A sincere question for Redwave

Not to mention the workers' strikes and revolts in Venezuela that he doesn't support because Hugo Chavez is as left-wing as they come.

TB4p
 
A re-post for the militant keepers of the peace

Iraq, Iran, and DPRK do have certain advantages that could allow them to succeed with a more open economy and greater freedoms (too bad they have the full backing of a rusty 8000nuke giant) Here's a reminder to JAZZY, TB, GWB, Uncle Ronnie, and other keepers of the peace (Republicans)---why liberal democracy building usually doesn't work and why it could eventually hurt them politically.

World Systems 101:

There is a belief that it is liberal democracy that encourages stability, development and social harmony--and that the core (developed world) has been trying to transmit this form of government to the periphery states (developing world) who are viewed as less evolved for their lack of stability and liberal democracy.

What most of the core doesn't understand is that the lack of political stability and liberal democracy in the periphery is just as predetermined by the system as the reality of liberal democracy and stability is predetermined in the core. Stability or instability, liberal democracy or authoritarianism has little to do with the social potential of the populations or cultures but rather everything to do with the fundamental anatomy of the capitalist world economy.

Authoritarianism and political instability is prevalent in the periphery because--

--Since consumers don't subsidize periphery workers' households by paying a higher price for periphery products, there is less money in the periphery. This sends small children out to earn money or starve--no education is received. Some Afghan girls do attend school but only after they've worked a 12+hour day making rugs--boys mine for coal on slave wages (less than $5 a month).

--Since there is relatively little wealth, that means politicians and political parties will have little to offer the electorate in terms of benefit packages in exchange for votes.

--Thus, there is little support for the local political structure and you have little stability.

--When people get hungry and organisations like the army see their budgets threatened, they move to overthrow the government.

--With little support for the local political system based on little wealth to offer the populace in exchange for their support, politicians revert to a more coercive mechanism.

--The gun replaces wealth as a means to get people to accept the status quo. The rest of the perks that go with liberal democracy are of course discarded (if they ever were functional)

--History says this is the typical situation--however, our current period does have examples of significant popular democracies in the periphery but they are still on shaky ground and are still relatively affluent (South America). They only superficially appear to be like core democracies---they are characterised by the concentration of wealth and political power, also the marginalisation of the electoral process. Obviously, the difference in the periphery democracy results from the periphery's structural disadvantageous position in the world economy.

--During a period such as now when democracy is fairly prevalent in the periphery, there still is little wealth political parties can redistribute to the electorate for their support. That party's time in control likely will be limited until the next election, unless they turn to the gun.

--It is true that Communism is less likely to truly be successful in the periphery--the nature of this system is compounded with a fuming core, they levy sanctions and send in the secret armies. Sometimes that even props up the most brutal general to savior status if he can fend invaders off. In these places the gun initially becomes the coercive tool.

--Bolivia is the prime repeater--over 200 governments in less than 200 years

A country's ideology is generally the by product of economic status--not derived from the expectations of the populace or the ideals America brings to the table. Politics in the periphery is aptly regarded as "the politics of failure", probably even more so when we get involved---I'll qualify that by saying unless it is an attempt to prevent genocide--our involvement has to be better than the alternative. (I'll qualify my qualification by saying unless they are fully backed by a rusty 8000nuke giant that wants to challenge us)
 
Re: A re-post for the militant keepers of the peace

70/30 said:
Iraq, Iran, and DPRK do have certain advantages that could allow them to succeed with a more open economy and greater freedoms (too bad they have the full backing of a rusty 8000nuke giant) Here's a reminder to JAZZY, TB, GWB, Uncle Ronnie, and other keepers of the peace (Republicans)---why liberal democracy building usually doesn't work and why it could eventually hurt them politically.

World Systems 101:

There is a belief that it is liberal democracy that encourages stability, development and social harmony--and that the core (developed world) has been trying to transmit this form of government to the periphery states (developing world) who are viewed as less evolved for their lack of stability and liberal democracy.

