butters
High on a Hill
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2009
- Posts
- 85,972
over the last couple of nights i've been watching the back-to-back running of THE STATE. really interesting, hard to watch in places. complex emotional content/characters' p.o.v's.
the final comments in this article says it 'fails at the human level'. not sure i agree with that as it had me connecting all over the place, finding sympathy for characters in situations they've only themselves to blame for but as they become disillusioned with what they first believed in. one character, in particular, as aghast at the violence against other muslims he witnesses - but then he and others are shown 2 rooms - one, they are told, is filled with men who stayed behind to protect the women but have all been shot in the head, and the second hosts the bodies of the raped and murdered women. his expression hardens and he's understanding why the people he just saw being killed were being killed. whether or not what he was told is true is never answered, and makes it even more a mess if it is true. he also is shocked by the female slaves and the fact that children can be purchased for stuff illegal in most countries today - so he buys a mother and daughter to protect them from abuse.
http://www.bbc.com/culture/story/20170919-how-new-drama-the-state-captures-the-essence-of-isThe State begins in 2015, near the height of the group’s success following its capture of Mosul. Recruits are flocking to Syria to join the Black Flag. The series follows four British characters, Shakira, a doctor and single motherwho has brought her nine-year-old son Isaac along with her. Jalal, who has come, along with his friend Ziyad, to join after his brother became a martyr for the group, and finally, Ushna a teenager dreaming of being a Jihadi wife.
the final comments in this article says it 'fails at the human level'. not sure i agree with that as it had me connecting all over the place, finding sympathy for characters in situations they've only themselves to blame for but as they become disillusioned with what they first believed in. one character, in particular, as aghast at the violence against other muslims he witnesses - but then he and others are shown 2 rooms - one, they are told, is filled with men who stayed behind to protect the women but have all been shot in the head, and the second hosts the bodies of the raped and murdered women. his expression hardens and he's understanding why the people he just saw being killed were being killed. whether or not what he was told is true is never answered, and makes it even more a mess if it is true. he also is shocked by the female slaves and the fact that children can be purchased for stuff illegal in most countries today - so he buys a mother and daughter to protect them from abuse.
Last edited:

