about how the protagonist's was in some ways reserved so maybe you wanted the narration to reflect how he'd likely recall the events, which would mean sharing the intimate details without coarse blow by blow commentary. Still debating that one. You had some really cute lines and turn of phrase during the date, I would have liked to have seen more that kind of creativity in the bedroom scene.

The opening paragraph could be pared and tighter. The read isn't as smooth as it could be. Minor issue. In some places, I think you switched tenses. I'd revisit that.

Overall, very pleased. Tweaking maybe, but no major obstacles in my view. I look forward to reading more from you.

Oh, yes. I have read your lady in the green dress. I thought I had written you about that one. Let's talk about that some time.

Thanks again for the read. Here's the link for those who'd like to check this out:

http://www.literotica.com/stories/showstory.php?id=24672


Peace,

daughter
 
I have tried to ignore you but you seem to be monopolising the threads here at Literotica.

yo how about a more private method of complimenting/editing people's work like ya know this ain't the Sunday Times nor the Enquirerer.
How 'bout asking the Author's if they want YOUR critisiscm BROADCAST over Lit?
Yo you never heard of subtle feedback?
And again I say poetry ain't everyone's cup a tea,
Get over it already. Some like poetry some like erotica some like pics some like porn some like chat some like hardporn ? so what?
Da nada, can't please all of the folk all a the time
Chill I say, be real... what will be will be
 
feedback--I was ASKED

Unregistered--

I was told this forum was to post our feedback for stories. That's the description on the forum box. I was asked by Polar to read and comment to his story. I do not know your experience with boards or writers' list, but I am doing what is the norm where I have participated prior to Literotica.

I thought this is a place for intelligent discourse about stories and poetry. It matters less if parties agree. I think it matters more if our exchanges are civil and respectful. I respect an opinion that differs from mine.

If my behavior is odd for a writers' forum, I suspect the powers that be will advise.


Peace,

daughter
 
Unregistered, what's wrong with someone reviewing the stories?

I kind of like it.
 
I think daughter's comments were well done. Very straight and to the point, and complimentary as well as critical. Obviously from her post you can see that Polar Juice ASKED for her to read it. I think that public posting helps other writers too, not just the person who wrote the piece. However, I hope that PJ said it was all right to post comments here on the bulletin board. Otherwise, I do think it might have been better to send it via email.

Rock on, daughter. Great critique.
 
Public comments

Whisper--

Thank you.

I do my best to be tactful and honest. I comment when I see merit in a work. I don't waste my time or an author's being purposely mean. I may not write gushing praise, but I am honest and I respect every writer's efforts. Integrity matters in my book.

Polar Bear wrote me about my public comments and asked me to read his work. He said he liked my reviews. I read his story and did the same as I have done before.

There are times I miss the mark. Don't we all? If I offend someone, I am quick to make amends.

Peace,

daughter
 
Thanks for the comments

Sorry to not post earlier but I've been having computer problems..

Thanks you so much for the comments... I appreciate them imeasureably....

having them posted publically brings attention to my stories, and ensures me some recognition... who know's maybe soon just my name will bring readers strolling in...

Comments please... I can't get any better if I don't know what is wrong.

Thanks again , Hugs and kisses... and please lets talk....


Polar ;)

PS: To those that are afraid to put a name to their words.. hmmm are they really worth listening to?
 
Last edited:
Ah, I share your sentiments

PolarJuice--

Too funny. Interested in a collaboration? Posted a storyline in SRP. Have not participated in this forum before. Join me.

Peace,

daughter
 
Back
Top