What most of the core doesn't understand is that the lack of political stability and liberal democracy in the periphery is just as predetermined by the system as the reality of liberal democracy and stability is predetermined in the core. Stability or instability, liberal democracy or authoritarianism has little to do with the social potential of the populations or cultures but rather everything to do with the fundamental anatomy of the capitalist world economy.

Authoritarianism and political instability is prevalent in the periphery because--

--Since consumers don't subsidize periphery workers' households by paying a higher price for periphery products, there is less money in the periphery. This sends small children out to earn money or starve--no education is received. Some Afghan girls do attend school but only after they've worked a 12+hour day making rugs--boys mine for coal on slave wages (less than $5 a month).

--Since there is relatively little wealth, that means politicians and political parties will have little to offer the electorate in terms of benefit packages in exchange for votes.

--Thus, there is little support for the local political structure and you have little stability.

--When people get hungry and organisations like the army see their budgets threatened, they move to overthrow the government.

--With little support for the local political system based on little wealth to offer the populace in exchange for their support, politicians revert to a more coercive mechanism.

--The gun replaces wealth as a means to get people to accept the status quo. The rest of the perks that go with liberal democracy are of course discarded (if they ever were functional)

--History says this is the typical situation--however, our current period does have examples of significant popular democracies in the periphery but they are still on shaky ground and are still relatively affluent (South America). They only superficially appear to be like core democracies---they are characterised by the concentration of wealth and political power, also the marginalisation of the electoral process. Obviously, the difference in the periphery democracy results from the periphery's structural disadvantageous position in the world economy.

--During a period such as now when democracy is fairly prevalent in the periphery, there still is little wealth political parties can redistribute to the electorate for their support. That party's time in control likely will be limited until the next election, unless they turn to the gun.

--It is true that Communism is less likely to truly be successful in the periphery--the nature of this system is compounded with a fuming core, they levy sanctions and send in the secret armies. Sometimes that even props up the most brutal general to savior status if he can fend invaders off. In these places the gun initially becomes the coercive tool.

--Bolivia is the prime repeater--over 200 governments in less than 200 years

A country's ideology is generally the by product of economic status--not derived from the expectations of the populace or the ideals America brings to the table. Politics in the periphery is aptly regarded as "the politics of failure", probably even more so when we get involved---I'll qualify that by saying unless it is an attempt to prevent genocide--our involvement has to be better than the alternative. (I'll qualify my qualification by saying unless they are fully backed by a rusty 8000nuke giant that wants to challenge us)

What does this have to do with North Korea?
 
Sinthysist, Ishmael and myself in a non-partisan manner have concluded we have a Russian and PRC problem---not a problem that stems from KIM Il. Many more countries hate us than like us, nothing new---Bush has taken that to another level. Russia, China, and DPRK sell weapons to pretty much everyone---what's funny is Germany, France, the UK, and even Japan have been doing the objecting to the UN---thereby not forcing Russia and PRC to directly and publicly thwart our assault on Saddam. The DPRK is their insurance we act in their interest--or risk facing "a sea of fire".

To answer, TB-brought up Venezuela--invariably they'll bring up Brasil--

problems in South America won't get much better until they can move their cheap production plants to a lesser developed country.

---Since consumers don't subsidize periphery workers' households by paying a higher price for periphery products, there is less money in the periphery.

****I'll add--since DPRK is Russia's client state--and Russia is less than pleased with our international foreign policy in all continents, including Anarctica--it does involve North Korea.
 
Last edited:
70/30, I'm confused by the jargon. Please use short words in short sentences. Oviod terms like "periphery" unless you provide a compleat defination. Pretend that you are trying to explain yourself to an Okie, just be misunderstood by this one.
 
Samuari said:
70/30, I'm confused by the jargon. Please use short words in short sentences. Oviod terms like "periphery" unless you provide a compleat defination. Pretend that you are trying to explain yourself to an Okie, just be misunderstood by this one.

periphery = not in the centre

with long complex prose break it down in your head into smaller, easier to understand pieces...

