Anyone You Can Be, I Can Be Better ~Closed for Momadness~

[princesssexci]

http://www.tori.ng/userfiles/image/2015/oct/16/hot1.JPG​

Madison and Katrina were two completely different people. They had been since they hit the age of 2. While Maddie had been more of the tom boy in life hanging out with the guys, being one of the guys and much more studious and less superficial; her identical twin sister had grown to be the exact opposite. Kat hung out with the guys too but in a much different sense of the word. She was a cheer leader in high school so it was no surprise when she made the squad in college, she was part of a sorority and was always hanging off some phrat boys arm, like a trophy every week.

They looked exactly the same of course, so it wasn't like Madison couldn't get dates. She'd been on dates and had even had sex, not as much as sister but she wasn't a virgin.

They had long black hair, pouty lips, dark skin, 32d breasts, firm asses and brown eyes. It was clear they both stayed in shape. And just like sisters, they had their ups and downs, mainly downs. It had been like that since they'd hit puberty.

"I'm not going to your stupid phrat Halloween party." Maddie said through her cellphone receiver. She was in her dorm room flipping channels passing every stupid Halloween movie there was.

"First of all, it's a sorority party and it'll be fun. Our costumes could literally be each other." Kat said. She'd already chosen both their costumes, she was dressing up as a softball player. It wasn't her usual costume, normally she'd go as something skanky like the devil or some trashy version of a Disney princess.

"No." Maddie said.

"You need to get out. How long has it been since you got laid? You broke up with Henry a year ago, right?" Kat asked, not bothering to let her answer,"I'm not taking no for an answer. You're coming and I already bought your costume for you."

Maddie groaned as the phone clicked from Kats side. Kat made her way up to the dorm apartments and walked past a few freshmen. The truth was Kat had a bit of a problem, one of Maddies friends was extremely hot and one of the few guys who paid n attention to Kat.

So she might have invited him as Maddie to Kats sorority party, saying it would be fun. She didn't even bother knocking on the door, especially considering it was partially open."Guess who.." Kat said as she pushed the door open and threw the costume on the bed.

"I'm not going, Kat. Why do you look like me?" Maddie asked.

"It's a costume party." Kat pulled her out of the wooden chair she was wearing. "Just look at the costume." Maddie sighed and walked towards the bed, looking inside the bag. It was a leather cat suit and a cat girl mask. "You're fucking joking, right? Didn't you wear this last year?"

"Listen, you won't get laid looking like you or dressing like you, you should just go as me for the night. "

"You're up to something Kat."

Kat shrugged, "Maybe."

"Fine, I'll go for an hour." Madison said.

"Yay! You're gonna have so much fun."

 

[princesssexci]

Madison

Madison as Kat stepped into the Sigma house biting her lip. She couldn't believe that she was actually going through with this. How had she managed to let Katrina talk her into going to a dumb Halloween party and on top of that, dress up AS her. It was hard standing let alone walking in these damned heels. In an instant, she felt Kat's most recent boy toys Tyler come up behind her.

Fuck.

Would he know she wasn't Kat? She should probably tell him. Before she could correct him, he leaned foreward and kissed her before speaking. The real Kat giggled in the background.

Before they'd gotten into the party, Kat had told her to pretend to be her. Kat had said she couldn't do it but, how hard would it be to act like a total slut. Besides, it wasn't like Tyler was bad looking or anything.

"Wow.." Madison murmured against his lips as though he'd never kissed her before. "I mean, it's always wow but...wow." She lied then nodded her head. "Yeah, lets go in...for sure."

Kat

Kat couldn't believe she had managed to get Maddy to agree to go to this costume let alone pretend to be her. Ever since highschool it had always been her mission to get her to lighten up, have a little fun. Plus, she always had a thing for Cory but it always seemed like he checked out Madi more than her.

It didn't help that she was dating Tyler either....well, fucking Tyler. Could she even consider them boyfriend and girlfriend?

"Hey Cori!" She called, waving. She had to do this right, had to look as sweet and innocent as possible with just a hint of naughty that could be pulled out...with the right fellow.

Thinking like that made her want to barf but that was how her twin thought and she had to think like her twin to get the guy. How she'd manage to keep him around was beyond her, but she'd think about that later when the time came.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat blinked a few times while mentally cursing. Sure it was hella cute when Cori got all nerdy and stuff but she hadn’t thought about how she might have to actually understand what he was saying. She could agree though couldn’t she?

She sat on his lap, to look at the laptop. It all looked Greek to Kat but she shifted slightly to look back at him. “Yes, 1.4 you got it.” Everyone seemed to look disappointed that she didn’t go into great detail. “I mean do I even need to tell you why it’s 1.4 Guys we learned this already didn’t we? Basic...one oh one shit, stuff. Sorry, my sister made drink a few beers before coming here. Said it would loosen me up.”

Kat rolled her eyes dramatically then smiled at Cori. “You don’t mind if I sit here do you, it’s much comfier than standing.”

Madison

Madison followed Tyler towards the keg of beer feeling totally out of her element. She glanced back towards the kitchen wishing she could be in there talking code. While she probably could understand sports talk way more than her sister, the way she was dressed she was certain that talking about the Super Bowl and how crazy it was that the Eagles won was on Tyler’s mind right now, not the way he kept looking back at her and licking her lips.

