Book review - Mr Undesirable

TheEarl

Occasional visitor
Joined
Apr 1, 2002
Posts
9,808
For those who don't know, Mr Undesirable is the first offering from Author's Hangout regular Boota, or Scott Carpenter, as the name on the cover attests. I understand that it's self-published (although readily available through Amazon) and hasn't been picked up by a publisher as yet.

After reading it, I'm at something of a loss to understand why.

Mr Undesirable is a story of Lenny Kapowski, an 'underachieving loser living above my parent's garage, drinking every night, thinking about suicide, and compulsively jerking off to cheap porn.' His words. Just reading the first page will tell you a lot about the novel; the first joke is beautifully placed, setting the scene whilst also drawing an involuntary snort from the reader. Kapowski's an entertaining and very vibrant narrator; a self-aware bastard who whips off one-liners with a reckless abandon as he dreams up ever more pernicious ways to torment his adversaries.

Oh, and what adversaries he has. The book opens with a superb scene that encapsulates the awfulness of the inhabitants of Rambling Hills, a private housing complex where most of the action takes place. It's the home of the effortlessly arrogant, the ignorantly vertiginous, the disgustingly self-assured upper-middle-class. The inhabitants are mostly disgustingly self-possessed, yet Carpenter manages to individualise every one of them brilliantly, from the woman so blinkered that she believes extravagant holiday displays make life tolerable for the hoi polloi, to the man with so many wrinkles that he's likened to a giant foreskin.

These people have looked down on Lenny all his life, comfortable in their wealth and in the knowledge that scum like him could never rise to their heights. Until one day, a lottery ticket pays off and suddenly Lenny has more money than he could possibly know what to do with. So he decides to do the worst thing he can think of. He's going to become their neighbour.

The book thrills with Kapowski's revenges, from petty rule-bendings to shockingly disgusting displays of offensiveness, and is very difficult to put down, simply out of a desire to see what he can possibly do next. However, it is spoilt a little by occasional references to future events which deflate the drama somewhat. Sometimes the conflict will be set up on one page, only for the future resolution to be referred to in the next. You feel cheated, unable to fully enjoy Kapowski's antics when the end result is no longer in doubt.

However, that is but a minor detraction and you are rapidly brought back in by the sparkling wit and enjoyable cast of characters, all of whom bounce energetically from the page, whether they have a cameo or a leading role. Carpenter's first novel stings of Hiassen and Colin Bateman, but really steps out on its own for sheer joy of reading. You get the feeling that Scott Carpenter probably enjoyed writing this too and it shows in every page.

If there is justice, a publisher should soon be giving this book the attention that is deserves. Very thoroughly recommended.

Mr Undesirable

The Earl
 
Last edited:
Now I know what I'm going to read on the plane next week. I've had Boota's book here for months (in the towering TBR stack).

:D
 
The Earl,

Thank you for the great review! I am glad that you enjoyed my book. And you're absolutely right. I had a blast writing it. Cracked myself up. I didn't know if anyone else was going to laugh at it, but I had a damn good time with it. :) You've got a good point about my bad habit of giving away the end of certain scenarios too soon. (Ratfuck comes to mind.) But to make up for it I milked the hell out of some of the other ones.


Imp,

I hope my book can make your travel more entertaining.


Boota
 
Ratfuck does indeed come to mind. I would've been blown away by the end of that bit if I hadn't known what was coming. Bad Boota :D.

That review's now also up on the amazon.co.uk site.

The Earl
 
I didn't think those few instances were such big deals, so maybe that's what I was thinking when I threw in the taglines that gave things away. I did a lot of that just to keep the pages turning. I figured that most people, once they knew what happened - to Ratfuck, for instance - would want to continue reading to see how it happened. I hope it wasn't too distracting for you.

I have a few things like that in the new book, too. I wrote it in the same style, just with a different character narrating. Butchie, the bouncer at Gazonga's, is the main character in the new one. This shouldn't seem like such a suckerpunch for anyone who has read Mr. Undesirable. They know how he turned out. The story takes place in 1988 when Butchie was the high school football star (American football) with dreams of making it to the NFL and being courted by collegiate scouts. Since he's bouncing in a bar a reader can assume that he didn't make it to the NFL, but the cool part of the story is why he didn't. I will definitely keep your critique in mind when I'm doing the revisions on the new book.

Thanks again for the review and for the constructive criticism. And for posting that on the Amazon UK site. I appreciate it greatly.
 
Well, that's the thing - Mr Undesirable isn't obviously told in a reminiscing tense. It appears to be a chronological story from A to B. When something pops up suggesting that the narrator knows what's going to happen next, it's disconcerting, as we all assumed he was with us, the readers, in not knowing what was going to happen.

If you make it clear that he's reminiscing, then it's fine.

The Earl
 
I see what you're saying. That issue won't come up in the new book then because it's made obvious that it takes place in the past.
 
Sorry, I don't mean to harp on a single point. Just wanna keep this thread bumped, so am finding toot to post about.

The Earl
 
Well, I only read the first 150 pages ... but I was drawing stares on the plane for laughing out loud (frequently). Can't wait to find the time to get back to it!

:D
 
Thanks Imp for bumping this up. I meant to order a copy when I first learned about it. Just placed my Amazon order. :)
 
Back
Top