Could It Be True?

So, Labour will win, do you think?
If a GE were held today, probably. But a week is a long time in politics.
Nevertheless, Brits are Europeans, in the same way -- ways -- that Japanese are Asians. Rather more so, in fact -- Britain has no history of total isolationism from the continent.
No, we have a history of kicking the fuck out of them.
Do you think Britain would be better off with the euro?

Hmm. Debatable, that one. I think the addition of the UK might have helped stabilise the Euro against some of the precipitous falls it's seen since the global crash.
 
The British newspapers The Guardian and The Independent (both of which would be classed as politically left-leaning), have online reader surveys on how their readers would vote in a referendum on Europe. At the moment the Guardian readers would vote for Europe by 74% to 26%. Independent readers vote for Europe 62% to 33% with 5% don't know. I haven't seen an equivalent poll in either the Daily Mail or Telegraph, which would roughly be considered the rightist equivalents.

Britons have always had a degree of ambivalence towards the European project. Initially many leftists saw it as a capitalist project and opposed it to varying degrees. Rightists then came to regard it as socialism rampant.

The fact is that it is an oligarchical bureaucracy. It sees the imperative of establishing a European state with no regard for democratic accountability. In order to create this supra-national state it has created conditions that drew in political parties, public organisations, and major businesses, but in many ways failed to bring along populations.

Large sections of the British have been reluctant to surrender their national identity. Why? Many different reasons, but essentially there has been (to my mind) a distrust of the entire concept due to the feeling that we were being "sold a pup" by politicians and bureaucrats who regarded us as dupes. This has been amplified by the disregard for the plight of the ordinary people of Greece, Spain, Ireland, Italy, and Portugal by the privileged elite in Brussels, by their imposition of technocrats to oversee the actions of governments selected by the people.

Would it help any, if the arrangement of the EU were revised, making Parliament the real locus of power and supreme over the bureaucracy? Or would it appear even worse to Brits to be sharing continental power with the actual people of foreign countries?
 
2.3% according to wiki.

If the Monster Raving Loony Party stood for the European Parliament, they would probably displace Farage.

It wouldn't make much change to the rest of Europe's perception of the UK's attitude to the EU. Many of them already think we are Loony.
 
Would it help any, if the arrangement of the EU were revised, making Parliament the real locus of power and supreme over the bureaucracy? Or would it appear even worse to Brits to be sharing continental power with the actual people of foreign countries?

My personal line is that the current model has not been revised since the 1950s and I believe it needs a strategic rethink that is impossible under the current system. Those who could revise the EU are hamstrung by their own past. They have invested their prestige in what has gone by and to consider change would be to admit error.

The "regime" do not trust the people because they have either sidelined them for too long or lied to them for too long, depending on which particular country you live in.

It must be remembered that some European countries are not strangers to rebellion against their government, not least being France.
 
My personal line is that the current model has not been revised since the 1950s and I believe it needs a strategic rethink that is impossible under the current system. Those who could revise the EU are hamstrung by their own past. They have invested their prestige in what has gone by and to consider change would be to admit error.

The "regime" do not trust the people because they have either sidelined them for too long or lied to them for too long, depending on which particular country you live in.

It must be remembered that some European countries are not strangers to rebellion against their government, not least being France.

Just after I got out of the mob and I was back in Manc, I became good friends with the parents of a mate of mine. Both members of CPGB. Used to kill a few bottles of wine arguing politics and smoking Galoise. The dad was French. They were always convinced that the revolution was just around the corner. My argument was that Marx may have been right in his time about religion being the opium of the people, but these days it's TV, two cars and a holiday to Tenerife every year. The French really aren't that much different to us when push comes to shove.
 
Just after I got out of the mob and I was back in Manc, I became good friends with the parents of a mate of mine. Both members of CPGB. Used to kill a few bottles of wine arguing politics and smoking Galoise. The dad was French. They were always convinced that the revolution was just around the corner. My argument was that Marx may have been right in his time about religion being the opium of the people, but these days it's TV, two cars and a holiday to Tenerife every year. The French really aren't that much different to us when push comes to shove.

Gauloise? Nancy! We smoked Gitanes. Or Sweet Afton.
 
Last edited:
I started smoking Park Drive, nicked them from my dad.

I started smoking Havana cigars, nicked from my best friend's dad. The dad was the local Air Officer Commanding, didn't smoke, but kept the cigars for visitors...
 
Perhaps I'm not a revolutionary. My choice was Capstan Full Strength, Three Castles, and sometimes Passing Clouds...

http://www.thinkdifferentevents.co.uk/assets/images/Capstan(1).jpg

http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7014/6423690991_3c59d66106_b.jpg

http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6080/6084994196_e78909d4e1_z.jpg

Or Navy issue Blue Liners.

As a kid I found a pack of two Woodbine in my grandfather's. He smoked Gallagher's Blues, but when I did a google search it came back with Rory Gallagher's blues.
 
My argument was that Marx may have been right in his time about religion being the opium of the people, but these days it's TV, two cars and a holiday to Tenerife every year.

Or, you know, opium.
 
Back
Top