Blindfolded Wife Swap

[Carnevil9]

There are four couples, all good friends.* The husbands are always pressuring the wives to do a swap, but the wives want nothing to do with it. But the husbands are relentless and keep bringing it up.

Finally the wives devise a plan to shut them up. They agree to the swap, but the husbands must be blindfolded, and never know who they swapped with. The hubbies jump at the offer. They all meet at the arranged time and place (one of their houses? Rental cabin? Doesn't really matter) and the husbands are well and truly blindfolded. Each husband is taken by the hand and led to a bedroom by one of the wives, where they undress each other and then fuck like insane bunnies for several hours. Then the wives depart back to the living room.

The point of view would hop from one husband's head to another, as they enjoy the strange sex, totally different from their usual married couple sex, and at the same time, try to figure out which wife they are fucking. They all have trouble figuring it out.

In the end, we find out that each husband was actually fucking his own wife, but the wives were doing their best to behave like they imagined each of the other women would. It allows the wives as well as the husbands to break out of their ruts and really get into it.

I imagine most readers would figure out the "twist" long before the end, but I think it could still be a fun story. I'm not likely to write it, so, free to a good home.

*maybe three couples would be easier to handle from an author's standpoint?

 

[sirhugs]

Clever idea. The trick will be explaining why the guys can't tell their own wives by feel. I'd figure at least one guess quickly- the one whose wife always insists on sex in the pitch darkness.

 

[Lost_Yonder]

After several hours one would imagine they would have a good sense of who they were fucking, not to mention they would have to be some pretty amazing blindfolds to stay in place and the guy wouldn't try and take a peak. The moaning, the breast size, body size/feel, would seem to be easy give aways.

What if the it started slow, which the women all agree to. Blindfold the guys then they get a kiss and have to figure out which wife it was. As it is just a kiss, the wives are a bit more willing to swap. Then it progresses to feeling their breasts and trying to guess which is which. The women are of course drinking, letting their guard down. Perhaps one of the wives likes the idea while the other 2/3 refuse, so she orchestrates the whole thing, getting them to give up a little more each time till they themselves are quite turned on and get into trying to trick their husbands from figuring out who is giving them a blowjob, and eventually fucking...

 

[TarnishedPenny]

Clever idea. The trick will be explaining why the guys can't tell their own wives by feel.

This. There are a host of signals: body odor, vaginal shape, vaginal taste, scars and those ever-popular ‘female copulatory vocalizations.’ Not to mention basics like height, length of hair, boob size and so forth.

I like the basic idea, but there are a couple hurdles.

I do hope you succeed. Bags of potential.

 

[tristantrotsky]

Less Tarnished

This. There are a host of signals: body odor, vaginal shape, vaginal taste, scars and those ever-popular ‘female copulatory vocalizations.’ Not to mention basics like height, length of hair, boob size and so forth.
I like the basic idea, but there are a couple hurdles.
I do hope you succeed. Bags of potential.

The game - of course, is that they obviously know. But if they admit they know, the game comes to an end. The more they pretend to ignorance, the more sweet delicious fucking, sucking and pussy-licking they get. So who is going to admit...?

 

[Carnevil9]

The game - of course, is that they obviously know. But if they admit they know, the game comes to an end. The more they pretend to ignorance, the more sweet delicious fucking, sucking and pussy-licking they get. So who is going to admit...?

That is an excellent double twist! I can't believe I didn't think of it myself! Bravo!

Another option is to abandon the twist, and have the wives really go through with the swap. It could still make for an interesting story, with the guys trying to figure out who they are fucking. But the reader would have to know more about the characters in that case to make the mystery interesting.

 

[sirhugs]

That is an excellent double twist! I can't believe I didn't think of it myself! Bravo!

Another option is to abandon the twist, and have the wives really go through with the swap. It could still make for an interesting story, with the guys trying to figure out who they are fucking. But the reader would have to know more about the characters in that case to make the mystery interesting.

or someone protests the non-cheating cheat, so they really do swap....

 

[LupusDei]

or someone protests the non-cheating cheat, so they really do swap....

Or...

