Ask the physics student

There is a limit to the size of the universe that we can see. Outside of that is the part we cannot see.

If there's a boundary than by the time any light photons make it there, it creates more space. We're expanding. So getting to the "edge" is problematic since space itself expands and it's unlikely we'd outpace that.

If we get into multiverses, all bounds bets are off.
 
I like pears and peaches more than apples so would it be possible to change the whole Newton story to fit my likes? Maybe even a yellow cherry cuz them is awesome.
And why did he get a fig cookie named after him? Was it really a fig and not an apple?
 
If there's a boundary than by the time any light photons make it there, it creates more space. We're expanding. So getting to the "edge" is problematic since space itself expands and it's unlikely we'd outpace that.

If we get into multiverses, all bounds bets are off.
We can see 13.7 billion lightyears away on a good day. What we see is what happened way over there 13.7 billion years ago. It's likely that more has happened since, and that those bits have been sending out light away from our direction for another 13.7 billion years. But we will never get a look at that side of it.
 
Probably a dumb question, but how do cells and atoms relate? Are cells in the human body made up of molecules, which are combinations of atoms????
 
Probably a dumb question, but how do cells and atoms relate? Are cells in the human body made up of molecules, which are combinations of atoms????

Cells are like a trillion times the size of an atom.

Here are the atoms that make up 99.9% of you.

carbon
oxygen
hydrogen
phosphorus
nitrogen
calcium
potassium
Sulfur
Sodium
Chlorine

The rest of the elements in you like copper, molybdenum, nickle, lithium exist in the human body in trace amounts. Like 1.4e-8 trace...

They combine to make molecules mostly of water, protein, sugar and cellulose which build cells, which build tissues, which build organs which build organisms.

Elemental percentages you are by far and large made of hydrogen....by mass Oxygen (almost 2/3!!) and all matter is made of mostly empty space.
 
Last edited:
Thanks a lot BB - I appreciate your answer. I've put my blonde wig on so I can ask another :)

I read that the only solid matter that is part of an atom is the nucleus, and that an image of the ratio between that solid to the size of the atom would be as a pea at the centre of Westminster Cathedral. If the remainder is empty space, why do we sense everything as an inpenetrable solid?
 
Thanks a lot BB - I appreciate your answer. I've put my blonde wig on so I can ask another :)

I read that the only solid matter that is part of an atom is the nucleus, and that an image of the ratio between that solid to the size of the atom would be as a pea at the centre of Westminster Cathedral. If the remainder is empty space, why do we sense everything as an inpenetrable solid?

You can't technically call a nucleus solid matter. It's a part of what makes up matter.

The electrons that exist outside the atoms in orbit create the "shell" of the atom and it's those shells that are interacting.

More of a "field" than a shell, but if you consider the idea of a whole bunch of mostly empty eggs bumping into each other and not cracking, it might help.
 
Last edited:
Thanks a lot BB - I appreciate your answer. I've put my blonde wig on so I can ask another :)

I read that the only solid matter that is part of an atom is the nucleus, and that an image of the ratio between that solid to the size of the atom would be as a pea at the centre of Westminster Cathedral. If the remainder is empty space, why do we sense everything as an inpenetrable solid?

all nuclei carry a +charge, they repel each other, so atoms can only get so close.

like... when you try to push the wrong ends of two magnets together, and it feels as though there is something solid between them that you keep sliding off.
 
Probably a dumb question, but how do cells and atoms relate? Are cells in the human body made up of molecules, which are combinations of atoms????
For an idea of the scale difference between them, load this webpage: http://scaleofuniverse.com

A cell is around the scale of 10 to -4.5 meters, a molecule is 10 to -8.5 meters, and an atom is 10 to -10.0 meters.
 
Thanks a lot BB - I appreciate your answer. I've put my blonde wig on so I can ask another :)

I read that the only solid matter that is part of an atom is the nucleus, and that an image of the ratio between that solid to the size of the atom would be as a pea at the centre of Westminster Cathedral. If the remainder is empty space, why do we sense everything as an inpenetrable solid?

There are several physical principles at work to produce the effect and sensation of solid matter. However I'm a bit clusterminded at the moment so you're just going to have to trust they act in concert and generate what you perceive as the bulk properties of matter.

Electromagnetic sighting -- vision -- gives you the sensation of flat surfaces but what you are detecting are particles of light which have interacted with that matter in some fashion. Specifically, this was interaction with the election cloud which by volume comprises the majority of an atom. Photons, particles of light, can scatter, be absorbed and emitted from this electron cloud.

Electron clouds, themselves comprised of negative (electron) charges are mutually repulsive by electrostatic forces. This is the first mechanism by which atoms and molecules to not collapse on themselves.

