Don K Dyck
Devilish Don Downunder
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2002
- Posts
- 8,255
Re: Re: OC
Hi OC . . . I think you may be taking too much of a broad brush with your sweeping statements about Communism . . . I doubt that PR China is a failure . . . modified Marxism definitely, but hardly a failure.
Alternatively the "successes" of capitalism, as seen in Enron, Arthur Anderson, Haliburton and other recent corporate rip-offs for the benefit of Executive crooks protected from prosecution by the Corporations legislation, are "results" that have shaken the very foundations of Capitalism as the mess of the U$ economy is ignored by the Dubyah Shrub Administration intent on an Imperialist U$-Iraq War for Control of the World's Undeveloped Oil Reserves.
We have the USE, the name preferred y the Post-War Reconstruction Commission in 1943 but re-named it "European Union" . . . then put in place the same trade barriers that the U$A maintains . . . it gets messy very quickly . . .
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Think about it - if every person on earth had political representation in a single government, so much of the bullshit we now endure would disappear.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
This "One World Government" idea espoused by George Senior is nothing but a way for establishing the Bush Dynasty of U$ Presidents while ripping off the natural resources of all other nations using such tools as Manufacturing Investment Agreements (MIAs) and the restrictive trade practices embedded in the WTO for the benefit of U$ manufacturers. Americans like it because it props up their declining economy . . . and that is not for the benefit of other nations.
Primitive societies may be more violent in some cases . . . there was very little "warfare" in Oz before the European invasion in 1788 . . . and that was among over 500 language groups across the continent. There were ritual "battles" which ceased on the wounding of one warrior . . . in a nomadic hunter-gatherer society, a sick person is a liability who has to be carried "literally" when they cannot walk or if male, hunt . . . indeed, much of the work was done by women . . .
The Masai of South Africa have a great method for sorting out leadership contests . . . each rival is given a knnife and both are then put in the kraal (stockyard) with the whole community looking on . . . the winner is the survivor who kills his opponent . . . end of contest . . . without social upheaval . . . (take note Dubyah . . . )
The Cold War was mostly a creation of U$ foreign policy attempting to overcome the Atlantic Treaty which allowed post-WWII division of Europe . . . Patton caused a cock-up by advancing his tanks on Berlin until his fuel supply was cut off by U$ GHQ . . . Stalin never trusted the U$, and many of the "incidents" of the Cold War were attempts by the U$ Military to provoke USSR retaliation, which finally happened with the Cuba Missile Crisis . . . Kennedy and Kruchev resolved that face-to-face . . . and U$ interests assassinated JFK for his efforts, among other things . . .
The Cold War finished under Regan when Gorbochev acknowledged that the mobile ICBMs patrolling the East German border and capable of taking out Moscow in less than three minutes was an undefendable threat . . . so let's stop spending 35% of the failing USSR budget on the military and try to re-direct that spending to social policies. Gorbochev stopped the Cold war, not Regan . . . but Gorbochev got rolled and the U$ military, including NATO was now redundant.
>>>>>>>>>>>>
We Americans learned pretty fast that the leviathan needs a leash.
>>>>>>>>>>>>
The U$ leviathan is unfettered by either law or social pressure . . . at present, it is an oligarchy in the hands of an alcoholic in remission and his Fundamentalist Christian cronies . . . mixing fundamentalism with anything is dangerous, especially when those fundamentalists deprive the American people of their hard-won common law rights. Check out the misnamed Patriot Act and look into the Home Defense Act to see how the American people have been duped into accepting a war economy for the benefit of the oligarchy.

Oliver Clozoff said:I keep hearing you make this "Trotskyist" distinction, but to me it just seems like a convenient way for you to shrug off the obvious failures of communism - and should be pretty obvious that it's been a failure everywhere it's been tried?
Capitalism, on the other hand, has a pretty fair track record strictly based on results. One doesn't have to understand technical marxist theory to understand "all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others". In the end, both systems have to be judge on results
No, sillyhead. I based that one observation on that book. But you're absolutely right that I ought to know more about Marx before I critique his philosophy in depth. Unfortunately, I work 70+ hours a week and have to keep up with the latest psych literature, so politics is just a hobby. It's on my list to learn more.
But I'm much more well-informed about history and the history of communism in practice is pretty damned sorry.
And why not? We indulge your fantasy of the coming worldwide workers revolution almost daily. It wouldn't have to be called the USE if you find that distasteful. In fact, it would probably end up being an outgrowth of the UN. Think about it - if every person on earth had political representation in a single government, so much of the bullshit we now endure would disappear.
Disappear.
And we wouldn't even need to storm the Bastille or push the bougoisie off the land. It could come relatively smoothly.
Now that would be revolutionary.
Absolutely. Take a look at the anthropological literature of the last 30 years. Primative societies are far more violent than even the worst inner cities. And look no further than the US-Soviet arms race to see a classic Hobbesian trap - two societies deadly fearful of the other. Hobbes was the most astute judge of human nature I've come across. He rightly judged that the 3 prime human motivators are greed, fear, and desire for social status/reputation. Virtually all human conflict is born of one or more of these. Our laws and governments are formed to minimize this inevitable conflict.
Where Hobbes messed up was positing an unchecked leviathan. We Americans learned pretty fast that the leviathan needs a leash. That's where my other favorite philosopher - Locke - comes in.
But that's another story. Ollie needs sleepie.
Hi OC . . . I think you may be taking too much of a broad brush with your sweeping statements about Communism . . . I doubt that PR China is a failure . . . modified Marxism definitely, but hardly a failure.
Alternatively the "successes" of capitalism, as seen in Enron, Arthur Anderson, Haliburton and other recent corporate rip-offs for the benefit of Executive crooks protected from prosecution by the Corporations legislation, are "results" that have shaken the very foundations of Capitalism as the mess of the U$ economy is ignored by the Dubyah Shrub Administration intent on an Imperialist U$-Iraq War for Control of the World's Undeveloped Oil Reserves.
We have the USE, the name preferred y the Post-War Reconstruction Commission in 1943 but re-named it "European Union" . . . then put in place the same trade barriers that the U$A maintains . . . it gets messy very quickly . . .
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Think about it - if every person on earth had political representation in a single government, so much of the bullshit we now endure would disappear.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
This "One World Government" idea espoused by George Senior is nothing but a way for establishing the Bush Dynasty of U$ Presidents while ripping off the natural resources of all other nations using such tools as Manufacturing Investment Agreements (MIAs) and the restrictive trade practices embedded in the WTO for the benefit of U$ manufacturers. Americans like it because it props up their declining economy . . . and that is not for the benefit of other nations.
Primitive societies may be more violent in some cases . . . there was very little "warfare" in Oz before the European invasion in 1788 . . . and that was among over 500 language groups across the continent. There were ritual "battles" which ceased on the wounding of one warrior . . . in a nomadic hunter-gatherer society, a sick person is a liability who has to be carried "literally" when they cannot walk or if male, hunt . . . indeed, much of the work was done by women . . .
The Masai of South Africa have a great method for sorting out leadership contests . . . each rival is given a knnife and both are then put in the kraal (stockyard) with the whole community looking on . . . the winner is the survivor who kills his opponent . . . end of contest . . . without social upheaval . . . (take note Dubyah . . . )
The Cold War was mostly a creation of U$ foreign policy attempting to overcome the Atlantic Treaty which allowed post-WWII division of Europe . . . Patton caused a cock-up by advancing his tanks on Berlin until his fuel supply was cut off by U$ GHQ . . . Stalin never trusted the U$, and many of the "incidents" of the Cold War were attempts by the U$ Military to provoke USSR retaliation, which finally happened with the Cuba Missile Crisis . . . Kennedy and Kruchev resolved that face-to-face . . . and U$ interests assassinated JFK for his efforts, among other things . . .
The Cold War finished under Regan when Gorbochev acknowledged that the mobile ICBMs patrolling the East German border and capable of taking out Moscow in less than three minutes was an undefendable threat . . . so let's stop spending 35% of the failing USSR budget on the military and try to re-direct that spending to social policies. Gorbochev stopped the Cold war, not Regan . . . but Gorbochev got rolled and the U$ military, including NATO was now redundant.
>>>>>>>>>>>>
We Americans learned pretty fast that the leviathan needs a leash.
>>>>>>>>>>>>
The U$ leviathan is unfettered by either law or social pressure . . . at present, it is an oligarchy in the hands of an alcoholic in remission and his Fundamentalist Christian cronies . . . mixing fundamentalism with anything is dangerous, especially when those fundamentalists deprive the American people of their hard-won common law rights. Check out the misnamed Patriot Act and look into the Home Defense Act to see how the American people have been duped into accepting a war economy for the benefit of the oligarchy.