Not all of the guys were actually sure about it, it was safe teasing "knowing" it would never happen for real, so when wifes go with it but it turns out it's the pretended no-swap swap there's some disappointment but also relief, and nothing is admitted aloud while everyone knows everyone eventually figured it out. Even if it seems guys really enjoyed it anyway, it's actually the wifes who are a bit disappointed too in their collective after action review wondering how it would be for real, and perhaps a hubby or two who's the most eager (or even most opposed) to real swap pours oil in that fire, intentionally or not.

So there's a repeat, and this time it's assumed it will be just more of the same, but instead wife's do swap for real but make attempt to confuse that by imitating the counterpart as good as they can, swapping underwear, adjusting hairstyles to an extent and similar. Sure such attempt of deception falls apart even sooner than the first time, but it provides just enough plausible denial so it's not admitted aloud either, and guys pretend confusion even if know well whom they fucked, for a huge turn on for everyone.

This format is then repeated some half dozen times before a fifth (or whatever n+1) girl is brought in... oops, I'm drifting too far.

Anyhow, the wifes will need to be remarkably similar to pull this in any form. Perhaps two are sisters (not twins, but close) and some others are friends since cheerleader squad times or such.

 

[sirhugs]

Or...

Not all of the guys were actually sure about it, it was safe teasing "knowing" it would never happen for real, so when wifes go with it but it turns out it's the pretended no-swap swap there's some disappointment but also relief, and nothing is admitted aloud while everyone knows everyone eventually figured it out. Even if it seems guys really enjoyed it anyway, it's actually the wifes who are a bit disappointed too in their collective after action review wondering how it would be for real, and perhaps a hubby or two who's the most eager (or even most opposed) to real swap pours oil in that fire, intentionally or not.

So there's a repeat, and this time it's assumed it will be just more of the same, but instead wife's do swap for real but make attempt to confuse that by imitating the counterpart as good as they can, swapping underwear, adjusting hairstyles to an extent and similar. Sure such attempt of deception falls apart even sooner than the first time, but it provides just enough plausible denial so it's not admitted aloud either, and guys pretend confusion even if know well whom they fucked, for a huge turn on for everyone.

This format is then repeated some half dozen times before a fifth (or whatever n+1) girl is brought in... oops, I'm drifting too far.

Anyhow, the wifes will need to be remarkably similar to pull this in any form. Perhaps two are sisters (not twins, but close) and some others are friends since cheerleader squad times or such.

maybe they all belong to the same yoga studio and have similar body shapes?

I like this variation. It might just work to suspend the disbelief.

 

[Wifetheif]

There are four couples, all good friends.* The husbands are always pressuring the wives to do a swap, but the wives want nothing to do with it. But the husbands are relentless and keep bringing it up.

Finally the wives devise a plan to shut them up. They agree to the swap, but the husbands must be blindfolded, and never know who they swapped with. The hubbies jump at the offer. They all meet at the arranged time and place (one of their houses? Rental cabin? Doesn't really matter) and the husbands are well and truly blindfolded. Each husband is taken by the hand and led to a bedroom by one of the wives, where they undress each other and then fuck like insane bunnies for several hours. Then the wives depart back to the living room.

The point of view would hop from one husband's head to another, as they enjoy the strange sex, totally different from their usual married couple sex, and at the same time, try to figure out which wife they are fucking. They all have trouble figuring it out.

In the end, we find out that each husband was actually fucking his own wife, but the wives were doing their best to behave like they imagined each of the other women would. It allows the wives as well as the husbands to break out of their ruts and really get into it.

I imagine most readers would figure out the "twist" long before the end, but I think it could still be a fun story. I'm not likely to write it, so, free to a good home.

*maybe three couples would be easier to handle from an author's standpoint?