He handed her a red cup full of beer and she took it, sipping slowly trying not to cringe at the taste. She hated beer, with a passion but Kat loved beer with that same passion so she had to fake it.

He mentioned something about getting kinkier and having a threesome with Cory or one of the other guys.

“Ah...did I?”

Fuck you, Kat. She thought silently to herself then had to ask herself what would Katrina do?

“I didn’t think you’d come up something so quickly.” It wasn’t like Cory was bad looking though. Her sister would tell her to let lose and have fun, don’t be such a prude. Tyler had already called who he thought was Maddy a prude. What better way to show that she wasn’t.

Right?

She gulped down the rest of the beer, nervously. “Cory should be fine, I guess. I mean of course he’s ...where do we start?”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat grinned when Mary looked amazed that she’d been wrong. Kat shrugged her shoulders while silently breathing a sigh of relief that Cori had been right. So this was what her nerdy sister did at parties....code. No wonder she never got laid.

She didn’t understand why everyone was looking at her funny though as she played with Cori’s hair. It was amazingly well taken care of, really soft. Softer than hers. She was almost tempted to ask what shampoo he used but then she’d be friend zoning...

Her thoughts trailed off as Cori asked her what she was doing. Almost like he was disgusted by her actions.

“Uh...what do you mean?”

“Sweetie, if you were anyone else...I’d be cursing you out.” Pete said, with a laugh,” and telling you to get off my boyfriends lap. What did your sister do, drug you with x?”

Boyfriends...
lap...

Holy fucking shit.

Cori was...gay?! No wonder he never paid much attention to her. She all but jumped out of his lap. Maybe this was a very bad idea. “Yes..no..wait...” it was probably easier pretending she was high off ecstasy. “Maybe?”

Maddie

Maddie just stared at Cory with a y. He thought she was hot. She looked over at Kat pretending to be her, just as she jumped out of Cori with an i’s lap, and tried to contain her laughter.

Kat must’ve just figured out that Cori was fabulously gay.

“Umm...I dunno, she’s...”god help her she was about diss herself. “She’s a bit of a prude. I mean look at her costume.”

That didn’t seem to sway him though. But she wasn’t really up to giving Kat another guy to fuck, besides this guy wanted her...Maddy not Kat as Maddy.

“Tell you what, how about we do this threesome thing and if I enjoy it...I’ll tell Maddy you’re a GREAT fuck.”

Okay Maddy was starting to scare herself, she was starting to sound a LOT like Kat.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat was suddenly pulled outside with Mary and felt hella confused especially when she started interrogating her like the fbi. She looked almost...broken hearted or something. Weird. “Well I mean I cant be certain. She gave me a beer before coming here. I’m flirting with a guy who I obviously would never flirt with......because he’s gay and I set him up with Peter.” Kat lied. “It seems like obvious drugging to me.”

What else was Kat supposed to say?

“Your costume is cute by the way, never pictured you as a 90s Gwen Stefani but it works.”

There! Girls always responded well to compliments especially nerd girls and she seemed to beam at that.

See, it was easy being Maddie.
~~

“What? ....what are we do?”

Were they supposed to be doing some strip show or something? What was going on?! Maddy pursed her lips as Kats friends stared at her as if she’d lost her mind.

“I...”

Lily pulled her to the side giving the guys a reassuring smile. “Kitty Kat, you okay? We practiced this all week.”

“Right...I’ve just been really stressed and...what did we practice?”

Lily stared at her blinking a few times.

This wasn’t fun anymore.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat stared blankly at Mary for a moment until realization hit her. Had her and Maddy hooked up? She swallowed nervously because that was not something she'd seen her sister doing. She was hesitant to do anything though. Like should she kiss her? It would give her up if she didn't wouldn't it? She glanced behind them checking to see if anyone was watching. Though no one would even think that she was Kat because right now she wasn't and tomorrow, she wouldn't actually have to deal with the consequences.

"Um...sure?" Kat said slowly.

She fidgeted slightly as Mary leaned closer and lightly brushed her lips against hers. Weird, like she'd always joked around about her sister being lesbian but didn't actually think it was true or anything. Was Maddy lesbian? It didn't look like she was very disgusted when Kat's boyfriend grabbed her ass.

It took Kat a while to realize that she was slowly starting to respond back to the kiss, her mouth opening as Mary found her hips, gripping them and pulling Kat closer. God she was horny but she blamed it on the fact that by now, she was usually having a little naughty fun with Tyler.

~~

The rainbow rod trophy...

The words echoed in Maddie's mind. She remembered when her and Kat had first started college and Kat had tried to rope her into being part of the sorority. One of the first few tasks was the rainbow rod thingy. She vaguely remembered some of the rules, thank god. She wouldn't look like a complete idiot.

That was one thing her and Kat had in common. They both hated looking stupid. But really, who didn't care about that?

The contest was simple. All sorority pledges got assigned a different color of lipstick, bright colors. Then they would go about and offer to color the fraternity pledges of the brother flight's cocks with their different lipsticks. They would have to do different challenges to get their dick's colored. The winner on the fraternity side was the guy that had the most different colors on his dick or 'Rainbow Rod'. The winner on the girl side was the one who had put her color on the most dicks. The winners would get a trophy for the year.

