RobDownSouth
Oh Look....
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2002
- Posts
- 75,178
Wow, I went down a rabbit hole last night watching highlights of the Young Thug RICO murder trial this week.
Background: Young Thug has some super-lawyer named Brian Steele representing him in a case where a rapper on his record label killed someone. The State is trying to prove a rap record label is actually a criminal enterprise.
On June 11th, the judge, his court reporter, two district attorneys, the sheriff and two deputies tried to coerce a witness into testifying in a hearing held in the judges chamber at 7 pm on a Friday night. The defense was not notified.. This is an egregious error that gets most cases thrown out of court. The witness was threatened with a 12 year jail term for not testifying (!!!). The witness eventually agreed to testify but said upfront he would "lie like hell under oath". The judge agreed (???)
Steele found out about this and asked for the transcript of the illegal ex parte meeting in open court. The judge publicly blew a gasket. WHO TOLD YOU? Steele declined to say. The judge cited the defense attorney for "contempt" for filing a routine motion and sentenced him to 20 days in jail.
The head of the GA defense lawyers association appeared in court in defense of Brian Steele and got into a titanic back-and-forth with the judge. She told him he was applying the rules of a civil contempt charge with the penalties of a criminal defense charge and the judge responded with 5 minutes of legal gobbledygook saying that he had the "right" to rule on a motion where he (the judge) was now a witness in the proceedings. The judge uttered the magic words "I'ma gonna get this matter resolved right now", throwing criminal procedure to the wind and opening up a legal shitstorm about prejudicial behavior.
The Steel team filed an immediate emergency appeal to the Appeals court and got the judge's sentence suspended in record time.
They then asked for the judge's recusal from the case because of his documented bias towards the prosecution and the judge denied the recusal. The defense then filed the "professional bitchslap", a writ of mandamus to the GA supreme court, asking them to intervened.
The judge has been all nicey-nice the past two days...he knows he's in the national spotlight and on very thin legal ice.
Worth watching (it's everywhere) you seldom see a defense attorney quietly and professionally skewer a criminal court judge over and over. Judge: "now that I've ruled here, is there anything else before we proceed?" Attorney: "Actually your honor there are quite a few unresolved issues that I'd like the court to address..."
Background: Young Thug has some super-lawyer named Brian Steele representing him in a case where a rapper on his record label killed someone. The State is trying to prove a rap record label is actually a criminal enterprise.
On June 11th, the judge, his court reporter, two district attorneys, the sheriff and two deputies tried to coerce a witness into testifying in a hearing held in the judges chamber at 7 pm on a Friday night. The defense was not notified.. This is an egregious error that gets most cases thrown out of court. The witness was threatened with a 12 year jail term for not testifying (!!!). The witness eventually agreed to testify but said upfront he would "lie like hell under oath". The judge agreed (???)
Steele found out about this and asked for the transcript of the illegal ex parte meeting in open court. The judge publicly blew a gasket. WHO TOLD YOU? Steele declined to say. The judge cited the defense attorney for "contempt" for filing a routine motion and sentenced him to 20 days in jail.
The head of the GA defense lawyers association appeared in court in defense of Brian Steele and got into a titanic back-and-forth with the judge. She told him he was applying the rules of a civil contempt charge with the penalties of a criminal defense charge and the judge responded with 5 minutes of legal gobbledygook saying that he had the "right" to rule on a motion where he (the judge) was now a witness in the proceedings. The judge uttered the magic words "I'ma gonna get this matter resolved right now", throwing criminal procedure to the wind and opening up a legal shitstorm about prejudicial behavior.
The Steel team filed an immediate emergency appeal to the Appeals court and got the judge's sentence suspended in record time.
They then asked for the judge's recusal from the case because of his documented bias towards the prosecution and the judge denied the recusal. The defense then filed the "professional bitchslap", a writ of mandamus to the GA supreme court, asking them to intervened.
The judge has been all nicey-nice the past two days...he knows he's in the national spotlight and on very thin legal ice.
Worth watching (it's everywhere) you seldom see a defense attorney quietly and professionally skewer a criminal court judge over and over. Judge: "now that I've ruled here, is there anything else before we proceed?" Attorney: "Actually your honor there are quite a few unresolved issues that I'd like the court to address..."