:)

ppman
 
Samuari said:
70/30, I'm confused by the jargon. Please use short words in short sentences. Oviod terms like "periphery" unless you provide a compleat defination. Pretend that you are trying to explain yourself to an Okie, just be misunderstood by this one.
Good thing the internet has quote sites. But just so you're up to speed, I'll help you out...

Blessed are we who laugh at ourselves, for we shall always be amused.

Dumbed down translation:
Dose who laugh at demselves always giggling.
 
Good Gawd, lavy, why bring me into this unless you wish to discredit your argument...
 
Re: A re-post for the militant keepers of the peace

70/30 said:
Iraq, Iran, and DPRK do have certain advantages that could allow them to succeed with a more open economy and greater freedoms (too bad they have the full backing of a rusty 8000nuke giant) Here's a reminder to JAZZY, TB, GWB, Uncle Ronnie, and other keepers of the peace (Republicans)---why liberal democracy building usually doesn't work and why it could eventually hurt them politically.

World Systems 101:

There is a belief that it is liberal democracy that encourages stability, development and social harmony--and that the core (developed world) has been trying to transmit this form of government to the periphery states (developing world) who are viewed as less evolved for their lack of stability and liberal democracy.

What most of the core doesn't understand is that the lack of political stability and liberal democracy in the periphery is just as predetermined by the system as the reality of liberal democracy and stability is predetermined in the core. Stability or instability, liberal democracy or authoritarianism has little to do with the social potential of the populations or cultures but rather everything to do with the fundamental anatomy of the capitalist world economy.

Authoritarianism and political instability is prevalent in the periphery because--

--Since consumers don't subsidize periphery workers' households by paying a higher price for periphery products, there is less money in the periphery. This sends small children out to earn money or starve--no education is received. Some Afghan girls do attend school but only after they've worked a 12+hour day making rugs--boys mine for coal on slave wages (less than $5 a month).

--Since there is relatively little wealth, that means politicians and political parties will have little to offer the electorate in terms of benefit packages in exchange for votes.

--Thus, there is little support for the local political structure and you have little stability.

--When people get hungry and organisations like the army see their budgets threatened, they move to overthrow the government.

--With little support for the local political system based on little wealth to offer the populace in exchange for their support, politicians revert to a more coercive mechanism.

--The gun replaces wealth as a means to get people to accept the status quo. The rest of the perks that go with liberal democracy are of course discarded (if they ever were functional)

--History says this is the typical situation--however, our current period does have examples of significant popular democracies in the periphery but they are still on shaky ground and are still relatively affluent (South America). They only superficially appear to be like core democracies---they are characterised by the concentration of wealth and political power, also the marginalisation of the electoral process. Obviously, the difference in the periphery democracy results from the periphery's structural disadvantageous position in the world economy.

--During a period such as now when democracy is fairly prevalent in the periphery, there still is little wealth political parties can redistribute to the electorate for their support. That party's time in control likely will be limited until the next election, unless they turn to the gun.

--It is true that Communism is less likely to truly be successful in the periphery--the nature of this system is compounded with a fuming core, they levy sanctions and send in the secret armies. Sometimes that even props up the most brutal general to savior status if he can fend invaders off. In these places the gun initially becomes the coercive tool.

--Bolivia is the prime repeater--over 200 governments in less than 200 years

A country's ideology is generally the by product of economic status--not derived from the expectations of the populace or the ideals America brings to the table. Politics in the periphery is aptly regarded as "the politics of failure", probably even more so when we get involved---I'll qualify that by saying unless it is an attempt to prevent genocide--our involvement has to be better than the alternative. (I'll qualify my qualification by saying unless they are fully backed by a rusty 8000nuke giant that wants to challenge us)
There's absolutely no reason why North Korea and Venezuela can't be productive and quite wealthy members of the world community. Christ, North Korea can be just as technologically advanced as Japan (whom we bombed the shit out of and then rebuilt) or South Korea (ditto to a certain extent). Venezuela is a practicing member of OPEC.