This was the reason Maddy hadn't joined said sorority it was really demeaning and kind of stupid and was now left to Maddy, president of the feminist club to get the party started.


"What? Uh...god, I hope not. That would be embarassing wouldn't it?" Maddy said slowly. She gave Monika or whatever the girls name was, Maddy really couldn't keep track of her sisters best friends. "Don't worry about it, lets get through this first shall we?"

Did her sister even say words like shall?

Maddy cleared her throat and moved towards the crowd, taking a deep breath. "ALRIGHT LADIES! Who is ready to find out the winner of the Rainbow Rod contest?"


Tomika handed her the envelope and she slowly opened it. "The winner is Stacy Mckee!"

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

She could still taste the cherry lipgloss of Mary and while she should’ve said no. This wasn’t her life after all. That was sort of the point wasn’t it. During Halloween you were supposed to be someone you weren’t. Plus, Mary was kind of cute in her own little way.

Kat licked her lips glancing up seeing some of her sorority sisters giving them disgusted looks. It didn’t worry her because tonight she was Maddy. “Yeah, let’s ditch this popsicle stand before they try to convince us to join one of their sausage fest contests.”

Shit.

She suddenly remembered she was supposed to be announcing the winner of that Rainbow Rod contest but ...Maddy could handle it, right? Kat just wanted a small break from her popularity and that didn’t seem too much to ask.

Plus, Kat was really good at being naughty.

Maddy

After all the festivities were done which was really most of the sorority bitches talking about how much fun it was coloring up the frat boys cock with their different colored lipsticks, different tales were being passed around, Maddy found it hard to not roll her eyes.

Maybe she could ditch this popsicle stand. Would Tyler take her home? Sure she’d agreed to the whole threesome thing but, he hadn’t really mentioned since she’d first arrived. Someone shoved another red cup of beer in her hand which she assumed meant she was supposed to drink it. She took a few sips as she looked for her sisters fuck toy.

Finally she found him, “Hey can we go—“

And then he cut her off mentioning the threesome with Cory. SHIT! She thought she would’ve gotten out of this. She took another large gulp of her beer and followed him. He pulled up to the attic rooms and then inside one of them with a gigantic smile.

A pillowcase was thrown over her head and she screamed as her red cup of beer fell to the ground. “What the fuck is this Tyler?!”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Get into something more comfortable....

Kat combed her fingers through her hair and looked down at the cheesy softball costume she had on. Was she really going through with this? Her hands moved up to the buttons and slowly each one came undone.

Yes, apparently she was because it was way better than another one of Tyler’s cheesy way of being kinky.

She’d actually planned to make a clean break with him tonight if Maddy hadn’t agreed to switch places but she knew she’d have to do it soon.

After all, Maddy could only hold him off for so long and it wasn’t like she was going to be in any danger. He wasn’t about to do some gang bang let alone a threesome. They’d talked about it but he’d never actually gone through with it.

Soon, Kat was wiggling out of her softball pants, now in nothing but a pink laced bra with matching laced undies. She stepped into the bedroom and waited.

“Uh...I’m ready.”

God, she was really doing this, having her first lesbian encounter.

Maddy

Maddy felt a strong body come behind her, Tyler. She was trembling slight and nodded her head. Was this Kat and Tyler’s kind of foreplay because she was having a hard time finding this sexy.

Until he lifted the pillowcase slightly and kissed her roughly. Something in her twitched. For some reason, it was starting to become arousing as he tied her elbows up. She tugged slightly.

“I ...said...” her voice trailed off because she couldn’t tell her sisters boyfriend that she wasn’t Kat. Could she? He was so disgustingly perverted would he even stop. “Yes...” She said slowly. She heard the sounds of more feet. “B-but maybe I —I was just joking. It’s not just you and Cory is it?”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat
The tattoo on her ...shit!

“That, umm yes. I lost a bet with Kat, she told me I had to get a tattoo and that was the kindest of punishments.”

Kat glanced at the Xbox one controller. Of course her twins sexy time was playing some stupid video game.

“And for the outfit, lingerie I guess..um, I wanted to...I mean...I was hoping...” she looked up at Mary through her long lashes,”I wanted to do something different. Sorry, do I look like a slut?”

She shivered at the touch of Mary’s hand on her tattoo.

~~
Maddy

Gangbang?! holy shit. Well at least she now knew her sister didn’t purposely throw her into one of these. She felt someone’s hands unzip her catsuit and then squeeze her breasts.

Good god, how long had it been since she’d had real cock. Not a dildo that Mary shoved into her. She wasn’t a slut, no but because of her social circles she chose not to sleep around.

How good would that look? Fucking a bunch of guys and then standing up behind a podium protesting for women’s right.

Tyler mentioned something about a safe word. What? Wasn’t that like some bdsm territory? Her sister was into that?

“S-so much is happening so quickly, remind me what it is?” She said as she he tugged on the leash that was attached to the leather collar around her neck. He’d seen her sister naked probably so many times would he notice any differences?

Would he think her nipples looked smaller than Maddys? Something stupid like that.

And she hated admitting that this kind of turned her on. She could feel her pussy tightening with anticipation.