In quantum physics a class of particle, the fermions, obey what is referred to as the exclusion principle. The exclusion principle states the probability of finding like fermions in the same quantum state vanishes with proximity. The exclusion principle is not an actual force, but is rather a statistical artifact. Protons, neutrons, electrons and many atomic nuclei are fermions.
 
just explain the quantum states of electrons around an atom, tyvm.

Okay. So time for a serious answer I suppose. I'll provide a general answer and if there are any gaps you'd like filled subsequently we can do that.

So let's begin by thinking of electrons not as particles but as waves. There's a good chance you're familiar with the wave-particle duality from quantum physics, which is typically read as, quantum entities travel as waves but interact as particles. For now we're not going to justify or motivate the wave nature of electrons. We're just going to establish the electron wave as a thing.

Now instead of electrons in orbit of an atomic nucleus comprising an atom, we have standing waves. For imagery you can borrow plucked guitar strings. The harmonics of electron waves about an atomic nucleus correspond to allowed frequencies of these matter waves, correspond to allowed energy state referred to as electron orbitals. As another visual, imagine a hollow brass sphere which is struck and allowed to resonate. This resonation is a three dimensional standing wave.

We're going to make our standing electron wave model a little more sophisticated now by introducing several principles which were the fruits of what is historically referred to as first quantization. We can say that for an electron to shift from one orbital to another, to a higher or lower energy state, requires the absorption or emission of a quantum of energy, a photon, or an exchange of energy by some other interaction, perhaps an electromagnetic field. If an electron acquires sufficient energy it becomes kicked from its host atom altogether. Electrons on the outer orbitals are so loosely bound that in bulk they form an electron sea. It is the electron sea by which some materials become electrical conductors.

Another principle we can readily incorporate into our model is the exclusion principle. The principle is described in my last post in this thread. For the purposes of electron orbitals, the exclusion principle explains why orbitals cannot by redundantly occupied by electron waves.

Finally we can give the standard physical interpretation of matter waves. What the wave is modeling, properly calculated, is the probability (density) of the electron, for example, occurring in some particular state or location.
 
I'm getting there :)

I had to read the answers over a few times but it is making sense to me ( I left school at 15 so I have to image it in an abstract way rather than absorb it intellectually).

So what I want to know now is - if the most powerful visual aids can only go so small (maybe to the atomic level?), how do you get "proof" of such things as sub atomic particles? Are these simply mathematical equations which solve, or do you set out actions they must meet in order to be defined, or what? At what point is "real" real, or just a mental construct?

Again, thanks so much for sharing your knowledge!
 
I had to read the answers over a few times but it is making sense to me ( I left school at 15 so I have to image it in an abstract way rather than absorb it intellectually).

So what I want to know now is - if the most powerful visual aids can only go so small (maybe to the atomic level?), how do you get "proof" of such things as sub atomic particles? Are these simply mathematical equations which solve, or do you set out actions they must meet in order to be defined, or what? At what point is "real" real, or just a mental construct?

Again, thanks so much for sharing your knowledge!

You're very welcome! We've broached a lot in the way of particle physics, which is a highly abstruse discipline. If you feel like there should be more clarity than is offered please don't hesitate to say so.

To answer your question, especially in physics experimental confirmation or denial is heavily dependent on the interplay between theory and experiment. It may be implicit, but each and every observation makes hypotheses about the entities to be observed, the observational process, and the interaction between the observational process and observed entities. If we capture an image by scanning tunneling electron microscope, for example, we're making myriad hypotheses about the quantum physics involved, and the susceptibility of our entity to be observed by this form of microscopy.

To be more specific, "imaging" below the atomic scale involves particle interactions which are in some manner reflected to the observer. There are so many techniques available in the physics toolkit, but they all share this general feature. Take for example neutrino observation. One variety of neutrino detector, the scintillator, has some bulk mass, a fluid, whose atoms luminescence when one of its electrons becomes excited by a collision with a neutrino. This luminescence is picked up by photomultipliers surrounding the bulk mass and reported to the observers. In this way, an "image" is captured of an individual neutrino, a fundamental particle, but this imaging is highly dependent upon our theory which describes it.
 
Hmmm, it sounds as if, at this level, you are only able to capture a symbol, pointer, echo (not sure what word to use) of the reality that the symbol points to - and then are able to say that reality is true because it acts or behaves in a manner expected by the originating hypotheses. Am I understanding correctly?

If the act of observation at the sub atomic level actually changes the behaviour of the object of observation, how do you know what occurs without the interference of the act of observation?

On a slightly different note. If an observed action changes because of observation - and entangled particles(?) "know" each other so as to change behaviour in concert - is this the same "knowing". I mean does the observed change "know" it is being observed, in the same way each part of the entangled particle knows it's "sister"

I'm not sure I used to right words or communicated what I was trying to ask in that last paragraph.
 
Back
Top