So don't tell me that they're too poor for democracy.

TB4p
 
p_p_man said:
periphery = not in the centre

with long complex prose break it down in your head into smaller, easier to understand pieces...

:)

ppman

I thought the issue was an ecnomic one, and you answer with geometry? I'm confused.



:confused:
 
Re: A re-post for the militant keepers of the peace

70/30 said:
Iraq, Iran, and DPRK do have certain advantages that could allow them to succeed with a more open economy and greater freedoms (too bad they have the full backing of a rusty 8000nuke giant)



I can't stand the Soviets either.
 
Samuari said:
I thought the issue was an ecnomic one, and you answer with geometry? I'm confused.



:confused:
I think 70/30 did define "periphery" before using it . . .

70/30 said:
There is a belief that it is liberal democracy that encourages stability, development and social harmony--and that the core (developed world) has been trying to transmit this form of government to the periphery states (developing world) who are viewed as less evolved for their lack of stability and liberal democracy.

What most of the core doesn't understand is that the lack of political stability and liberal democracy in the periphery is just as . . .
TB4p
 
70/30, wad up!

Instability is da buziness.

Money, money, money.

Money!
 
Isnt it funny how DeadRave

doesnt answer.

And if he will......he will somehow blame the USA.
 
Re: Re: A re-post for the militant keepers of the peace

HeavyStick said:
I can't stand the Soviets either.

You got the wrong impression...I like the Russians...they write a great novel...they have some hot chicks.

Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Alexander Losyukov, arriving in Beijing en route to Pyongyang, said diplomacy must be given a chance to work.

"I am convinced that it's possible to resolve the situation peacefully, but to achieve that we have to work very well," Losyukov, Russia's top Asia expert, told reporters.

"We need time to do our work, quiet diplomacy, as they say. We must ensure there are no sharp declarations that could cause antagonism. Diplomacy must be given a chance to work in the search for a resolution."
 
I should have included the semi-periphery but that would have shot it up to World Systems 111. The point is: there are countries that will never have successful liberal democracies---they don't have the physical resources, educational level, and they are paid pennies. The developed world can invest in businesses that don't pay slave wages, they can provide medical assistance, educational opportunites, and they can provide ecological help. Conceivably that could eventually work in promoting a successful version of our ideology. It is stupid for anyone to think because a Madagascar is a republic they should make it big with hard work---their GDP per capita is $870 (ppp)---they produce plenty, their citizens work plenty hard.
 
Last edited:
Sam is right, better definitions will help:

Core States- The states in the core are states whose production is overwhelmingly dominated by skilled labor production, usually manufacturing or services.

Periphery States- The states in the periphery are states whose production is dominated by low-skill production, usually raw material production or agricultural labor in the fields.

Semi-Periphery States- The states in the semi-periphery are states whose production is a mix of both core production and periphery production.

Artificial supports (farm bill and steel tariff) passed by the USA, do sequester ourselves in areas we are vulnerable in. This does distort the world market and drives the value of certain foreign goods down by creating a greater supply and less demand. I brought up, Madagascar---they are in a special kind of trouble...

http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/ma.html

Formerly an independent kingdom, Madagascar became a French colony in 1886, but regained its independence in 1960. During 1992-93, free presidential and National Assembly elections were held, ending 17 years of single-party rule. In 1997, in the second presidential race, Didier RATSIRAKA, the leader during the 1970s and 1980s, was returned to the presidency. The 2001 presidential election was contested between the followers of Didier RATSIRAKA and Marc RAVALOMANANA, nearly causing secession of half of the country. In April 2002 the High Constitutional Court announced RAVALOMANANA the winner....

...soil erosion results from deforestation and overgrazing; desertification; surface water contaminated with raw sewage and other organic wastes; several species of flora and fauna unique to the island are endangered

arable land: 4%
permanent crops: 1%
0-14 years: 45%
42.41 births/1,000 population
5.77 children born/woman

positives--

80% literacy rate
HIV/AIDs adult prevalence-less than 1%
 
Back
Top