 

[princesssexci]

~Kat~

“Mmm I just bought them today.” Kat said in regards to her fancy new undies. At least THAT wasn’t a lie. She giggled as Mary crawled over her. Okay, so honestly she thought tonight she’d be getting some dick from some guy who didn’t know her(despite knowing her sister) and she didn’t know him so there’d be no emotional ties but this didn’t seem so bad.

She’d only ever gotten as far as making out and groping Tomika.

But that was when they were drunk or high.

Mary’s tits weren’t huge like her own but they were a nice handful. She squeezed them gently before Mary traveled lower with her kisses. Her own hands continued roaming down Mary’s body, cupping her ass through the cute innocent little Hello Kitty shorts.

Kat was so thankful she’d pulled the piercings out of her nipples earlier because that would’ve been a huge give away. She could get away with having a small tattoo and some sexy underwear but nipple piercings would’ve been way harder to explain.

~Maddy ~

Oh god, oh god, oh god!

Piercings? What the ever loving fuck? She knew her sister was a whore but she never thought her sister would go as far as getting piercings in her breasts. Also all the dirty words these guys were saying...

Suddenly Tyler broke through the sounds of the other guys asking her where she kept her piercings.

“They..they closed up. They were fucking infected like all kinds of weird shit coming out of the nipples. So I had to take them out. I’m sorry baby.”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat gasped sharply as Mary began using her mouth to toy with her breasts, her back arched into Mary as her fingers went through her braids.

Kat giggled at Mary’s amazement of her clean shaven pussy and silently thanked Tyler for always keeping it clean. “Thought you might like that.” Her hips jerked upward when Mary easily found her clit.

“Yesss...fuck!” She moaned as she pushed Mary’s face deeper into her cunt. It was crazy how fast she found it. It literally blew Kats mind.

Maddy

Maddy didn’t speak. What was she supposed to say? Oh sorry for not being clean shaven but I’m not really your girlfriend so our habits are slightly different.

She felt her panties get pulled down and heard Tyler’s order to get the razor and some water. Now, Maddy wasn’t an expert at this but she was pretty sure her sister would use feminine shaving cream and had even witnessed her buying some at the drug store.

“You can use the shaving cream I bought, smells like berries.” But since she couldn’t see she wasn’t sure if it fell on deaf ears or not.

She felt the razor brush against her pubic hair and shivered but tried to stay as still as possible.

When Tyler was finished she could feel ...everything, the air hitting her. It was almost liberating and then she felt someone tease her opening and bit back a moan.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat felt Mary’s tongue get super close to her g-spot and gasped sharply as her body began to tremble once she found it. “Oh god, oh god, oh my fucking...” Kat whimpered. The orgasm washed over her super quick and her body seized up. She’d never felt so...alive before.

Once she’d calmed down from the amazing orgasm, Kat felt almost indebted to give Mary the same pleasure. Could she do it though? She’d never done this kind of thing with a woman before.

Kat sat up a bit and smiled sweetly,

“May I?”

Maddy

Maddy felt a bunch of cocks brush against her mouth as Kats boyfriend ordered her to open wide, along with a ‘threat’. It took her a minute to readjust to the light in the bedroom. It didn’t take long to realize she was literally surrounded by cocks.

As Cory’s cock pushed into her mouth first, she moaned. God, how long had it been since she’d sucked cock? She felt someone behind her push her head into a steady rhythm as other guys stood there stroking while watching her.

She could feel herself dampening slightly as she watched what she usually considered a sickening display of sexualizing a woman only this time she was the woman. Mary would be disgusted at the sight but somehow that didn’t seem to matter.

“Stroke my cock, bitch.” One of them said and shakily her hand lifted and began stroking one of the cocks. Another cock pushed on her cheekbone indicating that they wanted a hand job too. So she lifted her free hand and started stroking...

 

[princesssexci]

~Kat~

“Spread them bitch.”

It sounded so unnatural for Mary to say those words. True, Kat didn’t really know Mary at all but it sounded utterly cheesy coming from her that it made Kat giggle and spread her legs. She licked her lips. She reached up and squeezed Mary’s breasts moaning at the feel of the cocks slipping inside of her.

She moved in rhythm with Mary’s motions. Her lips parted as she let out a low moan. She pinched Mary’s nipples, then massaged them because Mary never said she couldn’t play with her tits.

And they were so squishy yet firm. Kat lifted her head slightly and her tongue brushed over the nipple that her hand wasn’t playing with.

~Maddy~

Maddy groaned as one of the cocks from...she thought Tyler called him Heath earlier pulled out of her mouth but they weren’t finished. She felt something prodding at her asshole and then slowly slid in.

“Fuck!” She hissed before Tyler slipped into her commenting on how wet she was. Probably because her body had never been assaulted by so many cocks at once.

“This is some good footage.”

Footage? People were gonna see this?! She didn’t have a chance to question it though.

“Fuuuck yes!” She cried out before the next cock slipped into her mouth.

She couldn’t complain because despite having never been used like this, the only experience with multiple cocks had been with Mary.

This was different though, she could feel them pulsing inside of her.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat whimpered as the toy slid in her and out, not totally out, just a back and forth motion. She was so incredibly wet, god she couldn't even remember the last time she'd been this wet before. Even Tyler had never gotten her off this much. Thankfully, she had managed to get rid of him for the night. It was nice to finally let her hair down and just be.


