Corporate accountability

Corporate Income Tax (Federal)

Ishmael said:
Here we go again.

First of all, that chart is falacious and misleading. It shows corporate taxes as a percentage of GDP. Not as a percentage of tax revenues. Get the chart that shows them as a percentage of tax revenues and you will have something of relavence.

Second, corporations don't pay taxes. Never have, never will (under our current tax code).

Ishmael

Well, corporations are most certainly subject to income taxes in the usa. Here is the link of where to start reading:

http://www.irs.gov/formspubs/page/0,,id=12175,00.html

The chart may be misleading, but it does demonstrate the declining level of corporate income taxes as a proportion of gdp.

Corporations have many options available which have been foreclosed for other taxpayers in the usa. Again, a government preference system. corporations are *SUPPOSED* to be treated as individuals. Would we had it so good!
 
Re: Corporate Income Tax (Federal)

n-erasmus said:
Well, corporations are most certainly subject to income taxes in the usa. Here is the link of where to start reading:

http://www.irs.gov/formspubs/page/0,,id=12175,00.html

The chart may be misleading, but it does demonstrate the declining level of corporate income taxes as a proportion of gdp.

Corporations have many options available which have been foreclosed for other taxpayers in the usa. Again, a government preference system. corporations are *SUPPOSED* to be treated as individuals. Would we had it so good!

Forget the forms. They are not an issue and corporations still don't 'pay' taxes. They DO act as tax collectors for the government.

Consider, I am a small business owner. The government passes a law increasing my tax burden. What do I do? I raise my price. I am competitive and my pricing structure is finely tuned. A reduction in my profit margin will actually translate into a loss of jobs, then business. All of my competitors are equally effected. We all raise our prices.

So, who paid the tax. Oh sure, I filled out the forms and wrote the check. But my customers paid the tax.

Follow that chain to the end and you find that only individual taxpayers ever pay any taxes. Ever. Coporate taxes are a fraud perpetrated by the government on the ignorant. Further, they are the most 'regressive' of all taxes if you are talking about food and housing.

Now, back to the chart. It shows nothing. Nothing at all. Only if you are to compare corporate taxes to individual taxes do you have a case for this thread at all. (And I think that sandia may be right, I want his ass to prove it.)

Ishmael
 
Can someone actually give me a reasoned argument AGAINST a flat tax, and an abolition of this garbled crap we have now?

"but but but, he has MORE than me" is not a reasoned argument.
 
Ishmael said:
Here we go again.

First of all, that chart is falacious and misleading. It shows corporate taxes as a percentage of GDP. Not as a percentage of tax revenues. Get the chart that shows them as a percentage of tax revenues and you will have something of relavence.

Second, corporations don't pay taxes. Never have, never will (under our current tax code).

Ishmael

It took me forever to find this, mutherfucker.

http://w3.access.gpo.gov/usbudget/fy2001/2-4.gif

I hope you're happy!

Link: http://w3.access.gpo.gov/usbudget/fy2001/guide02.html
 
As you can see, social security - a regressive tax which disproportionately affects the poor - has increased dramatically, while corp. taxes have decreased proportionately.
 
Sandia said:
As you can see, social security - a regressive tax which disproportionately affects the poor - has increased dramatically, while corp. taxes have decreased proportionately.

how the hell does social security count as a regressive tax? its for a so called "Progressive" cause.
 
I like corporations that know how to throw a good party, myself.

A well and fully stocked hostility suite at a trade show every now and then would straighten out you and your silly "tax the corporations" nonsense, Sandia.

Graphs, shmaphs.

:)
 
Lancecastor said:
I like corporations that know how to throw a good party, myself.

A well and fully stocked hostility suite at a trade show every now and then would straighten out you and your silly "tax the corporations" nonsense, Sandia.

Graphs, shmaphs.

:)

Do those come with prostitutes, Lance?
 
Re: Re: Corporate Income Tax (Federal)

Ishmael said:
Forget the forms. They are not an issue and corporations still don't 'pay' taxes. They DO act as tax collectors for the government.

Consider, I am a small business owner. The government passes a law increasing my tax burden. What do I do? I raise my price. I am competitive and my pricing structure is finely tuned. A reduction in my profit margin will actually translate into a loss of jobs, then business. All of my competitors are equally effected. We all raise our prices.

So, who paid the tax. Oh sure, I filled out the forms and wrote the check. But my customers paid the tax.

Follow that chain to the end and you find that only individual taxpayers ever pay any taxes. Ever. Coporate taxes are a fraud perpetrated by the government on the ignorant. Further, they are the most 'regressive' of all taxes if you are talking about food and housing.

