Damn it!

"you wanna buy a rifle that a UN soldier had? never fired, and dropped only once."

Many troops in UN uniforms have fought and died to preserve peace BUT all too often they are given impossible missions with ridiculous rules of engagement that prevent them from acting when they should.

It doesn't help when the 'enemy' is told what the UN's rules of engagement are.

If you give soldiers rifles but tell them never to shoot, and the opposition know the UN soldiers aren't allowed to fire, you are just sending unarmed men to be brushed aside.

Edited to add: If the US had fought the Vietnam war under the rules of engagement for the WWII Pacific Campaign - the US would have won. If they had fought Vietnam under any UN ROEs since the Korean War, they would have lost within weeks.

What were the ROE for the Pacific Campaign?

If it's Japanese - don't stop firing with everything you've got until you're really sure it's dead. Then add a few more rounds to make sure.
 
Last edited:
Edited to add: If the US had fought the Vietnam war under the rules of engagement for the WWII Pacific Campaign - the US would have won. If they had fought Vietnam under any UN ROEs since the Korean War, they would have lost within weeks.

I do not believe that Vietnam was lost due to the ROE. More violence and a total invasion of the North, would have secured a military victory, much as our lightning victory in Iraq against their military was secured. We would still be in Vietnam fighting against insurgents even if we had militarily crushed the north.
 
I do not believe that Vietnam was lost due to the ROE. More violence and a total invasion of the North, would have secured a military victory, much as our lightning victory in Iraq against their military was secured. We would still be in Vietnam fighting against insurgents even if we had militarily crushed the north.

Exactly. If the Pacific Campaign ROE had been used in Vietnam, the US would have won the war militarily, even if that had meant using nuclear weapons on China.

But the cost to the US of winning the Vietnam War in that way would have been politically unacceptable - to the US. The US had limited objectives in Vietnam and the ROE were set for those objectives.

That is the problem with UN troops. They are sent to achieve limited objectives and NOT given appropriate ROE for even those objectives - because giving the appropriate ROE would be politically unacceptable to the UN.
 
Back
Top