"I... I think I love you..!"

"Oh goood....." she moaned out long and hard as her own orgasm washed over her. She vaguely heard the words that Mary had said but it didn't really pop out at her until she started coming down from that wave of ecstasy.

I love you...

Shit...shit...

"I uh....wow." Kat said slowly, unsure of how to respond. Her sister would say something back right? But she didn't know how Maddie would respond to this. "That's....great. Uh, before I can answer that ...lets um play Overlook...watch. Overwatch and then maybe I can.....shit!"

It was then that she noticed as she had been moving off of the bed towards the game control, after having glanced at the tv screen. A tiny box with them in it showed on the screen.

"Oh...my god.... Did you...."

430 viewers...

"Did ...oh my god...." Kat quickly placed her hand over her butterfly tattoo. "I--I have to go." Without another word, she ran into the bathroom with her and locked the door. "TURN IT THE FUCK OFF MARY..."

She began hyperventilating. something she hadn't done since she was 13.

Maddie

Maddie was in a daze barely out of her own little sexual high. She'd never seen so much cum in her whole entire life and her body had never been so fucking sore before except for after going hiking.

It wasn't until she heard some of the guys talking about a live feed that she slowly came out of her daze. "Not a bitch, fuck you..." she mumbled stumbling over to where Tyler was looking as her sister, the real Kat ran into the bathroom.

"Oh no, she didn't just..."

Poor Mary.

How in the hell was she going to explain anything to Mary tomorrow. Oh hey, that wasn't me you fucked, that was my twin? Mary stood there looking, swallowing hard before the screen went black.

“Weird, s-she always told me she was into ....” she could vaguely hear herself rambling about a sex life she wasn’t supposed to know much about. “I didn’t realize she....maybe she was experimenting or something?”

 

[princesssexci]

~Kat~

Kat tried to gain control of her self and calm her breathing down. Once she did, She combed her fingers through her hair and took another deep breath, before unlocking the door. Since she had had a mini asthma attack she hadn't put her clothes back on yet. Kat slowly opened the door and stared at Mary who looked...utterly heart broken.

"Mary, I'm sorry I freaked, I just...this is all happening so fast and..."

Kat pushed one of Mary's braids out her eyes. "Lets just take things slow huh? No titles, just us. Especially now that everyone knows..." Well, at least 430 people now knew that her sister was in a lesbian relationship. Though she had to admit, she didn't mind Mary's company it was rather refreshing, a breath of fresh air.

Besides, if Maddie could experiment...why couldn't she?

~~

~Maddie~

Maddie felt the light caresses of Tyler and felt her body begin to slowly come back to life as he washed her clean. Her nipples hardened distinctly as his hands brushed soap over them toying with them a little bit and caused her to moan. The sudden feel of his hands freezing made her wonder did something happen.

God, what was wrong with her?

This man wasn't even her boyfriend, he was her sisters but already she craved his touch. She suddenly felt him turn her around and kiss her. She moaned into it this time not feeling so...awkward about it. The kiss was hot and passionate,deep and lustful.

"Y-you do?" She stammered. Could her body even handle that, being fucked again. It was still sore from the three hour fucking from earlier. She was pretty certain that Kat wouldn't object though, would she? Wouldn't it give it away that she was Maddie. Did it even matter at this point? Right now, after what she saw on the live feed, it was probably better being Kat right now.

Her hands grazed over his muscular chest, going down further until they found his cock...

 

[princesssexci]

Maddie

"So... umm... I was thinking about staying here tonight..."


Maddie didn't say anything for a minute. If he stayed, if ...she stayed, that meant she couldn't go back to her own dorm room, her real dorm or even her own life. She must've been taking too long to answer because Tyler's brows creased as if he sensed something wrong.

"Ah, sure."

Within moments, she found herself curled up into him. It felt...oddly nice. It shouldn't feel nice though. What if Kat came back and wanted to switch back or thought she was trying to steal her boyfriend?

It wasn't her intention that was for sure because this hadn't been her idea to begin with. She did take into account that he wasn't talking much, just holding her and caressing her arm.

"Whatcha thinking?" She whispered, glancing up at him.

"Nothing really. I was wondering where all this energy came from? I mean... normally, you would not have thought twice about this love making with me after what you had been through." When he paused, she swallowed hard but didn't say anything. "It's almost as if your a whole different person...

"Tyler, I have to tell you--"

"...and I am liking it."

Just when she was getting ready to do the right thing. Maddie always knew that Tyler was hot and even felt kind of jealous that her sister had managed to start dating him before she did plus when she was herself, he was a huuuuge asshole which made him even less appealing.

"I mean, it is Halloween. Isn't that the whole point, to be a whole new person buut if you want me to keep it up." Maddie did her best to do Kat's typical dismissive shrug, "It's not that hard."

God, she was going to Hell for this.

Kat

Kat let out a small sigh of relief and sat on the bed. SHe didn't quite understand WHY she was still there but, felt really bad for breaking this poor girls heart. Plus, she was sure that knowing Tyler, he was still there and she had to do her best to avoid Tyler considering she had no idea what was happening.

"What we planned on....no, of course not. Things have been crazy with ....ya know finals coming up and stuff, what..did we have planned on Monday?"