Now, back to the chart. It shows nothing. Nothing at all. Only if you are to compare corporate taxes to individual taxes do you have a case for this thread at all. (And I think that sandia may be right, I want his ass to prove it.)

Ishmael

If corporations had total pricing power, this would be true. If General Mills could charge whatever it wanted for its Fruit Loops, it wouldn't need to worry about taxes. But it does worry about taxes, because it can't charge whatever it wants, and paying taxes means less profit on the bottom line. That's what all those corporate lobbyists and tax accountants are for, Ish.

Aquila, social security is a regressive tax because it comes out of the first dollar a person makes, no matter how poor he is, but ends after a certain income level. "Regressive" means it hurts the poor more than the rich.

A couple of arguments against the flat tax: One, it wouldn't make taxes much simpler. It's true you wouldn't have to look up your tax on the tax table, but you'd still have to use a calculator, to make sure you got it right.

Two, the government would have to increase taxes dramatically on middle and lower income filers in order to make up for the taxes saved by the very rich.

Three - the moral argument - wealthy people benefit from the system more, and therefore ought to contribute more to keep it going.
 
Hear hear !!

Sandia said:
Do those come with prostitutes, Lance?

That's the spirit!!

Actually ish has a pretty good point, *IF* the taxed entity is a closed system. Problem is that it is not, especially for corporations. That is why treatment of corporations, particularily multi-national and foreign corporations.

You create a Bermuda corporation. You are perfectly free to under US law. That corporation is *NOT* a US taxable entity, but is a Bermuda "person". This company creates a Cyprus corporation. The Cyprus corp is completely "hidden" from the US tax system since it is a foreign owned foreign corporation. This corporation sells your US corp widgets for $2.00. It buys them in the US for $1.00. They have been *EXPORTED* even if they stay in the same warehouse in Chicago. You sell the widget for $2.75, which is the market rate. God! Expenses these days. You have a deductible tax loss which reduces your other taxes (resulting in the *EXPORT* of tax dollars & a "trade deficit") and your foreign companies have the untaxed $1.00 markup from the Cypriot corp.

And, thus, the system is *NOT* closed at all.

This maneuver happens with the majority of big companies and results in losses and limos. :D

Klar??
 
Re: Re: Corporate accountability

Ishmael said:
So what's your point? And why the surprise?

And corporatons have NEVER paid any taxes. Never will.

There are SAP's and there are IRS rules. Big deal.

Ishmael

Actually there have been a few times that corporations did pay taxes. In the years leading up to both world wars corporations and the wealthiest of Americans lobbied congress to raise there taxes to help with the war efforts. Belive it or not it happened. Of course the war on terrorism was to be funded by a lowering of corporate taxes, go figure
 
Re: Hear hear !!

n-erasmus said:
That's the spirit!!

Actually ish has a pretty good point, *IF* the taxed entity is a closed system. Problem is that it is not, especially for corporations. That is why treatment of corporations, particularily multi-national and foreign corporations.

You create a Bermuda corporation. You are perfectly free to under US law. That corporation is *NOT* a US taxable entity, but is a Bermuda "person". This company creates a Cyprus corporation. The Cyprus corp is completely "hidden" from the US tax system since it is a foreign owned foreign corporation. This corporation sells your US corp widgets for $2.00. It buys them in the US for $1.00. They have been *EXPORTED* even if they stay in the same warehouse in Chicago. You sell the widget for $2.75, which is the market rate. God! Expenses these days. You have a deductible tax loss which reduces your other taxes (resulting in the *EXPORT* of tax dollars & a "trade deficit") and your foreign companies have the untaxed $1.00 markup from the Cypriot corp.

And, thus, the system is *NOT* closed at all.

This maneuver happens with the majority of big companies and results in losses and limos. :D

Klar??

Here in Connecticut that was to happen with Stanleyworks...But there was an outcry and it was stopped things may be begining to change a bit....
 
Re: Re: Hear hear !!

symplesimon said:
Here in Connecticut that was to happen with Stanleyworks...But there was an outcry and it was stopped things may be begining to change a bit....

Well perhaps when the lights focus brightly. But the real problem is that the us tax system shifts the expenses of government from the beneficiaries to working people who get very little but pay a lot. I *AM* for free trade, just not for subsidies of companies that sell here, are "American" when they want something (e.g. "protection"), but who discriminate against american-born people and pay few taxes, if any. Of course, the government cooperates with them, which is how they can do it. But the people lose, not win. Try IBM and microsift. There is a "shortage" of mercan engineers you know. So they import 'em and then dump 'em on the people when done. While mercans with perfectly good knowledge wait tables. "Protected" equally by the law. Right.
 
Back
Top