Authors who don't hang out on the AH

HectorBidon

Should know better
Joined
Oct 10, 2010
Posts
428
The Story Tags Portal says that as of today this site contains 533,682 stories by 94,815 authors. (Per a fairly recent discussion, it's probably more accurate to say 94,815 "accounts," since this number probably doesn't factor in that some authors have more than one account.) In any event, that's a lot of accounts, and it dawned on me that I don't think I've ever come across anywhere near that many authors here on the AH.

To investigate this more fully, I looked at the 100 most recently published stories as of today. This included 90 stories published on 10/17/2022 and 10 stories published on 10/16/2022. I looked the author of each story up on the Member Search Page and the Forum Search Page to find the number of his or her stories, followers, and forum posts.

There turned out to be 92 distinct authors in all (some had had more than one story come out). Of these, only 18 had ever posted on one of the forums. There were two heavy posters: SusanJillParker (2,155 posts, 675 stories, 8501 followers) and Pixiehoff (10,197 posts, 330 stories, 907 followers). The next three highest posters had 64, 23, and 17 posts, and all the rest had less than 10. A full 74 authors had never posted on a forum at all. I didn't analyze which forums were posted to, but it's pretty clear that at least 90 of the 92 authors were not regular contributors to the AH.

Many of the authors were quite prolific. 27 had more than 50 stories, and 11 had more than 100. Notable were rawlyrawls (157 stories, 3995 followers), imhapless (205 stories, 2957 followers), and mypenname3000 (555 stories, 4917 followers), none of whom have ever posted to any forum.

I have to say I was a bit surprised by the results. When I think of a Lit author, I tend to think of someone whom I've encountered here on the AH. But, in fact, it seems that the lion's share of Lit authors don't come here at all. They publish and are read and have their fans and get their comments, but they don't show up here, not to brag, or to rant, or to ask for advice, or to give it. (This point has been made here on the forum before, but I've never realized it so starkly.)

Now granted, this was a small sample—just one day's worth of stories. I'm sure that we AH regulars might have had a better showing if I'd picked some other random day last week. And, it's entirely possible that some of the authors on my list do follow the AH without posting or are really AH regulars themselves just publishing under different accounts.

But I think it's an undeniable fact that an awful lot of Lit stories are being written and published without our even being aware of them. Kind of makes me wonder whether all those authors are missing anything at all by not being privy to our pontification, and what we're missing by not being privy to theirs.
 
Honestly? Unless they have a specific question they can't find an answer to anywhere else, they're better off not knowing about the forums. Not that it can't be a fun place and you can make some friends, but writing wise? Best to be left on your own. I published for over a year and had a couple dozen stories before I came to the AH and I have often thought over the years I'm glad I did it that way so I wasn't influenced by a lot of what gets discussed here, which is often more concern over stats than actual writing.

And those people don't end up with the forum trolls bombing their stories whenever something is said they don't like.
 
I saw the forum as an opportunity to learn from other authors about my work. Was the feedback I was getting unusual or just the normal.
Secondly, I can try and advertise my stories once they drop off "new". Especially if I have reedited them!

Not sure 1.1 days of information is great enough source? You probably need a week or a month? To get across section of data to forum dwellers?
 
I personally know three writers that don't make a habit of visiting here. One has never, although they are prolific in other forums here. The other two have only a handful of posts total.
 
It took me several years of writing stories and publishing them here before joining the forums, and probably another year after that before posting anything here. I can't remember what motivated me, but I've benefited from participating.
 
I hang out on the forum partly to help me find people I might be interested in reading. People who play with language and words often write stories I like.

If I was simply interested in stories with particular acts, then I wouldn't have got into the forum.
 
There are about 3 Million posts on the AH which is about 5% of the number of posts on all forums. However, less than 10% of all visitors to the site ever visit any forum. So obviously you are a very select bunch.:)
 
There are about 3 Million posts on the AH which is about 5% of the number of posts on all forums. However, less than 10% of all visitors to the site ever visit any forum. So obviously you are a very select bunch.:)
I've sometimes wondered who those people are that post to the General board and the Politics board. My quick impression is that there is a lot of - blather? - on those forums.
 
To investigate this more fully, I looked at the 100 most recently published stories as of today. This included 90 stories published on 10/17/2022 and 10 stories published on 10/16/2022. I looked the author of each story up on the Member Search Page and the Forum Search Page to find the number of his or her stories, followers, and forum posts.