God, this was hard, being someone that she wasn't. Though she had played a bit of Overwatch with Tyler when he was in a gamey mood, so she wasn't terrible at it but she wasn't an expert at it either.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Kat stares blankly at the tear gas and pistol.

“Oh right, THAT PLAN.” She said dumbly. What the fuck plan was that supposed to be? Were they committing a murder? What kind of plan involved a fucking gun?

“Of course I’m still in, why wouldn’t I be?” When Mary looked at her suspiciously, she smiled. “C’mon Mary don’t be mad at me. I just have a lot on my mind and ...”

What would she do if she forgot something Tyler said. She scooted off the bed and moved over to Mary wrapping her arms around her,

“And when most of the times it’s this really cute girl that knows every button to push... you can’t blame me can you.”

Maddie

“A BDSM club...” she repeated. How in the hell had she gotten into this mess. Clearly they were already into that kind of relationship since Tyler kept calling her pet but...

She wasn’t Kat.

She should tell him, right about now would be the BEST time to Tyler he and his friends just fucked his girlfriend’s sister. It was her only option out.

“Yeah, it’s not really my thing.” She agreed.

But he was already talking as if she agreed, and the kiss afterwards had pushed any reservations away “But trying new things sounds ...****.” She said trying her hardest not to sound hesitant. Honestly, how had he not figured it out yet?

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

She wasn’t sure how to answer Mary because she had no answers. Cute nicknames? Wtf. “Well, I didn’t realize I had to pull your braids all the time, plus when your...friend is giving you a mind blowing orgasm calling her a cutesy nickname wasn’t the first thing I think of. Besides—I was thinking of...”

Thankfully, her sentence got cut off by a bamming on the door. As Mary hurried off the bed and told her to get dressed, Kat blinked feeling maybe NOW would be a good time to leave.

Of course she had to think of a reason to leave. Kat quickly put her costume back on and waited as Mary opened the door.

Maddie

"I know it's you... Maddie."

Maddie’s eyes widen at Tyler’s words as she peeked up at him. Was he for real? Granted, she was terrible at playing her sister, always had been but did better when they were kids. Probably because it was easier to play Fashion girl Teresa Barbie than it was to play Sorority slut Katarina.

She pushed back though as he told her it was her that he wanted. “W-what? I mean—I’m flattered, really but— “ she swallowed hard. A few minutes ago she felt like she was stealing her sisters boyfriend but was it stealing if he hadn’t known it was her? Not to mention, she thought they could switch back and no one would be the wiser.

“You don’t even know me. We had one night...which half was spent of your friends fucking me, because you thought I was Kat.” Why even bother denying it?

“Besides, how do you know it was Kats idea.” She also didn’t believe in ratting her sister out. “I could’ve been doing a sociology experiment on....how powerful sex is! Yeah and...can a man be blinded by ...his testosterone before he realizes what he’s doing. Congrats you figured it out sooner than I thought.”

While this was Kat’s idea and Maddie didn’t mind serving up revenge, she didn’t think throwing her sister under the bus was right.

“Besides, you are probably only interested in me because I went along with your gang bang.”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Oh god, what had Maddie gotten her into? Well—what had she gotten herself into? Because really, this had been her idea but —Maddie’s life seemed way more complicated than it looked. Now, she was trapped in some whacked out plan where she was either robbing a bank, blowing up the school, or doing some insane peta mission.

All of the above?

Now the gay crusade, the furries (what she called all animal rights activists), and her sisters wanna be girlfriend were all looking at her as if she knew what the fuck she was doing.

Surely by now, these idiots had figured out she wasn’t Maddie. She was shocked that Tyler hadn’t figured it out yet and sent Maddie home balling her eyes out.

“My plan, right...” she said slowly,”I have one and it’s AMAZING but, I want it to be a surprise. Guys I’ll be right back. I actually need to call someone who was a very important part of my plan.” She grabbed her phone and ran into the bathroom and dialed Maddie.

“C’mon, c’mon pick up the fucking phone, M.”

Maddie

“Fuuuck...” Maddie whimpered as Tyler slowly began thrusting into her, making it hard for her to focus on the right thing to do. If she continued pretending to be Kat, wouldn’t lines cross, morally...ethically.

Not to mention, she had people counting on her. Mary was counting on her. They were supposed to be rescuing animals tomorrow, to save them from being experimented—

She bit her lip as Tyler pulled back. Her body instinctively moving against him, before he slipped back inside her. “Yes...” she moaned more so because of the pleasure she felt instead of his plan. “W-wait I mean—“ and that was when he buried himself into her. She felt his cock press against her cervix.

Her moans grew,”Fuck...don’t stop, Tyler..”

Her phone suddenly started ringing, it was obvious who it was based on the ringtone Maddie assigned Kat, Me too by Meghan Trainor, because it was Kats favorite singer. Even as he ducked her she weakly reaches for the phone...

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

“Fuck!” Kat hissed as feared boiled into her. What was she going to do? Why the fuck hadn’t Maddie answered? She wanted to scream but took a few deep breaths. She could do this....whatever this was.

She sent a quick text to Maddie.

‘Your group of losers are here and I’m at a loss, send help ASAP. ‘

She came out of the bathroom and smiled at the awaiting groups. “So my uh...friend didn’t pick up and she was my last resort. But it will happen, I promise guys.”