A good possibility is to have the wives tentatively agree on one prior condition that the guys have to fulfill some absurdly expensive quest, perhaps completely refurbish the cabin or one of their houses with no outside help and pay for it with their own money. NO marital funds! The guys become ingenious businessmen, holding bake sales car washes and Go Fund Me campaigns to get the money. Perhaps both wives want very expensive but comparatively priced pieces of expensive jewelry or expensive works of art. To the amazement of both wives, the men succeed and present their hard-earned prizes at the cabin during one of their regular holiday getaways. Since the wives would look like complete weasels if they don't agree with it, they decide that the husbands must be blindfolded so that they won't spy the wife of their friend in the altogether. The women make the exchange then return to their own beds where the wives engage in sex with their husbands. In the morning, the men compare notes. They know that they have fucked each other's wife as well as their own, but since their own wives gave them mind-blowing sex afterward, it is hard for them to recall exactly what sex with each other's wife was like. They have memories, sensations the feel of lips on their cocks, the aroma of one, the softness, the curve of buttocks, of the silkiness of hair. Mabey both wives shaved for the occasion, something neither normally does. The wives have satisfied their vow but so mindfucked their hubbies, that they really can't savor it as they expected.

 

[missyunderstanding]

I figured it out when I read the word "blindfold"

You said: "I imagine most readers would figure out the "twist" long before the end"

You are correct that most readers would figure out the "twist" long before the end. It was too obvious... the wives wanted nothing to do with it... they came up with a plan...blindfolds. Too obvious.

So if you do write it you need a much bigger twist, or maybe a double or triple twist. But it could be a fun story.

 

[Magineer]

Well, the "twist" which I personally might apply here is to reverse the sexes.

Whereas men are normally deemed to be the "hunters" in sexual matters, I suggest it's not impossible for a raunchy set of housewives who meet up regularly - maybe a set of former Uni friends or suchlike - to come up with the idea of trying to inveigle their husbands into accepting such a proposition.

Maybe they have a book reading circle and they're discussing - over a glass of wine - something similar which came up in the plot..? It occurs to them that they might try it for themselves in real life.

Could be the husbands are normally fairly timid and non-dynamic when it comes to sex. The women think that a certain amount of new spice might be produced within their marriages..?

 

[sirhugs]

Well, the "twist" which I personally might apply here is to reverse the sexes.

Whereas men are normally deemed to be the "hunters" in sexual matters, I suggest it's not impossible for a raunchy set of housewives who meet up regularly - maybe a set of former Uni friends or suchlike - to come up with the idea of trying to inveigle their husbands into accepting such a proposition.

Maybe they have a book reading circle and they're discussing - over a glass of wine - something similar which came up in the plot..? It occurs to them that they might try it for themselves in real life.

Could be the husbands are normally fairly timid and non-dynamic when it comes to sex. The women think that a certain amount of new spice might be produced within their marriages..?

would all the hubbies be timid? Maybe the thrill is in who gets the one alpha male?

 

[LiverpoolMaster]

Well, the "twist" which I personally might apply here is to reverse the sexes.

Whereas men are normally deemed to be the "hunters" in sexual matters, I suggest it's not impossible for a raunchy set of housewives who meet up regularly - maybe a set of former Uni friends or suchlike - to come up with the idea of trying to inveigle their husbands into accepting such a proposition.

Maybe they have a book reading circle and they're discussing - over a glass of wine - something similar which came up in the plot..? It occurs to them that they might try it for themselves in real life.

Could be the husbands are normally fairly timid and non-dynamic when it comes to sex. The women think that a certain amount of new spice might be produced within their marriages..?

I'll second that idea. The psychological "journey" which the wives go on is part of the build-up here.

So, so boring always for the men to be chasing the women. To have the blindfolds applied to the men would be a refreshing and novel take.

 

[Hypoxia]

Blindfolds fall away but absolute darkness and silence remain.

Scenario: the four friendly couples, naked and blindfolded, their ears plugged, stumble into a room festooned with beds and soft furniture, and supplied with lube tubes. Warned to not speak, they remove blindfolds and grope about. Whomever is touched is sucked and fucked. Sure, each may recognize who they're with, but silence induces pseudo-anonymity and frees inhibitions. All can get their freak on without embarrassing consequences beyond cum-splatters. Ring a bell every few minutes so they circulate.

 

[Carnevil9]

Blindfolds fall away......

I was thinking something that covers the entire head and locks under the chin, like a bondage mask. Mouth hole to allow for oral pleasures optional.