There turned out to be 92 distinct authors in all (some had had more than one story come out). Of these, only 18 had ever posted on one of the forums. There were two heavy posters: SusanJillParker (2,155 posts, 675 stories, 8501 followers) and Pixiehoff (10,197 posts, 330 stories, 907 followers). The next three highest posters had 64, 23, and 17 posts, and all the rest had less than 10. A full 74 authors had never posted on a forum at all. I didn't analyze which forums were posted to, but it's pretty clear that at least 90 of the 92 authors were not regular contributors to the AH.

Many of the authors were quite prolific. 27 had more than 50 stories, and 11 had more than 100. Notable were rawlyrawls (157 stories, 3995 followers), imhapless (205 stories, 2957 followers), and mypenname3000 (555 stories, 4917 followers), none of whom have ever posted to any forum.

Note that selecting by "authors with recently published stories" will bias your sample towards those who are more prolific, which may then bias the percentage who are on the forum.

I'm not too surprised though - any time I look at New Stories most of the names are ones I don't see in the forums.
 
My first interest in the forums was in the editor's forum, and then in the feedback forum. I didn't have much interest in AH, and when I did look in to see what was going on I found people here to be awfully prickly. Why would someone get involved in that?

I didn't have much to say on the forums until I found the social threads: Naoko's thread, the Last thread, TxRad's coffee house, and the event support threads. People there were more friendly.

It all makes me wonder how long it might take for the new audio booth to gain a crowd.
 
Your research numbers are off. My sr71plt account, for instance, has posted to the AH as recently as last week, is the fourth most productive account at Lit. for all time, has 1,019 posted stories, two recently, nearly 52,000 discussion posts, and 2,745 followers. And yet it's not mentioned in your reporting at all. So, I assume your research is just incomplete.

Some of those you do index are long gone.

Even this, my KeithD account (23,799 posts, 373 stories, 961 followers), dwarfs the numbers of at least one you list as a heavy poster (Pixiehoff). Your thread specifies hanging out in the AH. I see no evidence that Pixiehoff posts to the AH at all.
 
Last edited:
Your research numbers are off. My sr71plt account, for instance, has posted to the AH as recently as last week, is the fourth most productive account at Lit. for all time, has 1,019 posted stories, two recently, nearly 52,000 discussion posts, and 2,745 followers. And yet it's not mentioned in your reporting at all. So, I assume your research is just incomplete.

Some of those you do index are long gone.

Even this, my KeithD account (23,799 posts, 373 stories, 961 followers), dwarfs the numbers of at least one you list as a heavy poster (Pixiehoff). Your thread specifies hanging out in the AH. I see no evidence that Pixiehoff posts to the AH at all.
We all agree you're a heavy hitter, prolific at posting, and have many, many, many accounts.
 
I've only been on the site a little over a month. I think a month and 10 days not positive. I had read stories here for years but only joined when I got the itch to write. Anyway, I found this by accident following the link to forum on the pull-down in my control panel. I haven't looked at any other forums. This was the one that interested me. I read more than I comment, best to listen and learn ... but sometimes I have opinions.
 
As I understand the subject of this thread it isn't about those who post here, but rather, those who do not.
Stop your petty attacking. The OP used examples of those posting to the AH and I merely pointed out the faultiness of the research on the stats the OP used with the stats I actually know.
 
Stop your petty attacking. The OP used examples of those posting to the AH and I merely pointed out the faultiness of the research on the stats the OP used with the stats I actually know.
Please accept my apology, and I'm sorry I hurt your feelings. I didn't even reference you in the posting; I only pointed out the thread is about those writers that do not participate here. It was not intended to be an attack on you.

However, I do admire your ability to turn any thread to yourself.
 
Please accept my apology, and I'm sorry I hurt your feelings. I didn't even reference you in the posting; I only pointed out the thread is about those writers that do not participate here. It was not intended to be an attack on you.

However, I do admire your ability to turn any thread to yourself.
You inform us of your story status hourly. If we can endure your juvenile posting. you can jolly well do the same.
 
I think whether or not an author comes to the AH probably depends on what they are hoping to find here. In pre-Covid days, I used to hang out at the pub a bit. But I didn't go there for writing advice. (I didn't even go there for the alcohol.) I went there for amiable company. My friend Bill seldom goes to a pub. He hangs out at the golf club. And I'm pretty sure that he doesn't go there to talk golf.
 
Ogg has informed others as much as I about the status of his story. Why don't you go and shame him as well?
Ogg doesn't attack me for posting like everyone else does. You and LC hypocritically do. No one blows their own trumpets here like you two do.

One response to the OP's question on why more authors don't hang around the AH is that the AH can be a very hostile environment and often provides a launching pad for the stalking of the author and his/her stories.
 
Back
Top