Kat wasn’t sure what IT was but there was no way out of this. “Why are you guys looking at me like that? I mean you trust me, right?”

Maddie

“O-okay...” she whimpered against his neck.

“You mean yes daddy.”

“Yessss daddyyyy...” she whimpered as he slammed into her again. She was so close again and shivered as the cold handcuffs hooked onto her hands.

“Good girl...now...your reward.”

“Ohhhh fuck, Tyler!!!!” She screamed, her pussy extremely wet and extremely sensitive. There was another difference between her and Kat, while they were both pretty loud during sex, Kat moaned and Maddie squealed with passion especially when she enjoyed it a lot and she was squealing.

Any thoughts about the real Kat slowly drifted to the back of her mind as she pulled on the handcuffs so she could touch Tyler.

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

“Ohhhhhh!!! Right the animal rights thing.” She mumbled but thankfully, no one heard. She’d forgotten her sister was into all this stuff. It was one of the main reasons her and Maddie stopped being inseparable.

“Saving animals, guys I got this. Like don’t even worry.”

After they finished going over their plans, Mary tried asking her again what was going on with her but she played it off like no big deal and distracted her by asking if she could stay the night.

After all, there was no way she could go to Maddie’s place, she had no key and Maddie wasn’t exactly answering. Her phone kept going to voicemail.

The rescue mission started at 4:30. Everything seemed to be going okay with the plans. Daniel and whatever her name was we’re going along with their plan with the grenades or whatever, Cory and his boyfriend were doing their thing.

That left her and Mary to rescue the animals. But they weren’t on the best speaking terms because Mary didn’t understand her. Hell she didn’t understand herself right now.

Mary was on the lookout outside

“HANDS UP AND KEEP EM UP “

8:30

“Look at the camera please.”

Kat was balling. How the fuck had she ended up with a criminal record? In fact, it wasn’t even her that was getting the record.

“Listen, this is a HUGE mistake. Who you want is my twin sister Maddie. Not me. I don’t do the whole orange is the new black thing.” Kat laughed but the officer just stared at her.

“Look at the camera.”

“But...”

“Listen bitch you all suddenly have twins that did the crime, look at the fucking camera now. Then we’ll like take your selfie okay?”the officer growled.

“Listen my name is not Maddie, it’s Kat. This whole thing, this whole idea was hers. “

~~

Maddie

Rap music filled the room as Maddie’s eyes slowly opened. She had a moment where her mind was blank. Dazedly, she glanced at the clock. It was 8:30 in the morning. Her body ached.

8:30 in the...OH SHIT. She tried to reach for something to stable herself but only found herself rolling off the bed because surprise, surprise her hands were cuffed. Her phone was on the chair.

She vaguely remembered it ringing but didn’t recall answering it. Kat hadn’t come back yet which means... did they go through with it? The plan.

The shower was going and she huffed. It was definitely not easy getting up when your hands were cuffed. “Tyler...” came her small raspy voice, probably from all the orgasms she’d had, all the screaming. “Helllp...”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

“But...” Kat started then mentally screamed. Okay, yeah sure it was her that they found but, she should NOT have been there. This should’ve been Maddie’s problem not hers. Kat should’ve been her room with Tyler trying to convince her to cuddle with him.

“Listen, I can tell you the truth. That’s not a problem.”

When the detective nodded her head to nonverbally tell her to continue, she took a deep breath before she started talking quickly.

“Yesterday was our annual costume party, I convinced Maddie to switch places with me because I didn’t want to do some stupid threesome my....fwb planned. I’m actually losing interest in him I just couldn’t find a way to tell him and so I thought my sister THE REAL MADDIE could do it for me because she’s usually such a prude like no way she would have a threesome.”

The detective looked bored.

“Anyways, we switched and then Maddie’s friend Mary told me about some plan they had but she didn’t ACTUALLY tell me, just said we had a plan and I was the most important key to...DONT WRITE THAT DOWN. I’m not the key, my sister Maddie is the key. Fuck.listen I didn’t even touch any of those stupid animals. I’m not exactly eco friendly, my sister is always going on about how the makeup I use is tested on animals blah blah blah. ”

Maddie

Maddie reached for her phone despite what Tyler said and turned it on. She’d missed at least 10 calls. 5 early this morning around 1 and 5 right before 4:30. She hit play on the voice mail.

“Maddie, this isn’t fucking funny. Why haven’t you answered? Why are these weirdos talking about ski masks. Are you in a gang miss goody two shoes?”

She skipped a few messages.

“M, please pick up. This isn’t fun anymore. Your friends are weird and I think Mary is obsessed with you. “

Maddie set the phone back on the table and glanced up at Tyler. Whatever was happening with Kat, she must’ve been okay now. She stopped calling. Maybe she was with Mary?

Just then, on the radio the newscaster mentioned a break in where an African American female was caught stealing animals among the list of other offenses. They describe her as 5’6 chocolate skin tone with black hair...matching Maddie’s description and that was what sold it.

Good lord, that could’ve been her.

“I’d have to erase my personal information on my phone. Ya know, in case one of Kats...my friends look at my phone.”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

They dragged her to a holding cell next. Apparently no one believed her when she said this wasn’t even her idea. The detective had said everyone said that but this time it was true.

And Kat had lied about a lot of stuff.

“Welcome to your new home, Madison.” The guard said but Kat rolled her eyes.

“You’re going to feel real stupid when you find out I’m not the girl you want and my name isn’t Madison it’s Kat!” At that point she was shoved into the cell, another girl sat on the top bunk.

“Hi, I’m Maddie. I guess.” Kat went for the bottom bunk but the girl jumped off the top bunk and pushed Kat out of the way before laying on the bottom bunk.

“No, it’s fine. I wanted the top bunk anyways.” Kat lied.

~~
Maddie

“Oh god, but I’m a terrible liar. Do you really think they’ll question me. Tyler I was supposed to be at that ...that...” She could barely form words. But at the same time she couldn’t be Maddie right now because all of her friends would think she threw them under the bus.

And she did, not purposely but still...

“You don’t think...what if I told them we switched but she’s not Maddie, she’s Kat and she still went through with everything ...” at the look he gave her, she shrunk back. There really was no way out of this other than turning herself in or pretending to be Kat.

“Fine, I-I’ll do it. I guess.”

Plus he hadn’t put his clothes on yet so she had a reallly nice view and she’d always been a fan of a man with a nice sculpted chest. Suddenly Maddie began to giggle,”Does she really call you daddy?” When he nodded it only made her giggle more.

“Sorry, it’s just Kat was never a daddy’s girl. So it’s kind of amusing that she’d call you that.”

 

[princesssexci]

Kat

Little....fish?!

Who the fuck was she calling little fish? They were all going to be sorry that they threw her into this cage with this hoe. Literally, the girl looked like a...

She was shoved into the small bathroom area and pressed her against the wall. This chick was far rougher than Mary had been and her Kat's first instinct was to fight. She had this thing about being dominated, she didn't like it. She was the top bitch in her sorority and there was no way...

"Rule 1.) You take care of me and I will take care of you. Rule 2.) You take care of me period or I will bust your face open little hoe. Rule 3.)..."

Kat felt her grab her breasts and squeezed. Fuuuck, she internally moaned, though she held her glare as the girl ignored her insolent looks and continued talking.

"These girls... are mine. This whole package... is mine... Do I make myself clear?"

Her first thoughts were fight or flight. There was not exactly any place to run in this joint so....

"Fuck you! Do you know who I am?"

Someone from another cell yelled, "Get the little eco friendly bitch, Lakeen!"

Kat could already see the anger blazing in 'Lakeen's' eyes. "W-wait, sorry I didn't mean... sorry, yes I understand."

Maddie

Maddie inwardly panicked as Tyler went to the door and answered it. There stood two officers. This was it, fight or flight. If she ran then she'd be guilty even though technically despite the whole operation being her idea, she hadn't actually done anything.

And if she admitted to it being her idea but having nothing to do with it, she'd be an accomplice. Wouldn't she?

Fuck. She glanced back at Tyler who said he'd be right behind her.


Once they arrived at the precinct, they took her as Kat to the precinct. Some of the officers looked amazed though she didn't see why. Were twins not the normal around here?

Officer Kendrick led her to the interviewing room and she glanced at the mirror. She always watched Law and Order she knew there were other officers behind the glass.

"So we have your sister, Madison in a holding cell." The Detective said as she stepped inside. "She has some interesting stories to tell. She mentioned that you are the real Madison and she's Kat. So let's start with that. What is your full name?"

She could almost hear Tyler telling her to lie.

"Katarina Michelle Hendrix. Is my sister okay?" She really was worried. Kat was definitely not the same prison type but then neither was she.

"She's fine, for now. Where were you this morning at 4:30 am?"

"I was asleep with my boyfriend."

 

[princesssexci]

Did they have any diffrentiating marks? She had to think about it for a minute until the previous night came back to her. Kat would have nipple piercings or at least the holes to prove that she has them. Maddie didn't think that Kat wore them last night though because to accurately tell she wasn't Kat would be not to have them on. But something Kat couldn't get rid of was the tattoo on her ....

Where did Tyler say it was?

"She has a tattoo!!" Maddie blurted out. " I'm not sure where or what it looks like because it's obviously hidden so our God obsessed parents don't freak out." She said trying to sound as much as Kat as she could.

"And how do I know you don't also have a tattoo?" The detective asked.

"You can always ask my boyfriend. He should be here soon enough, if he isn't already. "

The detective made notes and then took Maddie to the room where her and her sister could talk.

Kat was thrown into the room, her eyes wide. Her eyes were black underneath her eyes and she glared at Maddie. "What the fuck, Maddie?" Kat snapped, "Why didn't you answer your phone last night?"

Maddie just stared at Kat having conflicted thoughts. She really didn't want to be in jail.

"Maddie, please don't do this again." Maddie said to Kat.

Kat glared at her, "Don't you dare Maddie me. This isn't funny. This whole thing was your idea, I shouldn't be in jail for a crime you would've committed if we hadn't switched places. There is a girl in my jail cell that wants to make me her BITCH. Maddie."

The detective came in at that point. "I'm so sorry, officer. She's done this ever since we were kids. Pretend to be me whenever she got in trouble. I think she even flirted with my boyfriend once."